Favorites
Design Vault Ep. 28 55 Brighton with Rob Clocker
ABOUT THE ARCHITECT:
![]()
|
Rob joined Hacin in 2014 and assumed the role of Vice President and Managing Principal in 2023, bringing 30 years of experience in award-winning renovation and new construction projects. During his time at Hacin, he has completed The Whitney Hotel in Beacon Hill, the IIDA New England award-winning IDEO Cambridge, Public Garden Townhouse, and Chestnut Townhouse 2. He is also managing the ongoing mixed-use development at 41 Berkeley Street. Previously a Senior Associate at Perkins+Will in San Francisco, Rob led the revitalization of a 26-story Art Deco office tower, the transformation of a historic hospital to apartments in the Presidio of San Francisco, and the P/A award-winning design for the Calexico Land Port of Entry. As an advocate for stewardship of the built environment, he has spoken publicly on adaptive re-use and sustainable design. Rob is a registered architect, LEED Accredited Professional, and member of the Ipswich Zoning Board of Appeals. He holds a Master of Architecture degree from MIT and an undergraduate degree in Architecture from the University of Virginia. In his spare time, Rob enjoys carpentry, travel and photography. |
---|
ABOUT THE PROJECT:
55 Brighton, a mixed-use commercial project located in the Allston, marks the completion of Packard Crossing, a multi-phase residential development from the Hamilton Company which provides new-build housing options in a densely populated area of the city. Completed in the spring of 2023, this project transforms a once-underutilized site that previously housed an Auto Zone and parking lots into a vibrant and sustainable addition to the community. Spanning nearly 100,000 square feet of finished space, with an additional 70,000 square feet allocated to structured parking, 55 Brighton seamlessly integrates with the surrounding context while addressing the community’s needs.
The project’s architectural concept embraces the reinterpretation of the rhythms and scale of the surrounding block while paying homage to the area's automotive heritage. The façade, with its distinctive fanned design, draws nostalgic inspiration from the winged tails of iconic 1950s automobiles, prompted by the adjacent historic Packard manufacturing facility. The brick detailing, meticulously designed to tie into the fabric of the neighborhood, adds a touch of warmth and familiarity while metal paneling on the top floor creates a dynamic visual contrast to further enhance the depth and character of the building's exterior. The façade design provides different visual experiences depending on the direction of approach along Brighton Avenue.
From the project's inception in 2015, the design team aimed to create a through-block connection, linking 55 Brighton with 83 Gardner, the initial phase of the development (completed by Hacin in 2020). Working in collaboration with Ground, Inc., the team created a pedestrian link through the block that promotes walkability and enhances the area's overall connectivity. By reinforcing the primary street edge with active retail, 55 Brighton contributes to the neighborhood’s bustling environment; the inclusion of 78 rental units contributes much-needed housing, particularly for the area’s large population of college students.
The Packard Crossing complex embraces sustainable design strategies and materials such as low-flow fixtures, solar panels, and ground water recharge, and 55 Brighton has targeted LEED Gold certification. The project's commitment to sustainability is further emphasized by the inclusion of newly planted trees, leaving the site with far more green space than previously existed. By replacing surface lots with 175 covered spaces, the project addresses the parking needs of the community and offers a visually appealing solution to the needs of future development opportunities.
Mirroring the architectural concept, the interior design of 55 Brighton was also carefully crafted to reflect vibrant streetscape patterns and automotive shapes and forms. The team selected materials and finishes that embody the project's goals and create a harmonious blend of functionality and aesthetics. The inclusion of Packard-inspired details honors the area's history and adds a unique touch to the living areas, grounding the space with its specific context and past.
55 Brighton
Featuring Oyster Grey Wirecut
See MoreTRANSCRIPT
00;00;00;02 - 00;00;05;13
Doug Pat (DP)
Let's go inside the vault. The design vault.
00;00;05;15 - 00;00;36;09
Rob Clocker (RC)
This collection of blocks has several landscaped alleys to help connect people from front to back. So having pedestrian connections through the block were an important part of the planning of the project. The project itself is a fairly typical four and five stories of housing overtop of a parking podium kind of housing project, which you see all over the country.
But we had hoped to blend it in with the neighborhood, of course, and so had to find ways to tie it together.
00;00;36;11 - 00;03;34;04
DP
This is my guest, Rob Clocker. I'll share more about him shortly in this episode from The Design Vault. We highlight Rob's project, 55 Brighton Avenue in Boston, Massachusetts. 55 Brighton is a mixed use commercial project that marks the completion of the Packard Crossing housing development in the Allston neighborhood of Boston. The building transforms a once underutilized site that previously housed retail and parking lots.
Transform the site into a vibrant and sustainable addition to the community. The architecture pays homage to the area's manufacturing heritage. The design concept reflects the vibrant streetscape patterns and automotive detailing. The building contains nearly 100,000 square feet of finished space, with an additional 70,000 square feet allocated to structured parking. The project reinterprets the rhythms and scale of the surrounding block, while paying homage to the area's automotive heritage.
The facade, with its distinctive folded fan like design, draws nostalgic inspiration from the wing tails of iconic 1950s automobiles. This design move prompted by the adjacent historic Packard Manufacturing facility. The brick details tie into the fabric of the neighborhood and add warmth and familiarity. While metal panels at the top floor create a dynamic visual contrast to the brick facade.
The complex embraces sustainable design strategies and materials such as low flow fixtures, solar panels and groundwater recharge. Hi, I'm Doug Pat and this is Design Vault. Hi. Rob Clocker holds a master of architecture degree from MIT and an undergraduate degree in architecture from the University of Virginia. Previously a senior associate at Perkins and Will in San Francisco. He's now a vice president and managing principal at Hacin, an award winning interdisciplinary architecture and design firm in Boston.
With 30 years of experience and award winning renovation and new construction projects. Rob's worked on buildings from office towers to land ports of entry. During his time in Hacin, he completed the Whitney Hotel in Beacon Hill, The IIDA New England award winning ideas. Cambridge Public Garden Townhouse and 55 Brighton Avenue. He's also managing the ongoing mixed use development at 41 Berkeley Street.
As an advocate for stewardship of the built environment, he's spoken on adaptive reuse and sustainable design. Rob is a registered architect, LEED accredited professional and member of the Ipswich Zoning Board of Appeals. So welcome, Rob. It's nice to have you with us today. So tell us a little bit about Hacin Architecture and Design firm in Boston. So where are you guys located in the city?
What's the size of the firm? How long have you been around and what type of architectural and design work do you do?
00;03;34;07 - 00;04;42;16
RC
Thank you, Doug. It's really great to be here with you. Hacin is, as you mentioned, an interdisciplinary design firm where 35 people we take the word interdisciplinary pretty seriously. We have architects, we have interior designers, we have visual and graphic designers. And we think of that because as a concept driven firm, we like to take the idea of the design all the way from the outside of the architecture to the inside and throughout to the entire experience.
The firm is located in the south end of Boston, which is one of Boston's many historic neighborhoods. It was founded 30 years ago by our founding principal. David Hacin started at his dining room table and gradually built up to the 35 people we have today. And all that time has been in the South end. So in some sense, we're a neighborhood architecture firm.
In another sense, we think we've learned how to build buildings and do design in places that people love in ways that they recognize. We like to joke that the buildings we build are ones we ourselves are going to have to live with ten, 20, 30 years from now.
00;04;42;19 - 00;04;47;03
DP
So you were at Perkins and well, for a little while and then ultimately found Hacin.
00;04;47;05 - 00;05;36;12
RC
It's a little bit of a convoluted story but yes, those are the facts. My career trajectory had me moving across the country four times to California and back to Boston, and I did each of those moves twice. But the last time when I was in California, I worked with Perkins and Will, and that experience was quite formative in terms of some of the things we may be talking about today because we were an outgrowth of another local firm in San Francisco, which did a lot of adaptive reuse work.
And in that role, I was able to learn surprisingly quite a bit about Brick, even though we were in San Francisco, where you don't think of that as a building material. And there's quite a bit of historic architecture out there, as you might imagine. So learning to work in that context set the stage for some of the projects I do today.
00;05;36;15 - 00;05;47;25
DP
So you've been Hacin how seen relative to all of the other things that you've done in the practice of architecture?
00;05;47;27 - 00;06;31;12
RC
My current role, which is relatively new one, starting as of last year, I'm managing principal of the firm, our founding principal, after 30 years, and a lot of growth, decided that it would be a good idea to get a new batch of principals. So we have five of us now, in addition to David Hacin and as the managing principal.
My job, of course, is to try to help us stay focused on the business side of the practice, which, as you may know, as an architect, isn't the most fun part. However, it does matter tremendously, and I like to think of it as fundamental to helping us do the great design work we do, because ultimately, if we don't do good business work, we're not going to be able to do great design work.
00;06;31;15 - 00;06;37;25
DP
So true. So let's dig in here and talk a little bit about the project. How did you guys get the work?
00;06;37;27 - 00;07;38;12
RC
Sure. As with many projects in Boston, it's a very much relationship based city. This owner, the Hamilton Company, is old company and one of the largest landlords in Boston founded by Harold Brown. And in that very neighborhood that the project exists, we developed a relationship with them and they reached out to us specifically because they understood that we knew how to fit new buildings into existing neighborhoods, as well as to help owners like this company navigate the sometimes complex approvals process, which you find in many East Coast cities.
And Boston is certainly one that has its web of interested parties in every project. The Hamilton Company, however, because of being a longstanding company, has very good relationships with the neighborhood, with neighborhood association owns as well as the city. And so it was a good partnership in coming up with a design that would appeal to a lot of different factions.
00;07;38;14 - 00;07;45;19
DP
So tell us a little bit about the site, the history of the location, what was there and what you guys ultimately built.
00;07;45;21 - 00;08;45;14
RC
This site, which is an area called Packard's Crossing, which is so named because originally it was a location of a Packard car manufacturing plant, is a mixed use site. It has a lot of Boston rowhouses that go further down the street from our location. But the location of the particular project did have some of those more industrial uses.
And in the more recent years it had been transformed somewhat into parking lots and some low rise retail in ways that weren't necessarily sensitive to the neighborhood. As it happens, one of those buildings was the owners primary headquarters, and so it was a very near and dear to them that they do something on this site, which was good.
And because this was their headquarters, they owned numerous properties that adjoins. So they undertook a master planning process with us to think about how they could not only develop a 55 Brighton but 83 Gardiner, which is nearby and tie it all together in a sensitive way.
00;08;45;17 - 00;08;51;19
DP
So what was the ultimate scope and what were the programmatic requirements for the project? The building you designed.
00;08;51;21 - 00;09;52;29
RC
The program for 55 Brighton, on the face of it, is a fairly straightforward program. It's 77 rental units, a housing and parking garage for that housing as well as retail that would line Brighton Avenue, which is a mixed use street. The more interesting or maybe effective overlay of that program is that this collection of blocks has several landscaped alleys to help connect people from front to back.
The streets in this neighborhood aren't necessarily as frequent as some city streets are. And so having pedestrian connections through the block were an important part of the planning of the project, as well as part of the approvals for the project. And the project itself is a fairly typical four and five stories of housing overtop of a parking podium kind of housing project, which you see all over the country.
But we had hoped to blend it in with the neighborhood, of course, and so had to find ways to tie it together.
00;09;53;01 - 00;10;20;18
DP
Yeah, it's an interesting building. So you guys had to do a bunch of things with the architect. Sure. You used a lot of masonry out there, various colors, but the brick patterning and specifically stylistically the building facade as it sort of peels away in a number of locations. Very interesting. So the building's contemporary, particularly the cantilevered folding panels, and yet you utilize brick and various traditional patterns and colors.
So tell us a little bit about that.
00;10;20;21 - 00;12;26;05
RC
Sure. Our approach to the design of the facade, especially on Brighton Avenue, was the kind we take to many of our projects, which is to look carefully at the context. We look at not only what's built today, but what was built in the neighborhood previously and of course, like many of these traditional neighborhoods, there's a strong rhythm of bays and of brick along the street, which on one hand we wanted to pick up some kind of rhythm, but on the other hand, we certainly didn't want to just mimic it.
That's always the challenge we have as designers is how do we build something for today in a neighborhood from yesterday? So what we chose to do in this case, as you mentioned, is we peel the brick facade back in a regular rhythm of bays, which echoes those bays further down the street. But we do it in a way that isn't just your traditional symmetrical bay.
It lifts the facade apart in a sense. So when you're looking at it from one direction, you see a rhythm of brick bays. When you look at it from the other direction, it looks like a number of vertical metal turrets that are more reflective of what you see beyond because in that direction you're looking towards downtown, where you see a lot of the towers of downtown Boston.
So that was an important design aspect as well that you had a different experience of this building from one direction than you do from the other. And then one other aspect of that design choice has to do with how brick is used today. We no longer build load bearing brick walls. There's a lot of reasons for that, as much as we love them, but there are many, many load bearing brick walls in Boston.
So when we peel these elements back, we're just using face brick cavity wall construction like you see on all contemporary construction. But we wrapped it around, so it's the thickness of a load bearing wall, but you can still see that it's suspended in there. It's a little bit of a tongue in cheek acknowledgment of it's both symbolic of a load bearing material, but also it's being used in a way that's contemporary as a way to clad the building and give it a sense of identity.
00;12;26;08 - 00;12;37;26
DP
So let's back up just for a second. I always like to ask the architects about the project restrictions they had in regard to zoning or historical requirements. Could you talk a little bit about that?
00;12;37;28 - 00;12;45;19
RC
This project, like everywhere in Boston, as I mentioned, we have a robust approvals process for any larger projects.
00;12;45;19 - 00;12;50;06
DP
I like the word robust, it's very respectful.
00;12;50;13 - 00;13;49;06
RC
All the intentions are good. Sometimes it can become complex. Of course, this project is larger than would have normally been allowed by the underlying zoning, so it went through this process to approve a larger building and part of those approvals then have a lot to do with review of the design to make sure that the design is going to mitigate the scale of the building fit into the neighborhood in ways that we hope we've been able to be successful here, and that also there are elements to the design which contribute to the neighborhood, which gets back to some of those connections in the landscaping that I mentioned.
And as it happens on top of the rear of the building on one level, up on the parking is an extensively landscaped courtyard which is made for the residents of the building. So to this approval, we of course, had to meet with neighborhood groups. We had to go through numerous public hearings and we think we reached a place where all parties felt like there was a good compromise with this building.
00;13;49;08 - 00;13;51;14
DP
So was there a historical review.
00;13;51;20 - 00;14;02;26
RC
In this particular neighborhood? Interestingly enough, there was not a historic district review. This piece of Boston, although it has a lot of buildings from long ago, is not a designated landmark district.
00;14;02;28 - 00;14;27;09
DP
Interesting. Yeah, I thought the notion of showing this facade as it peels away as a thick masonry wall, this kind of tongue in cheek reference to historic architecture is really interesting. A great idea. Tell us a little bit about the building and plan. It looks like a giant rectangle, and yet you've done an awful lot with the facade and the undulations in the forms.
00;14;27;11 - 00;16;39;13
RC
That's one simple thing about the building is that the site is a rectangle, which we don't get a lot of those in Boston. So we were excited about that. But the housing portion component is an L-shape because as you know, with multifamily housing, there's a dimension which plays itself out really well. The rectangle of the footprint of the building has to do with the parking.
So the front of that is lined with retail on the building lobby. And then above that is the two lengths of the L-shaped housing. What we did with that then is to articulate those different volumes. That's also where we turn to the brick patterning to identify the different areas of the building. And we had to do this though, within some constraints of course, because this is a rental building and the owners wanted to keep the housing reasonably affordable.
So all of the brick we use is actually just standard modular brick, which means it's the kind of brick that we love because it's easy to lay out. It creates an eight inch by eight inch grid on the building and to be creative with modular brick, we had to do things like turn the brick on its side, create soldier courses and find ways to push the brick inward and outwards to create shadow lines.
And one of the aspects of these fins on the front of the building that we've been talking about is that they actually curve outward from the main facade. But we wanted to achieve this curve without buying any special bricks. And when the contractors did their mock up and brought it out in the sun, everybody to our horror, recognized that it was creating all kinds of jagged shadows because the bricks were rectangular and they were trying to create a curve in order to help them with that.
We actually went back to our drawings. We laid out the coursing of those brick courses and created them some full sized brick causing diagrams, which the Masons then used. They relayed out the mockups and it came out looking smooth. And this was one of those cases where what we love about Brick is it depends so much on the Masons and their desire and skill to make things work.
And that back and forth really, I think made the building much better.
00;16;39;16 - 00;17;04;29
DP
So let's start with the parameters for building materials. When you guys got rolling, did you just decide, Well, Boston's got a lot of bricks, so that's what we're going to use for the majority of the building. And then talk a little bit more about some of these coursing tapes that you use, because I did see some soldier coursing.
I saw some regular type of courses. And then, of course, there are all kinds of strategies to create shadow lines in the facade underneath the windows, etc..
00;17;05;01 - 00;18;17;23
RC
Yeah, the decision to use brick, as you say, dug was a pretty foregone conclusion. We were working in a block where all of the existing buildings, the historic buildings were brick, and it's the kind of material that really helps bring identity to the building in a way that people feel like fits with Boston. This was an idea that sometimes we fight as designers, we think we want to do something new in this city that's all made out of bricks.
But I think over time we've come to recognize that the fact of Brick in Boston is one that's time tested. It's one that brings identity to the place. And so we accepted it fairly quickly and then set out to figure out, well, how do we create different proportions, different forms, and articulate the building with these bricks as well as bring different colors to it.
So it's not all just red brick. We did use a much darker brick for the base of the building, which helps ground the building helps those bays feel like they're floating up above. And then in the courtyard we use some yellow brick, which is not what you see from the street. It gives you some variation for the expression of the building and also brightens up that space.
00;18;17;25 - 00;18;24;20
DP
Could you tell us a little bit more about the coursing types and the strategies to create shadow lines in the facade?
00;18;24;23 - 00;19;10;10
RC
Yes, we were constrained to using just regular shaped bricks. One of the coursing techniques we used was to help with the rhythm of the windows of the building. With housing, you get repetitive windows because we want to use the same kind of windows and we have repetitive apartment units. However, we wanted to create some different scale to those windows, and we use this by creating brick panels which frame some of the windows and help the windows appear to create larger patterns on the facade.
And in these brick patterns, we simply stacked the bricks and then pushed every other brick inward by about an inch, which created this nice textured shadow line, which gave it a little bit of depth similar to the depth the window had. That was one of the techniques we used to help give the building some life.
00;19;10;12 - 00;19;28;08
DP
So it's also interesting you guys ended up doing mock ups, which we all as architects end up seeing in the field an awful lot of times when we're using a lot of masonry or when things get complex. How did you do the drawings? The architectural drawings, were there 3D, was it BIM modeling, was it 2D?
00;19;28;10 - 00;20;38;26
RC
On this project, like many of our projects, we have both a design model and then a construction model. So early on we built the building and sketch up that lets us study forms colors fairly quickly and do variations to help dial in some of the aspects of the building which are going to be most conducive to the design as well as lets us be flexible with some of the city approvals processes when different requirements are brought up around the design development phase, though, we certainly built the same model in Revit and that becomes the actual construction model and Revit is where we really get into the brick detailing.
We don't draw every single brick, although we sometimes like our clients to think we're doing that. We use a combination of patterns on the surface of the model, which are very accurate to the brick module with certain areas where we will go in and manually layout the coursing because we know it needs to work in a certain way.
And so we do love using these tools. They really help us make sure that what we draw is what the Masons are going to be able to build.
00;20;38;28 - 00;21;01;25
DP
Yeah, I was really surprised when I was looking at the photographs, the peeling facade, if you will, these fan like projections. There was one photograph I looked at and you can actually start to see the curve the way the brick is manipulated in the facade. So it's not a hard line. I did not expect that when I saw that photograph.
That must have been really interesting to see worked out in the field.
00;21;01;27 - 00;22;01;22
RC
It was very interesting to see worked out in the field. That curve, however simple it seemed to us, was actually somewhat difficult for the Masons to achieve. They did do a mock up of that curve, which was not successful initially because when they laid out that mock up and put it in the sun, we saw immediately that the corners of the bricks were shadowing over top of each other, that they were struggling to make sure the crossing was smooth.
And so we went back to our drawings and we laid out each course a brick for them and printed a full sized drawing of that, causing to have them give that a try because we use the geometry of the curve to lay out where the corners should fall. Then when the Masons used that template and rebuilt the mockup, it actually came out quite smooth, which is the result you see today.
And we're actually kind of excited because that's a 20 degree change in plain between the face of the building and those projections, and it's achieved in two and a half courses of brick.
00;22;01;25 - 00;22;03;16
DP
My gosh, that's incredible.
00;22;03;19 - 00;22;08;04
RC
Flat bricks too. So we didn't have to buy curved bricks, which nobody likes to do.
00;22;08;06 - 00;22;16;15
DP
Did you do that by making the radius larger for that curve rather than having a smaller radius? Am I understanding that correctly?
00;22;16;17 - 00;22;37;28
RC
It was almost simpler than that. The radius didn't change. It's just which parts of the brick touched the radius needed to be adjusted because the Masons were having the corners and the flats of the bricks that were of course with each other overlapping in a way that cast shadows. And if we just moved those back, the shadows faded away.
00;22;38;04 - 00;22;44;01
DP
Very cool. So how many people were on the team working on the building over time?
00;22;44;03 - 00;23;10;16
RC
From the start of the project, we had just a couple of people. We had our project manager, Jeff Brown, as well as a couple of junior designers helping with the various models and presentations. By the time we got to CDs, there were five of us putting the drawings together and then for construction it was down back to just two of us getting through the various needs of the construction site.
00;23;10;18 - 00;23;14;23
DP
And how long was the process start to finish, including reviews.
00;23;14;25 - 00;23;42;12
RC
These kind of projects, tt's always interesting to answer that question because we've been working on this site with this owner for over ten years. This project was in the queue to it's the biggest one on the site, but it was one of the last ones we did with them. So the early ideas for it were probably seven or eight years ago.
But by the time we started the actual design, that took a little over a year and a half, then the construction took about two and a half years.
00;23;42;14 - 00;23;51;03
DP
So I love to ask architects if there was anything interesting through the design and construction process that you guys learned that was kind of new to you?
00;23;51;05 - 00;24;55;27
RC
Yeah, I think this project probably one of the more interesting and challenging but creative aspects of the project is that this client is their own developer and their own contractor. They are the ones who both financed the building and built the building, but they did hire us to design the building and of course hired the subcontractors to build the building with them.
But there were many times when you're working with a client who is building their own buildings that they are in a hurry because they figured they know what they're doing and they want to move forward and so very often we would find ourselves kind of rushing to stay, keep up with them. And what I think was an important lesson for us or something we were glad about is that we did take the time to do a really strong set of drawings during the design phase so that every time the client tried to get ahead of us, we had a good set of documents to help them not get into trouble.
That's not always the case. Sometimes clients will hurry you through the design with the thought that during construction you can figure out some more of the details.
00;24;56;00 - 00;25;00;24
DP
So the project wasn't bid out then to a contractor or it was?
00;25;00;27 - 00;25;11;02
RC
The project was not bid out to a general contractor because the general contractor was the client. However, they did bid out all of the different trades, including the masonry trades.
00;25;11;04 - 00;25;15;01
DP
So it was an extraordinarily thorough set by the time you guys were done.
00;25;15;08 - 00;25;19;17
RC
We did have a very strong set of drawings which always makes us happy and protects us.
00;25;19;19 - 00;25;32;24
DP
Makes things a little easier down the road. So, Rob, you've been an architect for a while. Based on what you know today about being an architect, do you have any words of advice for your younger self or even young architects coming down the pike?
00;25;32;27 - 00;25;56;13
RC
Sure. I think one of the pieces of advice I have learned over the career is it really matters to trust in the simplicity of design and to keep things basic. You may think, as I did as a young designer, that you need to add a lot of ideas and things like Brick are boring. But actually if you just stick with the basics, you can come up with quite an elegant solution.
00;25;56;15 - 00;26;33;06
DP
Yeah, I always find that interesting, this idea that when you have limitations or parameters, many times young people think, Well, I'm not going to be able to do anything creative inside of this notion that things should be simple or minimal in some way. And yet I think that is the key to creating things that have never been done before.
Perhaps I love this idea that when I'm given lots of restrictions, I still have to be, I still want to be creative. So I think that ties a little bit into what you just said.
00;26;33;09 - 00;26;54;11
RC
I completely agree. I think something else we find about trying to stick with the basics is very often when you're trying to tell a story and come up with a concept which other people can understand, you really have to stick to the story and stick to the basics. And so these rules were made for a reason and they're really great to flex and learn from.
00;26;54;14 - 00;27;03;24
DP
Well, Rob, thank you very much for being with us today. And thanks for your time. Where can people go to learn more about Hacin Architecture and Design and yourself?
00;27;03;26 - 00;27;21;20
RC
Thank you, Doug. It's been a great pleasure to be here today. And you can go to www.Hacin.com to learn about us or come to Boston's South End. And we're always happy to give people a tour of both our projects and a lot of the great historic architecture in Boston.
00;27;21;22 - 00;27;27;28
DP
Well, thanks again, Rob. Beautiful project. Congratulations. And we'll see you around Boston.
00;27;28;01 - 00;27;31;10
RC
Thank you, Doug.
You May Also Be Interested In
We Can Help With Your Next Project
Discover the latest + greatest in design trends, industry news & pro tips from pros.
For all of your project needs, you’ll find everything you need at a Supply Center.
Let Us Know How We Can Help!
Design Vault Ep. 27 389 Weirfield with Tom Loftus
ABOUT THE ARCHITECT:
![]()
|
Tom’s first exposure to working in the architectural field came from working in wood-frame construction. His passion for the industry grew, and he soon realized that as an architect he would be afforded more creative license to design structures that would have a lasting impact on the community. Tom brings over 14 years of project management experience to the team at Aufgang. Prior to joining the firm, he spent several years at various other firms in the city and Westchester County, where he gained experience leading the development of projects ranging from single family residential units to multi-family mid-rise structures and interiors. As Studio Director at Aufgang, Tom is a leader in all aspects of project development – from designing the beginning concept, to overseeing the project through the construction process to completion. He has extensive knowledge and experience in project management, schematic design, project design development, construction drawings, design quality, and project construction. He is also a leader in building and maintaining client relationships, managing team’s workloads, and client and consultant coordination. Tom is a firm believer in the powerful role that technology plays in design, and avidly follows the latest technology trends as inspiration for efficient and innovative designs. |
---|
ABOUT THE PROJECT:
389 Weirfield Street is a 12-story, 50,100 GSF rental project consisting of 66 residential units with 66 parking spaces, with 46 market rate and 20 affordable rate units, and including a common roof deck, library, half court, exterior seating, huddle rooms, café, and amenity room. This building was constructed along with 378 Weirfield St., located across the street. The amenities of both buildings are available to both buildings’ residents.

TRANSCRIPT
00;00;00;02 - 00;00;05;13
Doug Pat (DP)
Let's go inside the vault. The design vault.
00;00;05;16 - 00;00;27;11
Tom Loftus (TL)
So we really had to be mindful of availability of product and the budget. So this is what started driving us to start playing with different bonding patterns. If we stack the brick one way versus another way, if we do a running bond versus a stack bond versus a Flemish bond, how can we play around with our stacking patterns and try to make something unique?
00;00;27;13 - 00;02;46;23
DP
This is my guest, Tom Loftus. I'll share more about him shortly. In this episode from the Design Vault, we highlight Tom's 389 Weirfield Project in Brooklyn, New York. 389 Weirfield in Brooklyn is a 12 story 50,000 square foot rental project consisting of 66 residential units, a common roof deck, library and cafe. The building was constructed along with a second at 378 Weirfield just across the street.
The building features a very unique singular masonry facade we'll discuss today. The sole decorative facade is done in undulating rail like bricks, which is in a creative vertical design. The bricks are dark and called Ebonite Smooth. They protrude in patterns at equally spaced cadence as the facade climbs. The windows are set apart from the vertical masonry bands with frames of varying height, which capture the windows between the horizontal spans. The singular brick facade was a unique way of setting apart a building that might otherwise be much like any other.
Hi, I'm Doug Pat and this is Design Vault. Tom Loftus has a bachelor degree in architecture from New York Institute of Technology. He also has a certificate in business management from Cornell University and is a licensed architect in New York.
Tom's first exposure to working in the architectural field came from a job in wood frame construction. After a number of years working in Westchester County, he brings over 20 years of project management experience to outgoing architects. As studio director, he has extensive knowledge and experience in project management, schematic design, design, development, construction drawings, design quality and project construction.
He's also a leader in building and maintaining client relationships, managing teams’ workloads, plus client and consultant coordination. So welcome, Tom. It's nice to have you with us today. So tell us a little bit about Aufgang Architects in Suffern New York. So where are you guys located in Suffern? What's the size of the firm? How long has it been around and what kind of work do you guys do?
00;02;47;01 - 00;03;37;20
TL
Great, first and foremost. Thanks a lot, Doug, for having me on the podcast today. I'm really excited to be here. So we're located here in downtown Suffern, right down the street from the train station pretty close to central Manhattan. So our firm is about 50 people right now. We primarily do residential work. I'd say about 90% of our work is in the residential field.
We do everything from low rise to high rise buildings, primarily in the five boroughs. But we also have projects in the tri state area and a few scattered around the country as well. A lot of those projects are mixed use with commercial on the first, second or few floors and then residential apartments above. The residential work that we do ranges in everything from luxury condos all the way to homeless shelters and really a range of everything in between.
00;03;37;22 - 00;03;39;28
DP
So how long has Aufgang Architects been around?
00;03;40;05 - 00;04;19;22
TL
Outgoing has been around. I think we're going about 50 years now. Ari is the third owner of the company, and when I started, I worked together with Ari and our former principal, Hugo, and they partnered for a while and he had also taken over the firm from someone else. So probably in the early seventies, if I have my history of the firm correct.
We started in Rockland County doing small scale residential rehab work and grew in time and in size with our clients and our work type from one partner to the next, and really have kept our foot in our roots in residential and then grown laterally in the industry.
00;04;19;25 - 00;04;27;22
DP
Tom, tell us a little bit about yourself. How long have you been practicing architecture and your role as studio director?
00;04;27;25 - 00;05;16;29
TL
Sure. It feels like forever. Honestly, every once in a while I wonder, am I still really doing this? But I've been in the architecture field now just a little over 20 years, and I started working in Westchester County. Small scale wood frame, residential. It was a natural stepping stone for me. After I got out of high school, I thought I want to be a framer.
And after getting really tired of carrying three quarter inch plywood up a ladder, I said, Nope, time to go back to school and study architecture. And from there I worked at a variety of firms in Manhattan, in Westchester County, doing a variety of different work. And when I found this firm, the scale work that we were doing, the residential work, it tied into something I loved with my single family housing experience.
It kind of stuck and I ended up staying here for quite a while.
00;05;17;01 - 00;05;23;25
DP
It's a long time practicing as an architect. I kind of say the same thing about or to myself about how long it's been.
00;05;23;27 - 00;06;23;12
TL
Sure, I've really grown in the company here. It's been a fantastic partnership with Ari. When I started, I came in really as an assistant project manager. A lot of my experience was not relative to the scale of the projects we were doing, although in other firms I was working in a bit of a leadership role running point on smaller scale projects, so it took a little time to learn the ropes, if you will, in the different construction types.
And I've moved up into the role of studio director now, so I work very closely with our senior management and the rest of our senior staff looking at our workload, our resource management, project proposals, client relationships and really stay involved with the team from the very start of the project until close out to handle the day to day operations of the office as a whole.
Ari, myself and our controller meet frequently to talk about some of the more boring business side of things and then the more fun happens working with the architects on the day to day and the projects.
00;06;23;15 - 00;06;33;19
DP
So let's dig in here and talk about this very interesting facade of yours. How did your office get the project, or is this a project that the office created?
00;06;33;21 - 00;07;57;02
TL
Yeah, this was actually an interesting project that came at a time when everything started shutting down right at the start of the COVID pandemic. And we had a really good recommendation from a long time client that we had worked with, and we had met a new client remotely who was involved on the construction side of things, and we hit it off.
We started talking and it was the first time ever that I met someone virtually and had meetings like this on screens, and we were trying to build a new professional working relationship. So it was very unique in the way that the project started. And again, we do a lot of our work really based on recommendations. We really pride ourselves in building good relationships with our client base, and that's really how the project got started.
They had this unique property in Bushwick and if you know the area in Brooklyn at all, it's a lot of small scale row housing, if you will, maybe 3 to 4 storeys and there really aren't too many open lots. And in this particular project it was unique. There was a large portion of the lot that had an easement that couldn't be built on it, and it provided a good amount of air rights which allowed us to follow the zoning path to do a much taller building than you usually would see in this neighborhood.
Most of the buildings were very close together, and that's really how it started and how the project grew and how we ended up with a 12 storey building in the middle of Bushwick.
00;07;57;05 - 00;08;04;19
DP
So did you guys know right away that you were going to be able to make a tall building there, or did it take a little bit of examination first?
00;08;04;21 - 00;08;48;13
TL
It took a little bit of examination. Usually what we do as architects is we really try to help guide our clients to bring their projects to fruition. This is the property I have. What can you build? How much can you build? There are two different zoning parts you can follow, primarily three different zoning parts in New York City that will help you establish the bulk, the height, the size of the building.
So we'll study that first and foremost with our clients and present them the different options. And based on the geometry of this lot, when we saw the potential to get a little height on this building, be separated from the other surrounding residential buildings, it gave them a nice opportunity to have a building with some great potential for views in an otherwise low height area.
00;08;48;15 - 00;08;53;12
DP
So what was the scope and the programmatic requirements for the project once you got rolling?
00;08;53;14 - 00;09;32;03
TL
Typically and specifically to this project, our scope was everything from working with the development team to help them flush out the parameters of their funding program. So when you work with different agencies in New York City and in the state and you're following certain guidelines to provide certain square footages and distribution of units, we work right at the very beginning with them to help them find the right mix and size of units, right with the development team.
From there, we work through design and construction administration all the way until the close of the project. So we really gave soup to nuts services here. Full scope on the building.
00;09;32;05 - 00;09;48;24
DP
So let's talk a little bit about the building design stylistically. So you guys designed quite a unique facade, while the other three facades, from what I can tell from the photos, are relatively subdued. Tell us about the main idea behind this.
00;09;48;26 - 00;11;17;22
TL
First and foremost, we love Brick. Brick as an architect, for us, it's really a timeless material and it's a durable material and it fits in really well to so many different urban fabrics in so many different places. In my opinion, what made 389 unique was the timing that this project was happening. It was happening at a time where the future was uncertain.
We didn't know what was going to come of this pandemic. We had to be incredibly mindful of the budget. Many times we like to create building facades that are two different materials having a nice dialog or different color bricks. So we really had to be mindful of availability of product and the economics, the budget, and really try to come up with something that would be unique but be something that the client could achieve.
So this is what started driving us to start playing with different bonding patterns if we stacked the brick one way versus another way, if we do a running bond versus a stack bond versus a Flemish bond, how can we play around with our stack in patterns and try to make something unique? So that was really what started pushing us in this direction of going with a single color brick and then really focusing on how to find a challenge enough for the mason that they don't hate us and say these are architects of the worst.
Have something be achievable for them. But that also will give a nice unique context to the neighborhood.
00;11;17;25 - 00;11;24;28
DP
Were there any aesthetic reviews of the building before you guys got rolling with the city?
00;11;24;28 - 00;11;49;21
TL
With the city for this particular project, there were no agencies on the city or state side that had any reason to opine on the design. We were not going for any variances. We didn't really have to go to the community board, although we did not need their aesthetic approvals. It is something that we're always mindful of working within the urban fabric and how it's going to lend itself to the context of the neighborhood is always an important consideration of ours.
00;11;49;23 - 00;12;01;09
DP
So let's back up just a little bit. So the building plan, are we talking rectangle, square, relatively straightforward. Then of course, there's parking on the site. You had said that there was a portion of the site that you could not build on.
00;12;01;11 - 00;13;07;01
TL
That's correct. So for this particular massing to make this building work, the footprint was rather small. It actually made a very efficient floor plate with a very tight core of stairs, elevator and corridor, and then apartments around all sides of that. So it really became a very compact, high efficiency floor plate with very little loss factor. And it was something that we were able to just work all the way up the building.
So there were quite a bit of revisions back and forth, variations that we had worked on to find the right mix and balance of that to fit within the envelope. The same thing then translated to the facade a bit earlier we were talking about what did the design iterations look like there, through the whole process of finding the right solution and the facade design that we felt was the right match for this building.
We did digital 3D models, plenty of sketches and even on site mockups working together with the Masons saying, We know you can do this, we believe in you, please don't kill us. And did plenty of mock ups there to really work it out.
00;13;07;03 - 00;13;11;25
DP
Was it a challenge finding a good mason, or did you guys have somebody lined up right off the bat?
00;13;11;27 - 00;14;04;09
TL
I think that's really one of the keys. You have to have really good subs. So whatever the type of work you're doing in this case, the Masons, you need to have a good working relationship with them. And often it's the architect working directly with the general contractor. But in these cases we invited the Masons into the architecture meetings, we invited them into the AOC meetings towards the end and said, Look, let's work through some of these details.
Let's talk through it. How is this going to work? It wasn't incredibly complex or challenging, but we wanted to make sure that the person who was directing their team to install the Brick really felt confident that they could achieve what we were looking for. We never wanted to come out on site and say, This is all wrong. That's not what we want to do.
And I really think engaging with those professionals early on is important to try to get the end result that you're looking for.
00;14;04;12 - 00;14;16;20
DP
Yeah, we try to bring in a contractor at schematic design. Once we wrap up schematic design, we have them price the project. This is in high and residential work that I do. So single family homes.
00;14;16;22 - 00;14;33;09
TL
Right? And in this case we didn't have a mason lined up. We didn't have a recommendation. The developer slash contractor, they were one and the same here. They had already had an existing relationship with this Mason and we started just working with them early on in the process.
00;14;33;11 - 00;14;54;17
DP
So could you do your best to describe the evolution of the design of that facade and then try to describe the facade? I'm going to encourage our listeners to go to the Glen-Gery site and take a look at some of these photographs because it's really striking. I've never seen anything like it. It's a great idea. The clients must have been thrilled when you presented the drawings.
00;14;54;19 - 00;17;33;18
TL
Thank you very much for that. We've seen a lot of example of brick facade that has quite a bit of movement in it, and these brick facades more often than not, are panelized prefab, and that's a way that you can achieve quite a bit of movement with brick using this idea of this undulation and this movement in the brick as an inspiration.
That's what triggered us to start thinking about how a brick pattern, the stacking pattern, really might help us achieve what we wanted to do here. So if our listeners are familiar with Brick parents, which I hope they are, we're in a brick podcast, we utilized a Flemish bond pattern and a running bond pattern. So the Flemish bond pattern has a standard brick with the long face.
The following brick is then rotated 90 degrees with the short face and the pattern is repeated. Taking this idea of combining a Flemish bond pattern with a running bond pattern, we now have these bricks that are half size, if you will, square proportion to create the movement and the undulation throughout the facade. We detailed a Flemish bond pattern with a large number of running bond, then a increasing increment of Flemish bond and a decreasing increment to running bond.
So we took the pattern and as you got closer to the center of the pattern we created, you had a higher frequency of Flemish bond. And as you moved away towards the end of the pattern that moved vertically up the building, it was stretched out with more running bond. So that's a lot of back and forth with different bond patterns.
Ultimately, by having that Flemish bond brick, we then protruded it out from the facade in the center of the pattern where the Flemish bond patterns are stacked very closely together. The bricks protruded the largest amount. And then as that pattern was separated and pulled apart from top to bottom, the brick became closer and closer to the facade.
So we basically created a formula that the mason can follow. For every increment, the brick would step out a half inch further, and this is what gave the facade that undulation, as you move up the bricks, steps out and back in by using this bonding pattern. It also created a really dynamic shadow which was something that we really loved.
When the sun hits the building the right way, you get a really fantastic shadow where you have that brick and it just really, in my opinion, created a beautiful cadence that worked through that pattern.
00;17;33;21 - 00;17;41;27
DP
So it really does remind one of Braille. So how far what's the furthest protrusion for one brick?
00;17;42;00 - 00;18;01;07
TL
I do like that description of Braille. You instantly have an image in your mind of these protruding points that they create the pattern. The furthest protrusion is about two and a half inches at the center of the pattern. And then as it works its way down in half inch increments, it goes back down to zero and the pattern becomes flush.
00;18;01;10 - 00;18;20;02
DP
So you guys said that you worked on this in 2D and in 3D. I would imagine if you did some sun studies, you got a better sense for how much shade and shadow was going to be produced by these protruding bricks? Did you do the project in BIM? Is it Revit? Because I saw 2D drawings of this?
00;18;20;04 - 00;18;42;25
TL
Yes. It isn't Revit. It is a BIM project. While we were in the design phase, we actually used a few different softwares SketchUp and Enscape and Revit along with AutoCAD, and we really did a series of 2D sketches, 2D drawings and 3D studies, partial facade studies. Just to get a sense of how this all might look.
00;18;42;28 - 00;18;49;26
DP
And how many iterations ultimately did you go through? I mean, big iterations, like is it two or three or ten or?
00;18;49;28 - 00;19;42;12
TL
Once we just came to the conclusion that we need to stick with a singular color brick here in the front, I'd say we probably had about ten different versions. It's a slim, tall building with very large windows, really trying to maintain a nice modulation of those windows in that spacing, but also then maintain a standardized brick dimension. So for a long time we were playing around with the inches of the bricks so that we were at a half size brick or full size brick.
Should we use a stack bond and emphasize the verticality of the building? How often should we introduce a horizontal element so that it's not looking like a stack of pancakes, for lack of a better expression? So really, we had a good amount of iterations here until we got to the point where we really like the running bond, Flemish bonds.
00;19;42;14 - 00;19;58;19
DP
I like the way you describe that. From what I remember looking at these photos, the windows are framed out differently. So you have a series of windows which have an individual frame, and then at one point in the building, that frame actually wraps a few stories of windows, right? So you break up the facade that way, too.
00;19;58;19 - 00;20;26;03
TL
Exactly. Playing with the verticality of the building, we did group a series of windows, two windows stacked vertically, three windows stacked vertically and created a frame around those windows. And this helped take that 12 story building and just give it a little bit of scale as it moved up the building. So these groups have two vertical windows that are now framed together.
Then also had the movement of the undulating brick happening between them.
00;20;26;05 - 00;20;28;28
DP
You guys really thought through it. It's a real beautiful facade.
00;20;29;04 - 00;20;29;29
TL
Thank you.
00;20;30;01 - 00;20;34;06
DP
So how big was the team that worked on the project? Just a few people?
00;20;34;08 - 00;21;17;08
TL
Every project is staffed with a dedicated associate director who are all registered architects, a project manager, and then the support staff. When we were in the design phase, we had the project manager working together with one of our designers. So we really had a team of to playing around with this and then bouncing the idea back off of the associate on the project.
Then once we really ramped it up into production, we would stack two or three people on the project. As you get closer to submission deadlines and trying to get into the Department of Buildings to get permits done, we would build the team up. Usually there was always at least two people on the project that were always there from day one.
They haven't left the project and they stayed on from beginning to end.
00;21;17;10 - 00;21;26;09
DP
So how long did it take to build the building? I would imagine it was pretty cool watching that facade go up. First couple stories. You must have been thinking, Wow, man, this is going to be something.
00;21;26;12 - 00;21;51;29
TL
You know, the construction team, they did a fantastic job. They had a really good crew out there. And around 24 months, the building went up and then all the fine details coming out of the pandemic. It was interesting. There were certain trades that just took longer because of materiality, distribution chain, supply chain, availability of product, which threw little curveballs here and there.
But all in all, the sequence and timing was fairly smooth.
00;21;52;01 - 00;22;01;13
DP
So it seems like I learned something new every project. Was there anything that you guys learned while you were out in the field or doing these drawings or dealing with the client?
00;22;01;16 - 00;22;48;06
TL
There certainly was. You know, I had spoken about the Mason earlier on, and that was certainly a good lesson. Building a good relationship with your Mason early in the project is really important and I joke about it. Sometimes they look at the architect's details and think, Are these guys crazy? We're not going to build this. There's going to be a better way to do it.
And I think that was really the big lesson we took here, establishing that good relationship and also giving the tradesmen the respect that they deserve. They're installing the work. They know some of the nuances of how this gets installed and taking that into consideration, finding that common ground so that you don't bring your ego into the conversation and giving them that professional respect and you're going to get it back.
That was definitely a good lesson here.
00;22;48;08 - 00;23;16;16
DP
That seems like a lesson I've learned over and over again throughout my career. When you're young, you go out there and you think you know everything and you've got an answer for everything, or you're going to fake your way through it, or however you choose to deal with it. But as you get older, you realize that these people that you're working with, many of them have an awful lot of experience, and it would be a good idea to sit and listen to them and actually ask them questions rather than tell them what to do.
00;23;16;18 - 00;23;38;10
TL
That's right. And I always find that working with our up and coming project managers and our younger staff, it's always those lessons that you try to instill in them. It helps them understand how to build those relationships because this industry is built on relationships and if we can do that, we're going to navigate successfully through any project.
00;23;38;13 - 00;23;58;03
DP
Well, you guys have been around a long time, 50 years. Goodness gracious. That's incredible. Congratulations, Tom. You've been an architect for over two decades. Based on what you know today about being an architect, do you have any words of advice for your younger self or maybe some young architects working their way up the ranks?
00;23;58;05 - 00;24;13;16
TL
Yes, don't worry. It's going to work out, if you love it, stick with it. It's a long road. And just when you think maybe you should change your major, you might still be out of college 20 years and asking yourself, Should I change my major? If you love it, stick with it. It's rewarding.
00;24;13;19 - 00;24;28;05
DP
That's really funny. I feel like I've changed my major all the time.
My goodness. So, Tom, it's been great to have you here. Thanks for your time. Where can people go to learn more about Wolfgang Architects and yourself?
00;24;28;07 - 00;24;38;19
TL
They can go right to our web site at Aufgang.com and they can find all the information about us there. They can follow us on LinkedIn and Twitter and all the different platforms.
00;24;38;21 - 00;24;45;21
DP
Well, thank you very much, Tom. It's been great. And I encourage people to go to the site and take a look at this very interesting building. Thank you.
00;24;45;29 - 00;24;50;18
TL
Doug. I really appreciate it. It was great chatting with you here today. I had a great time.
00;24;50;21 - 00;25;18;12
DP
Awesome. Thank you.
You May Also Be Interested In
We Can Help With Your Next Project
Discover the latest + greatest in design trends, industry news & pro tips from pros.
For all of your project needs, you’ll find everything you need at a Supply Center.
Let Us Know How We Can Help!
Design Vault Ep. 26 1 Java with Jeremy Iannucci
ABOUT THE ARCHITECT:
![]()
|
Born and raised in New York City, architect Jeremy Iannucci brings a design perspective that is deeply influenced by the city's ever-changing landscape. His architectural philosophy, founded on the potential of every effort he contributes to, is intricately woven with each site's narrative and heritage.
In addition to working at Marvel, Jeremy serves as a respected design critic at The City College of New York and Pratt Institute. Here, he seeks to both nurture emerging talent and build a larger, more informed design community.
|
---|
ABOUT THE PROJECT:
Goals / Project / Sustainability:
1 Java is a mixed-use residential building located in Greenpoint, Brooklyn, Marvel serves as the project’s design architect and master planner. The project responds to NYC housing market and owners needs, addressing: sustainability, constructability, risk mitigation, tax incentives, and marketability. The development investment strategy requires net-zero ready design and maximization of floor area, the project also includes the largest geothermal array in New York State. The building will participate in the 421a Affordable New York and Inclusionary Housing program, providing up to 261 affordable housing units out 871 total units. This project replaces the former two-story Jerome Motel, which had been used for supportive services. The S:US team offered relocation to current residents, while more than tripling the former site's capacity, responding to the city's housing needs.
Background:
The full city-block site incorporates the only privately-owned pier in NYC. Given the size of the development and the uniqueness of the site on Greenpoint’s East River, Marvel assessed the project from an urban design perspective and a street-level/local point of view. Marvel sought a cohesive design that also broke down the massing into more relatable elements and a more active street front. Unlike most of Brooklyn’s brownstone neighborhoods, Greenpoint housing was created for those who worked there. This is a neighborhood of workers - people who built and sustained the industries that thrived on the docks and in its industrial areas. Marvel’s approach to design involves a research-based process based on information gathering, analysis, engagement and outreach, to arrive at the best design solutions. Our process ensures that design responds to current issues, client, stakeholder, and community priorities, follows best practices while promoting innovation. Our multi-disciplinary team enables open conversations among the team and stakeholders, ensuring collaboration and consensus on design solutions. The research and analysis phase informs the Project Goals and Objectives, which are used as guidelines throughout the design process.
Features / Qualities:
• Acoustical separation (from exterior and between interior spaces)
• Enterprise Green Communities (sustainable initiative)
• LEED Gold
• Fitwel certified
• Net-zero ready
• Geothermal (ground-sourced heat pump)
• Thermally broken façade systems including brick, metal and concrete panel, and glazing systems
• Amenity spaces include lounges, fitness areas, Planted outdoor terraces, recreation areas, rooftop pool
• Landscaped rooftops
• Landscaped, publicly accessible waterfront park (designed by JCFO with MARVEL collaboration)
• Landscaped streetscapes with integrated resiliency (site is within the flood plain)
• Mixed-use with retail, townhomes, food and beverage offerings at grade
Finished Project:
The building rises from Greenpoint into two distinct towers which vary in plan and elevation (355’ and 205’) to maximize light, views, and openness as they mitigate the impact of tower height on the surrounding streets. Terraces on the east and west faces of the tower modulate the Greenpoint-facing and East River-facing elevations while creating private terraces for units and amenity spaces. Retail, food & beverage, live-work spaces and other community facing spaces are consolidated along West and India Streets. The existing circulation and commuter route reinforced by the India Street ferry service make locating the primary pedestrian residential entrance on India St. a natural choice. The pier, already an attractor, can be programmed as an extension of India St. and Waterfront Plaza experiences and increase 1 Java’s ability to become a year- round destination. Townhomes share setback stoops and a small secondary convenience lobby for the low-rise along Java Street. Java St will be marked by a quieter more private character leading from West St. to the waterfront. Services and vehicular access are oriented towards Java Street and reinforce India Street’s pedestrian character.


TRANSCRIPT
00;00;00;02 - 00;00;05;14
Doug Pat (DP)
Let's go inside the vault. The design vault.
00;00;05;17 - 00;00;30;22
Jeremy Iannucci (JI)
We like to think that the entire project comes from the community around it. We looked at a series of precedents in the Greenpoint neighborhood, historically in Greenpoint, specifically on the waterfront, to inspire the way that we detail these facades. We have a collection of different brick styles that help to break up the massing of the building, different articulations, as well as material breaks with the two precast towers.
00;00;30;25 - 00;03;22;21
DP
This is my guest, Jeremy Iannucci. I'll share more about him shortly. In this episode from The Design Vault, we highlight Marvel’s Project 1 Java in Greenpoint, Brooklyn. 1 Java is a mixed use residential series of buildings located in Greenpoint, Brooklyn. The project responds to the New York City housing market and owners' needs addressing sustainability, constructability, risk mitigation, tax incentives and marketability.
The Development Investment Strategy required a net zero ready design and maximization of floor area. The project includes the largest geothermal array in New York State. The building will participate in the 421A affordable New York and inclusionary housing program, which provides up to 261 affordable housing units out of a total of 871. The new architecture consists of two towers, of prefabricated concrete sheet panels and three lower buildings varying from 6 to 10 storeys with brick masonry facades.
All five buildings rise from Greenpoint in a U-shape plan to maximize light views and open space. Terraces on the east and west. Facades of the towers modulate the elevation while creating private terraces for units and amenity spaces. Retail, food and beverage and live workspaces are consolidated along West and India streets. Townhomes share setback stoops, and a small secondary convenience lobby for the low rise along Java Street.
Hi, I'm Doug Pat and this is Design Vault. Jeremy Iannucci is a registered architect at Marvel in New York City. He has a Bachelor of Architecture from City College's Spitzer School of Architecture. His portfolio encompasses a number of challenging endeavors at Marvel, including a mixed use project located in Brooklyn's Waterfront, which we will discuss today. Jeremy enjoys taking part in international design competitions, one of which was recently shortlisted in a competition to design a children's hospice center, and another was awarded an honorary mention in which he designed a house relying exclusively on daylighting for organizing spaces and form making.
Jeremy also serves as a design critic at the City College of New York and Pratt Institute. So welcome, Jeremy. It's nice to have you with us today. So tell us a little bit about Marvel in New York City. So where in the city are you located? What's the size of the firm? How long has it been around and what type of work do you guys do?
00;03;22;23 - 00;03;52;02
JI
Thank you so much for having me on. We are a New York firm. We also have offices in Puerto Rico, Richmond, Virginia, more recently, Barcelona. We're currently located in New York, in Tribeca, and around 200 people at this point. As far as projects that we take on, we like to say design everywhere for everyone. We don't try to limit ourselves to typology.
We take whatever comes at us. We measure everything against the values of the firm and we really just enjoy design.
00;03;52;05 - 00;03;58;21
DP
So tell us a little bit about yourself. How long have you been working as an architect and what's your role in the office?
00;03;58;23 - 00;04;08;27
JI
So in the office I really work through all stages of the project, through design, working on developing proposals, project delivery and currently in construction to administration.
00;04;08;29 - 00;04;13;06
DP
So this is a really beautiful project and it's extraordinarily large.
00;04;13;12 - 00;04;14;13
JI
Yes, it is.
00;04;14;15 - 00;04;17;06
DP
So how did your office get the project?
00;04;17;08 - 00;04;33;02
JI
So we were invited to participate in the RFP back in fall of 2020. So there was a few other notable firms in the competition. We were lucky enough to be awarded the project, and we've been working hand in hand with Lendlease in bringing it to fruition ever since.
00;04;33;05 - 00;04;37;27
DP
Did you know the clients before you entered the competition?
00;04;37;29 - 00;04;47;23
JI
We had some previous relations with the clients as a contractor, but they've recently started opening a development wing in the United States. This is our first project, working with them in that capacity.
00;04;47;27 - 00;04;53;19
DP
So this site is really large. Could you give us a little history of the location?
00;04;53;21 - 00;05;23;07
JI
The site is 200 feet in the north south and then between West Street and the East River. Around 600 feet with 40 feet reserved for a waterfront esplanade. We actually pulled back even a little bit further from that. And it's located right on the waterfront in Greenpoint. There was recently a rezoning that allowed for a whole redesign of the waterfront, and our project is one of the earlier projects in that redevelopment.
00;05;23;09 - 00;05;29;05
DP
So could you give us an idea of what the scope of the project is and the programmatic requirements?
00;05;29;07 - 00;05;49;14
JI
So it's a residential project, around 834 units, encompassing a total of around 800,000 square feet. This also comes with a series of amenity spaces, a series of retail spaces, as well as that waterfront park, and also a collection of rooftop amenities and green space.
00;05;49;17 - 00;05;56;11
DP
So let's talk about the building design stylistically. Were you guys borrowing from anything locally?
00;05;56;14 - 00;06;21;16
JI
We like to think that the entire project comes from the community around it. We looked at a series of precedents in the Greenpoint neighborhood, historically in Greenpoint, specifically on the waterfront, to inspire the way that we detail these facades. We have a collection of different brick styles that help to break up the massing of the building, different articulations, as well as material breaks with the two precast towers.
00;06;21;18 - 00;06;26;20
DP
So what was on the site before you guys ended up building the new architecture?
00;06;26;23 - 00;06;51;02
JI
Previously, there was a two story warehouse on the site and it really was kind of a beautiful space in its own right before we got the chance to tour around, before it was demolished. And I think walking around really inspired us just with these qualities of light and materials and things that were really native to the waterfront before all of this redevelopment.
00;06;51;05 - 00;07;00;18
DP
And the project, as I said, very large. Could you tell me a little bit about the zoning requirements and any challenges you guys had in terms of planning?
00;07;00;21 - 00;08;03;15
JI
So the project is as of right, it follows the zoning guidelines, the lot itself is actually split up into two different zones. So towards the inland it's mostly low rise. We had a height cap of 65 feet with portions that were allowable to go up to 100. And then towards the waterfront, the zoning actually got a little more complicated where there were a few different conditions that you could meet.
It opened up these different paths for how the building could be formed. One path was a one tower scheme, which would bring you up to 360 feet. And then the other was actually a two tower scheme where if one tower made it to 200 feet, the other would be allowed up to 400 feet. We took advantage of that in order to move more of the mass to the waterfront.
It helped gradually declined the building back into the fabric of the community and it provided more waterfront views overall, just a better experience and connection of the building, both to the water and to the community.
00;08;03;17 - 00;08;06;02
DP
So were there any floodplain restrictions?
00;08;06;05 - 00;08;49;21
JI
Yes. The floodplain has actually set one foot above the highest point of the site, which is the most inland. And then the site gradually slopes down another 6 to 7 feet towards the water. So much of the initial design strategy of the project was finding ways to transition from the ground to above that floodplain elevation. And we accomplished this a number of ways.
We actually set the building back the distance from the lot line as we get closer to the water, and this allows us to use landscaping as a way to gradually transition back up to that flood elevation, as well as moving all of our program spaces above and then moving more utilitarian spaces such as bike rooms down below the flood elevation.
00;08;49;24 - 00;09;12;26
DP
So I'm thinking about our listeners, how to describe the site because we have a series of buildings here. Is there a simple way for you to explain the building plans on the site? So first we describe the shape of the site and plan, and then if you could give us an idea about how those buildings are organized on the site.
00;09;12;29 - 00;09;40;18
JI
So the site's essentially just a rectangle. It's the size of a full city block and on three sides, on the north, the east and the south, we have streets and then the west side is the waterfront. It's the East River. So the way that we've organized the buildings around the site is in this U-shape, where they start up in the northwest corner, move around down West Street and then below, creating a view that opens up towards the water.
00;09;40;20 - 00;09;43;19
DP
So it's really all about the views, which it should be.
00;09;43;21 - 00;09;58;19
JI
Yes, it's something that it needs to be on the waterfront as well as it is about the views back into the neighborhood. We try to open up the view corridors from the building and leave as much view towards the water and towards the horizon from the rest of Greenpoint as we can.
00;09;58;22 - 00;10;08;12
DP
So tell us a little bit about the material choices. You've got a series of different materials and colors there. What were the decisions behind that?
00;10;08;15 - 00;11;00;05
JI
The building massing itself is broken up into five unique buildings and out of those we have two towers that are precast, and those are the buildings on the waterfront and then inland. There are three different buildings that range from ten stories to six stories. And those three buildings are brick. And that we really wanted to draw back from a lot of our inspirations in the Greenpoint community.
There's no shortage of brick precedents there. There's beautiful buildings such as the Astral, which is this Queen Ann red brick Terracotta building. There's St Anthony's Church, which is red brick and limestone trim. It's really beautiful, striking building. We looked towards kind of the history of the waterfront, those manufacturing, industrial buildings, and used that precedent to define these brick colors, these three different brick buildings.
00;11;00;08 - 00;11;28;28
DP
So interestingly, the facades. So we've got the shorter, or we've got the less tall architecture, which are brick buildings, and the facades are a series of what I'll call punctures with spandrel, it looks like spandrel brick in between each one of these vertically in between each one of the window openings, correct? Yes. So how many studies did you guys end up doing to decide what these facades looked like?
00;11;29;00 - 00;12;07;13
JI
Everything kind of melded together at some point. It's hard to break it down into a number because it was just this completely iterative process where we'd look at something, we'd make a model, we draw it, we'd look at it again, we'd make another model, we draw it. And this evolved from the concept schematic designs all the way through to the construction document development.
This idea of the different brick details that actually came from wanting to streamline the project. So we used the same details on each of the brick buildings, but we remixed them in each one. We use them in a different order to create a different identity for each of these.
00;12;07;20 - 00;12;25;01
DP
I think what's really interesting about these facades too, so you separate the facade these into squares or rectangles, and then they have this very, well, it looks subtle in elevation from far away, but it's actually a very large construction joint in between each one of these square rectangular panels, correct?
00;12;25;03 - 00;12;40;03
JI
Yes. We use that construction joint and we overemphasize it. We use this double soldier coursing reveal as a way to further break up the massing and kind of imply this subdivisions within the buildings.
00;12;40;06 - 00;12;43;17
DP
And how deep is that? Is that one brick thickness?
00;12;43;22 - 00;12;44;20
JI
It's two inches.
00;12;44;20 - 00;12;55;11
DP
Two inches. It's nice because when you look at the facade, I mean, it looks quite homogenous. But if you look at it a little bit more deeply, it's separated in these squares and rectangles. Very pretty.
00;12;55;16 - 00;13;14;27
JI
Yeah, that's the effect that we really want to go for in terms of how this fits into the fabric of Greenpoint. We like the idea of there being this large scale massing that breaks down and continues to break down the closer you get and it relates to more your scale relative to the way that you're viewing it.
00;13;15;00 - 00;13;22;07
DP
It really does scale the architecture nicely. So how about the building review with the city? Was that time consuming?
00;13;22;09 - 00;13;34;17
JI
Not at all. As I said, we were as of right building. So working through the construction documents, we were also working through permitting at the same time. It was a very easy flow from one stage to the next.
00;13;34;19 - 00;13;37;18
DP
Now, did you guys work in 2D and in 3D?
00;13;37;26 - 00;13;46;28
JI
Yes. 2D, 3D, physical models, sketches. Things were being passed around the office for a year and a half related to this.
00;13;47;01 - 00;13;51;00
DP
Do you work in Revit or AutoCAD or ArchiCAD?
00;13;51;02 - 00;13;58;26
JI
We're primarily a Revit office. We use Revit for our project delivery. We also do a bit of work in AutoCAD and in Rhino.
00;13;59;02 - 00;14;03;24
DP
So when you did presentation with the clients, did you show them three dimensional images and models?
00;14;04;01 - 00;14;31;01
JI
Yes, there is a lot of modeling. We actually very early on in the project, we built this eight foot long model of the Greenpoint waterfront, and we were working through just several dozens of iterations of the massing, the two towers, a one tower option, and we were all just spread out around the table, around this model, flipping through the different massings and trying to figure out what worked best with what else we were seeing on the waterfront.
00;14;31;04 - 00;14;33;00
DP
I bet the client really enjoyed that.
00;14;33;00 - 00;14;36;26
JI
It was a blast. Every office meeting was always a mini party.
00;14;36;28 - 00;14;57;08
DP
Yeah, clients love models. I mean, they love 3D images. I'm sure when you showed them these three dimensional images, particularly the towers, which are really quite beautiful, the way the facades step back and move forward. And they're just, the architecture is very interesting. So I'm sure they really enjoyed it, especially when they saw the first renderings.
00;14;57;10 - 00;15;12;11
JI
Yeah, again, it was a lot of fun and all these models were tactile and interactive, so it gave us a chance to move some of these blocks and figure out the correct portion, the correct distance that we'd want things to overhang to shift and slide past each other.
00;15;12;14 - 00;15;17;06
DP
So how many people worked on the project? How many people were involved in the office on the team?
00;15;17;11 - 00;15;44;07
JI
It fluctuated throughout phase. I think at the height of it we had around 12 people total, and that's assembling the full construction package, Through concept the team was a bit smaller, we maybe 4 to 6 and this is also spread out between a few of the different locations of our offices. So we had a team in our San Juan, Puerto Rico office and a team at our New York office, both working hand in hand on this.
00;15;44;09 - 00;16;06;15
DP
You know, as an aside, what's really pretty, the red brick that you guys use there, there are a lot of lighter bricks in that facade. And so it makes it look almost pink in color. But you get up close to it and you can see a lot of variations in these colors, in the red colored brick, a lot of like I'll call it value, but it's light and dark red brick.
00;16;06;18 - 00;17;10;16
JI
For that facade we're using a blended brick and we wanted that to echo some of the red brick buildings that you already see on West Street on the waterfront. That was kind of our launching point for coming up with this brick palette. We knew that there was going to be a red brick building. We knew that it was going to be relative to those warehouses and then the other two bricks were kind of an offshoot, based on how we wanted to frame this story of the building as you move around the site.
So to the north, there's a lighter brick. It's something that we see as a little more modern. We try to keep the tones of the brick and mortar and the sills and other materials a little more homogenous and then on the flip side of that, on the southern street of the building Java Street, we wanted to use something with a bit more variation.
We wanted a higher contrast between the grout and the brick, a higher variability within the bricks. And that's something that we saw as a little more nostalgic to some of those worker housings and the smaller buildings that you begin to see as you move more inland.
00;17;10;18 - 00;17;16;27
DP
Now the colors work very nicely together. So where are you guys in the construction phase on this? Forgive me for not knowing.
00;17;16;29 - 00;17;33;05
JI
Where currently pouring the concrete structure. We're up to the sixth floor now, I believe. We have gotten all of the brick pallets finalized. We've gotten all the precast facades cast. It's really kind of a game of assembly at this point.
00;17;33;07 - 00;17;41;28
DP
So, Jeremy, you're a young architect. I'm sure you're learning a lot. As you go along here, anything memorable so far?
00;17;42;01 - 00;18;01;06
JI
It's so hard to pick one thing. This entire project has just been an incredible learning experience. Admittedly, early in my career, there's so many different conditions, so much to consider with a project of this size that I really feel like I got a good breadth of exposure to so many facets of the industry now.
00;18;01;06 - 00;18;03;18
DP
Do you get to be out in the field a lot?
00;18;03;21 - 00;18;27;22
JI
Yes. Every week we have our owner and constructor meetings. We have bank walks on the side and really get to see the progress and it's moving so quickly, month by month. And also I live not too far from the site, so every week I try to make it out there and just see what's going on, see what's changed, and it's kind of humbling just seeing something come to life.
00;18;27;25 - 00;18;46;27
DP
I would imagine something this large, I've never worked on a project that's larger than a residential home. I mean, I've worked on schools early on, but working on a job that's this big has got to be humbling and profound and extraordinarily interesting all at the same time.
00;18;46;29 - 00;19;07;27
JI
Yeah, it's been challenging, but I think throughout all of it I've been extremely lucky just having in the support of a firm like Marvel as well as just an incredibly talented team of consultants, of engineers and clients who have really just been supportive and on board and actively participating in every step of the design.
00;19;08;00 - 00;19;12;29
DP
So I'd like to ask most of our guests, did you guys have any challenges finding a mason?
00;19;13;02 - 00;19;27;21
JI
No, actually, the mason that we've gone with bundling, we've worked on a few of our projects with them before, and the second that they came on board with the project, our confidence kind of skyrocketed. Just because we've had such a good experience with them previously.
00;19;27;23 - 00;19;37;24
DP
For all those young architects out there looking for work at a firm that they admire, how might you recommend young people find the right job?
00;19;37;26 - 00;20;22;06
JI
Well, the right job is kind of a hard thing to qualify. I think the best advice I could give on that is to just put your name out there wherever you can. Don't be shy in asking people for connections and asking people to kind of put you in a position that you think would be beneficial to you. With Marvel, actually, I had a friend from school who knew someone, and through them I was able to get my resume and I actually don't think Marvel was actively hiring. But I got the interview and it went very well. I loved everyone on the team and they loved me and I think I really landed in my right place. But I encourage everyone to really put yourself out to as many places as you can so you can see what fits for you and what works for you.
00;20;22;08 - 00;20;41;12
DP
I always kind of wonder is an older guy working in this field now to social media have a benefit in terms of finding work today? That is, is it easier to reach out to people that you simply don't know with your resume and thoughts about, hey, I'd love to work with your firm?
00;20;41;15 - 00;21;14;24
JI
Yeah, I think it plays a big part. It's playing an increasing part to Instagram as a way that I see a lot of firms work, a lot of firms putting out calls for applications for either positions or internships. It really increases the amount of exposure and it puts everything in one place where people might just passively see it.
And then there's also LinkedIn, where I get so many people messaging me about my experience at Marvel and kind of things that they're looking for, things that they would want to know about if they were to apply for a position or an internship.
00;21;14;27 - 00;22;17;12
DP
It's interesting, just as an aside, I never really thought about this, but when you said it puts things in one place, the web really does help them. It sounds really dumb, but to a guy like me who's 55 years old when I was young, you either have to see an architect work in a magazine, you visit their office and you get to see all the photos of all of their work.
But the web really does an amazing job of putting absolutely everything in one location, right? So you go, especially an app like Instagram, where you simply open it up, go to a page and you can see all 400 projects or 30 projects or whatever it is, and contact people at the firm in 2 minutes. It really has changed the paradigm for employment or simply for marketing and all these other things.
I know it all sounds very obvious, but as I sit here with a young architect, it makes me think that your world is simply very different than what mine used to be.
00;22;17;19 - 00;22;30;19
JI
I also think it's democratized in a way. It's given smaller firms a greater opportunity and platform to put their work out that it could be on the same level with the kind of content that you see from much larger firms.
00;22;30;22 - 00;22;40;06
DP
I love that. That makes a lot of sense. So, Jeremy, it's been great to have you here. Thank you so much for your time. Where can people go to learn more about Marvel and yourself?
00;22;40;06 - 00;22;50;03
JI
Yeah, thank you, Doug. You can visit our website, MarvelDesign.com or also please follow us on Instagram at @Marvel_is_design.
00;22;50;05 - 00;22;55;28
DP
All right well, Jeremy, thank you very much again for being here. It's been great to have you as a guest.
00;22;55;29 - 00;22;59;28
JI
Yeah. Thank you so much, Doug.
You May Also Be Interested In
We Can Help With Your Next Project
Discover the latest + greatest in design trends, industry news & pro tips from pros.
For all of your project needs, you’ll find everything you need at a Supply Center.
Let Us Know How We Can Help!
Design Vault Ep. 25 102 Bainbridge with Michelle Todd
ABOUT THE ARCHITECT:
![]()
|
A design firm specializing in progressive and innovative designs that enhance the environment and existing urban fabric. * Our focus is to design and develop projects that are sensitive and responsible to social wellness, cradle to cradle architecture and the planet. * Better buildings. Better change.
Michelle Todd is an architect and urban community activist who has a longstanding passion for socially responsive, innovatively progressive, and restorative preservation design. Michelle grew up in Brooklyn’s Bedford-Stuyvesant neighborhood in the 1970s before it was hip, in one of Mayor John Lindsay’s modular housing developments. She knew she wanted to be an architect at ten and had big plans for the empty lot across from her apartment building.
It was the beginning of her interest in Urban Planning and how socially responsive architecture can do something positive for people and the planet. After a brief stint at Perkins Eastman, she opened her own firm in 2008. Since then, she has worked for small and large corporations such as Snapple, the New York City agency Office of Emergency Management and private residential projects. Since 2008 she has since set up her own studio in Brooklyn, New York and focuses on historic renovations and additions to collaborate more directly with clients and be closer to the construction process. She has worked on landmark designated buildings, bakeries, restaurants, school projects and completed dexterous renovations which push the envelope of the expected, creating simple beautiful spaces. Michelle has a Master of Science from Columbia University GSAPP in Architecture and Urban Design, where she was awarded the Lucille Smyser Lowenfish Honors Award for work in Urban Design. Master Planning of Community Developments is an initiative she is well versed in accomplishing. She is certified as a consultant with the International Institute of Building Enclosures (IIBEC) and Living Future Accredited (LFA) with the International Living Future Institute. She also studied at the famous École de Beaux-Arts in Fontainebleau, France. She is an adjunct Professor at New York City CUNY College and a licensed architect in New York State and Maryland State. You can find her gardening and planning programming with the AIA Brooklyn COTE Committee and AIA National Regional & Urban Design Committee.
|
---|
ABOUT THE PROJECT:
Residents of New York City take immense pride in their city, renowned for its vibrant energy, rich culture, and remarkable history. Among the numerous neighborhoods, Brooklyn's Bedford-Stuyvesant, fondly known as Bed-Stuy, stands out with its collection of over 8,000 buildings pre-dating the 20th century.
One of those buildings immersed in this historical tapestry is the beautiful home of 102 Bainbridge Street located in the Bedford Stuyvesant original Stuyvesant Heights Historic District which was designated on September 14th, 1971. It was built within a row of building Nos. 76-104 and is a long group of houses planned to form seven freestanding architectural units, consisting of fourteen paired houses plus a single house at the eastern end. These unusual two-story houses, designed by W. F. McCarthy, are of red brick laid in Flemish bond, and were built in 1919 for Samuel Willen, treasurer of the Prosser Construction Company. 102 Bainbridge itself is a modified Spanish Renaissance style with a triple arch loggia surmounted by a group of five (5) double hung windows. The roof parapet rises at the center in an arch supported on concave shoulders. The house is set back behind brick terraces with brick balustrades and are approached by L-shape stoops set back at a common wall.
The initiation for the restoration for this building was due to the exterior façade along the roof parapet on the west and north elevation were buckling with severe step cracking occurring along masonry segments in the façade with patches of damaged stucco. Within the west façade along the base of the stepped parapet were damaged steel tie rods. At the north façade, the center stone pediment needed to be supported correctly and coping stones above it had to be repaired. At grade, the front façade along the brick terraces walls showed signs of masonry buckling and deterioration. The entire existing roof, skylights, roof hatch and areas of limestone and blue stone above and below the windows were in dire need of repair.
The premise to rectify the structural conditions of the home began early in the design to utilize sustainable means and methods to restore the building. A major step taken was not to replace the areas along the façade again with new stucco. Stucco accounts for 8.2% of carbon emissions and is a material that is hard to maintain due to temperature change effects, dealing with moisture and freezing. During the removal process of the existing stucco along the rear east elevation the homeowners genuinely liked the appearance of the natural brick underneath. The advantage of keeping the natural brick exposed was its resilience to harsh climatic resistance, durable, low-maintenance, fireproof, noise cancelling, energy efficient and just made the building more attractive. The existing brick under the stucco in the rear of the home was a different brick color and style from the original masonry brick along the front east elevation and north elevation. We therefore chose a brick like the underlining brick called Glen Gehry Cushwa Calvert Series Middle Plantation Brick 52-DD along with 403 mortars to match masonry bond style.
As the construction project continued upon removal of the stucco face, it was revealed that a 1956 addition to 102 Bainbridge Street along the second-floor rear east and south façade was framed with wood along the exterior instead of masonry as per the original blueprints and approval submitted. Even though this construction was done before the landmark designation in 1971, the use of wood was illegal back then and present-day NYC building code because the building is along a shared property line with an adjacent building. This plot twist made the project move from being an exterior renovation to a demolition and reconstruction of a new addition.
To address this issue, the structural engineering firm Silman Structural Engineering was brought in to provide consultation on the next steps. Their recommendation was to reuse the existing steel lintels that were located under the wood along the exterior façade where the original windows were located and the roof structure. An entirely new structural design was created to merge the old methodologies of the 2-wythe masonry wall with the new steel framing from Marino\WARE. Scott Hughes Principal Director of Structural Engineering at Silman stated he specified Marino-Ware products because of the wealth of publicly available published information about them and their sustainable qualities of steel being robust, long-lasting, and 100% recyclable, making it unmatched by most other building materials in terms of its lifecycle. The new wall construction entailed the structural steel from Marino Ware which has the environmental product declaration from UL, USG glass mat sheathing made of recycled material and is 100% recyclable, the Blueskin vapor barrier to contribute the energy efficiency of the home and Glen Gehry bricks for the 2-wythe exterior wall. The existing steel lintels rediscovered remained to install the original style windows back at those locations along the east and south façade.
In correcting the existing parapet at the roof, we replaced the existing steel tie rods with the assistance of a local steel maker in Brooklyn who created each unique piece separately. This became handy when we had to go back to him again to create additional steel tie rods, upon the demolition of the top parapet along the north façade. There it was discovered the masonry construction was three wythe and within it were steel tie rods hidden from view to support the center of the arch with the stone pediment along with the concave shoulders.
The masonry wall along the front porch during the demolition process existing bricks were analyzed closely to see which ones could be salvaged and reused. This helped to maintain the budget of the project but also to have less impact to add to the wasteful construction materials to landfills which brick encompasses about 6.54% sadly. Areas within the masonry façade that were in decent shape stayed and dilapidated areas were replaced with new bricks. The entire roof was professionally abated and replaced using Siplast roofing system which uses reusable insulation to bright white liquid-applied roof membranes and granule surface that helps reduce atmospheric pollution. The environmental and sustainable goals were met with the reduction of building energy use, increase roof longevity and reduction of urban heat island effect. The large skylight was replicated and replaced. The small skylight on the roof was replaced with an operable solar skylight which aids natural light and ventilation to come into the building.
All existing coping stones were cleaned, repaired, reused, and restored. New limestone and blue stone used in the restoration was advocated from quarries and manufacturers who met ANSI/NSC 373 Standard.
Completing the exterior façade restoration entailed the replacement of the steel window lintels for some of the existing windows. The steel used was recyclable. The homeowners desired to have all the windows replaced for the home to save energy, save money obtain ultimate insulation, climate control, more light, less noise, dust, and outside pollutants. The windows was provided by Norwood Window and Doors because of their strong advocacy of their products created from sustainable harvested lumber and NRFC rating.





TRANSCRIPT
00;00;00;02 - 00;00;05;10
Doug Pat (DP)
Let's go inside the vault. The design vault.
00;00;05;12 - 00;00;34;05
Michelle Todd (MT)
So the whole idea was to fix the parapet and also to fix all of the step cracking within the facade. It was a beautiful building of brick in the front and the original status was that it had stucco on the very rear portion. We wind up finding out that this particular building, it wasn't brick behind it, it was actually wood.
So that therefore became more of an extensive project in which it wasn't just a renovation of the exterior facade, it was now a whole new addition and also an entire new rebuild.
00;00;34;07 - 00;01;01;23
DP
This is my guest, Michelle Todd. I'll share more about her shortly. In this episode from The Design Vault. We highlight Michelle's restoration project at 102 Bainbridge Street in Brooklyn's Bedford-Stuyvesant neighborhood. The Bainbridge Street renovation project is located in the Stuyvesant Heights Historic District. It was built within a row of buildings, which is a long group of houses planned to form seven freestanding architectural units.
00;01;01;28 - 00;03;46;13
DP
102 is situated at the end of the row. It's a modified Spanish residential style home with a triple arched loggia made of red brick laid in Flemish pond. The roof parapet rises at the center in an arch supported on concave shoulders. The restoration was begun to repair a buckling roof parapet, deteriorated walls, damaged pediment and cracking stucco facade.
Renovation work was extensive and a decision was made early not to replace the stucco, but rather leave and repair the natural brick masonry. The building scope also changed during construction from an exterior renovation to demolition and reconstruction due to construction material issues. Structural engineers were also consulted to create a necessary and unique wall construction method. The existing roof skylights, roof hatch and areas of limestone and bluestone were also repaired.
The project was also recently awarded the 2023 Lucy G. Moses New York Landmark Conservancy Award. Hi, I'm Doug Pat and this is Design Vault. Michelle Todd is an architect and principal of M.Todd Architects in Bedford-Stuyvesant, New York. Michelle has a master of science from Columbia University in architecture and urban design. She also studied at the École des Beaux-Arts in France.
Michelle grew up in Brooklyn's Bedford-Stuyvesant neighborhood in the 1970s. She knew she wanted to be an architect by the age of ten. Her interests today focus on urban planning and socially responsive architecture. After a brief stint at Perkins Eastman, she opened her own firm in 2008. Since then, she's worked for small and large corporations such as Snapple, the New York City Agency Office of Emergency Management, as well as private residential projects.
Her studio in Brooklyn, New York, focuses on historic renovations and additions, collaborating directly with clients and working closely with the general contractor during construction. Michelle's worked on Landmark designated buildings, bakeries, restaurants, schools and renovation projects. She's an adjunct professor at the New York City CUNY College and a licensed architect in New York State and Maryland. She's certified as a consultant with the International Institute of Building Enclosures, and Living Future accredited with the International Living Future Institute.
Welcome, Michelle. It's nice to have you with us today. So tell us a little bit about M.Todd Architects in Brooklyn. So where in Bed-Stuy are you located? What's the size of the firm? How long have you been around? And tell us a little more about project types.
00;03;46;16 - 00;04;19;19
MT
The firm is in the heart of Bedford-Stuyvesant on the whole Z Street. Been around since 2008 was almost 15 years as of March of this year, 2024. And basically the firm is small, is about three people, we specialize specifically in historical preservation, as well as residential private editions, commercial projects such as restaurants, bake houses and also schools. So basically you have a realm of achievement in different areas, which is commercial, residential and also business.
00;04;19;21 - 00;04;26;09
DP
So tell us a little bit about yourself. How long have you been practicing architecture and what's your role in the office as principal?
00;04;26;12 - 00;05;00;18
MT
I've been practicing architecture since 2008, when I received my license. However, I do have decades of experience before then in working at previous larger offices, in smaller offices to gain the experience I needed. Because, as you know, as an architect, you have to have at least three years working first in the field and then afterwards you're able to take the examination.
So once I did that, then just made initiative to just start my own practice. And basically I am the principal where I do a lot of marketing as well as clients in order to obtain business.
00;05;00;20 - 00;05;02;15
DP
And you said you have some employees?
00;05;02;21 - 00;05;13;16
MT
I do have employees. They're basically consultants. So basically I have a expediter. I have a drafts person. I have also my consultants, such as structural engineer, mechanical engineers.
00;05;13;19 - 00;05;21;08
DP
That's interesting. So you have an expediter that you guys use. And is that to make the process working with the city a little easier?
00;05;21;11 - 00;05;33;17
MT
It really does make it easier because as a person with a small firm, your hands are in everything. So to have somebody to be on the outside, to be able to do that type of work is appreciative and helpful.
00;05;33;19 - 00;05;46;05
DP
That's really cool. I mean, just as an aside, I hadn't really thought about the need for an expediter in a firm like that, but that makes perfect sense. So let's dig in here and talk about the home. How did your office get the project?
00;05;46;07 - 00;06;08;01
MT
I received the project in regards to as a dear friend, where I'm on the New York City Landmark Committee for Bedford-Stuyvesant specifically, and Community Board three, and he was a good member, Fred Jones, rest in peace. He had a friend who was in need of architectural services, so he recommended me to the client, which is the richest family, about this project.
00;06;08;03 - 00;06;10;01
DP
So you didn't know the clients before you got the job?
00;06;10;06 - 00;06;18;04
MT
I didn't know the clients. It was a friend of a friend, and he just talked highly about me and said that you should work with me in regards to this project.
00;06;18;06 - 00;06;24;26
DP
So give us a little history about the location. And was I correct in stating that the unit is an end unit?
00;06;24;29 - 00;07;08;00
MT
It is. It's in the beautiful, original, historic district of Bedford-Stuyvesant, which is known as Stuyvesant Heights, and it was established as a landmark district in 1971. So this set of buildings, it's literally between Stuyvesant and Lewis on Bainbridge. There's about 14 series of the buildings, and it's at the end row and there are Spanish style Renaissance buildings. That was created by W.f. McCarthy, who was an architect back in 1919.
And the unique thing about these buildings is that it's the only buildings I've ever been in with it has two staircases inside where there's one in the back and one in the front. So I guess back in those days they would have the servants come through the back and then the owners come through the front.
00;07;08;03 - 00;07;10;14
DP
Roughly, what's the square footage of the project?
00;07;10;16 - 00;07;13;09
MT
It's about 1200 square feet.
00;07;13;11 - 00;07;17;05
DP
And what was the scope and the programmatic requirements from the owner?
00;07;17;07 - 00;10;08;12
MT
Well, the original scope and program was that it was in terrible need in regards to the existing structure, the parapet was buckling. So on the north facade as well as the south and west facades, it was just crumbling. They were scared that it was going to fall down in some way. So the whole idea was to fix the parapet and also to fix all of the step cracking within the facade.
But then as we went along, we started to think also, it was a beautiful building of brick in the front. And the original status was that it had stucco on the very rear portion. Once we started to do the renovation was like, you know, we don't really need the stucco. It really looks beautiful with the brick itself. So we started to expose all the stucco, and by exposing all the stucco, we wound up finding out that this particular building, it wasn't brick behind it, it was actually wood.
So that therefore became more of an extensive project in which it wasn't just the renovation of the exterior facade, it was now a whole new addition and also an entire new rebuild. So we found out the history, and that was the nice thing about it. We really had to go back in the history of it. This is where the assistance of the expediter really came into play, because basically we found out that back in 1956, the building itself had a permit to actually do a addition because all of these beautiful houses.
What makes them so special in this neighborhood, too, is that they have their own private driveway, which many people don't have in that area. And also they have a garage. But then also on the second floor of each of these houses, they have a beautiful sunroom with a balcony. The person who owned the property at 102 Bainbridge, he basically wanted to make an addition.
So he eliminated that balcony and extended the whole square footage of the building so it can be enclosed. When we removed the stucco, we found out that instead of it masonry, he had it wood. So that was back in 1956. So we had to go back all the way to the building department to find out what the original drawings were, which we found out which were these beautiful blueprint drawings that you don't see anymore.
And it said that year they were legally supposed to have an addition, but it was supposed to be made out of brick, not wood. So that's where the whole expedition kind of came in. I had to go back to New York City building department, as well as the landmarks, because everyone was like shocked that it was wood versus masonry.
And we basically had to do a whole reconstruction. And that's where I guess the product of Glen-Gery came into play, because what happened to you is that on the back of the facade, all the bricks in the building weren't the same. The bricks in the front of the building were made out of Beldon, and it was a different type of color scheme.
But then when we removed the stucco in the back, it was a beautiful match with the Glen-Gery Kushwaha Calvert Plantation Middle Plantation, 52DD. It was a perfect match to it. Again, we had to go back to landmarks to make sure that they were approve of that brick to match what was in the rear facade that was being used.
00;10;08;15 - 00;10;17;12
DP
So what's interesting about the photographs that you sent is that the building looks as though some of these walls were completely taken down.
00;10;17;18 - 00;10;59;01
MT
It was because due to the fact it was stucco and I'm an architect that's very conscious about the environment. And stucco is something I concrete and it adds to the carbon footprint. So the whole idea was that this project specifically was to eliminate that process in really being more progressive and more enhancing to the environment. So that's why we didn't use stucco.
We wanted to just expose the beautiful masonry itself. And therefore, by eliminating the stucco, we saw the building was in need of much deeper repair than we expected. That was the thing, because in 1956 you figured that the contractors would be honest and they would do what they were supposed to do. But he wasn’t. And therefore that made this more of an adventure to get it right.
00;10;59;03 - 00;11;05;27
DP
So I would imagine there are a number of other buildings on that block that were also made of wood, that the interior wall construction. Is that correct?
00;11;06;00 - 00;11;44;10
MT
I don't know. That's the whole thing. What happened is, what makes this special is that this is the only house that has the addition. That's it. Everybody else has the sunroom. So this once in particular you thought that you would put it in masonry, but it's in it makes sense. First landmarks had to come and see it.
They were, like, shocked. Then I received the structural engineer, which was SOMA Engineering Firm, which is a great engineering firm. They came, they were shocked. The construction company that we work with, Naim Construction, all of us was basically shocked that this was behind the stucco because it looked like everything was fine. But when exposed, that's when we all gathered together as a team to like how we can resolve this.
00;11;44;16 - 00;11;52;22
DP
Interesting. Let's back up and talk a little bit about the plan of the building. I would assume it's just a large rectangle, two storey rectangle.
00;11;52;24 - 00;11;54;23
MT
Exactly. It was a two storey rectangle.
00;11;55;00 - 00;11;59;29
DP
And had you been contracted to design the interiors as well?
00;12;00;04 - 00;12;20;18
MT
I have for later date because what happens is based on the fact that now the photographs that you have here show of what it was existing. We went back to the premise of what it was back in 1919 when the solarium had these beautiful corner windows. So the design now is encompassing back the original style of that format.
00;12;20;20 - 00;12;25;05
DP
So you had to work with the city. How long did that process take?
00;12;25;08 - 00;12;53;21
MT
This is how it began. The project began in May 2020, during the pandemic. Then we actually had approval to start construction in April of 2021. Then all of these items, open issues about the facade not being what it was, and reconstruction, we basically spent about two years after that, and it was completed around October 20, 23. So it was back and forth with New York Landmarks as well as New York City Building Department.
00;12;53;27 - 00;12;55;09
DP
And the client had somewhere to live.
00;12;55;16 - 00;13;08;12
MT
He lived on the first floor. So the top floor. It was a blessing that he was able to live on the first floor while all this construction was going on. And in the top floor, basically, he had tenants, but then they moved out. When this major construction of us doing the rebuild.
00;13;08;15 - 00;13;09;07
DP
A lot of noise.
00;13;09;13 - 00;13;11;04
MT
It was a lot of noise.
00;13;11;04 - 00;13;11;23
DP
Very dusty.
00;13;11;24 - 00;13;15;00
MT
But it was fun.
00;13;15;02 - 00;13;24;10
DP
That's great. I'm interested as an architect about the drawings that you created in the very beginning. Did you work in 3D or just 2D?
00;13;24;12 - 00;13;33;28
MT
I worked in 2D, but then afterwards, when we started to look at what this condition that was taking place in the rear, I started looking at it in 3D and how it would be.
00;13;34;05 - 00;13;38;05
DP
And did you have to present drawings to a historic commission?
00;13;38;07 - 00;13;47;14
MT
Yes, we present it to Brian Blazak, is one of the senior preservationists on in New York City Landmarks. We had to show the drawings of what we planned to do.
00;13;47;16 - 00;13;48;26
DP
Exterior elevations?
00;13;49;03 - 00;13;50;24
MT
Yeah, exterior elevations.
00;13;50;26 - 00;13;58;25
DP
So again, backing up a little bit, you removed the stucco on one facade and replaced masonry on another. Is that correct?
00;13;58;28 - 00;14;25;03
MT
It's on the same facade. What happens is, is that the entire facade was placed in stucco. But then when we looked at the south elevation, so the windows were there, but it was infilled with wood. And that's what was shocking to everybody because basically it was really dilapidated and it also kind of made sense for the owner later on because he said his tenants always felt cold in that part of the room.
And it made sense because it was the wood and that masonry, there was no insulation whatsoever.
00;14;25;06 - 00;14;30;17
DP
So tell us a little bit about the new wall system that you guys had to create because of that condition.
00;14;30;19 - 00;15;17;03
MT
So the new wall system was still going back to what was historically done in regards to the rear facade was made out of three widths of brick, which basically is like three layers. And what we had to do is that we had to abide by what the actual, once we removed the stucco, what the actual pattern was, because it was a common bond, because as I stated in the beginning, the pattern in the front of the house was completely different than the pattern in the back of the house.
So once we established that, then we wanted to really make it structurally sound and we incorporated steel within the wall. So basically you have the three whiffs of brick on the outside, then you have the steel. It was stainless steel that made sure it was resource sustainably. And then we have our insulation and then our finishes in the inside.
00;15;17;06 - 00;15;26;25
DP
So the project sounds really interesting. Did you guys learn anything new about construction technologies or about building typologies in working on this project?
00;15;26;27 - 00;15;58;06
MT
Yes, the use of materials because again, was very selective about which materials we're going to use because since this building was already historically landmarked since 1919, we wanted to make sure that it lasts for another 100 years. So was very selective on who the steel came from, where the insulation came from, where the bricks came from. All of these were really mindful things and I think moving forward with other projects, I continue doing that, making sure that they are friendly to the planet as well as to the people who are going to live and utilize the buildings.
00;15;58;08 - 00;16;04;18
DP
So did the client bring the general contractor to the project or did you interview a number of contractors?
00;16;04;20 - 00;16;10;09
MT
We did interview a number of contractors, but then the client himself selected Naim Construction for it.
00;16;10;12 - 00;16;15;19
DP
And clearly there's a lot of masonry work. Did you have any challenges finding a good mason?
00;16;15;21 - 00;16;45;27
MT
Oh no. He has very excellent masons and they were very accommodating because we had to go back and forth with New York City Landmarks when we were selecting the bricks where we had to actually do a sample of the wall where the wood infill was of how the brick was going to look. So one of his masons, George, was really who's one of the oldest ones there.
It has most experience. He was very patient. We went on the scaffolding and it was a really cold day, but we did the whole mock up and it came out beautiful. And therefore Landmark said, Yes, go with it.
00;16;45;29 - 00;16;49;16
DP
So you did the mock up and the city came out and took a look at it?
00;16;49;19 - 00;16;56;05
MT
No, we took photographs and then afterwards they were like, because it was cold.
00;16;56;07 - 00;17;05;24
DP
So the city doesn't like to go out on cold days? I think we’ll leave that in there. That's good. So I assume the client's living there now?
00;17;06;02 - 00;17;09;17
MT
He is. He's living in the bottom floor still, but he's happy with the work.
00;17;09;20 - 00;17;12;25
DP
So is it complete? And he has a tenant on the second floor?
00;17;13;00 - 00;17;22;21
MT
He doesn't have a tenant on the second floor. And it's not quite complete yet because now we're just waiting for the historical windows to come in. So that is the last crème de la crème.
00;17;22;23 - 00;17;24;27
DP
And who is the manufacturer of the windows?
00;17;25;03 - 00;17;36;10
MT
It is Norwood Manufacturers, a Canadian company. And again, it was very selective on them because the way they use and harvest wood in order to make the windows, we're really mindful about that.
00;17;36;17 - 00;17;39;23
DP
Interesting. Are they double glazed? Triple glazed?
00;17;39;25 - 00;17;49;03
MT
They're triple glazed, low e glass index and they're quite beautiful. They're the original to what was there before of the windows? So they're replicating those.
00;17;49;05 - 00;17;57;00
DP
So I'm curious in terms of color, you were able to find a brick that you were happy with. You said that matched on the exterior.
00;17;57;02 - 00;18;12;16
MT
The contractor has suggested he was like, this will be a perfect break. I did research and was a Glen-Gery Kushwaha Calvert 52 DD Middle Plantation. That was the one that was selected. And when we put it in place, it was perfect to what was there from 1919.
00;18;12;22 - 00;18;15;27
DP
So do all these row homes, they all must look the same?
00;18;16;02 - 00;18;45;16
MT
They basically all look the same. And the other fascinating thing too, with the project, when we were doing the demo for the wood infield, all the bricks, I learned this like recently from my practice that the bricks that we were removing, that were there all had the names of the brick companies on there. And you don't see that anymore in which they were actually etched into the brick.
I was like, Wow, It's like, fascinating. So it was like an archeological project in the same way of doing something better for the building for another hundred years.
00;18;45;19 - 00;18;52;24
DP
So when you guys put these new windows in, what about the color? Can you do whatever color you want or the colors have to match the other homes.
00;18;52;26 - 00;18;57;13
MT
The colors have to match. It is going to be made out of wood, but they're going to be of a white finish.
00;18;57;16 - 00;19;00;10
DP
And they have to be traditional in style to match the others.
00;19;00;16 - 00;19;01;06
MT
Exactly.
00;19;01;06 - 00;19;11;17
DP
Interesting. So, Michelle, you've been an architect for some time. Based on what you know today about being an architect, you have any words of advice for your younger self or maybe architects coming up in the ranks?
00;19;11;19 - 00;19;41;21
MT
I would say don't quit on yourself. That's for me personally, as a woman and a woman of color in this industry, to always just believe in yourself, that what you find really interesting and powerful within yourself will just keep working at it and you'll get recognition. But it's not really about the recognition. I've always known I wanted to be an architect.
I feel architecture is like a stewardship. You are helping other people to obtain their desires and dreams and designs, but then also, too, helping the planet.
00;19;41;24 - 00;19;49;23
DP
So, Michelle, it's been great to have you here today. Thank you so much for your time. Where could people go to learn more M.Todd Architect and yourself?
00;19;49;26 - 00;19;56;06
MT
You can find me on my website at MToddArchitects.com and then also I'm on LinkedIn.
00;19;56;08 - 00;19;58;10
DP
Well, thank you very much. It has been great to have you.
00;19;58;17 - 00;20;00;24
MT
Thank you so much. Appreciate the opportunity.
You May Also Be Interested In
We Can Help With Your Next Project
Discover the latest + greatest in design trends, industry news & pro tips from pros.
For all of your project needs, you’ll find everything you need at a Supply Center.
Let Us Know How We Can Help!
Design Vault Ep. 24 Sansom5 with Gabe Deck
ABOUT THE ARCHITECT:
![]()
|
Gabe Deck grew up in Central Pennsylvania before doing his BArch at Temple University (class of 2007) in Philadelphia. He is a big-time Philadelphia guy, and stayed in Philly after college and have lived and worked in most areas of central Philly. He recently relocated to the suburbs with his wife Alex and 2 young boys, ages 3 and 5. Gabe began his early career working for Wallace Roberts and Todd working on a variety of project types all over the country. After the 2008 recession, he got his real estate license where he made a number of contacts in residential development. Over the next few years, these relationships lead to a number of small residential design projects moonlighting on the side of his full time job. Once he got his arch license in 2013, he quit his job and started his own residential design firm out of a spare bedroom in his house. Gabe’s focus of work was mostly urban, small scale residential additions which quickly grew into new construction townhouse developments and then larger adaptive reuse residential projects. The scale of work grew over the first few years, as did the business. Gabe hired and then partnered with Derek Spencer and together they rebranded to Gnome Architects in late 2018.
The Philadelphia based Gnome Architects team is currently nine people and is operated out of an amazing repurposed public high school called BOK in south Philadelphia. The firm focuses on residential design with context driven solutions, with 400+ projects to date, mostly in Philly but also in other parts of the country as far reaching as Colorado and Maine. The current focus of Gnome Architects is 2 pronged:
|
---|
ABOUT THE PROJECT:
The Client wanted a collaboration between a team of well versed Philadelphia and New York developers. The site is a 5,000 SF rectangular parcel with 3 street frontages that previously contained a 1 and 2 story nondescript office building. Site is located in center city Philadelphia, very close to the Rittenhouse and Fitler squares, and within 2 blocks of the Schuylkill river. The neighboring context is a mixture of commercial and residential use buildings. Much of the nearby residential vernacular spans in scale from modest 3 story trinities to 4 and 5 story brownstone mansions. Some challenges of the site included a 5' grade change across the main frontage and also being within a flood zone adjacent to the Schuylkill river. The developer team challenged Gnome to design 5 high end townhouses which would maximize the square footage potential while avoiding any zoning variance process and also meeting flood zone regulations. By-right parking was a challenge - the zoning district only allowed for underground parking so we were able to lean on the zoning definition for underground which included space below the floodplane base flood elevation (BFE). The homes themselves are very luxurious - each home contains 4BRs, 6 bathrooms, elevator, 2 car parking, 3 outdoor spaces in and 5000+ GSF across 5 stories and a pilot house level. Although the building massings are 5 stories + a pilot house level (reads as 6 stories), the brick is held to the top of the 4th floor with a projecting cornice in an effort to reduce the visual feel to the massing in comparison to the neighbors. Most neighbor buildings are primarily brick masonry which was the biggest driver for the materiality of the Sansom5.
Nearby brick and facade colors are a bit all over the place so Gnome chose a beige/brown tone which would fit in with the nearby colors while also could move the aesthetic towards the contemporary feel that the developers wanted to achieve. Much of the design inspiration came from the neighboring context of traditional row-home brick facades with strong cornice lines. Brick selection is Stonington Gray Velour. Other facade materials include large format nutmeg cast stone panels to complement the earth tone brick, gray flatlock metal panel, warm wood accent cladding, and a mix of black and brown clad slim profile windows. The windows within the masonry are brown to complement the earth tones while the windows in the other cladding areas are black. Plan driven windows made for challenges to organize the facade elements between the ground and upper floors - we landed on a language of brick pattern changes and cast stone accent pieces that would extend horizontally flanking the upper floor windows to create alignments with the lower floor window language. The field brick is a traditional running bond where the brick accent elements are a mixture of recessed and projected stacked bond detailing.
A lot of design interest was created at the home entry doors where we had to mitigate 5-6' of grade change from the sidewalk to the front door sill due to the flood level coordination. Gnome accentuated the entry by partially recessing the facade around the front door to make a 2 story tall "portal" framed in cast stone. Within the portal, a cast stone feature wall behind a built in brick planter wall as well as a wall flanking the exterior entry stairs with a dimple brick pattern creates multiple layers of masonry texture as you proceed to the front door. Grade change stepping and control joints were minimized on the front elevation by way of recessed metal channels between the homes. This also helped the front facades of the homes read independently.
Sansom5
design by Gnome Architects
View projectTRANSCRIPT
00;00;00;02 - 00;00;05;10
Doug Pat (DP)
Let's go inside the vault. The design vault.
00;00;05;12 - 00;00;30;08
Gabe Deck (GD)
We wanted to make sure we could fit as many units while making them as wide as possible. So five ended up being kind of the magic balance point to get them feeling pretty wide, really maximizing at least four bedrooms, five plus bathrooms, elevators and then roof deck spaces are pretty key for Philadelphia Center City townhouse developments. These houses each contain three roof deck spaces.
00;00;30;10 - 00;03;16;07
DP
This is my guest, Gabriel Deck. I'll share more about him shortly. In this episode from the Design Vault, we highlight Gabriel's Sansom5 Project in Center City, Philadelphia, Sansom5 is a collaborative venture between Philadelphia and New York developers. The site is a 5000 square foot rectangular parcel with three street frontages that previously contained small office buildings. The site is in Center City, Philadelphia, close to the Rittenhouse and Fittler's Squares.
There's a five foot grade change across the main frontage, and the parcel sits within a flood zone adjacent to the Schuylkill River. Most neighborhood buildings are primarily brick masonry with strong cornice lines, which drove esthetic and material choices. Each townhouse features entry door locations where grade changes mitigated and the facade is recessed within a portal of capstone. The project, which is light brown brick, also features facade materials that include gray, flat block, metal panels, wood, accent cladding, and a mix of black and brown clad, slim profile windows.
The project includes five high-end townhouses which maximize square footage. Each home contains four bedrooms, six bathrooms, an elevator and three outdoor spaces. Hi, I'm Doug Pat, and this is Design Vault. Gabriel Deck has a Bachelor of Architecture from Temple University. He describes himself as a big time Philadelphia guy, having stayed in Philly after college and continues to do business there.
He began his career working for Wallace Roberts on a variety of project types. After the 2008 recession, he got his real estate license, where he made a number of contacts in residential development over the next few years. These relationships led to a number of small residential design projects. He eventually started his own small firm. His work was mostly urban, small scale residential editions, which quickly grew into new construction townhouse developments and then larger adaptive reuse residential projects.
The scale of work grew over the first few years, as did the business. The firm was rebranded GNOME Architects in 2018. The team is currently nine people operating out of a repurposed public high school in South Philadelphia. The firm has 400 plus projects to date, mostly in Philly, but also in other parts of the country as far reaching as Colorado and Maine.
Welcome Gabe. It's nice to have you with us today. So tell us a little bit about GNOME Architects in Philly. Where are you guys located? What's the size of the firm? How long has it been around and what type of work do you do?
00;03;16;09 - 00;04;27;27
GD
So GNOME Architects has been around since about 2018 after a rebrand of my previous business. We're currently a team of nine people comprised of myself and my business partner, Derek Spencer, and a handful of designers. So the business started back in 2013. Originally when I quit my job at WRC to focus on some small residential projects that I had acquired from developer contacts that I had made working in real estate.
Philadelphia is a small town in terms of the industry. Word spreads and quickly I was able to get a lot of project work by way of these developer contacts. Most of the projects were third floor additions, small townhouse, new construction, infill projects. And once I partnered with Derek Spencer, we started focusing a bit more on larger multifamily work.
The team grew, the project scale grew. Now we are working on developer driven business on one end of the firm doing large multifamily work, low rise podium buildings. Most are 30 to 50 units in scale. And then on the other side, we're doing custom single family homeowner projects with interior design as well.
00;04;27;29 - 00;04;41;10
DP
So Gabe you had your real estate license, which is pretty interesting for an architect, and you use that, I'm assuming, for a few years during the recession and then kind of moved back into architecture. When did you get your architectural license?
00;04;41;13 - 00;04;58;08
GD
So architectural license came around 2012, couple of years after the real estate license, and kind of was doing the two in tandem, you know, working nights and weekends trying to do sales. I got burned out pretty quickly, doing a full time job with an architecture firm, and then that on nights and weekends, it was a lot.
00;04;58;11 - 00;05;15;06
DP
What's so interesting to me is over the course of my career, I have met a lot of architects that end up doing lots of different jobs because architects aren't always busy all the time and they're one of the first people hit by recessions.
00;05;15;08 - 00;05;36;28
GD
Yes. And that's exactly kind of what happened to the big firm that I was with. I wasn't sure of my future there, wasn't sure what I was going to do. And real estate. I had a number of friends that were in the business. I went in that direction and I figured it was somewhat parallel to an interest in residential design.
So it seemed like a natural fit and thankfully it led to a lot of good relationships and some work to start the business.
00;05;37;05 - 00;05;42;19
DP
Yeah, it certainly sounds fortuitous. So what is your role in the office as a principal?
00;05;42;25 - 00;06;01;00
GD
I share the burden of running of the office with my business partner, Derek Spencer. I would say my role is more in the CEO traditional sense, while also the design director of the firm, where my business partner is handling more of the technical development of things and more overseeing the design development of things.
00;06;01;02 - 00;06;06;14
DP
So it's always interesting to find out how people end up working together. How'd you meet Derek?
00;06;06;17 - 00;06;40;10
GD
Derek and I started working together. He was my first employee, actually. I met him through mutual contacts when I realized I was spread too thin, working out of a spare bedroom in my home in the early days of my business. Derek was currently working for a firm across town, that’s, I'd say, one of our competitors. He was looking for something new, and it was the infancy stages of the business, so he came to start working with me.
And fast forward to three years later, we had a team of four of us and we were ready to rebrand and create GNOME Architects.
00;06;40;13 - 00;06;57;06
DP
So let's dig in here and talk about the project. This is really beautiful and I would imagine it took some time to get done in Center City, Philadelphia. So how did your office get the project? And you did mention obviously that you had some relationships or acquaintances that were developers.
00;06;57;09 - 00;07;23;25
GD
This project actually came from one of my very first clients that I had who was connected with the real estate office where I hung my license at that time. It was a partnership between that long existing client and a couple of developers from New York City that purchased the property, and we assisted them to take it through all of the permitting process and all the hoops we had to jump through as it's a pretty sensitive site.
00;07;23;27 - 00;07;28;02
DP
So could you give us a little history of the location before your buildings?
00;07;28;04 - 00;07;57;09
GD
So the site is on the western end of Center City, Philadelphia, about a block away from the Schuylkill River, sits in a floodplain about five feet or so below the FEMA flood zone line. It was a three sided site. So we had challenges to create, drive all access and building entrances and maximizing the use of both Center city and looking west towards the river.
So it was a challenging yet a site that had a lot of great opportunity as well to work with it.
00;07;57;12 - 00;08;03;10
DP
Yes, So unusual to get a piece of property in the city with three street frontages.
00;08;03;13 - 00;08;18;27
GD
Yeah, it's pretty uncommon, but it actually allows for some benefits as far as how you apply the zoning code and how city planning orients. The frontages actually worked to our benefit to get a driver on the back and five houses fronting the broad side of the site.
00;08;18;29 - 00;08;43;06
DP
So, Gabe, what was the scope of the project and what were the programmatic requirements for the townhouses?
00;08;43;09 - 00;09;09;12
GD
So the scope of the project was to try to maximize as many townhouse units as we could across the site, while also ensuring that they felt large and spacious and wide with Philadelphia townhouse development. You're often dealing with very narrow properties, so anything that's built new construction is typically somewhere between 14 and 20 feet wide or so. So we wanted to make sure we could fit as many units while making them as wide as possible.
00;09;09;12 - 00;09;30;29
GD
So five ended up being kind of the magic balance point to get them feeling pretty wide. The developer wanted to make sure we could provide as much parking as possible, so each unit has a two car garage and then really maximizing at least four bedrooms, five plus bathrooms, elevators, and then the big thing here also is just outdoor spaces.
00;09;30;29 - 00;09;42;01
GD
So roof deck spaces are pretty key for Philadelphia Center City Townhouse developments. These houses each contain three roof deck spaces.
00;09;42;04 - 00;09;45;02
DP
And how many stories has the project has had? Four or five.
00;09;45;04 - 00;09;59;18
GD
It's technically five stories by way of the code. However, there is a pilot house on top of each house, which also contains some livable or habitable space, which makes the buildings read as six stories interesting.
00;09;59;18 - 00;10;21;08
DP
So let's talk a little bit about the style, the architecture, some of the buildings that surround it. I had mentioned that we had some pretty strong cornice lines locally and you probably picked up on that in terms of brick courses. And then we've got some really beautiful, tall, decorative patterning on each one of these facades.
00;10;21;15 - 00;10;45;02
GD
We typically like to do our best to work in some contextual elements into our projects. So with this site, there's a lot of surrounding context that has primarily brick material, very strong cornice lines at the rooflines. So inserting a new development that is essentially six stories adjacent to a lot of three and four story buildings, we had to kind of get creative to make things fit in.
00;10;45;05 - 00;11;08;23
GD
So we kind of struck a line at the top of the fourth floor for the brick material. Coming up to that, a chorus line at the top of the fourth floor. And then we selected a kind of a gray, brown, beige tone brick, as a lot of the neighboring buildings are a variety of colors. So there's not really a strong predominance of red brick or white brick or brown.
00;11;08;23 - 00;11;16;20
GD
It's kind of all over the place. So the gray brown tone of the selected brick that we used kind of was a nice middle ground for it.
00;11;16;22 - 00;11;34;10
DP
So let's go back to the zoning for a second. So these buildings step back as they move up above that third story. Plus they're up at least on one end, at least five feet, creating these stoops. Did you have to step the buildings back? I know you clearly did that for functional reasons to have these roof gardens up there.
00;11;34;17 - 00;11;57;18
GD
Yes. So it was, again, just a way to kind of fit within the context of the lower height buildings around us. The zoning code didn't really require us to set the buildings back where we did. We did it more for the outdoor spaces, but the fourth floor line was kind of the natural place to do a material transition to make the massing fit well with the vernacular nearby.
00;11;57;20 - 00;12;00;28
DP
Were there any historical reviews by the zoning board?
00;12;01;00 - 00;12;31;12
GD
Surprisingly, this was not a historical designated site, so we were not subject to any historic review. I would say the biggest hurdles we had or really within meeting the flood zone regulations. So it was a challenge to make sure we maintained all the FEMA regulations so these buildings don't have basements. We have flood doors on all facades and the challenges related to keeping your habitable floors above the flood plain were the big driving elements for this.
00;12;31;15 - 00;12;45;24
DP
Okay, so first floors above the floodplain, the base, the plinth, I'll call it, is masonry, is brick masonry. So you have these doors. Do they have to be a certain size? And I would imagine they're breakaway or is that the way it works?
00;12;45;26 - 00;13;06;23
GD
So each structure had to have a number of flood vents on at least two sides of the exterior walls. The size of these denser, I believe, one square inch per square foot of building footprint. They allow for the passing of flood water going in and out of the building just to relieve the flood pressure that the building would be subject to.
00;13;06;28 - 00;13;21;11
GD
So we did our best to hide them in kind of inconspicuous areas along the front facade where they were required, as well as the back of the building where the dry is. That's not really seen from the public right of way. So it was a nice place to hide these vents.
00;13;21;13 - 00;13;32;09
DP
So tell me about the apartments and plants we get along rectangle and each one of these is more squarish in plan. And I'm also wondering, I don't see the two car garages.
00;13;32;11 - 00;13;56;26
GD
Yeah. So the garages are all facing a rear drive aisle that we were able to hide. It's like a one way drive I'll access that comes in off of one of the small side streets, exits on the far end of the other side street. And then there are two car garages at the rear of each home are facing this drive while the driveway is also covered by a series of exterior decks, each deck serving one of the houses.
00;13;56;26 - 00;14;01;13
GD
So it's a covered drive aisle with a garage door. At either end of it, you never actually see it.
00;14;01;19 - 00;14;04;11
DP
And the buildings in plan are the each rectangles.
00;14;04;13 - 00;14;17;17
GD
Yes. So they're roughly, I'd say, 22, 23 feet wide by 40 to 50 feet deep with the drive at the rear and the main entrance at the opposite side facing the street frontage.
00;14;17;20 - 00;14;23;24
DP
So what was the building review like with the city of Philadelphia? Was that challenging? Was it time consuming?
00;14;24;01 - 00;14;45;16
GD
So it had a bit of back and forth. Our office handling primarily projects in Philadelphia. We've made a lot of good relationships with different plans examiners, different city agencies. I've gotten to know the process pretty well, as it is rather daunting for anyone who's unfamiliar with it. So I would say this project had a number of rounds of verifies from the plans.
00;14;45;16 - 00;15;10;14
GD
Examiner is mostly related to the interpretation of the parking that was implemented as well as kind of the interpretation of the roof deck access structures and that type of things. And typically it's a dialog with them to make sure everyone's kind of on the same page and there's a middle ground you need to find. But I would say we got through it in a couple of rounds, which was better than we had expected given the sensitive features of the site.
00;15;10;16 - 00;15;25;02
DP
So building materials you guys used primary Li Brick, I mentioned to you before we got rolling, it's a light. It appears to be a light brown brick. It's actually called Stonington gray velour. It's got a wide variety of values or shades in it.
00;15;25;08 - 00;15;46;03
GD
This was a really beautiful brick that worked well for our goals to kind of strike a line between the various masonry colors of the surrounding buildings. So it actually has a nice amount of variety in it. Some of the bricks are a lot more brown and darker. Some of the bricks are very light kind of in the the off-white color range.
00;15;46;03 - 00;16;06;16
GD
So once you get close, you really see the variety of color that's in there, which is really nice. And then at different times of the day, it also reads a little bit differently in the morning in direct sunlight. It kind of has a more of a warm brown tone to it and kind of in the twilight hours of the sun going down, there's a lot of reflectivity is caught.
00;16;06;16 - 00;16;13;14
GD
And when you look closely at it, so it really speaks well to the contemporary approach that the building esthetic has.
00;16;13;16 - 00;16;42;09
DP
What I love about this project is the brick pattern. You guys really spent a lot of time working on all the different patterning that's happening at the Stoops and around the windows, at the cornice lines. So tell us about how you did that in the office. Right? Typically we see a designer working on exterior elevation drawings and then, you know, the lead designers review them and it's back and forth and then eventually you're putting that into the CDs and you're doing mock ups in the field.
00;16;42;09 - 00;16;43;19
DP
So how did that go?
00;16;43;22 - 00;17;09;08
GD
Yeah, so it surprisingly went pretty smoothly on this project. The brick patterning that we went with was kind of a solution to a number of problems. We had planned driven windows, which is typical of these Philadelphia townhouse projects where you don't have a lot of space. So your windows can only go in certain areas. But then when you want to create alignments vertically on the facade and such, you've got to kind of get creative.
00;17;09;08 - 00;17;32;11
GD
Sometimes if that's a goal. So the brick patterning that we implemented was a tool to kind of strike these alignments vertically in the facade. So we have this recessed entry portal that is maybe two thirds of the width of the frontage, but the windows on the upper floors could not necessarily align with the jams of that portal opening.
00;17;32;11 - 00;18;01;20
GD
So we implemented brick patterning at the JAMB locations of the windows to then create a hard line that would align with the portal entryway below. That's one way we used the pattern to help. We also used it to just create interest on the facade. As I mentioned, the flood zone required us to keep the living spaces pretty high out of grade and that resulted in what would otherwise be a rather blank wall at the base of the building.
00;18;01;20 - 00;18;17;09
GD
The changes in brick pattern were a tool to kind of add some interest, so the brick we chose in relationship to a lot of cast stone that also creates some interesting accents around the window openings was a nice balance.
00;18;17;12 - 00;18;26;27
DP
What I really love is in this photograph on the far left you've got the brick patterning at the center stoop, but the patterning is completely different. On the left and right.
00;18;26;29 - 00;18;52;27
GD
The stoops were a huge focus of the design, so we had to get the occupants about 5 to 6 feet above the sidewalk level to the entry doors, which instead of having kind of a visible staircase that would otherwise dominate the sidewalk, we utilized a screen wall of brick in front of the staircase entryway that was also in front of a patterned planter box.
00;18;52;27 - 00;19;16;10
GD
So you have these multiple layers of masonry that add interest at the staircase. It allows us to insert some greenery as well. So it's a very tactile experience as you walk up to the front door of these houses that worked out very beautifully and the execution of the masonry and saw was fantastic by the mason as well, which we were very pleased to see.
00;19;16;12 - 00;19;39;18
GD
We had a series of conversations with the GC to make sure everyone was on the same page with the detailing. Our construction documents were very thorough to make sure that the areas of recess patterning as well as kind of projected roll lock and soldier course detailing was achieved and all the shadow lines could be read throughout the day as the sun moves around the building.
00;19;39;20 - 00;19;42;16
DP
So did you guys draw this in 2D and 3D?
00;19;42;18 - 00;20;12;01
GD
Yes. Our process typically starts with a three dimensional model of the building that we get to a comfortable point. We utilize sketch up primarily for a design tool in the schematic phase. And once we're happy with the sketch model, we move into 2D drawing. This project was done a few years ago before our office implemented Revit, but we were still able to successfully document how all the masonry patterning was working in 2D.
00;20;12;04 - 00;20;16;29
DP
So did you show the three dimensional model to the clients along the way?
00;20;17;06 - 00;20;42;27
GD
We did. We had a number of options for this projects. They were all similar in the materiality, but some were maybe a little more traditional, others were even more contemporary looking. So we utilized the 3D models as a design tool to visualize the project to the client. And in the end they were very happy with one of the options we chose, which had very minimal changes that they needed to see.
00;20;43;00 - 00;20;47;25
DP
Clients love 3D models, right? Were you able to model any of the BRIC in SketchUp?
00;20;47;27 - 00;21;17;18
GD
We built the SketchUp model and applied some custom made material swatches that we built utilizing other brick colors, and we made sure we could match exactly what the Stonington gray velour would look like. And then it was just a matter of scaling the pattern down to the brick unit. So even in the areas where you have these dimple patterns that read against the entryway walls, all of the patterns were aligned perfectly to align up with the massing recesses that took place in the model.
00;21;17;18 - 00;21;19;20
GD
So it ended up being pretty successful.
00;21;19;22 - 00;21;23;26
DP
So how many people worked on the team for the project from the architects office?
00;21;23;28 - 00;21;40;10
GD
I would say that through the design process there were at least four of us that work through the design concepts together and I would say primarily one designer and myself kind of pushed the design to where it is now. But back when we did the project, it was a pretty collaborative effort within the office.
00;21;40;13 - 00;21;48;08
DP
So I feel like every project I learn something new. Did you guys learn anything through the process of working on this project?
00;21;48;11 - 00;22;11;06
GD
We learned quite a bit, especially in terms of the brick detailing here. We kind of learned that certain patterns have rules around them, especially when you're utilizing like a stacked pattern where you have these very clean vertical lines that need to be maintained. It's tricky to make sure that things don't read as a mistake within that patterning, especially as it relates to where you put windows.
00;22;11;08 - 00;22;31;10
GD
So we had to make sure our window spacing was just right. So you didn't results in little slivers of brick that would be noticeable and read as a mistake. So we took a lot of care in making sure that the tolerances and the actual window sizes and everything were worked in to make sure that we didn't end up with those kind of conditions.
00;22;31;12 - 00;22;45;08
DP
And that takes some pretty close work with the. Mason You mentioned that you thought the execution worked out well. Did you guys have a tough time finding a mason or was the first mason you guys ended up meeting the person you used.
00;22;45;10 - 00;23;11;22
GD
So the general contractor, it was his team, really. And the mason that he chose and started the project with kind of nailed it right from the start. We had probably two or three on site meetings with the Mason, looking at the drawings. That's a back and forth with some questions. And then ultimately we had a small mockup in the field and everyone was on the same page and collectively in the room together to make sure that the execution was going to happen just right.
00;23;11;22 - 00;23;12;18
GD
And it did.
00;23;12;20 - 00;23;40;09
DP
So last thing I wanted to ask you about was the metal panels on the fourth floor and these large bay windows on the outside edges of the building. Really beautiful. These are great details. You see these bay window details everywhere on 1930s and forties, city architecture. And I think doing that on the ends of these buildings and then adding the flat lock metal panels to the fourth floor is really beautiful.
00;23;40;11 - 00;23;41;19
DP
Great detail.
00;23;41;22 - 00;23;59;21
GD
Yeah. So back to kind of the challenges of working in Philadelphia and not a lot of space to work with. The bay windows are always a tool to add a little bit more interior square footage, but the challenge is always Hadia clad them. How do you make them feel appropriate when the rest of the facade material is masonry?
00;23;59;23 - 00;24;29;00
GD
Yeah, we kind of struck a line with a traditional meets contemporary bay esthetic to compliment the window patterns within the masonry as well. So the bays have very kind of glassy windows, wrapping all sides in the same style of windows as the punched openings within the flanking brick masonry and then the color of the bays being much darker than the masonry was meant to draw more attention away from the bay and actually focus it on the adjacent brick masonry.
00;24;29;02 - 00;24;48;17
DP
One more comment or question. These entry portals are beautiful. Was it tough for you guys to decide? Okay, we're going to set back the front door and these very large windows lose a little bit of square footage, but we get these entries which are highly differentiated on the facade or along the facade.
00;24;48;20 - 00;25;11;06
GD
Yes. So the entry portal was a result of trying to solve a problem around the narrow sidewalk. The city only allows you to project so far into the public right of way and you're trying to make this nice prominent entrance for this luxury townhouse. And in order to achieve a wide staircase going up there, you got to kind of recess the frontage of the building.
00;25;11;06 - 00;25;31;25
GD
So we accomplished that by recessing just the entryway that the ground floor. When I mentioned being in the floodplain, we had to get the first floor up pretty high. So the entry door is actually at a middle landing between the garage level in the first floor. The first floor is actually up about ten feet above the sidewalk. So we recessed the entryway.
00;25;31;25 - 00;25;40;02
GD
It allowed us to have four or five foot wide steps leading up to the front door and a nice prominent procession up the steps to the front door of the house.
00;25;40;09 - 00;26;03;15
DP
Well, Gabe, it's a beautiful project. When I first saw these photos, I was really excited to do this interview. So I have done so many different things in my career while being an architect. And while it's not that unusual, I've found that being an architect has helped me to be good at lots of other things in my life.
00;26;03;18 - 00;26;30;10
DP
The other thing that I will say is that we end up working on many different things in our lives, even if we're let's say you end up doing stair details for a large firm for ten years and you think I wasted all that time doing stair details. The reality is we never really know when any of the things that we learn how to do will come in handy and can ultimately change our life in some way, even if it's in a small way.
00;26;30;10 - 00;26;45;28
DP
So I think it's really cool that you got your real estate license because you made all of these relationships or just a couple relationships that ultimately helped you become a successful architect. It's a big deal, right? So I don't think you give yourself enough credit.
00;26;46;00 - 00;27;04;16
GD
Yeah, I think I realized early on that I was good at some things, but not good at everything I needed to be good at. So the relationships were everything, especially in the early days. So knowing when to reach out to the people who know the solution is a big part of being an architect, a big part of being an entrepreneur.
00;27;04;16 - 00;27;22;22
GD
Starting a business as well is, you know, you need to do it right. You have a license that you got to hang your hat on. So it's critical for you to understand when it's time to reach out for design professionals outside of your purview and outside of your profession for the right solution to problems on your projects.
00;27;22;24 - 00;27;29;20
DP
So, Gabe, it's been great to have you here. Thanks so much for your time. Where can people go to learn more about No more architects and yourself?
00;27;29;22 - 00;27;44;25
GD
Sure. So our website is pretty current websites WWE and gnome arch dot com genome RC. I would say even more current than that is our Instagram account, which is also at Gnome Arch.
00;27;44;28 - 00;27;47;19
DP
So one more question. Where did you get the name?
00;27;47;21 - 00;28;09;22
GD
The name actually came from a rebranding exercise that we did back in 2018 and we were looking to create a new identity that spoke to the residential nature of our products and we wanted to kind of speak to the home and a place of being. So the gnome, the garden gnome is a character that does that. It's the marker of place.
00;28;09;22 - 00;28;35;29
GD
We also wanted the branding to be very memorable and approachable, so we initially kind of wrote off a name that came to us from our rebranding company and we thought it was crazy. And the more rounds of more names they suggested to us, the more we came back to that first stab of GNOME being the solution and so happy that we trusted in the company that we rebranded with and it's worked out for us very well.
00;28;36;05 - 00;28;37;25
DP
It's a great story. Well, thanks again, Gabe.
00;28;38;00 - 00;28;41;13
GD
Thank you.
00;28;41;16 - 00;29;05;01
DP
Thanks for listening. If you learned something today, share this episode with a friend and give us a rating and review on Apple Podcasts to help others find the show. If you want to find out more about today's project, visit Glengarry com forward slash design dash vault that's gleaned GSR y dot com forward slash design dash vault one even more inspiration.
00;29;05;01 - 00;29;28;24
DP
Take a look around Glengarry icon while you're there. Glengarry is one of the nation's largest brick manufacturers and an industry leader for its diversified product line of more than 600 brick products with inspiring photos, useful resources, easy search tools, helpful design studios, and more. I'm sure you'll find the inspiration you need to stretch your imagination
You May Also Be Interested In
We Can Help With Your Next Project
Discover the latest + greatest in design trends, industry news & pro tips from pros.
For all of your project needs, you’ll find everything you need at a Supply Center.
Let Us Know How We Can Help!
Design Vault Ep. 23 Private Residence with Ross Padluck
ABOUT THE ARCHITECT:
![]()
|
Ross Padluck is a Partner at Kligerman Architecture & Design. He joined the firm under Ike Kligerman Barkley in 2010. Ross’ passion for architecture began with a childhood fascination of historic New England homes. Before joining the firm, Ross worked at Skidmore, Owings and Merrill and Superstructures. He matriculated at the New York Institute of Technology for a bachelor degree in architecture, where he accepted the AIA Henry Adams Medal as valedictorian of the School of Architecture. His work at Kligerman Architecture & design has been featured in Architectural Digest, Luxe, Interiors and Gallerie.
Daniela is also an educator. Since the early 1980’s she has taught at Yale University as a TA, University of Pennsylvania and Drexel University, and has developed and taught Bryn Mawr College’s design studio program. She often serves on juries for professional awards in architectural design and construction quality, as well as serving on academic reviews.
|
---|
ABOUT THE PROJECT:
The house is located on a narrow, urban lot. The vernacular of the neighborhood includes many homes from the 1920s that utilize various elements of brick and stone cladding combined with tile roofs and decorative windows.
We drew our inspiration from the Italian Art Deco movement as well as the German Expressionists. We studied the work of Piero Portaluppi, who was preeminent in Italy in the 1920s and 1930s. His architecture is a streamlined Deco Classicism with creative forms and decorative elements. We also looked at German architects such as Fritz Hoger and Henrich Muller, who were creative very experimental forms with brick.
For the exterior design of this home, the goal was to create a very detailed exterior that complemented the established vernacular of the neighborhood while still standing on its own. We created a monochrome color palette of rich colors by using Hunt Valley colored brick from Glen Gery, lilac sandstone, black windows, toned stucco, black slate, and copper. All of the brick designs on the house were made with using standardized special shapes from the catalog, and pairing the shapes together to create unique combinations. This results in the gentle undulation of the columns between the front windows, and the corduroy texture of the chimney. The crown above the entry arch was created all from standard bricks, and is supported by the solid sandstone column, affectionately referred to as the Chess Piece by the masons.
The leaded glass panels in the windows utilized wavy restoration glass and clear roundels. The delicateness of the leaded glass panels is contrasted by the weight and mass of the brick piers. The roof dormers are clad in copper. We kept the detailing on the dormers tight, they appear as objects perched on the roof, invoking the work of the Germans in the 20s.
All of the detailing on the house is subtle. The brick is the star of the design. We’ve molded and shaped and cut it to create a masonry skin, similar to how we use wood shingles. All of these elements gently pull together to create a home that commands a quiet, solid presence on the block.

TRANSCRIPT
00;00;00;02 - 00;00;05;09
Doug Pat (DP)
Let's go inside the vault. The design vault.
00;00;05;11 - 00;00;30;15
Ross Padluck (RP)
What we did on the inside was opened the living room, the dining room and the family room in the back with these pocketing doors so that when the doors are closed, you can have these very private moments in the house. But when they're entertaining, the series of pocket doors opens up. So the property is really open from the front terrace into the living room, dining room and the yard in the back so you can kind of open the house up front to back, or you could close it down from more intimate settings.
00;00;30;17 - 00;03;44;04
DP
This is my guest, Ross Padluck. I'll share more about him shortly. In this episode from the Design Vault, we highlight an Italian art Deco private residence designed by Ross. The private residence we're discussing today is located on a narrow urban lot in a neighborhood which includes many homes from the 1920s. These homes feature various elements of brick and stone cladding combined with tile roofs and decorative windows.
The new home was inspired by the Italian art deco movement, as well as the German Expressionist. It draws from the work of Piero Portaluppi, a preeminent architect of streamlined art deco classicism in Italy in the 1920s and thirties. Other inspirations include German architects Fritz Hogar and Heinrich Muller, well-known for creative and experimental forms constructed with brick.
The exterior of the home is composed of details that decidedly complement the vernacular of the neighborhood. The construction palette of masonry includes brick, lilac sandstone, black windows, black slate and copper. Interestingly, the brick shapes, which appear to be custom, are actually all standard Glen-Gery modules. The course work is detailed and unique. The leaded glass panels in the windows are restoration glass and the roof dormers are clad in copper.
The details of the house are mannerist yet subtle, and the brick is creatively patterned in coursed to give the house a unique personality. Hi, I'm Doug Pat and this is Design Vault. Ross Padluck is a registered architect and partner at Kligerman Architecture & Design in New York City. Ross has a Bachelor of Architecture degree from New York Institute of Technology, where he received AIA Henry Adams medal as valedictorian of the School of Architecture.
Ross’s passion for architecture started young. Back then, he remembers being fascinated with the historic homes of New England. He joined Kligerman Architecture & Design in 2010. His work has been featured in Architectural Digest, Lux Interiors, and Gallery. His firm is known for design, rooted in tradition, but modern in its sculptural forms, precise details, material integrity and liberal use of glass.
The firm still creates presentations by hand and uses the latest digital technologies, including 3D printers and VR. So welcome, Ross. It's nice to have you with us today. So tell us a little bit about Kligerman Architecture & Design in New York City. So where are you guys located in the city? What size is the firm? How long has it been around and what type of work do you do?
00;03;44;06 - 00;04;29;13
RP
Well, thank you for having me. Kligerman Architecture & Design, we’re actually just up the street from the Brickworks Studio. We're on the corner of 42nd Street and Fifth Avenue across the street from the library. We're in 505th Avenue, which is a Shreve, Lamb and Harmon Building which is, I guess, considered the sister building to the Empire State Building. They were built at the same time with the same architect and 505th was completed first before the Empire State Building.
And at the time it was the tallest building in the world. Before it was surpassed by its sister, the Empire State Building. We're about a 40 person architecture and interiors firm. We do high end residential architecture, mostly single family. We were known as Ike Kligerman Barkley when I joined the firm. We went through an ownership transition last year when I became a partner.
00;04;29;20 - 00;04;39;06
DP
Well, interestingly, as an aside, I do high end residential architecture. I worked with a gentleman named Joe Moore for about 20 years. He's up in the Greenwich area.
00;04;39;14 - 00;04;40;27
RP
Okay. That's a great neighborhood.
00;04;41;02 - 00;04;48;24
DP
Yeah, that's really cool. So tell us a little bit about yourself. So how long have you been practicing architecture and what's your role in the office as partner?
00;04;49;01 - 00;05;20;11
RP
I always knew I wanted to be an architect. Since I was in preschool. I was sort of drawing houses and building them out of blocks when I was in preschool. So it was just a natural career. And I come from a family of architects, so it just sort of all made sense. My first job actually, I started of working for an architect when I was 14 years old.
Yeah, I did. After school drafting for an architect in high school and kind of had various internships and stuff from there at Kligerman, as a partner there, I run a studio, oversee probably about a dozen projects at the moment.
00;05;20;18 - 00;05;24;27
DP
Tell me about your family. Family of architects. That's interesting. Both mom and dad?
00;05;25;01 - 00;05;41;03
RP
No, my uncle is an architect who was a kind of huge influence and resource on me. And I have a cousin who's an architect and one is an engineer. I have another cousin who's a graphic designer. So there's this sort of creative energy in the family. My grandmother was a painter, too.
00;05;41;06 - 00;05;43;27
DP
That's really cool. I mean, architects are pretty rare.
00;05;44;01 - 00;05;50;05
RP
It's kind of a not a common profession in families, but it sort of comes naturally to us, I guess.
00;05;50;12 - 00;05;56;01
DP
Very cool. So let's dig in here and talk about the home. So how did your office get the project?
00;05;56;07 - 00;06;05;15
RP
So it's a community that we've done a lot of work in over the years. We have a long history of doing work in that community and it was a referral from another client that we got the project.
00;06;05;17 - 00;06;07;09
DP
So you didn't know the clients?
00;06;07;09 - 00;06;10;09
RP
Did not know them, but they were friends of one of our other clients.
00;06;10;16 - 00;06;13;06
DP
And what about the location? So was there a house there?
00;06;13;13 - 00;06;23;24
RP
There was a house there. It was sort of a turn of the century house that had been badly renovated in the eighties. You know, we were growing family and it was time for a new house. So they turned to us to design it.
00;06;23;28 - 00;06;32;13
DP
So the location, there are lots of homes from the 1920s era and are they still there and simply getting renovated or is it turning over?
00;06;32;16 - 00;07;03;27
RP
There's not many left, the kind of vernacular of that neighborhood. There were a lot of homes built in that sort of 1920s timeframe that were kind of brick and stone and had slag glass windows and tile roofs like you mentioned. And there's kind of very Spanish and Moorish ornate feeling to them. Unfortunately, a lot of them have been torn down.
They've been replaced with newer and larger homes, but there's still a few left in the neighborhood. And the neighborhood is sort of maintains that character, even though the homes have been replaced of the sort of 1920s buildings.
00;07;04;00 - 00;07;16;20
DP
So that ultimately did impact the esthetic of the home that you design. We'll talk about that in a little bit. So what was the scope of the project? That is, what were the programmatic requirements for the project?
00;07;16;23 - 00;07;31;06
RP
It's a single-family home, so it had to have entertaining space and living space on the first floor for them. They do a lot of in-house, entertaining large parties and then enough space for the clients and their children on a very small lot.
00;07;31;09 - 00;07;39;08
DP
Yeah. So what were the project restrictions in terms of the height of the building and the size of the building on the lot? Were they pretty stringent?
00;07;39;08 - 00;07;55;03
RP
Yeah. The zoning in that neighborhood is pretty restrictive, so you have to fit a lot into a very small envelope. So you have to be really creative of how you use floor space and how you configure the building envelope to fit within the zoning requirements and the floor area restrictions.
00;07;55;05 - 00;08;01;13
DP
And you couldn't go over two and a half stories or okay, so I nailed that. That was the restriction. Two and a half stories?
00;08;01;13 - 00;08;07;03
RP
There's actually not a restriction of stories, it's a restriction of height. So that's what limits how far you can go.
00;08;07;10 - 00;08;10;02
DP
And FAR restrictions, is that what they call them.
00;08;10;02 - 00;08;13;02
RP
Yea, floor area ratio, it's pretty tight there.
00;08;13;04 - 00;08;41;24
DP
So let's talk a little bit about the building design. Stylistically, we talked a little bit about this already, the Italian art deco influence and of course the reference that I made earlier to the German architects. Interestingly, I was looking at Portal Whoopi's work online. I know it sounds a little bizarre, but it almost seemed like a modern cross between Palladio and Boulay, right?
I mean, it's just the symmetry is gorgeous. Some of the buildings that this man designed were unbelievable.
00;08;41;26 - 00;09;16;27
RP
Yeah, they're really incredible. I've had the fortune of being in a few of them in Italy, and Porto Lippi was sort of off the radar up until a couple of years ago. And now it's, you know, there's all these books out about them and everyone's sort of looking at it. But he just did really incredible sort of forward thinking work in Italy in that timeframe that was still sort of rooted in tradition, not too dissimilar from the work that we do at the firm.
So it sort of just seemed like a natural influence for us. A lot of his work was urban, a lot of it was in Milan, so it sort of had that urbanity to it like this house does.
00;09;17;04 - 00;09;22;27
DP
So tell us a little bit about the building plan. Looks relatively straightforward, like a large rectangle.
00;09;23;05 - 00;09;52;11
RP
Yeah, the sort of narrow rectangular lots. So there's not much you could do with it. What we did on the inside was opened the living room, the dining room and the family room in the back with these pocketing doors so that when the doors are closed, you can have these very private moments in the house. But when they're entertaining, the series of pocket doors opens up.
So the property is really open from the front terrace into the living room, dining room and the yard in the back so you could kind of open the house up front to back or you could close it down from more intimate settings.
00;09;52;14 - 00;10;00;17
DP
That's a really nice idea for a relatively narrow house. Who came up with that idea where the client's like, Whoa you guys showed it to them and they thought, Wow, this is really neat.
00;10;00;24 - 00;10;05;14
RP
You know, they were really kind of happy with it. We sort of hit it on the first shot, I guess you could say.
00;10;05;21 - 00;10;08;28
DP
So how large was the team that was working with you on the.
00;10;09;00 - 00;10;11;25
RP
It was me and at the time, John Ike.
00;10;11;27 - 00;10;19;17
DP
So let's talk a little bit about the facade, which is very interesting. All brick, who decided on brick?
00;10;19;23 - 00;10;31;19
RP
It's the vernacular in that neighborhood. Just about every house uses brick or stone or a combination of them. The natural choice to use. So we wouldn't recommend anything else in that neighborhood.
00;10;31;26 - 00;10;33;02
DP
And what about the color?
00;10;33;05 - 00;10;39;26
RP
So we wanted to create something that was a little richer, a little darker, a little moodier. And that's how we ended up with that color.
00;10;39;28 - 00;10;59;28
DP
I want to back up a little bit. I always ask our guests about the town reviews, like how long that process took was a challenging historical neighborhood, that sort of thing. What did you guys go through in terms of presentation? So you meet with the client, you show more schematic design. Then ultimately you've got to go to the town and get this thing approved.
00;11;00;07 - 00;11;05;15
RP
There wasn't any sort of historic or architectural review board there, so it was just the building department.
00;11;05;21 - 00;11;12;22
DP
And in terms of zoning requirements, the building had to be relatively narrow rights for the setbacks. Were they restrictive or?
00;11;12;25 - 00;11;24;10
RP
Restrictive on the sides? The biggest challenge is the floor area, which is very restrictive. You kind of have to fit a lot into a very small footprint. So there's very little wasted space in the floorplan.
00;11;24;12 - 00;11;42;01
DP
So let's talk about the facade. What I loved about this house was the figuring in the brick, right? So there were all stock sizes and shapes used by your company and was that intentional? You didn't want to spend extra money having these custom shapes made?
00;11;42;04 - 00;12;16;04
RP
Yeah, we wanted to have that in mind of trying to do this with stock shapes. We wanted to do an all-brick house, which is inherently a little more expensive. And instead of doing custom shapes, we looked through the Glen-Gery catalog to see what was available, sort of quote unquote in stock that wasn't custom made. And then we took these different shapes and create a different patterns and modules with them.
And that's how we created those sort of columns that are between the windows. And we created that corduroy texture that's on the chimney all out of Glen-Gery shapes.
00;12;16;06 - 00;12;27;19
DP
Yeah, I found that really beautiful. The piers in between the windows are figured, right? So when you guys design that, did you ultimately do mock ups in the fields to see what these things looked like?
00;12;27;25 - 00;12;40;03
RP
We 3D printed the brick shapes and then sort of put them together almost like Legos to see what makes sense and what makes an interesting shape. And we did mockups on our 3D printer with those brick shapes to kind of lay it out.
00;12;40;10 - 00;12;52;27
DP
And what about some of this interesting coursing that I found as I looked around the exterior elevations, for example, at the entrance, right? The coursing above that entrance is almost done in a star shape or a crown like shape.
00;12;53;04 - 00;13;16;03
RP
Yeah, it's sort of a star shape or a crown, as you say. And we had originally designed that in stone, and the owner had wanted the house to feel a lot more monochrome. So I said, Well, why don't we do it in Brick? And it sort of created that crown shape out of, it's just modular standard brick that's laid at different angles and it sort of radiates around the arch to create that pattern.
00;13;16;10 - 00;13;19;06
DP
To remind me some of the other details on the house.
00;13;19;13 - 00;13;58;12
RP
The house is about that arch. It's the entrance. It's very subtle because it's all done out of the brick. It doesn't really stand out, but it's a detail that you notice right away just the way the mortar joints are run to create that pattern. And then we have, as I mentioned, the special piers between the windows, which are created of three different pieces of brick special shapes that create that.
And there is the chimney, which is the corduroy texture. We also used some of the sill pieces to create a water table or sort of base around the house. And then we experimented with different patterns of brick running bonds and stock bonds to create different patterns and sections of the house to break up the mass of it a little bit.
00;13;58;19 - 00;14;01;11
DP
And the dormer is done in copper, which is really cool.
00;14;01;16 - 00;14;15;03
RP
I like when Dormers feel like objects on a roof. I don't like when the metal roof comes out. So we created them to feel, you know, like these copper boxes sitting on the roof, which is a very German kind of mannerism of going about that.
00;14;15;05 - 00;14;23;16
DP
So on a project like this, it's obviously really important to find a good mason. So you guys clearly found somebody liked. What was that process like?
00;14;23;22 - 00;14;37;18
RP
We worked very hand-in-hand with the Mason to create that. You know, we're very specific about all these different patterns and layouts. So it was a lot of site visits and working one on one to make sure our vision came to reality on the house.
00;14;37;20 - 00;14;47;28
DP
So you were talking about having a 3D printer and making these that must have been a really fun process, right? I mean, that's like the awesome stuff that architects get to do.
00;14;48;01 - 00;15;02;08
RP
Yeah, it is. The 3D printer itself is kind of a pain to use. It's finicky, but once you get it to actually do what you want it to do, being able to just sort of create these shapes and put them together was really satisfying. That's sort of how we create our vision.
00;15;02;08 - 00;15;04;20
DP
Did you guys do the building in Revit?
00;15;04;26 - 00;15;09;13
RP
The building was actually done in CAD, believe it or not, all 2D.
00;15;09;17 - 00;15;11;00
DP
So no 3D renderings?
00;15;11;02 - 00;15;12;27
RP
Nope. Except for hand renderings.
00;15;12;29 - 00;15;14;29
DP
Is that pretty typical for your office?
00;15;15;02 - 00;15;38;11
RP
Most of our projects are in Revit now. For me, the intricacies of the house, I felt more confident doing it in 2D. It's just the way my brain thinks. I still think of old school drafting and that's kind of what CAD does. And the house was small enough that it was manageable. A lot of our other houses that are much larger than this, it makes sense to do them in Revit, but I felt kind of old school doing it in CAD, but it worked out.
00;15;38;19 - 00;15;42;14
DP
And did the clients get to see these little models, the little modules or?
00;15;42;18 - 00;15;50;21
RP
Absolutely. We showed them, you know, this is the pattern and these are the different shapes of brick and they got a kick out of it, but they were excited.
00;15;50;24 - 00;15;59;05
DP
Yeah, very cool. So, we talked about the size of your team. There were two people that worked on the project essentially and start to finish. How long does that take for your office?
00;15;59;13 - 00;16;19;23
RP
Search to finish a house of the skills is about three years. We're about a year for design from when a client first hires us to get through schematic design construction documents, permitting, all of that. And then construction is about two years, which seems like a long time. But our houses are very custom and we're doing very one off sort of things.
00;16;19;28 - 00;16;22;05
RP
It takes time, but it's worth it in the end.
00;16;22;07 - 00;16;31;08
DP
Yeah, you know, that process can be pretty interesting for people that haven't done it before, the clients. Have these clients been through a custom home before?
00;16;31;14 - 00;16;38;06
RP
Not to this scale. They had renovated a home before, but they hadn't built a home like this before, so it was a first time for them.
00;16;38;09 - 00;16;40;17
DP
Well, I'm sure that we're very happy, the house is beautiful.
00;16;40;24 - 00;16;44;01
RP
Thank you. They were very happy. So we did our job.
00;16;44;03 - 00;16;50;10
DP
Awesome. So the column in the front. Very cool. Reminds me a lot of Frank Furnace.
00;16;50;16 - 00;16;50;28
RP
Yes.
00;16;50;28 - 00;16;53;11
DP
Whose idea was that? Where did that come from?
00;16;53;17 - 00;17;15;21
RP
That was mine. We wanted to create something special on that corner. Since it is the main entrance to the house. And it was inspired by a lot of the work that Portaluppi did, where he uses more classical elements and we didn't want to do another piece of brick there. It was time to do some stone. It is solid lilac sandstone that's supporting that brick arch.
00;17;15;24 - 00;17;18;00
DP
So was that difficult to have made?
00;17;18;02 - 00;17;25;01
RP
We had it custom made, unlike the brick, we did have the column custom made. It was milled in Canada.
00;17;25;03 - 00;17;36;04
DP
Did your team learn anything interesting through the design and construction process? It's clearly a pretty unique home, so there were a few new things for you guys, I would assume.
00;17;36;11 - 00;17;55;25
RP
Yeah, I think working through the brick shapes and the course thing, we try and get Windows to line up with brick coursing or if the windows are off, you adjust the stone sills to make up for the difference in brick. And I think we learned a lot about just making sure that the brick lines up everywhere.
00;17;55;28 - 00;18;06;19
DP
So were there any instances of we drew it this way, but then you get in the field and you're working with a mason, They're like, no, you know, we're not going to be on course here and we're going to have to adjust things.
00;18;06;19 - 00;18;32;16
RP
There were a few instances where the cursing under the windows was ever so slightly off, but we were able to adjust that with the stone sills and make it work. I was very exact when I drew it to make sure that everything mathematically worked out just because the design was so important to us and to the clients, we really wanted to make sure you could actually build it the way we intended it.
The drawings were pretty precise, and that led to a fairly smooth construction process.
00;18;32;18 - 00;19;03;09
DP
That's great. It is one of the most important things to me. After the house has been designed, we sign up the GC, we get rolling on the project, the project managers get to know one another. This would be the architect and the project manager for the general contractor. Those first couple meetings between those two people are really important because at that point you get to spend a lot of time explaining, okay, this is why I drew it this way and I need you to keep this in mind when we build it, right?
00;19;03;16 - 00;19;25;09
RP
Yeah. We were fortunate to have a really good contractor. He was really a craftsman. Very hands on approach, like we have with design and construction. He understood our design goals for the house and the quality goals, he really paid attention to the details and worked with us throughout construction to make sure the vision was carried out.
00;19;25;11 - 00;19;37;20
DP
So Ross, before you go, you've been an architect for a little while now. Based on what you know about being an architect today, do you have any words of advice for your younger self or even young architects getting started?
00;19;37;22 - 00;20;11;11
RP
I do. You know, the advice is to stick with it. A lot of people that I went to school with did not end up pursuing a career in architecture. For me, it's something I love doing. I'm very passionate about it and it's not an easy educational process. It's not an easy career. I think a lot of people get discouraged by that, but if you love it and you care about it, just stick with it because it's very rewarding and we get to do really unique and special things.
There's not a day that goes by that I don't regret my career choice.
00;20;11;16 - 00;20;24;07
DP
Well, that's really cool. Being a high-end residential architect can be extremely challenging, but also very rewarding long term because you're working on a singular typology and you can get really good at it.
00;20;24;11 - 00;20;56;25
RP
Yeah, well, you're designing for the end user and you're spending their money. So it's a high stakes process, but it's also very creative and you get to work with unique materials and work with craftsmen and people who are really good at what they do. So in that respect, yeah, it's really rewarding and we're creating things that people and families are going to use for the rest of their lives.
They're going to live in them. They're going to have their friends over. As challenging as it can be to work in that environment, we're just creating such special things. It's wonderful.
00;20;56;27 - 00;21;02;03
DP
Yeah, I like to say that we've got to know a lot about a lot to be a high-end residential architect.
00;21;02;05 - 00;21;13;16
RP
Yeah, you have to be an architect. You've got to be a plumber. An extra installer, a lawyer, an accountant, a marriage counselor. You have to be everything. A materials scientist.
00;21;13;17 - 00;21;27;01
DP
I like that. Marriage counselor. Marriage counselor, for sure. My goodness. So Ross, it's been great to have you here. Thanks for your time. Where can people go to learn more about Kligerman Architecture & Design and yourself?
00;21;27;03 - 00;21;31;21
RP
Check out our klingermanad.com. And you can also look at our Instagram account [@kligerman.ad].
00;21;31;24 - 00;21;34;00
DP
And do you have your own Instagram account as well?
00;21;34;01 - 00;21;38;06
RP
Yes, that's @RossPadluck.
You May Also Be Interested In
We Can Help With Your Next Project
Discover the latest + greatest in design trends, industry news & pro tips from pros.
For all of your project needs, you’ll find everything you need at a Supply Center.
Let Us Know How We Can Help!
Design Vault Ep. 22 Lawrenceville School with Daniela Holt Voith
ABOUT THE ARCHITECT:
![]()
|
Daniela Holt Voith, FAIA, LEED AP BD+C, IIDA, ASID, is a founding principal of Voith & Mactavish Architects and our director of design. Holding degrees from Yale University School of Architecture and Bryn Mawr College, Daniela has dedicated her career to promoting the advancement of design for educational environments. Her client-focused practice supports leading edge pedagogical thought and encourages mindful ways of living and learning. Daniela has developed a method of practice that moves fluidly from planning initiatives to building design. Her many long-term relationships with educational institutions result in designs that carefully suit her clients’ missions, reflect their architectural identities, and assist in achieving their strategic goals. She is also consistently looking for ways for her projects to be sustainable in innovative ways. Her work has received numerous national and local accolades.
Daniela is also an educator. Since the early 1980’s she has taught at Yale University as a TA, University of Pennsylvania and Drexel University, and has developed and taught Bryn Mawr College’s design studio program. She often serves on juries for professional awards in architectural design and construction quality, as well as serving on academic reviews.
|
---|
ABOUT THE PROJECT:
The prestigious independent school, Lawrenceville, sought to promote love and loyalty within its student body through a transformative renovation of the 1960’s-era Abbott Dining Hall that exclusively serves senior, or “Fifth Form,” students in their last year on campus. The project would respond to the style of the adjacent Upper House dorm and other Peabody & Stearns architecture to help achieve that goal.
VMA’s reconfiguration blends seamlessly into the Lawrenceville aesthetic with new brick facades and pitched slate roof, supported by glulam beam trusses. In addition to a complete redesign of the kitchen and servery, custom white oak furniture and booth seating ensure flexibility of layout. Finally, white oak paneling, terrazzo flooring, and over-scaled fireplaces complete the vision.
With its memorabilia-lined entry hallway, lounge, and private dining areas, Abbott may now serve as an exclusive space for seniors to socialize, dine, and reflect on their years at Lawrenceville. In addition, the enlarged terrace provides outdoor seating options for mealtime and special events, expanding the scope of possible activities in the space.

TRANSCRIPT
00;00;00;02 - 00;00;05;07
Doug Pat (DP)
Let's go inside the vault. The design vault.
00;00;05;10 - 00;00;30;11
Daniela Holt Voith (DHV)
Part of our design philosophy is to really make more of a home, both in terms of individual buildings, but also in terms of the context. And this design really is right up our alley in the sense that we love to combine mission and image. There is a strong mission to get the dining hall, which is for the fifth formers, a chance to rebond.
00;00;30;13 - 00;03;05;12
DP
This is my guest, Daniela Holt Voith. I'll share more about her shortly. In this episode from the Design Vault, we highlight Voith and MacTavish Architects Abbott Dining Hall in Lawrenceville, New Jersey. The Abbott Dining Hall is located at the Lawrenceville School in Lawrenceville, New Jersey. The renovation of the 1960s era dining hall exclusively serves senior or fifth form students in their last year on campus.
The project responds to the style of the adjacent upper house dorm and other Peabody and Sterns architecture and reminds one of both Shingle Style and Richardsonian Romanesque architecture. VMA’s reconfiguration blends seamlessly into the Lawrenceville esthetic with new brick facades, pitch slate roof and vaulted interior ceilings supported by glulam hammer beam trusses. In addition to a complete redesign of the kitchen and servery, custom white oak furniture and booth seating clad the interior, white oak paneling, terrazzo floor and over scaled fireplaces complete the vision.
Hi, I'm Doug Pat and this is Design Vault. Daniela Holt Voith is an architect and founding principle of Voith and MacTavish Architects and Director of Design. She holds degrees from Yale University School of Architecture and Bryn Mawr College. Since the early 1980s, she's taught at Yale University as a TA, University of Pennsylvania, Drexel University, and has developed and taught Bryn Mawr College's Design Studio program.
Mayor Michael Nutter appointed her to serve on the city's award winning 2008 zoning code Commission, which revised the city's 50-year-old zoning code. Danielle is currently president of the Institute for Classical Architecture and Art, Philadelphia Chapter director of the Carpenters Company of Philadelphia and Board member of the Design Leadership Foundation. Daniela has dedicated her career to promoting the advancement of design for educational environments.
Her client-focused practice supports leading edge pedagogical thought and encourages mindful ways of living and learning. Daniela loves to travel, bike and ride trains. She speaks French and German, travels frequently and collects early 20th century train lithographs. So welcome, Daniela. It's nice to have you with us today. So tell us a little bit about Voith and MacTavish Architects or VMA in Philadelphia.
So where in the city are you guys located? What's the size of the firm? How long has it been around and what type of work do you do?
00;03;05;15 - 00;03;41;14
DHV
Our firm has been celebrating its 35th year this year. We are located just on the edge of Center City on the Schuylkill River. So we have fabulous views of the river and city skyline. We are about 40 people, I think maybe 41 just this minute. And our primary focus is on design for education from pre-K to post-collegiate. But that encompasses a wide range of services, preservation, planning, architecture, as well as we have an interior studio and a wide range of projects, which is why this client type is so exciting for me.
00;03;41;19 - 00;03;45;14
DP
Interesting. So the firm size has grown over the years, I would assume.
00;03;45;17 - 00;03;55;08
DHV
Yes, we started off as two people and now our, as I said, almost 40. We actually grew during the pandemic. I have no explanation for it.
00;03;55;11 - 00;03;58;08
DP
That's incredible. And was that mainly in school work?
00;03;58;13 - 00;04;33;09
DHV
Almost exclusively, we do architecture planning, interiors and preservation, and we service school work primarily, but we do other work for other institutions, primarily nonprofit. For example, we're just completing a almost 100,000 square foot renovation of some factory buildings for an organization called Philadelphia Youth Basketball. So it has seven basketball courts, classrooms, leadership training, those sorts of facilities up in one of the more disadvantaged areas of Philadelphia.
00;04;33;11 - 00;04;35;10
DP
And do you guys do any residential work?
00;04;35;14 - 00;04;45;27
DHV
We do, actually. Thanks for asking. We just brought on three new partners, one of whom is Scott O’Barr, and he is heading up our residential studio. It's fairly new for us.
00;04;46;00 - 00;04;48;11
DP
Well, that's great. That's actually my, that's what I do. I do.
00;04;48;11 - 00;04;55;25
DHV
All right. Well, we started off doing residential but grew out of that and now we're coming back to residential again with the addition of Scott.
00;04;56;02 - 00;05;04;22
DP
That's great work. Good for you. So tell us a little bit about yourself. How long have you been practicing and what's your role in the office as a principal and director of design?
00;05;04;24 - 00;06;15;06
DHV
Well, my first job in architect's office was when I was 19 at the Architects Collaborative. I got an internship between my sophomore year and junior year at Bryn Mawr, and I loved it so much I took a year off and stayed there. Sadly, that firm doesn't exist anymore, but it was a great introduction to very high level design.
I graduated from architecture school in ‘81 and I've been working pretty much since I formed a partnership with my first employer, Toni Atkins. So it became Atkin Voith and Associates. So that existed for sadly only about three years. We were doing great, but somehow the relationship just wasn't going as well as it should have been. So I broke away and formed a new firm with one of the people that was an employee at the previous firm.
So Cameron MacTavish, who is a wonderful human being and very talented person, and I just bought him out about five years ago because he wanted to do other things and we're still great friends. That's amazing. And just this January took on three new partners. One of the people who was a partner previously, John Cluver, heads up the Preservation Studio.
So there are now five of us, the VMA five.
00;06;15;08 - 00;06;28;12
DP
Well, it sounds like your firm clearly has grown and you do wonderful work. I've been on your website and we'll talk about that a little bit later. So let's talk a little bit about this project. How did your office get the project?
00;06;28;15 - 00;07;12;00
DHV
Well, just as we usually do, it's a competitive business. I think we won it at the interview. The RFP was one of the most unusual ones that we've ever gotten because the brief was written about love and loyalty and how can architecture help young students form a really strong bond with a place. There is also a lot of humor involved at Lawrenceville.
There are a funny bunch, they love to joke, and so in our visual response that we sent in with our portfolio, we photoshopped the head and face of the CFO, who had written the RFP into almost every photo that had people in it. So he only found five of them.
00;07;12;02 - 00;07;13;04
DP
Where's Waldo?
00;07;13;07 - 00;07;28;24
DHV
It was exactly like Where's Waldo? But we tried to approach the interview in responding exactly to that. How do you create a sense of belonging and a sense of fascination and otherness in a place?
00;07;28;27 - 00;07;30;25
DP
So you didn't know the clients and you got the job?
00;07;30;26 - 00;07;31;17
DHV
That's correct.
00;07;31;17 - 00;07;38;05
DP
That's wonderful. Good for you. So let's talk a little bit about the history of the location you said is kind of special.
00;07;38;07 - 00;09;17;03
DHV
So Lawrenceville is one of the premier boarding schools in the country. It has a long tradition. Its original campus was laid out by Olmstead, and a lot of the architecture was done, as you mentioned, by Peabody and Stearns. Originally, it was laid out in a circle as many older boarding schools are. And as it grew, the planning paradigm became more oriented around quads.
This dining hall was built as an addition to a Peabody and Stearns dormitory. It had a flat roof, a pretty unsympathetic brick, big glass curtain wall that faced West, which you can only imagine was sun beating in at dinner time. So they pulled the curtains. So it was almost always dark. And so there was a lot to improve, but they didn't really want to diverge too much from the footprint of the building.
But essentially we took the building down to its foundations. We left the steel, took off the roof and kept these two side wings that are almost square and planned and put a new roof and new structure. As you mentioned, the big glulam trusses that look like heavy timber and then made a basically a six foot addition on the Western facade to create some really deep windows so that that West facing sun would get mitigated as it comes in and then really responded to the facade of the original dormitory on the other side.
So the facade is characterized by a round tower which forms the entry and six Romanesque arched windows, three on either side. So it has this very heavy look about its sense of gravitas.
00;09;17;06 - 00;09;23;05
DP
So this building really looked nothing like what it does today. Is that correct? The facades are completely new.
00;09;23;09 - 00;09;25;00
DHV
Completely new.
00;09;25;02 - 00;09;41;01
DP
So what's interesting about that, as I'm reading about your renovation 1960s building, I'm thinking this was clearly a very talented architect in the sixties. Now, that's amazing, right? So this building, he just took it down to the foundations. Okay, Now it all makes perfect sense.
00;09;41;01 - 00;09;41;19
DHV
Pretty much.
00;09;41;19 - 00;09;44;16
DP
My goodness.
00;09;44;16 - 00;09;47;00
DHV
It was a flat roof, 1960s building with a curtain wall.
00;09;47;06 - 00;09;53;05
DP
Yeah. Wow, that. Okay, that's pretty cool. So you guys know what you're doing? This thing is beautiful.
00;09;53;05 - 00;10;36;19
DHV
Thank you. Thank you. Well, part of our design philosophy is to really make more of a home, both in terms of individual buildings, but also in terms of the context. And this design really is right up our alley in the sense that we love to combine mission and image. As I said before, there is a strong mission to get the dining hall, which is for the fifth formers, their culminating year at the school, a chance to rebond. The school is organized so that there's a freshman dorm, but then they divide up into houses and they're in those houses for two years and then they come back together again as a class. So it's a chance to rebond.
00;10;36;21 - 00;10;41;22
DP
So tell me a little bit about the scope or programmatic requirements of the project from the beginning.
00;10;41;29 - 00;11;53;02
DHV
Right? So the dining hall seats about 250 to 300. The servery was a very old fashioned cafeteria line, which is way outdated in terms of food service. So the kitchens had to be upgraded, the servery completely renovated, the loading dock assisted and that sort of thing. So they also wanted to be able to use the room as an event space.
So it needed to handle various different seating configurations, a lot of AV component ends, video, that sort of thing. And they wanted to be able to clear out the room, as I said, for some events like dances. So I worked very closely with Thomas Moser. There's a fine mill worker up at Maine to develop a table. It looked like a very heavy wooden table.
It is a very heavy wooden table, but the top flips and you can put it up onto skateboards essentially and move them away. So it's now called the Daniela table, and it's available on their contract side if you're looking for a nesting trestle table. And that was really about it. It serves three meals a day other than the events that they do.
So one of the first was a wedding for the head of school, his daughter.
00;11;53;05 - 00;11;59;26
DP
So they must have had a decent budget for the project, right? They ended up making some custom furniture.
00;11;59;28 - 00;12;15;24
DHV
I think by most standards it was decent. The project in the end all in was $8 million. It's a 13,000 square foot building, so it's not incredibly expensive by residential short, but a lot of value I think, for what they invested in this building.
00;12;16;00 - 00;12;29;03
DP
So let's go backwards a little bit and talk about the building stylistically. So you mentioned, I mentioned earlier, Peabody and Stearns Architecture. I guess they may have been well known for shingle style architecture.
00;12;29;09 - 00;12;44;00
DHV
They were they were a firm of big reputation. And so I think the board members must have nabbed them from New York and brought them down to Lawrenceville. Shingle style definitely. But also this kind of masonry structures as well.
00;12;44;02 - 00;13;06;21
DP
So let's talk a little bit about project restrictions. So I don't know a whole lot about how to get a building built on a boarding school campus. What was that like? And are you working with the town and zoning ordinances there? And you're also working with the school and with esthetic issues. And are there any historical challenges other than trying to match certain architecture?
00;13;06;28 - 00;14;22;12
DHV
The zoning was easy because we were really staying pretty much within the same footprint. We're not adding impervious coverage. The construction logistics were tricky and we essentially cut a new entrance road onto the campus, a construction entrance, and fenced off the construction area. Obviously, student safety is a huge concern. Embedded into our specification are behavioral guidelines, no smoking, shirts on, no swear words.
There's a lot of that sort of thing that's required by most school campuses, actually. The construction needed to happen within a year. They only took that dining hall offline for just one school year, basically a real tricky part of the project was that the original contractor was somebody that we had done maybe 15 to 20 projects with, went out of business in the middle of the project.
So that was heartbreaking because they were such good contractors and caused a huge hiccup and because they were having such trouble, there was construction work that was done that wasn't necessarily supervised, and the school wanted some work to continue. So there was a lot of logistical issues that happened in transferring to another contractor.
00;14;22;19 - 00;14;27;29
DP
Did you have to hire like a construction manager to come in and help put it all back together?
00;14;28;01 - 00;14;48;15
DHV
No, the school, you know, was fairly sophisticated in terms of construction. Many schools are not, but there was insurance involved. And so there was insurance oversight. There was banking issues. There were a lot of things in transferring all that knowledge from one contractor to another. Not having the backup was challenging, but they did an amazing job in the end.
00;14;48;18 - 00;14;52;03
DP
So how long did the planning and design process take?
00;14;52;06 - 00;15;28;09
DHV
Probably just about a year, maybe a smidge longer. There's always that moment. We go through the design. We made models, we did beautiful drawings. There wasn't, like there often is, a hiatus for fundraising because the project was fully funded from the get go, so a single donor basically anteed up. So it was a fairly smooth process from the beginning of concept through the construction documents, the construction documents were a thing of beauty.
The Millwork was so detailed, the brickwork is so detailed. There is a lot to that set. I'd love to show them to you at some point.
00;15;28;12 - 00;15;34;22
DP
I'd love to see that. So what was the size of the team that you had working on the project?
00;15;34;24 - 00;15;47;17
DHV
Core team of myself, the project manager, Sennah Loftus, the architect, Andrew Lipschitz. And then there were probably two other people who were helping. So that's 5.
00;15;47;17 - 00;15;51;06
DP
And did you guys work in 2D and 3D?
00;15;51;08 - 00;16;03;20
DHV
This is a project that was done entirely in CAD so much detail that it not a lot of repetition and so many one off kinds of details that working in Revit would have hindered us.
00;16;03;20 - 00;16;11;29
DP
I think and you guys presented I'm assuming, drawings and ultimately maybe even models to the clients along the way. Did they enjoy that?
00;16;12;01 - 00;16;24;23
DHV
Of course, there's nothing like a model. So we actually made a model where we could take the roof off. The client could actually understand the roof structure and then see the space inside and then put the roof back on.
00;16;24;25 - 00;16;27;01
DP
Did you guys hire that out or did you make them?
00;16;27;01 - 00;16;43;09
DHV
We did it in-house. We have a great shop where we can do both woodworking, we have a laser cutter and also 3D printing. I think we're in the midst of phasing out the woodshop, sadly. But the other aspects of it is that prototyping is really important to us.
00;16;43;12 - 00;16;55;01
DP
So that's a good segway to the building esthetics. So I'm looking at some photos of the architecture. Did you guys replicate some of the archways that you found on campus and other buildings?
00;16;55;09 - 00;17;44;11
DHV
The main arches that are on this facade are derived directly from the front of the original dormitory. It's called Upper House. So from the upper house facade. But the curved tower entry was something that, you know, we studied Peabody and Stern a fair amount and we thought that would be appropriate. It, of course, was very tricky construction and detailing wise because not only is it curved, but we also put an arched top over the main doors.
So that arch is curving in elevation and in plan. Interestingly, if you flatten it out, it's actually and ellipse and the underside of the arch as you get into the door itself actually expands from the doorframe to the door head. It gets steeper because the curve is coming around.
00;17;44;13 - 00;17;46;09
DP
So they built formwork for that?
00;17;46;11 - 00;18;34;12
DHV
No? Well, I'm sure they did in terms of having an arch to lay everything up on. But the arches are actually true arches and we wanted that really deep window recess. So the brick is laid up on a facing block. So it's actually an eight inch facade on top of the structural law we have that depth really makes those arches read.
The arches have a stone arch on the outside. Then there's another arch on the inside that's made up of a header and a stretcher. So it's that deep. And then there's a hinge brick underneath that has a molded shape on it, basically, not quite a full round, but I guess a three quarter around section. And then it goes back into the return, which as I said, varies in depth as it goes around.
00;18;34;14 - 00;18;38;11
DP
Did you have any trouble finding a mason to do that work?
00;18;38;14 - 00;19;20;00
DHV
So we didn't find the mason, the contractors did. And the Masons on this job were really good, so we were happy. The brick is kind of a orangish red. The way we've laid it out has a very, almost monolithic feel because we picked a mortar that blends with the brick. It doesn't highlight each individual brick. So the mortar itself has that a similar coloration to the brick.
There's not much of just facade and it's laid up in running bond. In between the arches we have round medallions that are also made of brick. And then the center those medallions are a herringbone pattern. So there's an incredible amount of richness in the brickwork and it's highlighted by these masonry elements.
00;19;20;02 - 00;19;25;09
DP
I would imagine you did a lot of drawings in house of what this, ultimately, the facades were going to look like.
00;19;25;09 - 00;19;28;04
DHV
And then the shop drawings were amazing.
00;19;28;06 - 00;19;31;01
DP
And did you do many mock ups in the field?
00;19;31;04 - 00;19;54;24
DHV
So we did a mock up of the wall and a return. We did not do a full on mock up with the window inserted. We often do, but in this case we didn't. Tricky part was putting one of these arched openings into the existing brick of those sidings that I mentioned To start with. The brick actually is slightly different than the 1960s brick. That's the only bit of facade that remained.
00;19;54;27 - 00;19;59;01
DP
So the brick facade remained on those wings and then you matched?
00;19;59;07 - 00;20;04;06
DHV
Now we didn't match their contrasting sixties. Brick has more variation in it.
00;20;04;10 - 00;20;06;13
DP
It looks a little redder in the photos.
00;20;06;16 - 00;20;21;19
DHV
Yeah, it's just has a little bit more variation in the brick. But we tried to choose a brick that would blend both with the original Peabody and Sterns and those existing pieces of wall. I mean, in the end we could have just taken them down and started over, but we didn't.
00;20;21;21 - 00;20;36;24
DP
Right. You always, at least in my experience, you kind of pick and choose what you're going to keep and what you're not going to keep. And you look back, you're like, man, we probably spent more money keeping things than just tearing it down to the foundation gradually.
00;20;36;25 - 00;20;50;17
DHV
Absolutely. But part of the transformation of this building was not only this incredibly detailed facade, but also the very, very steeply pitched roof that's all slate. The dormers have copper on them and the tower itself has some copper on it.
00;20;50;19 - 00;20;55;14
DP
They must have loved that, the peak roof, the idea that they were getting rid of this flat roof.
00;20;55;14 - 00;21;04;21
DHV
Absolutely. I'm still hearing, I mean this was finished a number of years ago, and I still hear from people who've been on campus how amazing the space is.
00;21;04;24 - 00;21;13;14
DP
Let's talk a little bit about the trusses on the interior, even though they're not masonry. So in my experience those are called hammer beam trusses. Am I incorrect?
00;21;13;16 - 00;21;51;24
DHV
No, but basically this is a modern building and the span was fairly large. And so our engineers wanted this to be self-supporting. So they're made up of glulam pieces and then bolted together. There is a lot of concern actually by the client when they first saw the trusses go up because they weren't stained yet. And it has these heavy bolts in the plates and they're really worried that this is going to get too industrial looking.
And we painted the steel bits in a color that kind of calms down the contrast between the steel and the wood. And by the time the roof went on and everything else was going on, everybody's in love.
00;21;51;26 - 00;21;57;02
DP
You would never know. And I looked at those photos online. You'd never know there was any steel.
00;21;57;04 - 00;22;07;02
DHV
Yeah, it's just the balls. Sometimes we've done roofs that look like they're heavy timber but are actually steel clad. But in this case, the wood is actually self-supporting.
00;22;07;05 - 00;22;08;23
DP
Yeah, the interior's stunning.
00;22;08;26 - 00;22;09;10
DHV
Thank you.
00;22;09;10 - 00;22;14;21
DP
Is that one large rectangular space on the first floor other than the wing?
00;22;14;21 - 00;23;21;18
DHV
Yeah, other than the wings, it's not quite rectangular because the ends have sort of apses. They're angular. And so in the middle of each and there's an enormous fireplace, we pulled the base of the fireplace up off the floor so that you could see in to the fireplaces from the seated position. And then we had these incredible carvings done that are representative of themes on the campus.
And then, they're not wood burning their gas, but they certainly give this incredible warmth to events and the floor is made of terrazzo. And we carefully made a pattern of the terazzo. So but I said, these people are jokesters, right? And so one of the things that you can do with terrazzo, so it's imbed brass shapes into it.
We found a number of shapes again of animals and other things that are kind of spread through the Lawrenceville law. And then we put cockroaches on the floor. That's so there's like five or six cockroaches. So there's the question always is, well, where's the cockroach?
00;23;21;20 - 00;23;23;03
DP
I'd love to see that.
00;23;23;05 - 00;23;25;04
DHV
I can send you a photograph.
00;23;25;12 - 00;23;31;03
DP
Please do. So, did your team learn anything interesting through the design and construction process? Anything kind of new for you?
00;23;31;05 - 00;24;04;08
DHV
One of the things that we were very interested in anyway was the issue of the Western exposure. And we're a firm that is oriented towards sustainability. It kind of is part and parcel of every project that we do. And so the light mitigation was a big piece of it. So we did a number of lighting studies to see how deep we needed to make the niches to really be able to cut off the direct glare to the inside.
That was an interesting piece of work for us. The combination of computer modeling, lighting, simulation and facade design.
00;24;04;11 - 00;24;18;24
DP
Very cool. So, Daniela, you've been an architect and educator for some time. Based on what you know today about being an architect, do you have any words of advice for your younger self or maybe for young people coming up in the field today?
00;24;18;27 - 00;25;06;09
DHV
So everybody has to find their own selves. And I mentor a lot of women. Our office is more than 50% women. Being an architect on the job site is always a challenge. I found my own way, partially because I played a lot of basketball growing up and I played a lot of basketball with men. I already had this kind of knowledge of both teamwork, competitiveness, defensiveness, all of that all plays out in sports and then into real life.
But most people don't have that experience. They're not as big as tall as I am. I try and say, You're going to have to find your own way. But ultimately on the job site anyway, the person who signs the requisition for payment has the power. So I think my biggest piece of advice is learn to trust yourself and stand on your own two feet.
00;25;06;16 - 00;25;23;26
DP
It's great advice. When I think about myself as a young architect, a young human being for that matter, I was always looking for answers from someone else, always asking someone, How do I do this or How do I get to where I want to go? Or what do I even want to do with my life.
00;25;23;28 - 00;25;25;09
DHV
That only comes from inside.
00;25;25;15 - 00;25;36;22
DP
But it takes a long time to figure that out. And it's really nice that there are people that come alongside you and say, Hey, you know what? You have to look inside. The answers are actually all there already.
00;25;36;24 - 00;25;37;27
DHV
Correct. Nice way to put it.
00;25;38;00 - 00;25;47;18
DP
Well, I'm glad you've been there for lots of other women. So, Daniela, it's been great to have you here. Thanks for your time. Where can people go to learn more about VMA and yourself?
00;25;47;20 - 00;26;08;14
DHV
Our website is cumbersome in terms of its name, but its VoithandMacTavish.com. There's lots of information. If you want to know more about me, search Daniela Voith I think will get you there. You don't have to add my middle name, Holt. I even have a Wikipedia page. So there's a lot of information out there to be had about me.
00;26;08;20 - 00;26;12;18
DP
That's pretty cool. Well, thank you very much for your time today.
00;26;12;25 - 00;26;15;11
DHV
It's been a pleasure. Thank you so much for inviting me.
00;26;15;14 - 00;26;42;05
DP
Our pleasure.
You May Also Be Interested In
We Can Help With Your Next Project
Discover the latest + greatest in design trends, industry news & pro tips from pros.
For all of your project needs, you’ll find everything you need at a Supply Center.
Let Us Know How We Can Help!
Design Vault Ep. 21 Brick of Chicago with Will Quam
ABOUT THE ARCHITECT:
![]()
|
My name is Will. I live in Chicago, I’m an architecture photographer, architecture writer, and researcher. And I love bricks.
|
---|
TRANSCRIPT
00;00;00;02 - 00;00;05;12
Doug Pat (DP)
Let's go inside the vault. The design vault.
00;00;05;14 - 00;00;30;24
Will Quam (WQ)
The Fulton Market area, I think, is the place where some of the best brick architecture in Chicago is currently happening, because it's a place where you have a lot of these historical buildings and you have a lot of people coming in there building offices, residences, restaurants, and they want to make it feel like it's part of that history.
And so they're using brick. And then you have a lot of architects who are really pushing the limits on what they're able to decoratively do with the brick.
00;00;30;26 - 00;01;42;04
DP
This is my guest, Will Quam. I'll share more about him shortly in this bonus episode from the Design Vault. We talked to Will, an architecture photographer, writer, researcher and man who was fascinated with brick.
Hi. I'm Doug Patt and this is Design Vault. Will Quam lives in Chicago. He's currently writing a book for the University of Chicago Press on the history of brick architecture in the city.
He documents brick as a way to pay more attention to the world around him and encourages others to do the same. He believes it's been like learning a whole new language and a means to discovering great texts hidden in the buildings that surround him in his own words. Everything built is designed and has impact, good or bad. It's easy to walk by something like a brick building and pay it no mind.
But the world is so much more interesting when you ask the question, What is that and why is it the way it is? Above all, he believes nothing is boring and everything can be interesting and exciting, even bricks. So welcome Will, it's nice to have you with us today.
00;01;42;07 - 00;01;43;29
WQ
Thank you so much, Doug. It's great to be here.
00;01;44;02 - 00;01;50;09
DP
So tell us a little bit about where you're from and how you became so interested in brick and brick architecture.
00;01;50;16 - 00;03;52;24
WQ
I became interested in bricks through a very circuitous route. I am from Saint Paul, Minnesota, originally, which is a good brick town, a smaller brick town. I studied theater, I directed, I did set design. I acted, and I moved to Chicago originally to be a theater teacher, and that's what I did for about nine years. I taught middle school theater.
I taught afterschool programs, in school residencies. I wrote and directed plays with middle schoolers. The great thing about that work, besides just, you know, it was so fulfilling working with kids is my work brought me all over the city in the suburbs of Chicago, and Chicago is massive. The south side of Chicago alone is the size of Philadelphia.
And so coming from a place like Saint Paul, it was an introduction to a much larger built world. And so through my work, I was, you know, on the north side in the morning, the south side in the afternoon, the west side, in the evening, the suburbs the next day. And going around Chicago, you start to see that there are these very repetitive building types, the bungalow, the two flat, the courtyards style, the apartment hotel, and they're all made of brick pretty much exclusively.
You get some stone, you get the very occasional wood, but brick is the defining material. And I started to notice that it was the brick and specifically the face, the bricks on the front of these buildings that made them all unique. And they weren't just these red rectangles that I'd always thought of a brick as being. There's texture, there's color, there's pattern, there's usage.
And so I started taking pictures on my phone. And then one day in the basement of a theater where I was running a middle school theater camp, I started Instagram and posted them and people started asking me questions. And so I said, Well, I better research this, dove down the rabbit hole and then seven years later, here I am.
It's become my full time job, taking pictures for architects and suppliers and engineers. And then I lead these brick tours to such a natural spinoff of my earlier work. Taking that excitement and giving it away. I think that's the biggest thing about my work is I'm not trying to gate keep anything. I don't have a background in this.
I'm just a very passionate learner. And then on, my goal is just to give everything away in the most interesting and exciting way possible.
00;03;52;26 - 00;03;55;08
DP
Do you ever think to yourself, I should have been an architect?
00;03;55;14 - 00;04;36;20
WQ
I'm very lucky in that my great grandfather was an architecture journalist and instilled a lot of that in my dad. My great grandfather's the great John Entenza, who did the case study houses. I never met him, but my dad knew him well. So we grew up going on a lot of architecture tours, a lot of historic home tours.
And really the importance of the built world was instilled to me as a young man, but it was always something I thought, you know, I would just enjoy. And maybe that is I'm very lucky that I grew up playing trombone and singing in choirs, and I went to space camp and I was encouraged to have all these very multifaceted interests by parents who had these very multifaceted interests as well.
And so I was very lucky to be able to feel like I could explore things.
00;04;36;25 - 00;04;58;26
DP
It sounds really cool. I mean, it's almost like you're walking down the street and you see a building and it's made of brick, and it occurs to you, you get this thought like, Hey, that's kind of cool. I wonder why that looks like that. And then the next day gets a little more important. The next day gets a little bit more fascinating, and all of a sudden you've got this interest in something that sits so far outside of your wheelhouse. In a way, it's amazing.
00;04;59;02 - 00;05;37;16
WQ
Exactly. You know, it starts with somebody asking, What's that pattern? And me, I guess I'll look on Wikipedia and then I'm emailing a brick dealer, and then I'm finding books on the history of brick architecture to the point where now last week I spent a whole day at the University of Illinois Library reading through old copies of the brick and clay record from the 1970s.
And what makes it so great in Chicago, too, is you truly can walk down any street and you'll find great brick architecture, any residential street anywhere in this entire city. And the city is so big and changing so much so constantly that you can go down the same street again ten years later and you can have so many new things to discover.
00;05;37;19 - 00;05;41;03
DP
Yeah. As an aside, have you been to the Monadnock Building?
00;05;41;10 - 00;05;42;19
WQ
Love the Monadnock Building.
00;05;42;26 - 00;05;59;14
DP
Right? When I was in architecture school and I learned about that building and the fact that the base is six feet thick of brick masonry as the load bearing structure. The first thing I did when I got to Chicago was go to that building. I'm I just couldn't believe it. Right. It's amazing.
00;05;59;17 - 00;06;40;15
WQ
It's an unbelievable it's one I found has such lasting power as well as I interview architects. So many times, I'll ask them, what's your favorite brick building in the city? And I'd say 50% say the Monadnock Building. It's so honest with its material and so inventive at the same time. You know, one of the things as I've looked at it and photographed it, I've noticed is there's no hard lines on the building.
It's all using this molded brick made by the Chicago Anderson Brick Company. You get the sort of the plinth that rises up and then curves into the building and that it's not a sharp edge from a brick to another brick that's turning; there's a rounded brick to bridge that gap at every point. So the lines are kept incredibly smooth throughout the whole thing through this really intentional use.
00;06;40;17 - 00;06;41;27
DP
Yeah. Now, how about the cornice?
00;06;42;03 - 00;07;31;18
WQ
Oh, tremendous. Every piece of that was intentionally planned that way. There's nothing was done on accident, and that's still true today. You know, one of the things I try to push back on a lot is, you know, in my work, I'm a lot of times focusing and studying and photographing historic buildings and they're amazing. But people sort of feel that permission to say, oh, well, we just don't make them like we used to.
And there's only crap being made today and it's just not true. There's a lot of really amazing buildings being built today. The way we make them is different. The style we make them is different, but that's because so much has changed in the materials we use, making things efficient, making labor safe. And there's a lot of really great design out there that if we just say we don't make them like we used to, we neglect the work that architects and designers are still doing today with the same intentionality they were doing in the 1890 and the man was built.
00;07;31;25 - 00;08;38;20
DP
Well, it's a great segway. So we're going to talk about a few pieces of architecture today, two Chicago pieces and one New York City and then maybe some other buildings. So let's dig in here and learn a little bit more about brick architecture. First, let's talk about the Chicago Park District HQ Building by John Ronan Architects in Chicago.
The Chicago Park District headquarters is a 78,000 square foot building comprised of headquarters office space for the Chicago Park District Staff and Field House on a 17 acre park. The headquarters building is a two story circle in plan, with two courtyards. The building has a unique facade with individually curved metal panels, curtain wall glazing and a light brown brick facade with brick patterning.
An interesting fact that Will points out about the building, and in regard to the brick masonry set, the bricks used are all Chicago common bricks which were made locally. So Will, let's start out with that. Tell us a little bit more about the bricks of this building.
00;08;38;23 - 00;12;56;07
WQ
Yeah, they're made of Chicago common bricks which are the bricks made locally in Chicago and most cities in the 1800s and for part of the 1900s were producing their own brick, both common brick and face brick, face brick being the nicer, more intentionally made brick used on the fronts of buildings and common brick, the cheaper stuff to go in the guts.
What made Chicago unique is that we only made common brick. Our clay, which we had in massive abundance thanks to this glacial lake that you cover all of this dry land in Chicago, Lake Michigan used to extend far over what's now dry land. The still waters of that lake allowed all this clay to settle, but all this other stuff settled in that clay as well.
The perfect mix for making bricks. But it made bricks that were, frankly to those architects of that era, very ugly. They weren't predictable in any way. The levels of mineral in them were really varied, but one batch might come out yellow, one brown, one pink, one red, all these chunks of limestone in them. But the clay was right there and it was super cheap to make.
And so we made a ton of that and threw it in our buildings. But then we would import other bricks, nicer bricks from Saint Louis or Milwaukee or Pennsylvania or Texas to put on the fronts of buildings. But Chicago kept making these common bricks, and we made a massive amount of them. In 1871, the year of the Great Fire of Chicago, Chicago produced about a hundred million of them a year.
And part of what makes the timing of the fire so good, a little ironically, is that the year of the Fire, 1871, the Chicago brick industry had really finished mechanizing pretty much by that year. And so when the city burned down, the city was in, the brick makers of Chicago were in a unique position to help rebuild the city out of brick.
So that fire code, a new fire code could be met in a way that other cities like Boston, Boston's burned down several times because they kept having to rebuild out of wood. Chicago had this local brick making machinery to make it possible to rebuild with brick. So the year the fire reproduced about 100 million of them a year.
Ten years later, Chicago was producing 200 million of these a year. And by 1916, Chicago was producing just shy of 1 billion common bricks a year. And that's the year Chicago actually surpassed the Hudson Valley of upstate New York, which provided all the common brick for New York City. By 1916, Chicago's producing more common bricks than the entire common brick area of New York City.
About 11% of all the brick made in the United States in 1916, face brick or common brick was Chicago, common brick and more by about 100 million than all the brick made in Missouri, Wisconsin, Iowa and Indiana combined that year. So we made a ton of brick in these surface plants all over the city, and we kept it all local for the most part.
And so you go around Chicago into alleys and sides of buildings, and this is the brick that you see, this messy looking brick. And it was always covered up because it was considered too unpredictable, too ugly. But what happened was, starting in the 1960s, as we're entering this era of bright glazed bricks or these sort of sleek, smooth, sort of noisy and modern bricks, you get a generation of architects who start to be really drawn to the antique accidental look of these bricks, the variation on them.
This is the time as urban renewal was sort of ravaging Chicago, when all these buildings are being torn down all over the place and people start to save these common bricks and put them in new buildings because they can add the sense of antique ness and age to buildings in a way that a modern market and this new market of reclaimed brick is born.
And then by the 1982, when the last Chicago common brick manufacturer shuts down, there's suddenly this massive market for these reclaimed bricks. First for an antique look to a building in the seventies and eighties as people are really drawn to these earth tones, browns and rough sort of creamy whites of brick. But then today, especially, and in the case especially of this new Chicago Park district headquarters, these bricks, they've embodied carbon in them and so they get you a lot of lead points and they're much more eco friendly material to use.
And so you start to see a lot more use of this reclaimed material because of the way it ties in to a greater focus on ecological buildings. And it's perfect for this building. It's a gorgeous building sitting on this massive park and having this really earthy brick that's full of color variation, full of all these stones, full of all this stuff.
It makes it feel like it really is growing out of the park and a part of the park rather than a lot of park buildings that feel like they’re just placed down into the park.
00;12;56;09 - 00;13;07;03
DP
So I'm curious, just to back up, why did Chicago stop producing common brick? Was it because brick masonry was no longer load bearing? We were using steel and iron.
00;13;07;10 - 00;15;23;04
WQ
Yes. So Chicago and the country stopped using common brick, mostly after the Second World War when cavity wall construction became prominent. Concrete block is just a lot larger and a lot cheaper. In 1952, in Chicago, a 77 square foot wall of Chicago commons would cost about $120 to lay parts and labor. The same size wall out of concrete block was about $45.
And so this cost savings were huge. As labor then became more and more expensive and concrete became more and more affordable, people started moving away from the common brick. Then what happened is in 1970, Congress passes the Clean Air Act, forms the EPA and brick plants all over the country are putting tons of sulfur dioxide and ozone and smog into the air.
And for a lot of those companies, it was not too difficult to get into compliance. You know, you have a big beehive kill or tunnel kill, and you could put a scrubber on your vents and start to clean up your operation. These common brick manufacturers, by that point, there were just two left in the Chicago area. They were using what are called Pskov kilns, which basically you take a bunch of unfired bricks, make them into this massive pile with channels running through it.
You cover it in fired bricks and set it on fire from the inside. It's a super cheap way to make bricks that don't need to look nice but are effective. But the comparison I like to make is a traditional kiln works like an oven. You take your turkey, you put it in the oven, you close the door, you turn it on.
A Pskov kiln that the Chicago commons were made in. You take that same turkey, you put it on your countertop, you stick a gas jet in the butt you cover it in deli meat and light it on fire. It's a lot more messy. It does the same job, but it's a lot more messy and it's a lot harder to clean up.
And so the Chicago common plants looked at the economics. They were losing market share. They looked at the clay. They had left the Illinois brick company in Blue Island decided, we've only got about three years clay left or just shut down. And then they looked at the environmental impact. One of these companies in Muncie, Indiana, on days that they were burning there were certain intersections you just couldn't drive because they were so smog filled. To the credit of the American beer company who was in that last company, they spent tens and tens of thousands of dollars trying to find ways to come into compliance and to make it a cleaner operation and continue this business.
But it ultimately just wasn't economically viable.
00;15;23;10 - 00;15;34;11
DP
So back to the Chicago Park District headquarters building, did you ever read anything about why John Ronan Architects ultimately used common brick for the exterior of New York?
00;15;34;14 - 00;16;42;04
WQ
Yeah. A friend of mine supplied those reclaimed bricks for him. A big part of it was that environmental impact using that embodied carbon, using a local material, not needing to create any new emissions through the creation of material, and also the fact that it's a reclaimed material taken from demolished buildings nearby. It's taking that local material and using it for a local purpose, making it something more true to that place.
Then a different kind of imported brick. And John Ronan is an architect who really loves brick and has used brick in really creative ways. In Chicago, he did a high school at South Shore International Academy where he was very specific about these different colors or slightly different tones of brick, sort of a creamy white and a little bit more of a beige and figuring out exactly where he wanted these bands to go on the building.
He had a house on the north side that uses these super long format bricks in a really interesting way to enliven up this very geometric or rectilinear facade. So someone who's super intentional about brick and so the Park District headquarters is another example of him using brick in that really intentional way.
00;16;42;07 - 00;17;36;17
DP
Yeah, the building's really unique and it sounds like a very thoughtful office. So next, let's talk about McDonald's HQ in Chicago. The architect of record was Gensler. When I sat down to do a little bit of research online, I really couldn't find a whole lot of pictures which describe this building. There are many exterior pics that are kind of further away shots.
The interior photos that I did find on a variety of websites, really quite stunning with wood clad interior, gracious curves and a very contemporary feel. The exterior is also quite interesting. The building almost seems inverted with a steel and glass base and square glass curtain wall openings framed in brick above. So these brick frames are really actually quite beautiful.
And you sent me a couple of photos of these. Let's talk about those.
00;17;36;20 - 00;19;44;07
WQ
Yeah. So it's a big steel and glass building, but it does have these large brick frames that surround two stories of windows each. It's all precast thin brick made by a company in Germany. And to get to the importance of what that brick is on the building and why it's there, I think it's important to talk about the neighborhood it's in.
It's in an area called Fulton Market, part of the West Loop of Chicago, which a lot of people have probably heard of as sort of Chicago's new restaurant and tech hub. It was an area of meatpacking and warehouses and manufacturing for many, many years. In the last 15 years, it's become this massive area for some of the best restaurants in the city.
Google has a building there now, and so it's full of all these big brick buildings, these big old brick warehouses or storage buildings with large windows. And so I think it's so wonderful that this new steel and glass building made the intentional choice to embrace that brick material. But the other thing I love about it is that we talked about with Chicago common brick brick is no longer really being used as a structural material in the United States.
And so buildings like this that take that nature, that brick is no longer a structural material. They take it and use it instead as a purely decorative material. And I think they do such a wonderful job on this building because it's the thin brick that runs around these windows, sort of blue ish and golden and orange colors with a rolled edge and a little bit of sort of a knock or sort of bumps and stuff on the face of it.
It describes this herringbone and zigzag pattern through these spandrels and these mullions that run along the building in a way that serves no structural purpose at all. But it is beautiful to look at and tie in through the use of that brick. It ties it into the neighborhood. I think that's just such a wonderful thing to do at a time when a lot of new construction and here I've said earlier, there is a lot of great new construction, but there is a lot of construction that's using brick and really uninspired ways it's just slap at a bunch of structures up on a wall or between windows. And so to see a building like this, a really prominent building in a really prominent location, in a historic location, I love that they're using brick in such an interesting way.
00;19;44;09 - 00;20;03;15
DP
Yeah, I'd love to see the studies in the architect's office for all of these or for the variety of brick patterns where you get soldier coursing. You've got stacked herringbone, as you stated, you almost have something that looks close to a Greek key as well. It's really quite beautiful and the color is stunning in the sun.
00;20;03;22 - 00;20;29;01
WQ
It really is. I captured it in those photos I sent you. It faces the north side of the street. And so you get this beautiful raking light on it in the summer evenings and in the shadow, it's still got this sort of lovely warm orange to it. So it really is very present and there's so much going on.
It's the sort of thing where you look at it and you trace it along and you to start to, like you said, start to find all those little details, different details scattered throughout the brickwork.
00;20;29;08 - 00;20;54;03
DP
You know, it's really nice too. It's almost as though they're expressing the structural system on the exterior with these super tall piers which frame these windows. One starts to think, okay, well, maybe the structural steel system is hidden within that. I don't know whether or not that's actually the case, but it does remind one of an industrial building in Chicago 80 or 90 years ago, right?
00;20;54;09 - 00;21;49;09
WQ
Yeah. And those are the buildings that surround it there. And another little twist. I like that they idea is that those brick frames are not surrounding every single window or they don't run on every single story that you do get these big frames that surround two or three stories I can't quite remember. And so it still gives it this very light feeling, this very open feeling, while having that strong brick tie into the neighborhood.
And the Fulton Market area, I think is the place where some of the best brick architecture in Chicago is currently happening because it's a place where you have a lot of these historical buildings and you have a lot of people coming in there building offices, residences, restaurants, and they want to make it feel like it's part of that history.
And so they're using brick and then you have a lot of architects who are really pushing the limits on what they're able to decoratively do with the brick. And the McDonald's was a pretty fairly early example of that. But there are many more that have come in since they're in the area.
00;21;49;11 - 00;21;58;24
DP
That's an interesting point. So early McDonald's structures across the United States, do you know if they utilize brick pretty heavily?
00;21;58;26 - 00;23;58;26
WQ
You know, I've researched this. I have emailed with a fast food historian to find some answers. So, yeah, the early McDonald's drive ins were clad in ceramic tile, whites, bright whites, bright red, and then they made a very intentional choice. In 1975 or so, they did a big redesign sort of as the baby boomers who were driving there are now buying homes.
And what they did was they started putting these dark brown bricks. They redesigned their restaurants using this very dark, earthy brick and adding that classic McDonald's double mansard roof. And this is the era when like Wendy's ads for solariums, the restaurants become these very earthy buildings. The first one of those was in Matheson, Illinois, in the south suburbs.
And that was the time too where McDonald's actually built their first corporate headquarters in Oakbrook, Illinois, designed by Dirk Lohan. Mies van der Rohe's grandson, like those restaurants, is a building very much, it's covered in this wonderful sort of earthy iron, spotted brick and surrounded by a manmade lake and all these trees and very much engaging with nature at a time when they're trying to push away from that kind of bright colors, machine age, looking stuff into a more earthy thing.
And then you get into the 1990s and McDonald's does another major rebrand, adding these sort of pastel colors or a lot of painted white brick that I think a lot of people my generation are familiar with as well. And then now a lot of those McDonald's, they've torn them down. They've rebuilt them using smooth grays and blacks and whites.
And so McDonald's, you can really follow you know, one of my big passions is following how people have used brick throughout every decade of history that you can look at a building and based on the color, the texture, the use of the brick to tell when it was built and McDonald's in specific is a great way to do that.
You can look at the restaurants and see how they've changed the restaurants, and that gives you sort of a bellwether of how ideas about what purpose bricks should serve has changed. That's a very long answer to say, yes, McDonald's has used a lot of brick in their restaurants throughout the country.
00;23;58;29 - 00;24;08;04
DP
The building is really interesting because it's also kind of flipped, right? I mean, so the base should be masonry and the upper portion should all be glass and windows.
00;24;08;07 - 00;24;41;18
WQ
I hadn't really noticed that until you brought that up. It is pretty unusual in that way. It's about a two story big steel and glass expressed base story within the brick rising up above, and I don't know why that choice was made, but it is pretty striking and it creates maybe a much open feeling based story. And the base story, they have a restaurant where you can order, you know, all the traditional McDonald's things, but you can also they have a rotating list of items that you can get at McDonald's around the country. So you can get sometimes like a curry burger or something like that that they'd have in McDonald's, India, or I guess it wouldn’t be a burger, a curry chicken sandwich.
00;24;41;25 - 00;24;43;02
DP
The McRib, maybe.
00;24;43;02 - 00;24;46;12
WQ
Yeah, the McRib. All year long. Who knows? We can dream.
00;24;46;15 - 00;25;57;18
DP
Oh, you know, can dream. Oh, that's great. The final building that I'd love to talk about is the Grand Mulberry in New York City by Morris Adjmi Architects. I got to meet Morris Adjmi in the city. We talked a little bit about the Grand Mulberry that evening. The building is absolute stunning. It's incredibly creative. This is paraphrased from their website.
So traditionally, Italianate tenement buildings featured a tripartite white facade that consisted of a base, middle and top with different details and brickwork. The Grand Mulberry facade consists of banding at the building's base, pediment windows at the middle and arched windows and a cornice at the top with coin details defining the base. While the facade pattern is traditional, the application of the hand molded domed bricks is modern, the molded bricks representing an offset window pattern to the real ones.
The red orange color pays further homage to the red brick buildings found in the neighborhoods. So this building is really unique, not only because of its aesthetics, but because they used some custom brick.
00;25;57;20 - 00;28;13;22
WQ
Yeah, it's one of my favorite new brick buildings in the United States and one that I had on my radar for a long time. And I took a trip to New York this summer specifically to go photograph several buildings, and it was one of the first ones I hit because it's just such a striking building and I think a perfect use of brick as a modern material in a couple of ways.
One is that color, that beautiful reddish orange color, and talking about, you know, the history of what kind of bricks are people using in areas and those Italianate tenement buildings, that was an era where they were using this very smooth pressed red brick, and that was sort of the predominant material. So first, that color pays homage and two, like I mentioned before, embracing the brick as a decorative material in an age when it doesn't need to be structural anymore, it could have very easily just been a red brick punched opening building, but then using those specifically hand molded bricks to create that design on the building is such a simple, yet unbelievably inventive way to create design across the facade.
It reminds me a lot of one of my favorite buildings here in Chicago. There's a church, many Chicagoans, they know it. It's Saint Stanislaus Kostka. It's right next to the expressway. It's a big brick church right next to the expressway that you've probably driven by. It's built in 1881 for what came to be the largest Polish Catholic congregation in the country, maybe even the largest Catholic congregation in the country at the time.
It's a huge church made entirely of Chicago common brick. So using the cheapest brick they had available. But what the architect, Brooklyn based architect named [Patrick] Keeley, did, the front of the building, the main central window is very small and it's got wood tracery. But he took that common brick and by pushing it out and turning it created this much larger arc that surrounds it with smaller round sort of bull's eyes and these bands of densely and creates on the facade just through the movement of the brick, the illusion of a much grander central window, a much grander central design using that same material.
And I'm seeing the Grand Mulberry. That's what it immediately ties me back to, it's using that same material in just a slightly different way to create the appearance and the remembrance and the reminder of something different all through the use of the same material, but just in a slightly different way.
00;28;13;25 - 00;28;54;06
DP
Yeah, the building essentially has two facades, right? It has a facade that's made out of brick, and then it has a facade or a facade that's articulated in brick and then the real facade with glass and metal windows. It's a really creative piece of architecture. You know what I love? There are some really great shots of this building online from further away and up above, and the building matches all of the other architecture and yet is completely set apart.
It's like this little wonderfully articulated orange red cube which sets itself apart and yet kind of fits into everything around it. It's a really wonderful building.
00;28;54;09 - 00;30;25;04
WQ
It absolutely is. And the other thing I want to praise about it is the use of those hand molded bricks. They could have done any other sort of thing. They could have, you know, done a projecting header or something to create that design. But again, in this era when brick can be sort of freed as a purely design detail and it is a ceramic material that is made of earth sculpted by people and fired in fire.
We see more and more these days projects taking advantage of specifically that hand process. There's a couple projects here in Chicago, a couple of homes like in Lincoln Park that are using these sculpted hand sculpted bricks that brick companies have these artisans who will take that same material and apply this more sculptural treatment to it in all sorts of different ways, and bring the handmade process back into the fold.
You know, you don't have to get rid of your extruded modulus, but we now have the ability to use brick more decoratively. And let's bring a little bit of the handmade process back into it. And I think that's what is so great about this tool. Also, one of the thing is it could have been so easy for them to have those two facades line up the real and the false.
And it's just so spectacular to me that there is that offset, that offset to them also that the building has you know, it's this tripart, the tenements, but they're sort of the two pushed together and then there's it's almost as if another one kind of got built in later with a thick party wall. Again, it's not a perfect repetition of the same form over and over again.
It looks more realistic to how the city would have organically been built.
00;30;25;07 - 00;30;28;00
DP
Well, you talk just like an architect.
00;30;28;02 - 00;30;32;26
WQ
Listen, I'll take it. I'll take it. This is what you get if you don't have hobbies for many, many years.
00;30;32;29 - 00;30;40;02
DP
That's great. So I know you give tours. Do you do any teaching? Because you'd be an amazing teacher if you're not already.
00;30;40;08 - 00;33;10;13
WQ
I appreciate that. Yeah. So I don't do any teaching. I have taught photo classes and I have given a lot of talks with groups on the history of brick architecture, both for you know, architecture classes but also for things like various interest groups. But then I give these tours. I started about five years ago. A friend of mine who runs a great tour company here in Chicago called Chicago for Chicagoans basically slipped in my DMs and was like, You've got to do tours, you got to do it.
And I was like, okay, I guess I will. It's been perfect. I love doing it. It takes advantage of the teaching background I have. And like I said, I'm a guy who I like to see things and I like to tell people about them. I never want to and similar, you know, I do all this research for these two words using all these databases and newspaper archives and things.
And whenever anybody asks me how I do my research, I just can't wait to tell them I don't want to keep anything. I want you to be able to do all this research and dive into your own things as well. And the great thing about the tours is, you know, when I first started them four years ago, they were very solely brick focused.
You know, I'm teaching you about rowlock, soldier, shiner and all these things, but now as they've grown to eight different neighborhoods around the city and hopefully ten by next year, I treat brick as the beginning. If I can get you excited about a brick, I can get you to look closer at anything. You're going to look way too close to the brick, but you're also going to see the other ways in which the built environment or even the invisible environments change our city.
And Chicago's this amazing city because it has so much history and so many generations of history with 77 official neighborhoods. All of those are Brooklyn sub neighborhoods, and all of those have had several different generations of people and stories there. So every single place you go, you can find all this depth to dive into. If I can give one of my favorite examples that ties to brick when I tell people about Chicago common brick, you know, I talk about these clay pits that were all over the city.
There's a big one on the north side here. There's three small clay pits, these three small companies, and by 1900 they had formed into one large company, mining one big pit. By 1915, they moved out to Blue Island in the south suburbs. The city bought that pit from the city, filled it with garbage to get it back to ground level, paved it over.
And in 1929, they built Lane Tech High School on top of it, which is one of the largest high schools in the country and one of the most prestigious high schools in Chicago. It's this huge, beautiful gothic revival, high school built on this former clay pit that you wouldn't even know was there. And that's a wonderful example of all these things that are just hidden all over Chicago.
And you really don't have to look too hard to find them.
00;33;10;16 - 00;33;44;17
DP
Well, it's been a real pleasure to have you here today. You know, as much more than any architect or architectural historian about the subject of brick. And you're incredibly intelligent and articulate and what blows me away is that you do talk just like an architect. So it's been a real pleasure to have you here before you go, you're a guy with many varied interests.
Do you have any advice for someone who's passionate about so many things or maybe just about one thing and doesn't really know where to start?
00;33;44;23 - 00;34;22;16
WQ
I mean, I would say it can be hard. It can be difficult to start, but just the thing to do is start small and start somewhere. I'm someone who very much once I find something I want to know about, I can get way in my own way of like, Well, this can be too hard to learn everything, so it's not worth it.
You start somewhere. You know, for me, it was Wikipedia. It truly was just Wikipedia. And I started getting answers to questions. And then I start getting more questions. And that let me keep asking more questions and keep getting more answers and keep getting more questions and more answers. So I think it's just choose to start in a way that is simple and accessible to you and to dive down as deep as you can.
00;34;22;22 - 00;34;37;24
DP
Yeah, I think what's challenging for most people is they overthink it and wonder where everything's going. And it would seem to me that your experience has been so organic that it's worked out for you in many ways that you never really anticipated it.
00;34;37;26 - 00;35;09;21
WQ
Exactly. And something that is also really important to me is saying when I don't know the answer to something, you know, if someone asked me a question I don't know, just saying I don't know, because I think so often the instinct is to if you are want to be an expert in something, to try to pull things together, to create an answer to something you don't necessarily know.
But I think from my teaching days and working with kids and young people, it's so valuable not to do that, to be able to admit when you don't know the answer. And that often will lead people to their own curiosity and finding those answers for themselves. And then you can go off and do your research, too.
00;35;09;28 - 00;35;17;11
DP
Will, it's been great to have you here. Thanks for your time. Could you tell us about your websites and how people can find you?
00;35;17;17 - 00;35;53;22
WQ
Yeah. So my website is BrickofChicago.com. And that's where I have information about, you know, you can learn about brick bonds, you can learn about the history of Chicago common brick and my tours and I make a calendar as well and my website WillQuam.com, and that's for my architecture photography work.
I take pictures for architects and engineers and landscape architects and all sorts of people and organizations are around Chicago, so you can see my work there. And then I'm on Instagram, @bricksofchicago, posting different bricks from around Chicago, and then my travels every single day.
00;35;53;27 - 00;35;54;17
DP
Thanks, Will.
00;35;54;24 - 00;35;59;14
WQ
Thank you so much. It's been a delight.
You May Also Be Interested In
We Can Help With Your Next Project
Discover the latest + greatest in design trends, industry news & pro tips from pros.
For all of your project needs, you’ll find everything you need at a Supply Center.
Let Us Know How We Can Help!
Design Vault Ep. 20 MarketPlace at Fells Point with John Hutch
ABOUT THE ARCHITECT:
![]()
|
As one of the founding partners and principal of JP2 Architects, John Hutch plays an active role in the professional development and awareness of sustainable design within the firm. He brings 30 years of experience leading the design process and employing project management with an emphasis on project delivery. His background in both the public and private sector provides a diverse experience to meet the needs of any project. John is a talented architect with an international portfolio of mixed-use projects which includes corporate, hospitality, retail, multi-family, and entertainment facilities.
|
---|
ABOUT THE PROJECT:
Located in Historic Fells Point, Baltimore, MD, these new urban lifestyle apartments feature open rooms maximizing exterior daylight and views. The bulk of the units open onto a private courtyard space complete with fire pits and water features. Many of the units are rehabbed historic buildings from the late 1800’s with large windows and unique special features. The apartment buildings have direct access to over 100 community retail and entertainment venues on the Fells Point waterfront. In addition to the private courtyards, the project also features a club room, lounge, fitness center, and secured parking for the residents.
MarketPlace at Fells Point
Designed by JP2
View ProjectTRANSCRIPT
00;00;00;02 - 00;00;05;08
Doug Pat (DP)
Let's go inside the vault. The design vault.
00;00;05;10 - 00;00;22;07
John Hutch (JH)
One of the missions was to continue to keep the character of Broadway, of Fell's Point through those storefronts and set back the building's mass so that it was not present or felt when you're walking along the sidewalk.
00;00;22;14 - 00;02;25;12
DP
This is my guest, John Hutch. I'll share more about him shortly. In this episode from The Design Vault. We highlight John's Project Marketplace at Fell's Point. Marketplace Fell's Point is located in historic Fell's Point, Baltimore, Maryland. The new urban lifestyle apartments feature open rooms that maximize exterior daylight and the views. The bulk of the units in the marketplace project open onto private courtyard space, complete with firepits and water features.
Many of the units are rehabbed historic buildings from the late 1800s with large windows and special features. The apartment buildings have direct access to over 100 community retail and entertainment venues on Fell's Point waterfront. In addition to the private courtyards, the project also features a club room, lounge, fitness center and secure parking for the residents.
Hi, I'm Doug Pat and this is Design Vault. John Hutch, one of the founding partners and a principal at JP2 Architects in Baltimore, Maryland. John has a Bachelor of Science degree in architecture from the University of Cincinnati. He plays an active role in the professional development and awareness of sustainable design within his firm. He brings 30 years of experience leading the design process of employing project management with an emphasis on project delivery.
He has a background in both public and private sector work, which provides diverse experience for all of the projects the office takes on. John has an international portfolio of mixed use projects which include corporate hospitality, retail, multifamily and entertainment facilities. So welcome, John. It's nice to have you with us today. So tell us a little bit about JP2 Architects, where you guys are located in Baltimore? What's the size of your firm? How long have you been around and what kind of work do you do?
00;02;25;14 - 00;03;00;16
JH
Great. Thanks, Doug. We are about a 20 person firm, and we're located in the Canton area of Baltimore, which is adjacent to Fell's Point, where this project is located. We founded JP2 Architects in 2006 and I have two other founding partners, Jamie Pett and Gordon Gaudet. The three of us have been working together for almost 30 years now.
When I moved here in 1995, I got to know the two of them and we've been friends and colleagues and now partners ever since.
00;03;00;18 - 00;03;02;12
DP
Wow, That's really cool. How did you meet?
00;03;02;13 - 00;03;19;23
JH
So we all met at the large international firm of our RTKL, and we were each in the commercial group. Although I tended to bounce around between groups, which gave me a diverse experience. But we were still young, rising up through the ranks and learning a lot.
00;03;20;00 - 00;03;23;19
DP
That's really interesting. Did you guys always know that you wanted to start a firm together?
00;03;23;21 - 00;03;54;10
JH
No. We each probably had different starting points. I'd say it was always my dream to start a firm and I can thank my parents for saying hold on, hold on, hold on, you need more experience. So when I moved here to Baltimore, met the two of them, I spent about ten or 12 years there prior to the three of us starting, and I couldn't ask for better partners.
We each fulfill a different niche and role in the firm and bring different experience and complement each other very, very well.
00;03;54;13 - 00;04;05;00
DP
That's wonderful for our listeners. Sean and I were talking before we got rolling here, and I used to work in Baltimore, Maryland for Zeiger Sneed. I guess I'm wondering if you ever ran into them.
00;04;05;06 - 00;04;11;06
JH
I haven't met them in person, but we still run into them every once in a while, competing on a project.
00;04;11;11 - 00;04;19;27
DP
I'm sure you do. I'm not sure how involved they both are in the firm at this point, but they certainly did something really wonderful in Baltimore.
00;04;19;29 - 00;04;37;14
JH
They have and they've won a lot of awards in the area. And why I plan to my roots here in Baltimore was because the design and architectural community is strong, thriving. It's a livable city. And I really love the passion that everybody brings to their projects and profession here.
00;04;37;17 - 00;04;45;04
DP
That's great to hear. So tell me a little bit about yourself. How long have you been practicing and what's your role in the office as a partner?
00;04;45;06 - 00;05;38;09
JH
Sure. So I graduated from Cincinnati in ‘91. That was probably not the best time to be graduating and looking for a job, but I struggled through those first few years gaining experience. And so when we started JP2, as I mentioned, as I think it's always been my dream to start a job. So a lot of the business planning, the oversight of the firm in general, my background is probably more design delivery heavy.
But I think one of the beauties of the practice we've established is that we have an amazing group here that all overlaps and has a terrific sense of projects and project management and design from beginning to end. So I will take on some master planning and some design roles, but I can tell you that my partners can draw circles around me.
00;05;38;11 - 00;06;22;00
DP
We talk a lot about this with our guests, our university experience. So you go to college and you learn about design, you know, structures and HVAC equipment and all those kinds of things. But you never really think about everybody's going to be good at something different, right? Or they're going to be good at a few things and then somebody else is going to be.
And so you really need that if you're going to have a partner, if you're not going to run your own office, you're going to have partners. It's really important to overlap. It's important to complement one another and then allow those people to do a good job in the areas that they're good at. Right? It's not something that anybody ever discusses in college. You get out and it becomes reality where you got to run a business and make money.
00;06;22;02 - 00;06;50;20
JH
Exactly. It's amazing how many hats and projects I may touch in a day, but having a team around us and having colleagues that I work closely with allows that overlap. What it does is it extends those initial ideas of a project and allows the whole team to be on board throughout the process so they know the vision, they know what we're executing when you go from a design concept to actually detailing a project and how to deliver it.
00;06;50;26 - 00;06;58;09
DP
So true. Okay, so let's dig in here and talk about Marketplace at Fell's Point. So how did you guys get that project?
00;06;58;11 - 00;07;58;06
JH
It's a wonderful, wonderful history. And we actually made contact through an ex RTKL employee who was in the landscape department and he got out of the design profession and started purchasing and renovating a lot of row houses here and Fell’s Point and Canton area. And he and another developer, David Holmes, the person I was speaking about is Dan Winter, and the two of them started realizing that they had properties near each other.
So that became a genesis amongst the two of them. They were pursuing a strategy of basically a garage with office above it, and it was seven or eight stories tall and the community fought them all along the way. And Dan, knowing that we had just started our practice and respecting our design skills, said, Hey, can you guys give me some advice?
Take a look at this. What should we do here? That was how we landed the project.
00;07;58;06 - 00;08;00;07
DP
And essentially the function changed?
00;08;00;09 - 00;08;51;22
JH
There you go. So I'd say I'm probably a frustrated developer because I love to look at something and say what belongs, what fits, and also how do you make it financially viable? The project, as initially conceived, wasn't penciling out from a financial standpoint, and it was a lesson of less is more. Why fight what should be here, which is a dense, residential neighborhood of two and a half, three and a half story tall row houses.
There are lot lines throughout, so we being old school, put pencil to trace and started sketching some ideas and they started to look at it and lo and behold, they started to peak their interest. They started to put some performance together and look at it and said, You know what, this works. That was a big change.
00;08;51;25 - 00;08;55;09
DP
Yeah. So the architect sold the developer in a way.
00;08;55;10 - 00;08;59;07
JH
Exactly. We brought an idea.
00;08;59;10 - 00;09;06;17
DP
Yeah, you brought in a great idea. So give us a little history of the location because you guys use some of the existing buildings, correct?
00;09;06;19 - 00;09;59;11
JH
That is correct. The site is fantastic. As you know, Fell’s Point is rooted in history going all the way back to the late 1700s and early 1800s. It's a waterfront community here on the harbor in Baltimore. And is known for shipbuilding sales, it's a port. So the establishments, bars, restaurants, all of that catered to folks who were in that industry.
Fell’s Point at the time, which would have been 2008, was what you probably hear about Baltimore, boarded up windows and storefronts. And a lot of these properties were not worth much. And so as Dave Holmes and Dan Winter were purchasing these, they had to have some kind of hope and vision that they could transform them.
00;09;59;13 - 00;10;05;18
DP
Okay. So tell me a little bit about the scope of the project and the client's programmatic requirements.
00;10;05;20 - 00;11;05;28
JH
Sure. The scope of the project, the buildings have historic storefronts, even though many of them, think about it is the 1800s, they were not historic, they were new. And so over time, they go through a transformation that was anything but historically sensitive. So one of the missions was to continue to keep the character of Broadway, of Fell's Point through those storefronts and set back the buildings mass so that it was not present or felt when you're walking along the sidewalk.
I'm starting from a massing standpoint to tell you about the program because the storefronts then would still be, and there's about 28,000 square feet of retail and and entertainment. And then there are in total, there are two blocks. There's one on the east side and one on the west side of Broadway. And they total 160 apartment units.
00;11;06;00 - 00;11;16;17
DP
I'm trying to picture what this looks like because we got some existing buildings down here and we do have some new architecture as well in plan form. What am I looking at?
00;11;16;20 - 00;11;59;23
JH
You're looking at like an amoeba. Unfortunately, apartment units don't like that shape, but the West block touches all four streets around it, so it almost has tentacles and reaches out. So along this storefront were basically 2 to 3 stories and we were able to do that and then set back. But the setback piece is more of a U-shape so that you didn't again have a mass of a building just lurking behind these.
You only had the ends of the U-shape. A lot of the use of brick and color and materials in that area was so that they felt like they fit in.
00;11;59;25 - 00;12;03;02
DP
So the retail space, is that all new architecture?
00;12;03;04 - 00;12;52;10
JH
It is. So the whole block has new storefronts, but they're restored. So they're restored to the historic significance. We went through many photos and did a lot of research. The Historical Society was incredibly helpful in that front. The depth of this storefront or what was behind those is new. When you go out into, say, the suburbs, you're used to a concrete podium with, say, four levels of stick frame construction above it.
That is essentially what we did in this project. We have a concrete podium that separates the retail use from the residential use above that's needed by code, but also makes laying out the apartments above much more easily.
00;12;52;12 - 00;13;03;09
DP
So let's talk a little bit about stylistic choice for the new architecture and then what you guys ultimately did to restore to the exteriors of some of these existing buildings.
00;13;03;12 - 00;14;21;23
JH
Terrific. Yeah, we had a good dialog with the Historic Preservation group here. One of the concerns is always when you create new are you competing or you're trying to match the historic facades. And we literally had on the west block two missing teeth that were non contributing and it was obvious they were not contributing to the historic fabric of the community.
So our challenge was how to blend in. And this is where Glen-Gery was incredibly helpful with the brick choices, the brick style and how we detailed it. So we went with a more simplistic detailing of soldiers and roll locks than a brick facade on both of the missing infill pieces. So you had a character that was still there but not trying to replicate, and that's how we worked on the Broadway facades. Around the perimeter, if you want to look, there are two alleys on either end of the buildings. Those are brick buildings. They fit in, but took the same approach where we use bricks so that it became part of the urban fabric without trying to mimic the historic aspects of the existing.
00;14;21;26 - 00;14;28;02
DP
Did Glen-Gery have bricks that matched the original bricks from that long ago? From the 1800s?
00;14;28;05 - 00;14;55;02
JH
No. But we had some that fit really well. There were molded bricks. We use the Catawba, which is a Cushwa line on the Broadway faces. In the back, we used 56-DD brick, which is more of a monolithic brick. So that one, it's still molded, but it was more uniform. So you did have a little bit more of a contemporary feel or use to the brick than you do on the historic facades.
00;14;55;05 - 00;15;10;13
DP
Interesting. So back to the planning process for a second. So you guys, you sit down, you do some sketches, you got some ideas, you talk with the developers, and then when did it turn into a project and how long did it take from beginning to end?
00;15;10;20 - 00;17;56;28
JH
How long do you have? I think the process started in early 2008. We started our firm in 2006, so this was a significant project for us. We worked very close with Dan Winter and Dave Holmes through this process. They had been working with the neighborhood groups, listening then what they want. So we took these bum wad sketches and floor plans and stuff like that, and then it started to become real.
And then we could start to put together some imagery of the facades. We could start to look at how we were affecting adjacent neighbors and start showing them a reduced massing than what was proposed before we started this project. And that started to win over some converts. And so that process and going through, which you may have heard in this area called CHAP, which is the Commission for Historic and Architectural Preservation, was that historic piece probably took a year.
So we were still in a design process for a good year after we started and then I'd say about another nine months to a year after that, we got into construction documents again, history, right? So now we're into 2009 and we all know what happened in that era with the real estate market. So we had finished construction documents as a recession, The Great Recession was happening and the thought process was, let's file for permit. So again, I'm glad you're sitting because it is a long story. I'll try to keep it somewhat short and there are details to fill in that are fascinating. We did file in 2009. It sat for years for a number of reasons. For one, they couldn't get financing.
You can imagine paying 2006, 2007 prices and then suddenly the bank takes a look at your property and says it's worth a 10th of that so you don't have equity in the project anymore. And so they were running up against hurdles for this. So the project sat and they were then looking for partners that could help with the project.
So enter Klein Enterprises and Dolben is out of Boston, Massachusetts, and Kline is a local developer here. So they came in and basically took over the project with a little bit of revisioning. So it was probably two years after that. And the construction wound up, I think it was 2012, 2013 when we finally had substantial completion.
So you're looking at four or five years.
00;17;57;00 - 00;18;05;18
DP
Yeah, that's a long time to hang with the project, especially when you're done with the drawings and then everything just sits here like, what am I going to do now?
00;18;05;19 - 00;18;44;19
JH
Right, right. It was interesting. I learned a lot about developers along the way as we took the plans, took the idea to a number of other developers to partner with. Some of them didn't want anything to do with the retail piece. They love the residential, but they don't do retail. And I think that's where this partnership and where it landed was a great fit.
Dolben has tens of thousands of apartment units. Klein, there's a lot of mixed use, and so they were not afraid and they know the neighborhood and started to have a vision for what they could create in terms of an atmosphere and a buzz in that part of Fell's Point.
00;18;44;22 - 00;18;57;22
DP
So back to construction. So you're under construction. Any unique construction details that you guys came across using brick or anything else, especially with all these existing buildings out there, right?
00;18;57;25 - 00;20;23;26
JH
It was probably one of the most challenging projects you’re going to look at. I'm sure you've talked to a number of architects that when you do an urban infill, it's a challenge. We touch over a dozen property lines on the west block and over a dozen on the east block. Each one of those neighbors needed to be notified.
You had to figure out how you're going to close the gap on those property lines, how you're going to flash onto other people's party walls. Essentially, as boring as the back of the place was. We had wall sections at every property line because each one was a unique condition on the west block, where we have almost 100 apartment units, we also have an underground parking garage.
So we have about 60 parking spaces underground and all the initial readings or that we have a water table. So here you're creating a bathtub, you've got a water table. And I think it was Hurricane Sandy that had a storm surge that pushed water up to that block as well. So now you're thinking, okay, how do I prevent water from above and below from filling this garage?
And so we had to create under-floor and remediation for the ground water as it swells and being able to pump it, that water table rises and lowers. So when it rises, you're pumping 24/7.
00;20;23;28 - 00;20;31;06
DP
So how did you guys resolve this? You're still pumping water out of there. When the groundwater rises up and it's like a bathtub that you built.
00;20;31;11 - 00;20;33;07
JH
Exactly. You are.
00;20;33;09 - 00;20;35;17
DP
Unbelievable. That's expensive.
00;20;35;19 - 00;21;07;07
JH
It's expensive. And again, you can imagine, I mean, now we're 12 feet below all the properties around us as well. So there was an incredible amount of documentation of the properties adjacent to this project. To be sure these 1800 structures don't settle, don't crack, and then making deals with each one of them that if that happens, we'll repair it.
So there was an incredible amount of liability on the contractor owner and architects and engineers as well.
00;21;07;09 - 00;21;30;06
DP
Wow. You guys have a real constitution. I don't think I could handle that. Just way too much responsibility. You know, interestingly, I did some work with Habitat for Humanity when we lived in Baltimore. And I remember these brick buildings, these row homes, they were crumbling. When the brick is that old, did you guys run into issues like that?
00;21;30;09 - 00;22;27;06
JH
We did. The interesting part of this was finding a right contractor that could deal with this. You weren't looking at a suburban stick frame guy. They'd look at it and were scared. So we needed somebody that had some chops. We ended up with Lendlease and they did a terrific job supporting the historic facades during this time. And so we had every ten feet, a steel column going up the front of the facade and then being supported laterally with other beams and huge cement blocks to keep them from falling as things were excavated behind it.
So it was painstakingly slow at that point. But then also the timing had to be right in order to get the concrete slab there to then reinforce and support those walls and to tie them back in to the concrete slab so that they wouldn't, you know, fall out or fall in.
00;22;27;08 - 00;22;52;19
DP
It takes a special kind of person and firm to do this kind of work, to be involved in that stuff. Architects do all different kinds of jobs, right? And this is one of them working with historic architecture. So what about drawings? What kind of drawings did you guys put together for the architecture? Was it 2D, 3D, lots of details? And then of course, you had to hire engineers and do drawings for the existing condition work.
00;22;52;25 - 00;24;05;19
JH
That's correct. And early on there's a bit of surveying that you do. I would say that it was also incredible working with a civil engineer, because if you think each one of these properties also has utilities coming in and out of it, making sure that we're staying away from all of these. So the underground piece of this became incredibly complicated. The three dimensional aspects, my partners and I are not old, but, you know, we still do a lot by hand. So a lot of the three dimensional stuff in order to get information out there quickly was by hand a lot of two dimensional facades around the project to see how it would relate to the adjacent properties. A lot of wall sections. This would have been wonderful if we had the technology today and, you know, have a drone or something scan the existing conditions in three dimensions. There was a lot of back and forth. Fortunately, it's only a half a mile from our office, so it could be down there in a heartbeat as soon as they discovered things during construction. And that was a vital way of solving some of the problems that came up because so many of them you can't anticipate.
You can only suggest a solution until things get uncovered.
00;24;05;21 - 00;24;14;11
DP
Yeah. Instead of getting in your car and driving a half hour, you walk right out onto the street and walk down the street and you can take a look at whatever challenge you face that day.
00;24;14;14 - 00;24;15;08
JH
That's correct.
00;24;15;15 - 00;24;23;27
DP
So did your team learn anything interesting through the design and construction process? That's a loaded question.
00;24;24;00 - 00;26;07;16
JH
It is. And I'd say, you know, even just this discussion, you can see I mean, all of these things are something new. And I think that's the beauty of the profession. As you mentioned, you work on so many different types of projects. And what I love about how we work as a firm that we don't have these vertical silos, we work across different typologies and bring that knowledge base to each project, which lends itself to something like this where you have mixed uses.
So the retail spaces on the ground floor needed to have If I'm going to put a kitchen in there for a restaurant, I need exhaust. That's got to go up through a couple stories of apartment buildings. So that kind of coordination, anticipating the needs of each component so that each of them stood alone and was able to be successful on their own rather than handicapping one.
One of the things we were not able to do is create what would be normal for a retailer today in terms of ceiling heights. We had to hit the second floor windows of the facades. So sometimes that meant that a retailer could only have maybe a nine or ten foot ceiling in there in order to get all the ductwork and lighting and everything else below the concrete slab.
I'd say what we really learned was from a design perspective, how to work with the community. I think that was the big success here, that we were able to revitalize an area of Fell's Point, bring life to it, bring housing for people, for more activity, and to do that successfully where the community was extremely happy with the end result.
00;26;07;18 - 00;26;24;04
DP
So I'm curious, some of these brick buildings, the existing brick buildings, how did you guys handle the new interior wall systems insulation and how did that work and did that decrease then the interior space? Because some of these buildings are probably pretty narrow.
00;26;24;09 - 00;27;18;17
JH
That's correct. Working with a different module that you're basically given was different and you ended up with almost a wall within a wall in order to get the proper insulation and which made for some unique conditions out the windows where you notice how, you know, like suddenly you've got a big inset that's about a foot and a half to the window.
There were some cases where we had to bump up the ceiling or bump down the floor a little bit where some of these windows were as as much as we tried. There were some things we just couldn't change. So this section is what was fascinating on these projects in that front facade along Broadway, we had to ramp down a couple of feet in order to get to the level that was needed for those apartments.
So it was both in section and then also horizontally in terms of laying out apartments that utilize the existing facades.
00;27;18;19 - 00;27;30;22
DP
Yeah, a lot of site specific challenging conditions. I can see why being out there, being in person was really important because every building's going to be just a little bit different.
00;27;30;29 - 00;27;31;28
JH
That's correct.
00;27;32;00 - 00;27;46;16
DP
Before you go, John, you've been an architect for some time. Based on what you know today about being an architect, do you have any words of advice for either your younger self or maybe young architects coming up in the profession?
00;27;46;18 - 000;29;02;11
JH
I'd like to just call it dumb luck, but I was really, really fortunate to land in a dream job in the late eighties, and it set me on a course for a career that was, this has been phenomenal and a journey. Going to the University of Cincinnati, having a co-op program was fascinating. Your third year, you're going to work for a firm for three months and nobody wanted to work in New York City.
And so I said, I'll go. And that firm happened to be KPF. So I cut my teeth in college with six months working at Kohn Pedersen Fox working on international high rise structures. That set me on a course that took me from there to Disney Development to the West Coast, then back to Ohio before I even graduated college. So I tell that story because that's my advice to folks.
Go for it. Don't be shy. Try to find a path that speaks to your heart. And you know, it's one of the beautiful things about the United States is you can travel, you can go to another location where the jobs are, where you want to be, where you fit.
00;29;02;18 - 00;29;07;04
DP
Well, that's a really interesting point. I think we forget that. I certainly do.
00;29;07;06 - 00;29;11;03
JH
Got a little international connection that reminds me of it quite a bit.
00;29;11;05 - 00;29;18;18
DP
So, John, it's been great to have you here today. Thanks for your time. Where can people go to learn more about JP2 Architects and yourself?
00;29;18;21 - 00;29;37;17
JH
Well, we are active on social media, so your normal spots of LinkedIn, Facebook and Instagram. Our website is JP2architects.com. And as with a lot of folks, we're looking for people to grow with us. It's an exciting time right now.
00;29;37;20 - 00;29;41;11
DP
That's a great little plug. Awesome, man. Well, it's been great to meet you, John.
00;29;41;17 - 00;29;51;29
JH
I'll do one more plug. Part of this project is an isolated corner of the 600 block of Broadway, and that is where Brickworks is located.
00;29;52;00 - 00;29;53;04
DP
Get out of town.
00;29;53;07 - 00;30;27;18
JH
So that is one of the main reasons we wanted to use this project, not only because of the incredible history and everything else associated with it. We thought for sure that corner was made for a Starbucks, a first floor and a second floor seating. But that is not going to happen in Fell's Point. Fell's Point is about local businesses, local restaurants and Brickworks Studio there is phenomenal. I love it. It is such a great fit and we love having them a resource that's just down the street.
00;30;27;25 - 00;30;52;07
DP
Yeah, it's kind of perfect.
You May Also Be Interested In
We Can Help With Your Next Project
Discover the latest + greatest in design trends, industry news & pro tips from pros.
For all of your project needs, you’ll find everything you need at a Supply Center.
Let Us Know How We Can Help!
Design Vault Ep. 19 The Rogers Condominiums with Peter Miller
ABOUT THE ARCHITECT:
![]()
|
Peter Miller is a Partner of Palette Architecture, which he co-founded in 2010. He is a Director of the Executive Board of AIA-NY and a Design for Freedom Working Group member. Peter is a registered architect with 20+ years of experience focusing on designing and implementing innovative building systems and components. His notable projects include Grace Farms in New Canaan, CT; The National WWII Museum in New Orleans, LA; the Revitalization of Forest Park in St. Louis, MO; the Con" uence Master Plan of Missouri/Illinois; and NYC-HPD’s Small Lots Development Program. Peter’s work has won many design awards, including several AIA National Honor Awards and the Mies Crown Hall Americas Prize. His work has been featured in many publications, including Architectural Record, Elle Decor, Fast Company, Wall Street Journal, and the New York Times. Peter is originally from rural Indiana and is from a family of craftsmen, engineers, entrepreneurs, and tinkerers. He treasures the creative process of turning ideas into physical form. He is grateful for the privilege of making space for others and its effects on their lives. Peter holds a BS in Architecture from Washington University in St. Louis and a Master’s degree from the Graduate School of Architecture, Planning, and Preservation at Columbia University.
|
---|
ABOUT THE PROJECT:
Three adjacent lots in Prospect Le# erts Gardens are the project site for a new eighteen unit multi-family mixed use building. The massing is largely driven by the desire to create a building that ! ts bridges between the existing neighboring three story brick walk-ups and taller multi-family buildings of the future. This is realized by the creation of two masses—one smooth and the other ‘chunky’. The smooth mass is understated, more closely relating to the scale of existing urban fabric, while the chunky mass sits atop and in contrast, articulated and expressive. The articulations of the chunky mass form unique outdoor spaces for each two or three bedroom unit, a necessary and desirable program in the age of social distancing. The ground $ oor has ample space for commercial or community facility tenants.
The Rogers Condominiums
Designed by Palette Architecture
View ProjectTRANSCRIPT
00;00;00;02 - 00;00;05;12
Doug Pat (DP)
Let's go inside the vault. The design vault.
00;00;05;14 - 00;00;30;13
Peter Miller (PM)
Gentrification is always an issue in New York City, and trying to deal with that in a responsible way as an architect is something we often think about. Some people, you know, have a problem with larger buildings, but we're not talking about towers. The most bulk is on avenue is where I think people are a bit more comfortable. And because we're bringing residential into the neighborhood, that's usually something that's appreciated.
Everyone in New York believes rents and housing prices are too high and we need a greater supply.
00;00;30;18 - 00;01;00;18
DP
This is my guest, Peter Miller. I'll share more about him shortly. In this episode from the Design Vault we highlight Peter's project 625 Rogers Avenue. 625 Rogers Avenue is the site for a new mixed-use building with a primary use of residential ground level, commercial and community facility uses with a below grade enclosed parking lot. The architectural design for the building divides the overall mass into two distinct volumes a lower and upper.
The lower is a rectilinear form that relates to historic buildings in the area. This volume is meant to create a more contextual streetscape and a friendly residential feel. In contrast, the higher recessed form is articulated to relate to the new character of the neighborhood. It steps back and recedes as it rises, making it more private and less visible from the street.
The lower form is brick, the upper is stucco, the lower is dark, the upper is light. A side yard is included along the south elevation for more daylight glass and a restaurant terrace. Hi, I'm Doug Pat, and this is Design Vault. Peter Miller is a partner of Palatte Architecture, which he co-founded in 2010. He holds a B.S. in architecture from Washington University in Saint Louis and a master's degree from the Graduate School of Architecture, Planning and Preservation at Columbia University.
Peter is a director of the Executive Board of AIA New York and a Design for Freedom Working Group member. He's a registered architect with 20 plus years of experience focusing on designing and implementing innovative building systems and components. His notable projects include Grace Farms in New Canaan, Connecticut, The National World War Two Museum in New Orleans, The Revitalization of Forest Park in Saint Louis, the Confluence Masterplan of Missouri and NYC HPD's Small Lots Development Program.
Peter's work has won many design awards, including several AIA National Honors Awards and the Mies Crown Hall America's Prize. His work has been featured in Architectural Record, Elder Corps, Fast Company, The Wall Street Journal and The New York Times. He's originally from rural Indiana and is from a family of craftsmen, engineers, entrepreneurs and tinkerers. He treasures the creative process of turning ideas into physical form.
So welcome, Peter. It's nice to have you with us today. So tell us a little bit about Palatte Architecture in New York City. So it was founded in 2010. Where are you guys located In the city. What's the size of the firm? What type of work do you do?
00;03;17;08 - 00;04;01;09
PM
So we're located in the, I like to say the Union Square area. We're on 16th Street and Sixth Avenue. We are 11 people in total, three partners and eight architects. The work that we primarily do is residential in nature. It spans from multifamily, residential in the mid-sized range. 50 dwellings is probably an average size for a mid-sized development to custom residential townhouse projects within the city and custom houses ground up outside of the city.
In addition to the residential work, we do a variety of other things early education is a big part of what we do. Preschools, daycares, things of that nature, and some other commercial projects spanning from retail to restaurants.
00;04;01;12 - 00;04;02;08
DP
How's business?
00;04;02;14 - 00;04;30;04
PM
Businesses up and down. You know, when you own your own business, it's always a rollercoaster. I would say we're busy. There is a lot of work being constructed right now. We have a lot of projects in construction. Design work continues to come in. It's not quite as strong as it was a year ago. I think interest rates are affecting particularly the custom residential side of our business, but the multifamily business continues to be booming. We stay busy.
00;04;30;07 - 00;04;31;28
DP
Has the firm grown?
00;04;32;01 - 00;04;52;08
PM
We try very hard to stay the same size. We have a team of people that we really like and we trust them. And I think a big part of who we are is the consistency within our office. So when times get slow, we find ways to keep those people productive, and when times are busy, they go the extra mile for us and they put in the extra work.
00;04;52;10 - 00;04;59;17
DP
So tell us a little bit about yourself. So how long have you been practicing and what's your role in the office as a partner?
00;04;59;20 - 00;06;10;10
PM
So I've been practicing since early 2000s. I attended Columbia University for graduate school and finished in 2006 and spent a better part of a decade working for well-known firms, doing international projects, particularly of like museums and high end residential. We formed Palatte Architecture. I had two business partners, John Sunwoo and Jeff Wanders, and then we met at Columbia in studio, and there was always an idea that we wanted to work together.
It took a while. We had our own careers in other firms for a while and came back together and formed the office in 2010, but it took a little while to get off the ground. Within the firm my role is partner. We are fairly equal. It's one of our core elements at Pallet architecture, the three partners. We have complementary skills, but we all can perform anything within the office.
Projects are organized where each partner is in charge of one, and then beyond that, we have some other roles. One of my roles is sort of business management and human resources, so I do that in addition to all the design work, the construction administration.
00;06;10;09 - 00;06;15;17
DP
All right, so let's dig in here and talk about 625 Rogers Avenue. So how did your office get the project?
00;06;15;19 - 00;07;07;25
PM
So this is with a client we've been working with for a while is a little bit of background on Palette Architecture. We really started this firm fairly early in our careers. As such, we didn't have as many connections. A lot of things started out as they do in sort of those classic ideas of architecture. You're doing somebody's bathroom, somebody's kitchen, and then you do a good job and you end up doing their house and eventually you work your way up.
So it's been that way. We met this client when we were doing a lot of houses and they were looking to turn a house into a residential building, a multifamily four. So it was to turn like a big townhouse into a four family. And so we did that project for them and we built a relationship that's led to, I think, ten different projects with them now.
And this is the latest one. And so they've grown in scale each time. And this one's, I think, 25 units.
00;07;08;02 - 00;07;14;29
DP
The project is considerable size. So give us a little history of the location and what was there prior.
00;07;15;01 - 00;08;17;11
PM
This is in the Prospect Lefferts neighborhood of Brooklyn. So that is on the northeast side of Prospect Park. We've done a number of projects in this area. The site before this was largely vacant, there was a couple of dilapidated houses in that area. It was mostly a small demo and clearing the project is near the corner of Parkside and Rogers Avenue.
Rogers is the major thoroughfare through the Prospect Lefferts neighborhood. We do not have the actual corner lot, which was kind of an unusual situation in terms of design. There is a small brick building on the corner that has a bodega in the ground floor. Adjacent to them there was an easement in place for them to have access to the back of their building.
So we have a minimum of eight feet that we needed to keep open between us in their building. So we ended up with a building that had two facades, even though it wasn't on a corner because of the easement.
00;08;17;13 - 00;08;22;24
DP
So tell me a little bit about the scope of the project and the client's programmatic requirements.
00;08;22;26 - 00;09;08;03
PM
So the scope of the project is largely multi-family residential. As with any case, working with a developer, you know, it's maximizing units and floor area for the residential use. However, because it's on Rogers Avenue, which is a major thoroughfare, there was an overlay for commercial. So there was a desire to try to put as much commercial in here as was viable in terms of sales. On the ground floor we have two commercial spaces. One is designed to be a restaurant and the other is a bit more flexible, likely to be more of a retail establishment. And then in addition, there is a small community facility space on the ground floor. There is a lobby also on the ground floor that leads up to the residential spaces. And there is five floors, two through six, that is residential apartments above.
00;09;08;05 - 00;09;12;03
DP
So building plan. Could you describe that on the site shape?
00;09;12;05 - 00;09;27;04
PM
Yeah. So it's L-shaped, I would say, with one of the major legs being across Rogers Avenue and the other leg running parallel to this easement that I mentioned before. And then there is a courtyard in the back portion of the L.
00;09;27;06 - 00;09;33;10
DP
So project restrictions, zoning codes. What were you guys dealing with out there other than the easement?
00;09;33;12 - 00;10;21;05
PM
One of the things that has generated a lot of our work in Prospect Lefferts Gardens is there was a zoning change probably about a decade ago that allowed for larger bulk in the area. So a lot of the buildings along Rogers Avenue and in other parts of the neighborhood, are suddenly getting a lot bigger. And in some cases you're seeing full tear downs.
In some cases you're seeing vertical enlargements. In our case, it was important to have this contextual approach that some of the smaller buildings were going to remain for decades and others were going to instantly become larger. So we wanted something the span between those. That meant having a form that followed the context of those smaller buildings. So it's larger up to a setback, and then it sets back at the height of our neighbors and then becomes something a bit more fanciful above.
00;10;21;07 - 00;10;28;09
DP
I'm thinking about the neighbors, right? And I'm thinking about the neighborhood. And you said these buildings are getting bigger. Is that driving anybody crazy?
00;10;28;12 - 00;11;09;05
PM
Oh, certainly. It's a mixed neighborhood and gentrification is always an issue in New York City. And trying to deal with that in a responsible way as an architect is something we often think about. And it's certainly an issue in this neighborhood as well. Some people, you know, have a problem with larger buildings, but we're not talking about towers.
The bulk has risen from like four stories to six or seven stories. So it's a bit bigger. The most bulk is on avenues where I think people are a bit more comfortable with it. And because we're bringing residential into the neighborhood, that's usually something that's appreciated. Everyone in New York believes rents and housing prices are too high and that we need a greater supply. So there isn't a lot of tension, I think, on that.
00;11;09;08 - 00;11;17;22
DP
What is the city do in terms of review, esthetics and building height? Is there an open meeting and you guys are just about to go into construction?
00;11;17;29 - 00;13;21;19
PM
We are in construction. We've been in construction for almost a year. The superstructure is in place. A lot of the interiors are framed out and the building is fully enclosed. At this point, we are about to clad the exterior, so we're pretty far along in construction in terms of the city's take on the shape and the zoning of the building.
New York City is fairly as of right city. If you are following the zoning code, zoning text in the building code, you can largely do what you want, but it is fairly constrained, especially if you want to maximize the floor area, maximize the amount of units. So you often find yourself into these rectilinear envelopes if you're trying to maximize, but there's room for play.
And I think that's really what we were trying to do with this lower mass, is to build that out, make it very tight and taut and follow the context of the neighborhood. It was a bit more challenging on our site because we also had to deal with this easement. And so the easement is a whole swath of the property that you can't use.
You're probably aware, but in New York City, the amount that you can build is a factor of the lot size. So the larger the lot, the more you can build. However, if you're not allowed to build on a portion of the lot, then that same amount of area has to fit into a smaller envelope and so it gets tight.
That's kind of what led to the L-shape, is that we couldn't simply do it in a bar building across the main avenue. We had to put some sort of extension on to the back. But we were fortunate that that extension could follow the easement. So we get a lot of natural light and air from that. It's not legal light and air, which I think people from New York will be familiar with, which is something is a requirement for all apartments.
But we were able to get that through our courtyard and through our rear exposure. And so this was really like bonus windows and bonus light and air that we could get because of the easement. In addition, this corner building is quite a bit smaller, so we are afforded a lot of wonderful views over the top of it.
00;13;21;21 - 00;13;37;24
DP
So tell us a little bit about the design process. I just typed in 625 Rogers Avenue and there's a nice website that comes up and there are some great three dimensional images there that tell me a little bit about the design process. How does that work in your office and how long did it take for this project?
00;13;37;27 - 00;14;19;02
PM
The design process is usually quite rapid in New York City. I would say the actual meat of the process, which is kind of something that a lot of times you learn in school, you spend some time, you make some models, try out a few renderings and you come up with something and then you say, Well, we're not going to do this part.
Let's change it like that. That part of like coming to a form and a floor plan was probably an 8 to 10 week process. And then, of course, there's many stages after that coordinating with structure and mechanical and doing all the fine details and then that sort of thing, Then that's probably another couple of months.
00;14;19;04 - 00;14;21;21
DP
So were the clients excited about the project?
00;14;21;23 - 00;16;41;07
PM
Yes, they do value design a lot and so they were quite excited about it. I think there was always a question of how were we going to deal with this easement? And I think they were very excited about this idea of this lower box that is contextual. We weren't formally contextual. I think that's also probably important to mention.
It is a black brick, so it's not your traditional New York red brick or yellow brick that you might find in there. It is a black brick, so it is meant to pop a bit. What was important to us as a firm was to make something that was formally contextual, didn't look bigger than the neighbors didn't look imposing.
We're not interested in a building that like sticks out like a sore thumb. I think a lot of architects think that you need to make something flashy in order to be noticed, and then for people to come and want you to design another flashy thing that wasn't necessarily what we were after. We wanted something that had a calm facade to it and felt a bit like the neighborhood.
But this isn't the early 1900s, like the context was built in, so we can't do exactly that. So we were looking for something that was formally similar but materially different. And so we went with this black brick along the lower volume. And then of course we had more area to use and we had to put it somewhere. So we set it back and we gave it more articulation.
It's a bit of push and pull of rectangular volumes above, but it's a very light color and the idea was always to be set back enough to where it wasn't initially visible. It was more of a second look sort of thing that when you see the building, you're like, Oh, that feels like the size of other buildings in the neighborhood.
And then when you look a second time, you’re like actually it is not. And what's going on up above is really articulated and interesting. And why did they do this sort of thing? And the reason why we did a lot of that on the upper volume was to create outdoor spaces. This was a project that was conceived during the pandemic and then finalized throughout that process.
There was a lot of interest in our office about making outdoor spaces, particularly private outdoor spaces, beyond the size of balconies, spaces that were more of room size so that you could actually spend time outside with others and you could work outside when the weather is good. So a lot of the articulation on this upper volume was about trying to create private outdoor spaces for each of the interior units.
00;16;41;10 - 00;16;45;07
DP
So were there any unique construction details throughout the project?
00;16;45;09 - 00;18;20;15
PM
Certainly. And we are talking about brick, I'm sure, today. So I think that has a lot to do with it. We've been finding that thin brick has been really advantageous to us throughout the process. New York City is all about every inch. Every inch matters. Real estate agents will tell you that. So the thin brick does afford us a thinner wall thickness, which allows every unit to be a little bit bigger, the sales area to be a little bit bigger.
So that's something we'd like to do. But what we found great about the true brick system, which is what we used, is that it's a mechanically fastened thin brick which affords us new types of details. When you see the classical full brick, you can do corbelling, you can have some bricks, project out from others to create shadow lines and other types of articulation, which wasn't initially available in thin brick because everything just had to sit inside of a tray and anything that projected out would become too much of a load and either pop out.
And so what we were really excited about with this thin brick system, the true bricks, is that we could have a variety of brick depths while still saving these inches. And so there was a lot of thought about that in terms of details. We used different depths of thin brick to articulate slab edges and also areas of pattern and texture.
So within this brick volume on the base, there are strip windows. In between each strip window. We do have a textured brick that creates a bit of interest. It creates a patterned shadow on the facade, and then that is all captured in between these sort of expressed slab edges.
00;18;20;17 - 00;18;24;29
DP
So could you go through a wall section for me? Exterior to interior.?
00;18;25;01 - 00;19;29;12
PM
So we have on the exterior a variety of different depth thin bricks that snap into the true bricks tray system, which is sort of like a channel shaped system that is then attached into a kingspan karrier panel. So this is sort of an all in one cladding waterproofing insulation panel. I believe it's an XPS insulation that's wrapped in a metal panel.
And these are tongue and groove panels that come together and they're flashed at their tongue and groove. So the metal panel on the outside acts as waterproofing, especially when the joints are flashed. Then there is this completely separated other metal panel on the interior, the separated by this XPS installations that provides your insulation and then that interior panel allows you to attach to the studs.
So there's no need for sheathing or waterproofing layer or another set of insulation. It's all in one. So we have that karrier panel and then that is attached to the stud. And then on the interior of the stud we have our finishes, which is general sheetrock.
00;19;29;14 - 00;19;33;06
DP
And the installation values of the walls?
00;19;33;06 - 00;19;36;24
PM
Two and a half inches. So I'm guessing that's probably about R 14.
00;19;36;26 - 00;19;46;17
DP
That sounds really interesting. And using thin brick, I mean it's a veneer like anything anyway, so whether or not you're going to use something that's three and 5/8 thick or it's a half inch thick, it’s still a veneer.
00;19;48;19 - 00;20;22;13
PM
100% agree. We live in a world now where energy code and sustainability issues are vitally important. And for the most part we know Brick classically is like a veneer as a cladding and a structural system, but it's just really not done that way anymore. It's mostly a cladding system now because we need to have this rain screen where where air can move behind the facade, and we need continuous insulation.
So if it's going to be mostly a veneer. Now I'm a fan of the thin brick systems because it saves you that extra couple of inches.
00;20;22;16 - 00;20;40;15
DP
Yeah, I totally agree. And you touched on this a little bit. Just back to the esthetics. So tell us about the style choice. The building is contemporary. When I read about the architecture you guys talked about as statically trying to work with the existing architecture in the neighborhood. Tell us a little bit about that.
00;20;40;17 - 00;22;28;22
PM
I think it's largely about scale. So as I mentioned, we are trying to create a datum that matches with the neighbor. In terms of height. I think the concern back to what you mentioned before is that people are going to feel like their neighborhood is growing rapidly and that it feels much more urban than it used to. And so that was really important to us in terms of context to make the scale feel as if they had always known this building.
Beyond that, we felt that Brick was an important choice. There's a lot of brick in the neighborhood. We felt that other materials might feel too distinct from the rest of the context. I don't think it's important that we try to look exactly like the neighbors because we're in a different era, a different technology. But there needs to be some tie to the way it is.
And it was also sort of important to us that the windows had some sort of gridded logic to it to match the neighbors. So there's a nod to that. Beyond that, we felt freedom to go a different way. And so we relied on sort of a color choice as one way to do that, to create this darker volume on the lower part would sort of emphasize the height of the building that it matched the others because it's so present in its darkness.
The other thing we liked about the darkness is that it made all the details a bit more subtle. It gave us a little more freedom to do things like these patterned bricks and these shadow lines that indicated that this was a newer building and that it has some innovative techniques and details to it. But wasn't flashy to the point of look at me and forget everyone else in the neighborhood.
00;22;28;25 - 00;22;39;02
DP
That's well explained. So when you guys did drawings for the architecture, for the construction process, all 2D, 2D and 3D, Revit, what are you guys working out?
00;22;39;02 - 00;23;05;06
PM
Yeah, well, Revit. Our office is 100% BIM. We are an office that was founded since 2010. So the partners, all the employees, we all grew up in this, so we're 100% BIM. We use Revit as our software. So everything is done in Revit from beginning to end. We found this really beneficial with some of our clients too, because we can get the visualizations a lot quicker and that just makes them feel comfortable.
00;23;05;08 - 00;23;16;07
DP
Yeah, clients love that. Yeah, for sure. So do you guys learn anything interesting through the design in what you're currently in construction process? Anything new for you as you've been working on the architecture?
00;23;16;09 - 00;24;17;03
PM
Well, let's see things that I would want to talk about. Usually the lessons are the things that like you didn't see coming or you feel like you could have control. I think one thing that we really learned on this project is moving to this Kingspan panel that I mentioned before is a new thing for our office. We're doing it on two projects or two simultaneously.
We knew a lot about the details going into it and we really believed in it and we love it, but our contractors were not familiar with it and so there was definitely a lot of lessons in how to communicate these details because a lot of them came in and were like, They see these new Legos for the first time and they're like, Oh, they must go together like this.
And then you arrive at a site and you say, No, actually you put that piece on wrong. It should be like this. There was a lot of back and forth and learning about how to communicate, when to come in in the process with somebody that hasn't used the technology before and really get them up to speed on it.
00;24;17;06 - 00;24;42;15
DP
That's funny, yeah, GCs love that when you walk out into the field and you tell them they're wrong. Yeah, sure. Before you go, Peter, you've been an architect for some time based on what you know today about being an architect, do you have any words of advice for your younger version of you, or maybe for some students or young architects that are just getting rolling?
00;24;42;17 - 00;25;03;01
PM
Well, that's a great question. It's easier for me to advise my earlier self than advise a generic architect in school, and I hope this advice applies for me. I was always an introverted sort of person. I come from a very conservative rural background and it took me a while to learn how to really speak my voice to people.
And I think in school there's this sense that your work is always out there for critique and that you should be careful about everything you do. I think I've learned over time that as long as you follow your own voice and your own beliefs, that those things will fall in place. And so I would advise myself, when I was younger, to not be concerned about whether or not your voice is going to land perfectly amongst your audience.
I think as long as you believe in it passionately and you talk about it strongly and you think about it all the time and you critique yourself, that that will lead to stronger work and it will lead to people wanting to see your work and interact with your work and make sure that it gets built in the way that you had always imagined it.
00;25;03;02 - 00;25;51;16
DP
Yeah, I think that's a really beautiful way of looking at things right that it will land in the right location. You're just responsible for finding your voice and expressing it as best you can within the framework of the work that you do. That's great. So, Peter, it's been great to have you here. Thanks for your time. Where can people go to learn more about Palette Architecture and yourself?
00;25;51;19 - 00;26;13;22
PM
Well, certainly you can go to our website, PaletteArch.com, or they can follow us on Instagram also @PaletteArch.
00;26;13;24 - 00;26;29;26
DP
Well, Peter, thank you very much. It's been great to have you.
You May Also Be Interested In
We Can Help With Your Next Project
Discover the latest + greatest in design trends, industry news & pro tips from pros.
For all of your project needs, you’ll find everything you need at a Supply Center.
Let Us Know How We Can Help!