Favorites
Design Vault Ep. 5 Park + Elton with David Gross
ABOUT THE ARCHITECT:
![]()
|
David E. Gross, AIA is the Co-Founder and Executive Partner of GF55 Architects, a national firm with offices in New York City and Miami. GF55 has a specific expertise in Multi Family, Retail, Educational, Hospitality, and Industrial Architecture. Since 1984, GF55 has designed and built over 12 million square feet of housing nationally. David’s projects have received two Urban Land Institute Models of Excellence Awards and was the recipient of the Andrew J. Thomas “Pioneer in Housing” Award in 2010 from the NYC AIA Chapter. David received an AIA Award of Merit for the renovation and addition of a historic and significant Mid Century Modern house in Rye NY. His work has also been featured in Architectural Digest and The New York Times. David has established the David E. Gross Fellowship at the University of Pennsylvania Weitzman School of Design for the study of Housing. David is a board member at the University of Pennsylvania Weitzman School of Design advisory board to the School of Architecture, the New York State Association for Affordable Housing (NYSAFAH); Citizens Housing and Planning Council (CHPC) as well as the NY Housing Conference. He has been a visiting design juror at Yale College, New Jersey Institute of Technology, and Pratt Institute. From 2004 to 2016 he taught an annual session on the relationship of the Architect to the Development Process at the NYU Graduate School of Real Estate MBA Program. The continued progress and intelligent development of Architecture through future generations was fundamental to David’s decision in establishing this fellowship. David graduated Cum Laude with Distinction from the University of Pennsylvania. He also earned his Master of Architecture from the University of Pennsylvania where he was a Thesis Prize Finalist and a Stewardson Memorial Competition Representative. |
---|
ABOUT THE PROJECT:
Park and Elton, a development with 38 residential units consisting of two 5-story buildings, correspond to the Melrose Commons Urban Renewal Plan providing a range of affordable housing choices to support diversity. The sister buildings exemplify the goal of New York City’s affordable housing mission; providing quality housing through high design input and cost effective measures. The use of simple materials in a creative way resulted in these modest buildings. The subtle volume and height of Park and Elton maintain the human-scale of the public realm. The simple modern cornice and the differentiation of the window header detail with the application of the soldier brick pattern references the historical brick clad buildings found throughout the district.
Construction of the buildings included sustainable design elements and incorporated NYC Green Building Standards. Features include Energy Star appliances and lighting, high efficiency plumbing fixtures and high‐quality durable concrete plank and masonry bearing wall construction. Park and Elton are considered equivalent to LEED certified buildings.
Park + Elton
David E. Gross / GF55 Architects
See MoreTRANSCRIPT
00;00;00;00 - 00;00;05;11
Doug Patt (DP)
Let's go inside the vault. The design vault.
00;00;05;13 - 00;00;22;00
David Gross (DG)
Most of our buildings are taller and bigger. And this was a little bit of a throwback. A five-story building, not too many square feet, but it was a challenge for us and an opportunity to look at our housing work on a smaller scale and very proud of it.
00;00;22;02 - 00;02;59;25
DP
This is my guest, David Gross. I'll share more about him shortly. In this episode from the Design Vault, we’ll highlight David's project Park and Elton.
Park and Elton is a development with 38 residential units in the Bronx, consisting of two distinct five story buildings. These buildings correspond to the Melrose Commons Urban Renewal Plan. The plan provides a range of affordable housing choices for the Bronx.
The use of simple building materials, including brick in various patterns, colors and facade wall depths, makes these modest buildings appear quite unique. The simple modern masonry cornice and the differentiation of the window header detail with soldier course patterns reference the historical brick clad buildings found throughout the district. The subtle volume and height of Park and Elton also maintain a satisfying human scale.
Construction of the buildings included sustainable design elements and incorporated New York City Green building standards. Park and Elton are considered equivalent to LEED certified buildings.
Hi, I'm Doug Pat and this is Design Vault. Today we're talking to David E. Gross, AIA. David earned his Master of Architecture from the University of Pennsylvania and graduated cum laude with distinction.
David is the co-founder and executive partner of GF55 Architects, a national firm with offices in New York City and Miami. GF55, has expertise in multifamily, retail, educational, hospitality and industrial architecture. Since 1984, GF55 has designed and built over 12 million square feet of housing nationally. David's projects have received two Urban Land Institute Models of Excellence awards and was the recipient of the Andrew J. Thomas Pioneer and Housing Award in 2010 from the New York City AIA chapter.
David received an award of merit for the renovation and addition of a historic and significant mid-century modern house in Rye, New York. His work has also been featured in Architectural Digest and The New York Times. Today, we're going to talk to David about GF55’s Park and Elton Project.
Welcome, David. So, before we get started, tell us a little bit about GF55 Architects. I understand your firm is in both New York City and Miami. What's the size of the firm and do the offices take the same kind of work?
00;03;00;04 - 00;03;17;11
DG
We're very much a New York firm with a satellite office in Miami and the Miami offices in support of the New York workload. The needs of staffing vary, and sometimes we have the ability to staff the projects through the Miami workforce as opposed to the New York workforce.
00;03;17;13 - 00;03;24;03
DP
So, tell us a little bit about GF55 architects, who you're the co-founding partner. How did you guys get your start?
00;03;24;09 - 00;03;52;06
DG
My partner, Len, he's the “F” and I - Len Fusca - we met in grad school, and we were partners right away in both architectural terms and friendship terms. Down the road, 15 years later, we met Shy, also, who's our third partner and the three of us are close professionally and friendship wise. We're all friends. We have about 50 people right now and we have a varied practice. But really a specialty in housing.
00;03;52;08 - 00;03;54;18
DP
How long have you had the Miami location then?
00;03;54;25 - 00;03;57;23
DG
I would say since 2012.
00;03;57;27 - 00;03;58;27
DP
Has that been helpful?
00;03;59;01 - 00;03;59;27
DG
Very helpful.
00;04;00;03 - 00;04;04;25
DP
Do you have people that you work with locally and then you also work with them in Miami?
00;04;04;29 - 00;04;41;01
DG
Yes. The Miami office specializes in retail. We do a large amount of retail buildout work across the country, but our main office, I would say, is New York. In New York, we do a lot of projects that are versions of Park and Elton, but much larger. We also do charter schools and medical facilities, and we're working on a large storage facility near the JFK Airport, which came to us right before COVID and then the entire process of COVID with Amazon, it was all of a sudden that's a building type that was very much in demand.
00;04;41;06 - 00;04;46;21
DP
Ironically, it's a good segue way to what is your role in the office. Right. Everybody's doing something different. What are you doing now?
00;04;46;23 - 00;05;53;26
DG
I like being an architect. You know, sometimes I find that I maybe I'm focusing on the buildings too much. I would say that my role is focusing on the long-term growth of the company and the direction of the company.
We have an outside consultant on how to manage the office because at 50 people, all of a sudden, it's way too big for any of the three partners to direct themselves. And we value the expertise that we give, and we are mature enough now to value the expertise that outside consultants give us. So, we try to run the office very professionally. And I would say that a lot of our energy about running the office is motivating the workforce and we motivate the workforce through a carrot rather than a stick.
It's not the old school where you better be here or else. We have to market – intra-office marketing is almost as important as outside marketing. We have to make sure that everyone's gratified and satisfied because anybody under 40 demands that of us. It's challenging and it's interesting and it's – I like it. It's heartwarming.
00;05;54;02 - 00;06;01;06
DP
It's a neat paradigm, though. I mean, thinking deeply about your employees and their well-being and wanting to keep them, I think that's wonderful.
00;06;01;10 - 00;06;04;13
DG
We should sign you up for the volleyball team.
00;06;04;16 - 00;06;05;21
DP
I need about another foot!
00;06;05;24 - 00;06;10;00
DG
It's not just volleyball. It's après-volleyball that they like. You know, like apres-ski.
00;06;10;07 - 00;06;20;00
DP
That's great. All right, so let's dig in here and talk about Park and Elton. So, Park is at 3120 Park Avenue in the Bronx. Elton is East 159th Street in the Bronx, correct?
00;06;20;03 - 00;06;20;17
DG
Yes.
00;06;20;24 - 00;06;30;14
DP
So, you're a board member of the New York State Association for Affordable Housing, the Citizens Housing and Planning Council, as well as the New York Housing Conference, correct?
00;06;30;20 - 00;06;30;14
DG
Yes.
00;06;31;09 - 00;06;41;23
DP
You're intimately familiar with affordable housing. This project, did you know it was coming up? What was the process by which you interviewed or took the job or how did that work out for you?
00;06;41;26 - 00;07;31;26
DG
It was actually part two of a project. That part one was maybe ten years before that. And unfortunately, the original developer passed away. One of his employees took over the job and it's a unique project for us because most of our buildings are taller and bigger. And this was a little bit of a throwback, a five-story building, not too many square feet, but it was a challenge for us and an opportunity to look at our housing work on a smaller scale and very proud of it.
As you mentioned, I'm a member of housing organizations. I grew up, my father and grandfather were builder developers and while their work wasn't affordable with a capital A, it was affordable with a small A because they built stuff that was a modest price points. And I really have a lot of familiarity with that building type.
00;07;32;02 - 00;07;34;13
DP
Well, it sounds like something that can be pretty gratifying.
00;07;34;18 - 00;08;02;16
DG
Yeah, I would say that's my main professional focus. And Parker and Elton were challenging because even though they're small in scale, they're important. One of them is on the corner and it forms a strong impact on that street. And it's a part of the South Bronx, that is, the buildings are modest. These buildings are very much a breath of fresh air to the neighborhoods. They're small, but they punch above their weight class visually.
00;08;02;18 - 00;08;08;10
DP
So, did the architecture in the neighborhood affect the architecture that you ultimately made?
00;08;08;13 - 00;09;44;13
DG
I would say the architecture in the neighborhood affected it in scale, but not in aesthetics. I think that our point was to be not oppositional, but in contrast to the older buildings and, you know, one of our mottos is creative responses with humble materials. If you look at the classic modern architects, the housing was really an issue in the 1920s and it was never about luxury materials. Despite the Barcelona Pavilion and all the history of obviously building these amazing villas in a modernist style for very wealthy people. But the focus, on paper at least, was housing for people.
And what's so great about Park and Elton is because they're a small size, we really had to focus on the details. I would say that I had a great team in the office to work with. The original designer, Dimitri Papageorgiou and I worked on the basic idea. We had a third person on the team, Emily Koustae, who was sort of sitting next to Dimitri offering her opinion, said it so smartly that we listened. And then the woman who ran the job during construction, Ingrid Aguilar, she was also very important because during the construction we started to see some opportunities with the way the brick was laid that we tested it, she looked at it, she photographed it, she brought it back to the office, we changed it. There is a detail of white brick that goes up the building as if it's like bubbles floating into the air. They become fewer as they go vertical.
00;09;44;13 - 00;09;45;18
DP
It's denser below.
00;09;45;19 - 00;09;48;19
DG
Yeah, and that was all done during the construction.
00;09;48;24 - 00;09;52;17
DP
So, let's start with the client's programmatic requirements. What did they want?
00;09;48;24 - 00;10;52;28
DG
HPD is the housing preservation development arm of the New York City government. And they have strict guidelines about what size units and what mix you can build. And they have different programs that the developer wants to qualify for to get tax credits.
So, we had to satisfy the specific program for affordability that the city and the developer had worked out. So, we satisfy that the one bedrooms are 650 square feet, studios are 475, etc., etc. There's a million requirements on how big the windows can be and what kind of air conditioning and what the energy rating is. Even though they're affordable, they're built in a very, very quality manner.
So that was the first requirement. Then there's a zoning requirement for a maximum building height and a maximum lot coverage. And there's a lot of metrics and matrices that you have to satisfy in order to finally get to the way it looks.
00;10;53;05 - 00;10;56;02
DP
So, there weren't any breaks given to the fact that this is affordable house.
00;10;56;04 - 00;11;03;22
DG
No, no special breaks. It's built into the code that you get a certain benefit from building affordable units.
00;11;03;24 - 00;11;07;20
DP
So, tell us about the two sites. How were they the same? How were they different?
00;11;07;23 - 00;12;10;19
DG
The Park is on the corner, and it has a corner window that wraps the facade, and you see it from a distance. And then Elton is an infill building on a street that is at a diagonal to the building itself. And we knew that in order to come out of this alive, both mentally and architecturally and constructability wise, we had to make the buildings the same.
So, we made them the same. The choice to use brick was an easy one because brick is so flexible, because brick is a unit that's made so that you can change it as you lay the brick which is laid by a person. So, there's a way to get richness and detail in the facade through the brick. It's super durable and the way we did it where we have the window panels are shiny black brick as opposed to the, I think, two color blend on the rest of the building gives it the texture as if it were a different material.
00;12;10;22 - 00;12;25;10
DP
When I was reading about the project, you said that the building plans are super simple and yet, you know, you stand back, and you look at these things and there's – you got something going on. So, tell us a little bit about the building plans. How did you make them a little less like a box?
00;12;25;12 - 00;14;10;09
DG
There's a little tower on the end, and on each end to give the building a little more shape, you know, lack of a better term. But that's a right out of the zoning code that allows you to do that. New York is actually very conservative because quality housing, which is the current zoning for housing encourage you to make boxes so that when you go down the street, whether it's Park Avenue or 135th Street in the Bronx, all the buildings are the same height. They're looking to create that urban scale that's consistent. And along the avenues, it's taller and along the side streets it's lower. But it's consistent. And you can see from these photographs that our building is within a few feet of the adjacent buildings. So that's how we ended up with the massing.
In terms of the windows, it's very budget constrained. So, it's not just simple materials and creative ways. The whole process, you have to find the design and there's a discipline to using the materials to change the scale. For example, if we had just drawn the elevation with the windows, it would seem like a barracks. It would just be a box and it would seem very closed. But by doing visual tricks, like adding the side panels and a different color that matches the window frame, it expands the visual impact of the window opening and it makes the scale of the implied grid larger. So, it seems airier, but in fact it's not airier. It’s a visual trick. Architects are doing that all over the world to try to bring their buildings into scale.
00;14;10;13 - 00;14;17;05
DP
And you change the direction of the brick, right? The way the brick is laid, and the facade undulates somewhat, right?
00;14;17;09 - 00;15;22;22
DG
I mean, if you zoom in on the photographs that we're looking at, the horizontal bands, they're vertical and they're a stack bond. They line up as a grid. And the regular brick in between the horizontal bands is a running bond that stagger each joint the half a dimension of the brick. So, you get a different way the sunlight hits the brick. It adds visual nuance and detail, which I think there's a criticism of buildings when they're too stark, unless they're completely stark. And then the starkness is a design feature.
But I think you need to find the details to make the building visually interesting. I think you owe that, as the architect, to the world. It’s beauty, commodity and delight since Vitruvius said it, and he probably wishes he had copyrighted that phrase because that would be a great brand in 1642. But commodity is the function, and the structure is firmness, and delight is it has to look good. I mean, that's fundamental to being an architect. It has to look good.
00;15;22;29 - 00;15;27;10
DP
What about the color? How did you guys choose the brown? The variations of brown.
00;15;27;12 - 00;16;14;15
DG
The brick has sort of a brown, gray feel, and we wanted it to seem contemporary and not traditional in any way. I think that that brick that we used, because it's such a small quantity and it's a small relatively a small building, it's a more expensive brick than the cheapest. The developer, the builder, is often looking for the least expensive.
But in this case, the difference in the cost between a better brick and a simple brick was minimal. So, we went with a more fashionable, more stylish brick that you see in other buildings around town on a taller and more higher end buildings. In fact, we use this brick in other buildings, we like this building. There's sort of a little laboratory for us to explore other ideas.
00;16;14;18 - 00;16;18;15
DP
How was it working with the mason in the field? Did you guys do mockups?
00;16;18;17 - 00;16;46;21
DG
We did mockups. I think that Ingrid, she got the guys to do what she wanted. You know, so much of the world is about how do you get the other person to hear you and how do you get the other person to do what you want? And certainly, the architect has no literal power. They have the power of persuasion. And I think we worked closely with the developer and the contractors to persuade them to help us achieve our visual goals.
00;16;46;23 - 00;17;03;03
DP
Yeah, clearly. We're talking a little bit about design challenges here and we're talking about how you manipulated the bricks in various ways to create a facade that looks more appealing. Did brick solve any design challenges for you guys?
00;17;03;05 - 00;18;18;19
DG
I mean, brick has been a success since, you know, the Egyptians. Brick has been a success since the Neanderthals almost. But brick gives you a tremendously good thermal rating in New York. Any building that is built with public money or public support has to achieve a very high green rating. It's basically a LEED rating. 20 years ago, 15 years ago, everything was LEED. It had to be rated.
Well, the New York City green enterprise standards are fundamentally a LEED goal. So, we had to achieve that. We have to do an energy certification at the end and brick is just a tremendously flexible material for that. If you use a metal panel, which is much more expensive or a terracotta panel, it isn't necessarily any more energy efficient than brick.
So, brick helps with that because it's a small unit, it's flexible. So, if you run into a funky dimension in the space between your building and the property line in the adjacent building, it's easy to manipulate. And you can work with it on the site and the guy who's laying it can work with it for you.
00;18;08;22 - 00;18;24;20
DP
I don't know a whole lot about building in New York City. Talk a little bit about how long was the planning process for the building. How long did the review, the City Review take? How long was the design process? Construction process start to finish?
00;18;24;22 - 00;19;14;29
DG
That's a good question. It takes about 9 to 10 months to design a building from start to finish. In the middle of that process, you file the drawings about five months in with the city of New York. It takes four months plus to get the drawings approved. As they are reviewing the plans and asking for more information, you're working on the plans and filling in the information. So, the filing process and the production process, the design process are running in tandem. They're running concurrently.
Then there's another 2 to 3 months for the project to have the site prepared, demolition to take place, SOE which is a Support of Excavation process, you have to support the site as it's being excavated. And then I would say a building like this takes about 18 months to build.
00;19;15;06 - 00;19;16;10
DP
Park or Elton?
00;19;16;17 - 00;19;40;10
DG
They were both built simultaneously. They weren't built one and then the other built at the same time. So, when they did the foundation on one, they were doing the foundation on the other. The concrete sub was at both sides at the same time. The brick was done at the same time. These are simple load bearing buildings where it's a block backup to a brick facade and concrete floors and load bearing concrete walls.
00;19;40;15 - 00;19;41;14
DP
No steel?
00;19;41;15 - 00;19;44;14
DG
A miscellaneous steel over the windows. Miscellaneous steel at the corners.
00;19;44;20 - 00;19;45;24
DP
Just steel lintels and-
00;19;45;27 - 00;19;59;28
DG
Yeah, not too much steel. The spans are that long. And if you look at the building without the details, the masonry is about 35% of the width of the windows. So that's a very short span.
00;20;00;03 - 00;20;01;24
DP
What about ARB?
00;20;01;26 - 00;20;50;22
DG
There is no ARB in New York City. You can build a 100-storey building and – city planning, if you need any kind of variance, or you have a zoning issue, city planning acts as the architectural arbiter of the project. But if it's a simple project like this, an as-of-right project, you would be smart to show it to a community board because the community boards, you know, that's the smallest governmental association in the city and it's really the local people who are on a community board. Obviously, it's the people that really care. And you want the community board to be a part of your process. So, the developer will meet with the community board quietly, keep it friendly. And a project like this, I don't think there was any opposition whatsoever.
00;20;50;22 - 00;20;55;23
DP
And you do that - you wrap up schematic design, then you meet with people that are local.
00;20;56;00 - 00;21;20;03
DG
Exactly. To gain support because the last thing you want is opposition. I've worked in other cities and the great thing about New York is there are hurdles in front of you, many hurdles, but they're above ground. It's not like a game, you know, a video game where the hurdles come at you as you're running. You see them in front of you. The rules are transparent, and you can work the system.
00;21;20;06 - 00;21;26;14
DP
And when you guys present, do you present three dimensional images that you put together, Revit or-
00;21;26;14 - 00;21;47;22
DG
Revit. We do all of our work on three-dimensional building information modeling. Now, we don't use any CAD. Our staff is really talented and expert at BIM, and that means that when they're drawing, the very first line is a wall, not a line. And this three dimensionals are right there. And we have some very talented renderers.
00;21;47;25 - 00;21;53;12
DP
I’m sure. So, did you guys learn anything through the process of designing and getting these buildings built?
00;21;53;14 - 00;22;21;04
DG
The architecture is a very slow-paced world. If there's a crisis, you're not doing it right. There really shouldn't be any crises. Maybe when you're young and you forgot the most fundamental thing, there’s a crisis. But at this point, I would say that these buildings were inspirational for me because the four of us, the team, we were engaged all the way through, and we kept looking at it. It was a small project, and it was exciting in that way.
00;22;21;07 - 00;22;24;20
DP
I'll wrap it up with an easier question – maybe a harder question.
00;22;24;24 - 00;22;25;29
DG
Throw them at me. Come on.
00;22;26;05 - 00;22;29;05
DP
You clearly have a lot of experience being an architect-
00;22;29;29 - 00;22;32;13
DG
I didn't start out with gray hair. I've earned-
00;22;32;20 - 00;22;35;11
DP
I had hair.
00;22;32;20 - 00;22;37;12
DG
Exactly. Sure, you have hair.
00;22;37;15 - 00;22;45;25
DP
So, if you had to look back and give your younger self advice that you didn't know back then. What would it be, about being an architect.
00;22;45;27 - 00;23;24;22
DG
That's a great question. It reminds me of something I was thinking about on the way over here in preparation for today's chat. I think in any profession - medical, legal - your user group, your client is turned off to jargon. You can't speak with technical terms or only terms that another architect would recognize. So, I try very hard to be plainspoken and put things in terms of the benefit of the client and I think that that is something that I'm good at and people respond to that because the goal is to have a dialog with your client. And I think that's the best way.
00;23;24;29 - 00;23;44;05
DP
You know, interestingly, growing up, you must have seen how important that was with your father and his business. Having a good relationship, being a good communicator, being positive, never telling somebody no. Yeah, we can look at that. Let's give it a shot. So, it would seem to me that you learned an awful lot from your folks.
00;23;44;13 - 00;23;44;27
DG
I did.
00;23;45;04 - 00;23;49;24
DP
Well, David, it's been great to have you here. Thank you very much for your time. Where can people go to learn more about GF55?
00;23;49;26 - 00;24;00;02
DG
www.gf55.com or check out our Instagram page or our Twitter feed for all the stuff about us.
00;24;00;03 - 00;24;03;12
DP
All right, pretty straightforward. Well, thank you very much for your time. It's great to meet you.
00;24;03;19 - 00;24;05;11
DG
You too. I'm sure I'll see you soon.
00;24;05;12 - 00;24;09;01
DP
Right on.
You May Also Be Interested In
We Can Help With Your Next Project
Discover the latest + greatest in design trends, industry news & pro tips from pros.
For all of your project needs, you’ll find everything you need at a Supply Center.
Let Us Know How We Can Help!
Design Vault Ep. 6 Guildford Court with Peter VanderPoel
ABOUT THE ARCHITECT:
![]()
|
Peter VanderPoel is a practicing architect licensed in Maryland, Washington DC and Virginia. His practice focuses on residential and small commercial projects in and around Washington DC. He received a Bachelor of Architecture from the University of Kansas and a Master of Architecture from Virginia Tech and is a Certified Passive House Consultant. He has taught architecture at the university level for over 10 years and is current an Adjunct Professor at Virginia Tech's Washington Alexandria Architecture Center (WAAC) in Alexandria, Virginia. |
---|
ABOUT THE PROJECT:
The Guildford Court project was an opportunity to build a luxury home in a suburban area of McLean, Virginia. The demands of the site were the driver of the design. The lost is similar to the state of Georgia, both in shape and orientation, and is located on a cul-de-sac with a very narrow street frontage. The property lines that extended back from the street describe an angle of approximately 60 degrees. The lot if very steep, rising 20' as it extends back from the street to the northwest. "I find the best architectural solutions as ones that respond and accommodate external forces, rather than ignoring or fighting them" - Peter VanderPoel.
The 60 degree angle drawn by the property lines suggested three axes might be used, as a hexagon is defined by three axes to enclose its shape. The program called for three major components: automobile access and garage, semi-public (formal and casual entertaining) and private. Moving cars across the site and garaging them is naturally limited by a cars ability; climbing steep hills and parking on steeply sloped surfaces is undesirable. The south side of the site is the lowest area with a minimal slope running from east to west. This proved most desirable for moving cars on and off the site. Placing the garage block here would also provide some privacy for the interior portion of the lot. These axes allowed for programmatic elements to respond to one of the three axes, depending on needs and relationships. The street frontage is similar to Georgia's Atlantic coast; relatively narrow and near the south side of the property. The semi-public portion of the program is located here with an area for an office near the front entrance, beneath the private block and the family functions in the main, brick clad block. The private portion of the program was placed on the east side of the property raised up to meet the high end of the site, resting on the semi-private block. Stairs provided the hinge on which to turn these three block through their 120 degrees rotate with the semi-public and private stairs expressed as a grand, sculptural stair with a large skylight about. The splayed organization allowed for a natural courtyard scheme with the south and east side screened by the house itself and the trees and slope at the north and west to screen those views. The privacy afforded by this arrangement was leveraged by inclusion of a pool in this area. A series of terraced retaining walls, reliant on the same 3 axis grid, sculpted the steep portion of the site and carved out the level area for placement of the pool.
Guildford Court
Peter VanderPoel Architects
Read Case StudyTRANSCRIPT
00;00;00;00 - 00;00;05;13
Doug Patt (DP)
Let's go inside the vault. The design vault.
00;00;05;15 - 00;00;30;15
Peter Vanderpoel (PV)
Even though it wasn't important at the moment, but with COVID, the idea of having a prominent place or office in the house also came to the fore during the design process, three car garage, the expectation of a pool, some sort of flattened area for a deck around that pool, and then we've got the very steep hill in the back that turned into this terrace for someone could lay out there and get sun. It's fairly private there in the center of that spot.
00;00;30;17 - 00;02;15;21
DP
This is my guest, Peter Vanderpoel. I'll share more about him shortly. In this episode from The Design Vault, we’ll highlight Peter's project, Guilford Court. Guilford Court is a luxury home in a suburban area of McLean, Virginia. The lot is angular and located on a cul-de-sac with narrow street frontage. It's also quite steep, rising 20 feet as it extends back from the street.
Peter uses three separate virtual axes to inform the floor plan and programmatic organization of the house. The garage, located on the south side of the property, is clad in wood, while the private portion of the house, which resembles a kind of modern Tudor facade, is enclosed in fiber cement siding. The middle semipublic spaces are enclosed in a dark brick veneer.
The landscape also reflects the same three axis grid with sculpted geometry that level out the site.
Hi, I'm Doug Pat and this is Design Vault.
Today we're talking to Peter Vanderpoel, registered architect of Vanderpoel Architecture. Peter is a practicing architect, licensed in Maryland, Washington, D.C., and Virginia. His practice focuses on residential and small commercial projects in and around Washington, D.C. He received a Bachelor of Architecture from the University of Kansas and a Master of Architecture from Virginia Tech.
He's a certified Passive House consultant and has taught architecture at the university level for over ten years. He's currently an adjunct professor at Virginia Tech's Washington Alexandria Architecture Center, located in Alexandria, Virginia. So, let's get into the details. Welcome, Peter.
00;02;15;26 - 00;02;16;14
PV
Thank you.
00;02;16;16 - 00;02;27;21
DP
Thank you very much for being here. So first, tell us a little bit about Peter Vanderpoel architecture. Where you guys located? What type of projects do you take? And what have you been working on lately?
00;02;27;23 - 00;02;55;18
PV
The practice is located in Arlington, Virginia. If you're from the area, it's not far from the courthouse metro. Arlington used to be part of DC before receded back to Virginia a few hundred years ago. So we're right near downtown D.C. The practice is mostly residential and some small commercial projects. I'm trying to expand some of the commercial portfolio just to have a better balance in the marketplace. But I've been practicing - I've been on my own now for about 20 years now.
00;02;55;20 - 00;03;02;01
DP
Wow. So, tell me a little bit about the office. So how many people do you have working with you? Is that pretty consistent?
00;03;02;08 - 00;03;27;04
PV
So, the studio is in the backyard of my house, but it is off grid, so I have solar panels to run it and huge battery and a room in the back. It's not a passive house quality in terms of the exterior envelope, but it sort of leans those ways in response to the site. But it's very small. It's not much bigger than a garage. And I have two employees there, one full time, one part time. We can spend most of our day in there in a pretty comfortable fashion.
00;03;27;06 - 00;03;34;18
DP
That's pretty cool. Let's dig into that a little bit. So when did you decide to have an office or a building on your property that was off grid?
00;03;34;20 - 00;04;16;26
PV
Well, we used to have a garage. It was doing self-demolition over time. It used to be – it was not a Sears and Roebuck house, but it was a kit house from the 1980s. Yeah. And I forget the name of the company that made it. And it was one story. So, when my wife originally bought the house and then when our first child came, we decided to add the second floor.
And then I was working in the basement for a long time. But as the practice progressed, decided that I needed extra space. So, we finished off the demolition where the garage was essentially put it in the same location. But it's a story and a half. There's one floor and then there's a mezzanine above. Both my wife and I paint and so we have a couple easels up there on that second level. But the lower floor is all architecture.
00;04;17;03 - 00;04;19;19
DP
That's so cool. How long has your office been there then?
00;04;19;21 - 00;04;28;19
PV
Physically, for about five years. I started doing my own residential work in about 2001 when I was in graduate school, evenings and weekends.
00;04;28;22 - 00;04;31;16
DP
So, your first client, was that somebody you knew?
00;04;31;18 - 00;04;52;05
PV
No. It's a woman and I – she had a house not too far away, and she wanted to make it more energy efficient. So, we worked on that together. It went very well. And she decided that she wanted to do a more robust project. She bought the house across the street from her. Kind of a long, interesting story that goes with that. But then we built a new house for her and that was sort of my first big project.
00;04;52;12 - 00;04;57;02
DP
So, have you always been interested in energy efficiency in architecture and building?
00;04;57;08 - 00;05;29;16
PV
No, to be honest, it doesn't come up as often as you'd think and conversations with clients. But it's something that I'm trying to push now. As a passive house consultant, I can see the value of it, and it's not that difficult to get to. That's kind of fussy when it comes to construction, but in terms of the cost, it's making a much better envelope.
The tail on idea is that the mechanical systems, they don't need to be that special because you're not using them that much. The idea is not to be clever about producing energy, it’s to avoid using it in the first place. So, keep what you have.
00;05;29;18 - 00;05;34;26
DP
So, is it gotten less expensive over the last five or ten years to do energy efficient homes?
00;05;35;02 - 00;05;38;16
PV
I don't think so, because all of the construction costs have gone up after COVID.
00;05;38;22 - 00;05;39;10
DP
Oh wow, interesting.
00;05;39;10 - 00;05;54;11
PV
Everything associated with construction is – most of its up. Some things are starting to come down now. There are some materials that sort of lend towards that or lean towards the passive house and they're expensive like everything else. So, I don't think so.
00;05;54;18 - 00;06;02;28
DP
Interesting. Well, I’d love to talk more about that, but we're here to talk about Guilford Court. So, let's dig in here. How did you guys get the project? How did you get Guilford Court?
00;06;03;05 - 00;06;25;10
PV
I used to belong to a business networking group, and it was there that a friend of mine who was an insurance agent had met somebody who did construction. He wanted to do some projects and I went and had coffee with him one time, and then he had some backers who wanted to do a luxury home, and they found a lot in McLean. So he gave me the call and then we got started on the project from there. So, it was through business networking.
00;06;25;13 - 00;06;40;08
DP
Okay, so you didn't know the clients initially. Interesting. So, let's talk a little bit about the site. Tell me a little bit about the architecture around the site and I guess I should ask, was there a house on the site before you guys got there?
00;06;40;14 - 00;07;13;14
PV
Yes, there was. So, most of the houses there on that cul-de-sac were built, I would think in the seventies, the split-level brick. And over time – so when I first saw the site, all the houses on the cul-de-sac were like that. And during the design and construction process, I think at least two of them now have been torn down and rebuilt. There are a lot of tear downs in Washington D.C. because a lot of people come into the neighborhood – Amazon and whatnot – so it's not too hard to sell a house in that area at this moment. The houses that were on the lots were McMansion. I mean, I want to say-
00;07;13;17 - 00;07;17;05
DP
Sure. So stylistically, colonial stuff?
00;07;17;07 - 00;07;37;24
PV
Yes, colonial, stucco, no modern leanings at that time. That was sort of just before things were starting to get modern in the general building industry in D.C. So, it was typical suburban, large suburban houses. McLean's a wealthy community, so they're large and very nice but kind of standard stuff.
00;07;38;00 - 00;07;44;19
DP
Sure. So, it was kind of goofy when your client was like, hey, I want to do something modern. You're thinking, oh boy-
00;07;44;21 - 00;07;47;09
PV
Oh no. That's what I want to hear! I mean, the nice thing is I-
00;07;47;09 - 00;07;58;01
DP
No, I meant for all the neighbors – potentially for the neighbors. Sure. Right in the back of their mind. Did they ever talk about that? Hey, do you think, you know, we're going to put something modern here? We're excited about that. We don't really care.
00;07;58;05 - 00;08;09;10
PV
I think there's enough new things in that market, and new neighbors and so on that it's not as tight as it might be in terms of styles. And I think that's okay.
00;08;09;13 - 00;08;11;00
DP
How long has the house been finished now?
00;08;11;06 - 00;08;12;18
PV
It's been a couple – three years.
00;08;12;19 - 00;08;15;08
DP
Okay. So, you would have heard by now through the clients?
00;08;15;15 - 00;08;17;20
PV
Yes.
00;08;17;22 - 00;08;26;01
DP
So, let's see, programmatic requirements. So, you guys had your first meeting and they said, this is what we want. What was that?
00;08;26;03 - 00;09;25;17
PV
Well, the program was fairly standard, in that, the expectation to be a family, a number of bedrooms, a studio – if there was an artist, that would be sort of back on the site, but even though it wasn't important at the moment, but with COVID, the idea of having a prominent place or an office in the house also came to the fore during the design process – three car garage, the expectation of a pool, some sort of flattened area for a deck around that pool, and then we've got this very steep hill in the back that turned into this terrace for someone could lay out there and get sun. It's fairly private there in the center of that spot. So, in terms of the programmatic elements, they were more luxurious than some, but nothing out of the ordinary.
And then it was mostly dealing with the site that I think the interest started to come into the project because the first time I saw it, there was a house on there. We went out the back door and I went, ‘Oh my.’ In school you always go, ‘Oh, this will be challenging,’ but then in real life it's like, ‘oh, how are we going to do this?’
00;09;25;19 - 00;09;36;00
DP
So, did they talk about square footage in the beginning too? We want a house that's going to be 5,400 square feet, 3,000 square feet, 8,000. They have an idea because of square foot costs. Did they think about the house-
00;09;36;00 - 00;09;45;23
PV
No. As it was built – so, the contractor made some changes as the project was built. So, there was square footage added between permit and occupancy.
00;09;46;01 - 00;09;47;28
DP
You can do that? Don't you have to re permit?
00;09;48;03 - 00;09;56;08
PV
Different jurisdictions. Like they don't have an FAR in McLean. That's Fairfax County. Alexandria does and it's a-
00;09;56;09 - 00;09;59;09
DP
Yeah, I know. I deal with FAR like, it never ends.
00;09;59;09 - 00;09;59;19
PV
Yeah.
00;09;59;23 - 00;10;05;28
DP
And then you start thinking about renovating the basement and then FAR comes back in and you're working on the house and it's crazy.
00;10;06;01 - 00;10;08;29
PV
Yeah, it's just lot coverage there, and that's never a problem.
00;10;08;29 - 00;10;10;27
DP
Okay. What size is the house?
00;10;11;01 - 00;10;13;03
PV
I think it's 7,000.
00;10;13;03 - 00;10;29;18
DP
Okay, so let's talk a little bit about the building design. So, we already discussed the fact that you've got a site with some challenging topography. Talk a little bit about the unique geometry or the geometries that were generated based on what's physically out there.
00;10;29;18 - 00;12;18;03
PV
So, the lot as it looks in plan, in the site plan, it kind of looks like the state of Georgia and the Atlantic coast of Georgia, which just a little bit to the northeast of Florida is what's on the cul-de-sac. So, there's a very small entrance circle for the cul-de-sac, very small entrance onto the site, and then very steep as it goes up in the back.
And then these two angles that almost describe 60 degrees from the two property lines that go away from the cul-de-sac. And so, my first inclination was, well, that's almost 60 degrees. And so, a hexagonal plan would work on a plot like that. So, then I started looking at precedents for that. I know Frank Lloyd Wright had done the Hanna house in California that was based on the hexagon. He had done a whole series of projects based on geometry. So, I had looked at those, but it was through that less hexagonal forms and more towards three axes rather than we normally think of two axes that X and Y. But this now has these 120-degree rotation that with a hexagon you have three axes that are involved in describing that geometry and that was essentially the same geometry we had on that site. So that became the basis for the design.
And there were three geometries. We've got three programmatic elements of getting the cars on and off the semipublic and then the private. And then we also have this dramatic rise in height. So, we could also do the same thing vertically. We had the garage at the lowest level so the cars can get on easily. The semipublic now faces the street on this very narrow frontage and then the private is up highest and essentially resting on top of the semipublic block and runs back. But because the site is so steep, it touches ground. It's a grade at the back of the property, even though it's sitting on top of the lower level at the front.
00;12;18;06 - 00;12;35;05
DP
So, you did a lot of thinking about this project. The clients must really love that. I mean, you sit down with them, and you start talking about these three axes and three levels, three buildings, three heights, you know, the whole thing up there must have been like, “wow, man, this is really cool. This guy knows what he's doing.”
00;12;35;07 - 00;13;15;20
PV
You had mentioned that I teach, and one of the things that I find the easiest way to engage with clients is to talk about ideas rather than just areas and square footage costs, because everybody wants to be on board with that because thinking is the fun part of the design. The best compliment I get is somebody says, I never thought of that. I feel like, well, so I'm bringing value to this.
I have proposed several different designs. I think I had three different options. I had pinned them all up in the office and had wine and cheese for some people come in and just talk about it, and the design that is there right now was not my first choice. But then someone had said, “well, you know, this has all these things going on with these three axes.” And then it was like, ‘yeah, I think that is the best one.’
00;13;15;26 - 00;13;18;12
DP
When you're talking about people, is that the clients or other people?
00;13;18;12 - 00;13;20;18
PV
No, no. Other people in the office.
00;13;20;21 - 00;13;27;19
DP
Oh, that’s so great. So, you had a kind of design charrette in the office. Everybody's looking at it. You stand back and you kind of go through all the design options.
00;13;27;26 - 00;13;36;09
PV
And then the same thing will happen with the client. This was a speculative house, so it wasn't dealing with the final client, with the person who's going to move into the house.
00;13;36;11 - 00;13;42;15
DP
Oh, it was a spec house. Interesting.
So, local zoning codes and issues there.
00;13;42;18 - 00;14;08;29
PV
Fairfax County isn't that onerous. The usual, there's lot coverage. There's no aesthetic review. They do have those in Georgetown, in D.C., and in Old Town, in Alexandria, Virginia. But most of the other jurisdictions don't have an aesthetic review. And so, we didn't have to worry about that. The FAR, which happens in Alexandria, but not in Fairfax, we didn't have that. It's just lot coverage. It's rarely a problem.
00;14;09;02 - 00;14;10;25
DP
There wasn't anything too challenging.
00;14;10;28 - 00;14;11;17
PV
No.
00;14;11;19 - 00;14;12;15
DP
And building codes, IRC?
00;14;13;11 - 00;14;19;18
PV
Yeah, well, it's - Virginia has a uniform state building code, which is based on the IRC, and they have a couple of tweaks in there. But yeah.
00;14;19;24 - 00;14;26;27
DP
Right. Of course, they do. So, describe the building plan for us. What did you end up with?
00;14;27;00 - 00;16;50;09
PV
Well, one is getting the cars on and off the lot. They can't – just the nature of cars – they can't be going up and down hill. So, we need to get them on the shortest route and the lowest route so that if you think about the site as a state of Georgia, the Florida borderline was where the cars came in. The semipublic faced the cul-de-sac. It addressed through there and then we had stairs going up this series of stones, because one of the concerns was that's a long way up to get to that first floor just because it's so steep. So, we have these stones on the site that are shifted. So, you're sort of walking across these lily pads and then a diagonal that goes up and then a set of stairs. So, there's a variety of experiences moving towards the front of the house.
We also had the office portion and that was right inside the front door. So, if someone in the house decides to set up office there, they have a client come by. They don't have to go into the main house just in and out the front door, take care of business.
And then from there, a few more steps go into the main house. So that opens up in a very large open space. There's the fireplace, dining, living, kitchen are all in that area. And then behind the kitchen is sort of the pool deck area for showers and changing and so on. And then there's a large circular stair that's the pin.
So, if you think about the semipublic and the private, they splay out at 120 degrees and the stairway is the pin that holds us together to do that rotation. So, there's a very large grand sculptural stair up to the second level, and it comes up between the master bedroom and the additional bedrooms so that when you move towards the cul-de-sac, you're now in the master bedroom suite that is like this big diving board looking over. It's a tremendous site of this that was very challenging. But being in that master bedroom and looking out over the trees, away from the site, it's a dramatic view. Going the other direction, there are the other bedrooms, as I said, eventually gets back to grade because it gets so steep in the back. And then there's also the stair continues down.
So, there's a family room in the basement, a large television there as well. And then on the other end, we have that same rotation with the garage, and that's a much more modest stair coming from the garage into that living space. But it's based on those three axes and those two hinges to turn it on to the site, both in plan and in section.
00;16;50;15 - 00;17;00;28
DP
Yeah, that's really cool. So, tell us a little bit about the building materials. We’ve already discussed the house is modern and you use a series of different materials for the house.
00;17;01;01 - 00;17;31;29
PV
Right. There's fiber cement boards for the bedroom space and then the semipublic was a brick, and then the garage was - I think there's a wood on there. So, we have a couple of different faces. There's a brick facade for the semipublic. I think there's some brick as well on the garage. And we also brought some of the brick inside in the living spaces. We wanted to have a variety of materials to represent because everything's now being divided into threes with the garage, semipublic, private spaces.
00;17;32;01 - 00;17;38;19
DP
So, tell me a little bit about why you guys chose to use brick and in particular the dark brick.
00;17;38;22 - 00;17;55;25
PV
The dark brick. That was not my selection. I did not select the colors on that element, but it would also be contrasting. You could see the dramatic change in color because as I said, it's about these three elements and so they read differently everywhere you cut it.
00;17;56;00 - 00;18;02;21
DP
And it would seem to me that you chose to use brick as a differentiated design element, right?
00;18;02;23 - 00;18;13;08
PV
Right. It's also very common in this part of the country. In Old Town, Virginia, and just all up and down the East Coast, brick was the way to do durable construction and still is.
00;18;13;10 - 00;18;17;13
DP
Are there any houses around this one – are masonry as well?
00;18;17;17 - 00;18;36;11
PV
Yes. So, the houses that were there in the neighboring lots, most of them were split level with a lower with brick on the first floor and siding on the second floor. The houses that have come in their place, the two I can think of are stucco, but there's a lot of brick in the neighborhood.
00;18;36;14 - 00;18;53;12
DP
So, this is, as we discussed, it's contemporary. I wanted to talk a little bit about the unique construction details. I'm looking at these two facades that come together at the corner, and we've got two completely different building materials. That must have been a challenging detail. And you got a window, you got a corner window there. So how did you guys do that?
00;18;53;20 - 00;19;59;16
PV
There's steel in there to handle that opening on the corner. The reason why that angle is the way it is – something else that we hadn't discussed is that I used to play the drums, and still do. And for a long time, I used to play actually, in a bagpipe band. More sophisticated than you think – but, so, rhythms is something that I've been dealing with since I was ten years old.
And one thing that came up is what called polyrhythms, where you have overlaying rhythms. You take two rhythms that may not be so interesting on their own, but when they're overlaid with each other, then it creates something more interesting than either of them were to begin with. And that's how I view this project that this overlay, the reason why that window angle is there on the corner is because the geometry of the private portion has been thrust through the semipublic and so there's an angle that goes through. The chimney was rotated along that as well, and the contractor turned that back. But it was that slot that pushed through that mirrors the same access that the private portion is on.
00;19;59;19 - 00;20;05;03
DP
Is the chimney also masonry? And that's supported by steel. Doesn't run straight through the building.
00;20;05;06 - 00;20;07;19
PV
Right. There are portions of it that are supported with steel.
00;20;07;19 - 00;20;11;06
DP
Did you guys end up using any brick on the interior?
00;20;11;08 - 00;20;29;24
PV
Well, there is you can see it on the lower portion there. There's brick for the fireplace surround, which is in the lower left photograph there.
And there were also two trees on the site where we ended up pulling those up, but the contractor had those milled and use them for the trim. The wood that's above the fireplace there is from those trees.
00;20;30;00 - 00;20;31;13
DP
Do you remember the species?
00;20;31;15 - 00;20;34;16
PV
My recollection will be black locus, but I'm not sure.
00;20;34;18 - 00;20;47;06
DP
I was going to ask you what some of the historical precedents were for the for the architecture, but clearly were into much more modern architecture here. However, as you said, we see brick in the area.
00;20;47;08 - 00;20;52;08
PV
Yeah, there's brick. The material is common in Northern Virginia. The building forms.
00;20;52;15 - 00;20;54;02
DP
Yeah. I was going to say we've got gables here.
00;20;54;02 - 00;21;01;21
PV
Yeah, that's pretty common as well. So, the basis of it is traditional, but the implementation has become modern.
00;21;01;24 - 00;21;12;26
DP
And tell me a little bit, what I call this modern Tudor aesthetic. Where did that come from? And I know it's not modern Tudor but describe that for our listeners.
00;21;12;28 - 00;21;22;15
PV
So, from this view, the division of the fiber cement is accomplished with these vertical elements that come proud of the exterior finish.
00;21;22;18 - 00;21;28;16
DP
Okay, so they're not set back into the fiber cement. They're actually proud. So, it's applied.
00;21;28;18 - 00;21;44;00
PV
Yeah. And so that could be considered a reference. It was not the intention, but the half timbers that was common with timber houses would use expressed wood materials and then with stucco in between those and then the angles for the roofs are fairly standard.
00;21;44;05 - 00;21;44;24
DP
Are those 12:12’s?
00;21;45;07 - 00;21;51;25
PV
Tudor style, yes, they are. The contractor ended up putting living space up there as well. So, you made good use of that space.
00;21;51;25 - 00;21;59;28
DP
Oh, of course, that's great. And you had no issues with having a third or fourth story there, right? So, were there any height restrictions on the site?
00;22;00;04 - 00;22;06;12
PV
There are, but Fairfax County, you add up, it's an average the way it was in the back. We were okay on the front.
00;22;06;13 - 00;22;10;19
DP
Right. You said the third story, which was the basement was set down into the site.
00;22;10;22 - 00;22;18;04
PV
Yeah. You can see it on the left, the lower right image there you can see the window for the basement below that large corner window.
00;22;18;08 - 00;22;23;25
DP
So, did you learn anything new about brick dealing with these details, even with this cantilever?
00;22;23;27 - 00;22;37;29
PV
Well, no, it's just with steel implemented in there, it's fairly common. If you go through D.C., the urban renewal period of Georgetown in the seventies and eighties, there’s brick everywhere. And so, everybody knows how to work with brick in D.C.
00;22;38;03 - 00;22;55;19
DP
Well, it's clear it solved a design issue for you guys because you were looking for a series of materials that all went together, and I love the color. It goes so well with everything else. It really just works. I think it looks great. Now, who did the drawings for the job and did you do them in 2D and 3D, 3D, BIM?
00;22;56;11 - 00;23;14;28
PV
No. Well, we did a sketch up model. I was renting some space with the firm down, and Alexander at the time had a woman helping me out to do most of the construction documents in AutoCAD. And then we had the sketch up models for presentation just to talk about the design. There was originally, that's when I used to draw with my hands. I used to do it on sketch paper.
00;23;15;04 - 00;23;33;05
DP
You and me both. It's so great. I got so lucky, I worked in an office in Baltimore, and they got so slow that they trained me on CAD. This was 97, 98. Thank God. I would have been completely unemployable for the rest of my life had I not learned how to draw and, you know, how to use sketch up, which is great.
00;23;33;05 - 00;23;39;09
PV
Well, yes, I do. When I started though, we had a product called GDS, and it was McDonnell Douglas.
00;23;39;11 - 00;23;42;03
DP
Okay, So airplane software. You’ve gotta be kidding me. That’s great.
00;23;42;03 - 00;23;49;24
PV
It was their software. And there was a manual that was about two inches thick. And yeah, once you read it, you were fine, but it wasn't that friendly.
00;23;50;01 - 00;23;54;10
DP
Oh my gosh. So, sustainability and this house.
00;23;54;12 - 00;23;55;07
PV
Not a concern.
00;23;55;12 - 00;24;01;03
DP
Not an issue with the GC? Just wasn't something that you were going to push as part of the design build aspect of the house.
00;24;01;16 - 00;24;03;15
PV
No, that wasn't a concern for this project.
00;24;03;16 - 00;24;08;03
DP
No, I get it. I always ask all our guests; did you have any trouble finding a good mason?
00;24;08;05 - 00;24;11;22
PV
They're easy to find in Alexandria. If you see – I tell you what-
00;24;11;22 - 00;24;12;25
DP
Right. There’s so much brick in Washington.
00;24;12;27 - 00;24;26;16
PV
There's one project I can think of where they didn't get a good mason. I was down in Key West one time and they said, “you know, Hemingway did this wall.” And I said, ‘it looks like a drunk author did it.’
00;24;26;19 - 00;24;33;03
DP
That’s great. Oh, my gosh. So, before you go, I'd like to ask people, what's your favorite part about being an architect?
00;24;33;06 - 00;25;18;21
PV
It's in two phases right now. So, I used to teach full time. When I was teaching full time, I would say, I'm not making anything and I'm - that's what I'm trained to do. When I'm making things, often times I'll say, but this isn't about ideas. And so right now, the balance between those two is very gratifying. And being able to talk about ideas, which I like to think, is one of the benefits that I have in the office, because we'll talk about this stuff. I think everybody's more energized when that happens.
So, it's the camaraderie of the office. I know a lot of people are doing the remote work. We're in place and the studio. It's a fun place to be. The schematic design is my favorite part. You know, when I get close to retirement, everything else is going to go to somebody else.
00;25;18;21 - 00;25;19;02
DP
Oh, that's great.
00;25;19;10 - 00;25;21;19
PV
But I continue doing the schematic design.
00;25;21;21 - 00;25;27;13
DP
Yeah. So, I was going to ask you, what's the one thing you like least about being an architect? And it's probably all the other stuff.
00;25;27;13 - 00;25;32;03
PV
Site surveys. Yeah.
00;25;32;05 - 00;25;34;29
DP
You don't mean like existing condition stuff.
00;25;35;05 - 00;25;36;25
PV
Yeah, I haven't done that. We’re small enough, I’m not still doing that.
00;25;36;25 - 00;25;52;05
DP
It’d drive you nuts. Yeah, I get it, man. I've done many at home. Peter, you talked a little bit about Frank Lloyd Wright. Are there any architects that are usually in the back of your mind when you're designing that you really admire their work?
00;25;52;08 -00;26;35;17
PV
It more has to do with admiring the ideas because that's an inexhaustible font of information, whereas the projects they've done, they're done it does these certain things, but they're ideas that live inside of there that can apply to whatever project. So, depending on materials, depending on geometry, depending on what the site is telling me, that will determine then who I'll look to for references.
Like, for instance, as I mentioned, Frank Lloyd Wright did a series of houses based on a simple geometry that grew from one element that expanded. Corbusier, there was a lot of ideas in how he dealt with space, sort of the modern aesthetic, but it wasn't so much just this look. It had to do with accomplishing something he wanted to do intellectually.
00;26;35;20 - 00;26;41;29
DP
Yeah. Interestingly, Wright used brick in some of his work. Pretty effectively.
00;26;42;07 - 00;26;43;13
PV
Indian red.
00;26;43;15 - 00;26;52;26
DP
Yeah. Indian red. Well, Peter Vanderpoel, it was very nice to meet you today. Could you tell me how we can find out more about you and your architectural firm?
00;26;53;02 - 00;27;04;12
PV
Well, I have a website pvanderpoel.com P-V-A-N-D-E-R-P-O-E-L dot com. That has some samples of my work. And other than that, I'm pretty quiet.
00;27;04;14 - 00;27;07;00
DP
Well, great. The house is beautiful. Congratulations.
00;27;07;00 - 00;27;07;09
PV
Thank you.
00;27;07;16 - 00;27;09;13
DP
I'm sure it's been a big success.
00;27;09;15 - 00;27;13;22
PV
It's very gratifying to see that - to see ideas that happen.
00;27;13;24 - 00;27;15;18
DP
Yeah, I think it's the best part about being an architect.
00;27;15;18 - 00;27;18;14
PV
Marriage of the two things – having an idea that actually gets built.
00;27;18;21 - 00;27;45;25
DP
Yeah, that's great. Congratulations.
You May Also Be Interested In
We Can Help With Your Next Project
Discover the latest + greatest in design trends, industry news & pro tips from pros.
For all of your project needs, you’ll find everything you need at a Supply Center.
Let Us Know How We Can Help!
Design Vault Ep. 7 Henhawk House with Sussan Lari
ABOUT THE ARCHITECT:
![]()
|
As a graduate of the University of Tehran's School of Architecture in her native Iran, Sussan Lari continued her studies in America by completing two master's degrees in architecture and planning from the University of Pennsylvania. She began her professional career with the Eggers Group P.C., Architects, Planners, Interior Designers, where she was the first woman to be named Vice President and stayed with them for 13 years.
After giving birth to her daughter, Sussan founded her own firm - Sussan Lari Architect PC - in 1992, jumpstarting the new company with corporate interior architecture projects in Manhattan. In time, Sussan's interest evolved and today Sussan Lari Architect is a full-service boutique architectural and design build firm that crafts custom residential and commercial architecture in the greater tri-state area. This change of direction brought about a change of personnel; a new team of well-trained, devoted, and detail-oriented collaborators capable of handling the required creative and technical challenges. Sussan was elected President of the Long Island Chapter of the AIA for the year 2000, and her firm is an ongoing member.
Sussan Lari Architect aims to design and help build functional, comfortable, and beautifully designed spaces for modern living. The firm prides themselves on maintaining a mindful collaboration with all their clients, while also accomplishing their goals within budget and on schedule. By implementing a multidisciplinary approach, every project encompasses the entire spectrum of design and the construction process. Through meticulous attention to detail and passion for creative design solutions, their work is a unique reflection of each client's needs. This year, Sussan is celebration the 30-year anniversary of Sussan Lari Architect PC. |
---|
ABOUT THE PROJECT:
This project was a gut renovation and major expansion of an existing residence. The existing structure was approximately 4,100 square feet of a Tudor style architecture. Sussan's client purchased the house mostly because of the size of the property and its location. What they ended up keeping was the dining room, as the client liked the architectural, plaster ceiling and its decorative elements. We also kept the living room and its fireplace with the brick chimney that stood tall above the roof. Everything else was eliminated including the cellars.
The new 13,300 square foot construction framed these two existing rooms and expanded in three directions. The revised second floor added height to the first floor, except for the dining room that remained with a lower ceiling height. This design outcome was a L-shaped structure with a multi-level first and second floor which added playfulness and provided much higher ceilings for most rooms in the house.
The gallery was maintained all along the first and second floors overlooking the internal garden where the pool is located. The house enjoys plenty of windows to bring in natural light and connect the inside to the outside. Although the house is a Tudor style design language on the outside with intricate brick design layering, stucco & wood paneling, the inside is completely open, expansive, bright, and modern.
An excellent combination for today's modern residences with a classical exterior and a delightfully modern interior.
Henhawk House
Sussan Lari Architect PC
View MoreTRANSCRIPT
00;00;00;03 - 00;00;05;13
Doug Patt (DP)
Let's go inside the vault. The design vault.
00;00;05;15 - 00;00;36;20
Sussan Lari (SL)
The idea become into doing a L-shape design, and because it was kind of long L-shape, it gave me the opportunity to create the design as there are certain components of structures together with the playfulness of the roof, which is important for Tudor style and also different height and introduction of stucco and introduction of wood paneling, framing, stucco and brick.
00;00;36;23 - 00;02;42;08
DP
This is my guest, Sussan Lari. I'll share more about her shortly. In this episode from the Design Vault we’ll highlight Sussan's project, Henhawk House. This project was a renovation and major expansion of an existing 4,100 square foot residence. The new home is approximately 13,300 square feet.
The home features steeply pitched slate roofs, multiple gables of varying size, light red brick facades and half-timbered elevations with stucco infill and light gray wood. The homemade brick is highly detailed, with soldier, diagonal and herringbone coursing. The design also features tall, narrow windows, elliptical masonry archways and red copper gable finials, all of which reference early English domestic architecture and of course, the Tudor style. Although the exterior of the house is a traditional design language, the inside is completely open, functional, expansive, bright and modern.
Hi, I'm Doug Pat, and this is Design Vault.
Today we're talking to Sussan Lari, AIA. Sussan is a graduate of the University of Tehran School of Architecture in her native Iran. Sussan continued her studies in America with two master's degrees in architecture and planning from the University of Pennsylvania. She began her professional career with the Eggers group, P.C. in New York, where she was the first woman to be named vice president.
Sussan founded her own firm in 1992. Her businesses have full service, boutique, architectural and design build firm that crafts custom residential and commercial architecture in the greater tri state area. Sussan was elected president of the Long Island chapter of the American Institute of Architects for the year 2000, and her firm is an ongoing member. Sussan Lari, Architect, P.C. is celebrating their 30-year anniversary.
So, let's get into the details. Welcome, Sussan.
00;02;42;13 - 00;02;43;12
SL
Thank you.
00;02;43;14 - 00;02;51;15
DP
So, Susan, tell us a little bit about your firm. Where are you located? What's the size of the firm and what type of work do you typically do?
00;02;51;21 - 00;03;43;22
SL
My firm, located in Village of Rosslyn in Long Island. It's about half an hour drive from Manhattan, is on the north shore of Long Island, Nassau County. The space that we occupy is a very old building that was built in 1796. And we actually are the very first tenant of that upper portion of the building. The building was used mostly for offices, for timber construction. And it's a landmark building.
The owner of the building eventually was changed and turned into medical offices on the lower level. And then the upper portion was like an office space and a magnificent space in the attic that has never been used.
00;03;43;25 - 00;03;47;25
DP
And the space worked out in terms of your size and number of people you have.
00;03;48;00 - 00;05;05;05
SL
You know, I always wanted to have a smaller firm. I am a bit of a control freak, a bit OCD with perfectionism. So fortunately, or unfortunately, applies to my projects as well. I need to be intimately involved in the entire process, not only design but also selection of material finishes, you know, detailing selection of the trades. So, I thought that we really wouldn't and shouldn't have many, many projects at once.
So, my intention has never been to have a very large office. So, we all kind of involve on purpose intimately with every single project going on in the office. I believe that if I get my staff involved in the life of the project, then they will be more interested to contribute and perform to their best ability and they’re all involved with the client. So, it's like we all together. The number of people working for me at this point are five. So, we are six of us altogether. And at this point and for a while actually majority of our concentration has been on residential projects.
00;05;05;07 - 00;05;09;03
DP
So, what is your role in the office? What are you involved with?
00;05;09;06 - 00;05;11;01
SL
I put so many different hats.
00;05;11;04 - 00;05;12;13
DP
I kind of thought so.
00;05;12;15 - 00;06;00;03
SL
It's bringing marketing and bring client in. Although I have help. But then interviewing, accepting the project, preparing fee proposals. Design is all mine. That's what I do. Although right now Riccardo from my office, who is actually on paternal leave, has trained to be very good designer as well. As much as possible, I could make it happen, I let him get involved to have his point of view and he's really getting better and better. Majority I would say the concept is mine, detailing is mine, the bricks should be on an angle is mine, the interior architecture is mine, furniture furnishing... So I do a lot.
00;06;00;05 - 00;06;06;01
DP
So, tell me, you do a lot of drawing by hand, a lot of sketching. Is that the way you pass along your information and the ideas?
00;06;06;04 - 00;06;17;20
SL
No. Actually, yes, I do hand sketch. I do hand sketch during schematic and when I would like to explain an idea is all hand sketch, but everything else is CAD.
00;06;17;22 - 00;06;20;03
DP
Okay, so what CAD system are you guys on?
00;06;20;10 - 00;06;57;29
SL
Your basic CAD. Actually, because we are too detailed. I checked all different advancements of CAD, and I kind of thought that what we have, which is really basic CAD, has been incredibly helpful for us to provide us the possibility to go detailed. We detail everything. Like our set of construction drawing is close to maybe 30 drawings, just architecture. And when it gets to interior architecture is another like 30 drawings. We detail like cabinetry and bathroom tiles, that kind of stuff.
00;06;57;29 - 00;07;04;16
DP
Yeah, you get into everything. So, let's talk about the Henhawk house. So, tell me how your office got the project.
00;07;04;18 - 00;07;07;05
SL
Well, as usual, they find us-
00;07;07;07 - 00;07;07;26
DP
Word of mouth?
00;07;08;03 - 00;07;36;26
SL
Word of mouth. And they came to us. And it's a young couple. Very young. And the house was - they fall in love with the land. Location is really a fantastic location. The tree lined boulevard type street in Long Island. The house itself was Tudor style, brick, relatively small. Zoning wise, we were allowed to build close to 8,000 square feet and the existing house was close to 4,400 square feet.
00;07;36;27 - 00;07;38;13
DP
So, there's an FAR there?
00;07;38;15 - 00;08;06;10
SL
Yes. Yes. Everything we do is full force zoning and rules and that kind of I've learned them really well as much as can be played with, we have learned it all. But the house had character. But the house was dim, like typically Tudor style houses from outside are just stunningly gorgeous piece of structure. And when you go in, it’s just sad, dark.
00;08;06;15 - 00;08;11;23
DP
I love the way you describe that. It's so true. So many Tudors really feel that way. Absolutely.
00;08;11;29 - 00;08;47;14
SL
You know, in a way, it gives this kind of fear of people to the Tudor because they think Tudors are supposed to be dark interior and that is not going to happen with my approach to design, because I like the style of Tudor and I don't like the style of sad inside spaces. So, it's bright and happy and is open, is spacious. You know, lots of windows. And in this particular case, the expansion of the house was extensive because I needed to keep a chimney.
00;08;47;21 - 00;08;50;00
DP
Was this a functional chimney or boiler flues?
00;08;50;02 - 00;09;09;17
SL
Yes, functional chimney. And then we wanted to keep a fireplace. We wanted to keep a chimney and they wanted to keep the ceiling - plasterwork ceiling of a dining room - so I said, okay, if we keep all those three, but we get rid of everything else and that's what we-
00;09;09;18 - 00;09;12;10
DP
Wow, Right. I'm sure the contractor loved that.
00;09;12;14 - 00;10;27;23
SL
I work with a contractor. I absolutely love him. I'll get to the stories of my contractors because we are very involved in the construction process. So, my knowledge of construction is very high. And the contractor on this job was incredibly knowledgeable man who loved to do stuff like that but didn't care much to deal with clients and with everything else, paperwork,
So, it worked perfect. The idea become into doing a L-shape design, and because it was kind of long L-shape, it gives me the opportunity to create the design as there are certain components of structures together, section by section with the playfulness of a roof, which is important for Tudor style and also different height and also introduction of stucco and introduction of wood paneling, framing stucco and brick, and also playfulness of a brick. I think we were good in accomplishing that because it has its playfulness, and although it is relatively large, but it is not overwhelmingly massive.
00;10;27;29 - 00;10;29;18
DP
Yeah, I'd say it's well scaled.
00;10;29;21 - 00;11;23;02
SL
It is small scale, right? And then at the end we realized that there's no way we could match the old brick. So, I know Glen-Gery very well, because if I ever have done any brickwork, has been Glen-Gery. And why? Because the quality of the material, and I get service. So, I am fussy enough to worry about the size and also worry about the color of the grout. And I want to have two samples of it made before I even decide what color bricks. So, a rep does that service for us. And due to color, we provide the color to what brick and between those is what I chose. And eventually – and I have awesome mason that are Italian and five brothers and they’re one better than the other. They're local. And they do a magnificent job. And also they built a good size.
00;11;23;05 - 00;11;25;18
DP
They did a mockup for you.
00;11;25;20 - 00;12;06;23
SL
Mockup. Absolutely. And one other thing that I was almost kind of experimenting on this project was that I love the style of Tudor on the outside. I don't like the inside. So that was one issue. Second issue, I like the playfulness of how we could create interesting textures and playfulness of the laying of the brick, but Tudor would allow me to do that because we are compartmentalizing pieces, here and there. Other styles don't do that. And then that herringbone style has to be compartmentalized. Right?
00;12;06;26 - 00;12;08;23
DP
Yeah. And between the boards, I think at one.
00;12;08;23 - 00;12;55;10
SL
And between the board would work. We shouldn't do too much of it because too much of accessory, not good. So it allowed me to experiment and do detailed work and also choosing of the color of the brick and the color of the stucco and the freedom I had in detailing and designing and working also with the roof and with the roofer - I’m friend with the roofer, I'm friend with the Mason man, I’m friend - and to make sure that we get eventually a beautifully detailed house on the outside. And then when it come to the inside, our life is modern. We are living in this time. Our space should be representing our era.
00;12;55;17 - 00;12;57;29
DP
Did you guys use any brick on the interior?
00;12;58;06 - 00;13;00;14
SL
Not on this project.
00;13;00;16 - 00;13;08;06
DP
What were some of the historical precedents we were talking about? Details. Were there any local buildings that were Tudors? Was this the only Tudor locally?
00;13;08;06 - 00;13;27;22
SL
Yes. Actually, no. No, it's not. In this particular street, there are many other brick buildings. Typically, I would drive out on and look at the center and say, ‘Oh, this is so gorgeous.’ And, you know, it's one more beautiful than the other one. But I think mine, right now, it's really complete, in good level.
00;13;27;26 - 00;13;42;27
DP
I love – I love it. It's so great. Were there any significant setback issues? So, we were talking about the size of the existing houses almost three times smaller. Were there a significant number of zoning issues other than FAR, setback things?
00;13;42;29 - 00;13;51;21
SL
Yes. The chimney that I wanted to keep, which was right above the fireplace, was outside of skyline exposure.
00;13;51;22 - 00;13;54;09
DP
Okay. There was a height restriction.
00;13;54;11 - 00;15;41;16
SL
Yes, we always have height restriction. In this case, I said this an existing building. This is not a new house. This is a renovation of an existing house. So, I'm allowed to keep the chimney. And that chimney the end up to really change the inside of the chimney and outside of the chimney and all the bricks and everything.
But we kept the height – now, the zoning, building department going to hear that – fortunately, we had no issue of the setback because we had plenty of space from the front of the house in Kings Point, the setback requirement for front yard is 60 feet and we had way more than 60 feet. It was deep enough that I was able to create a parking courtyard in front of the house and the garage. We have one two car garage on the upper level and then three car garage in the lowest level. The garage is actually coming further out from the front of the house, but I don't think we had any other zoning issues.
But one other feature of the house that I thought it’s kind of important, as I was driving around and see all these Tudor houses, Tudor is not a box. Tudor is never a box. Tudor span, and that is one beautiful feature of when these all expand. We had a lot of width. Plenty of available width. The size of the property was very large, and we had enough room on the site and I thought that if I could add an extra width to the house we’ll be introducing a brick wall extending from the garage and that will be the access from the front of the house to the garden.
00;15;41;18 - 00;15;45;06
DP
And then you did a series of small windows along the garage, correct?
00;15;45;10 - 00;16;03;14
SL
Yes, because a simple wall without any detail in the front elevation was not a good idea. If I can introduce fenestration into the wall and breaking it because this is, again, the style of Tudor.
00;16;03;16 - 00;16;08;21
DP
Did you guys get to do any new details on this project that you hadn't done in the past?
00;16;08;23 - 00;16;23;28
SL
Yes. That brick herringbone is new. The playfulness of the brick above the entrance hall in the front and back. Front and back are identical in what they represent, and we don't repeat ourself. Literally, none of our projects are the same.
00;16;24;00 - 00;16;29;11
DP
I love the red copper finials on the gable ends. Does that double as lightning protection?
00;16;29;17 - 00;17;19;16
SL
Yes. And our roofer is just a master roofer. Unfortunately, he retired after pandemic. We loved him. Just spend a lot of time together coming up with ideas. And he performed beautifully.
And the door - there's also some - another feature we kept many of the existing trees. Trees are valuable. Don't like to cut trees. Doesn't matter if the tree is close to the house or tree is in front of the house. What’s wrong? Tree wants to be where tree wants to be. So, it was a tree that was really beautiful and wouldn't end up to be right in front of that passage to the garden. I couldn't cut the tree, said ‘let it be.’ And actually, in some of the pictures, you could see that the tree is right in front of the passage.
00;17;19;18 - 00;17;28;18
DP
So, this is a traditional home, but this question is kind of top of mind for most people today. Does sustainability come up with your clients at all, and materiality that you guys are using?
00;17;28;18 - 00;18;51;12
SL
Not with the client, but with my – with me, my office. We always do that. I've learned that maybe I've been kind of lucky here and there, having people who really care about sustainability. Sadly enough, majority don't, or they do not necessarily connect building material to sustainability. So, my office does for years. We do it without naming it because then they're concerned about the cost.
There are many different areas that we could really think about building the quality of heating and cooling system, the energy conservation insulation system. Those I do with that saying. My clients often who would not be bothered with that. Selection of the windows, undoubtedly. Using windows with the UL rated that transform the least amount of light, not brightness, but UV into the house we do. When it comes to insulation system, all spray foam. This goes without saying in every project we do. Selection of the material, natural, as much as we can. Selection of materials that are not biodegradable. I fight for that, to not do it.
00;18;51;15 - 00;18;53;27
DP
Did your clients want to use brick from the very beginning?
00;18;53;27 - 00;19;14;28
SL
Yeah, because their house was already brick. So, I thought that they liked the house, they loved the ceiling of the dining room. So fine, that was. And then I said, what else do you like? “We like the fireplace.” Okay, I like the chimney, but they like the fireplace. Fine. What else? “Brick.” And I said, okay, because Tudor style is brick.
00;19;15;04 - 00;19;23;24
DP
Well, I'm thinking it's solved so many design challenges for you guys. I mean, you got to be really playful with brick, but it also solved a lot of problems.
00;19;23;26 - 00;19;39;20
SL
Well, with brick, needless to say, is an amazing material. And it has been used for centuries and centuries and centuries, and still doing well. So, I don't quarrel when it comes to selection of brick.
00;19;39;23 - 00;19;44;00
DP
Did your team learn anything interesting through the process of building this building?
00;19;44;07 - 00;19;46;08
SL
We do on every building, actually.
00;19;46;10 - 00;19;53;22
DP
Isn't that interesting? It doesn’t matter how long you've been practicing, every one of us seems to learn something new every - every job. More than one thing.
00;19;53;28 - 00;19;57;26
SL
Undoubtedly. Information constantly changing.
00;19;57;27 - 00;20;00;09
DP
Yeah, that's a good point. It really does. Yeah.
00;20;00;11 - 00;20;30;09
SL
And what is available in the market constantly change. I think we become obsolete if we do not pay attention to what's happened. If we become comfortable in doing the same thing on and on, then our curiosity also lacks. And then we become so proud in what we do because we are successful and we are, you know, making money and we made it and we repeat the same thing. That is kind of the end of creativity.
00;20;30;11 - 00;20;35;18
DP
Off subject, have you thought at all about A.I. and what it means for our profession?
00;20;35;20 - 00;20;59;05
SL
Yes. I kind of love the idea. Yes. And I know that so much of worries there is there of AI to replace human beings. At the end, we are using the AI either to our benefit or not, but I think the benefits that AI could do are so amazingly high.
00;20;59;07 - 00;21;00;18
DP
So, using it as a tool.
00;21;00;22 - 00;21;01;27
SL
Like everything else.
00;21;02;04 - 00;21;20;23
DP
Well, I just wonder at what point, how much control are we going to have over how we're using AI, how our clients who aren't coming to architects are using AI, whether or not architects will ultimately use it as part of their services? It's a huge can of worms, but it's definitely something I've been thinking about.
00;21;21;00 - 00;21;24;01
SL
Let me tell you something. When I was graduating from UPenn-
00;21;24;02 - 00;21;25;11
DP
I went to Penn, by the way, too.
00;21;25;12 - 00;21;26;15
SL
Did you?
00;21;26;19 - 00;21;27;21
DP
I did. For graduate school, yeah.
00;21;27;26 - 00;22;02;19
SL
Okay. So same with me, graduate school. When I was graduating, they had a lecture, a farewell lecture. And the lecture was kind of gloomy because now you're done, graduated. We're sending you off to practice architecture, but we want to let you know the number of percentage of American buildings being designed by architects – I don’t remember exact number, but it was between nine and 11 – and then they said, compared to European – that I remember very well – 45%.
00;22;02;19 - 00;22;03;14
DP
Wow.
00;22;03;16 - 00;23;39;10
SL
So, I left school knowing that. Then I was thinking that that is not the problem necessarily with architect, but the problem of American not know what we do and the importance of our presence for every project. And that is again and again and again, we need to somehow change that level of knowledge of public work, which I think AIA is trying to do the best of their ability to inform public as the importance of architect, because we are not a set of drawings.
If anybody thinks that our work is a blueprint, then they have no clue of the importance of architect in any project. And we should also never try to compare ourself or believe that builders have taken our spot because typically, especially for residential architecture, people go to a contractor sometime before coming to the architect, and that is because contractor has been available and present for years and architects have not been available and present.
And the majority of quality architects, they don't want to even go to residential architecture because to them is just not good enough. And they have left this vast possibilities. We have – our builders build these buildings, by not the fault of themselves, because they don't know better of whatever is left of the world of residential architecture in America is sad.
00;23;39;12 - 00;24;14;07
DP
Wow. What I like about your position is that it's very positive, right? You could sit there and say, you know what, we're done designing, AI is going to be able to do it. It's going to have access to every design in the world and it's going to take over the world. And I love your explanation of being in school and hearing that architects – and I think I heard the same thing, that they were only responsible for a very small percentage of what was actually being done out there – and the reality is you still have a job and I still have a job, and although our jobs may change, I think we're going to be busy for a long time.
00;24;14;08 - 00;24;59;13
SL
We're going to be fine. We're going to be fine. And I think is gradually shifting. If people are shifting toward being concerned about their well-being, if shifting about being concerned about their health, their eating habit, small percentage, but we are small percentage when it comes to using our services. So, I think architecture and our part of the work, which is the importance of aesthetic, this is something I cannot put more emphasis on than anything else. Even if you don't need my knowledge, fine. But then the contractor’s knowledge – yes, he has knowledge of construction and maybe knowledge of material, but doesn't have knowledge of-
00;24;59;13 - 00;25;00;23
DP
Doesn't have the aesthetic training.
00;25;00;26 - 00;25;01;22
SL
No.
00;25;01;24 - 00;25;04;10
DP
Well, Sussan, it's been really nice to meet you.
00;25;04;15 - 00;25;05;28
SL
Thank you so much.
00;25;06;00 - 00;25;09;21
DP
So where do people go to find out more about Sussan Lari Architect, PC.
00;25;09;21 - 00;25;14;24
SL
I have a website, sussanlariarchitect and Instagram.
00;25;15;00 - 00;25;18;04
DP
Very good. Well, thank you very much for being here. It was really nice to meet you.
00;25;18;05 - 00;25;19;13
SL
Thank you very much for inviting me.
00;25;19;15 - 00;25;20;28
DP
I love your house. It's beautiful.
00;25;21;03 - 00;25;24;10
SL
Thank you.
You May Also Be Interested In
We Can Help With Your Next Project
Discover the latest + greatest in design trends, industry news & pro tips from pros.
For all of your project needs, you’ll find everything you need at a Supply Center.
Let Us Know How We Can Help!
Design Vault Ep. 8 Gansevoort Row with David Kubik
ABOUT THE ARCHITECT:
![]()
|
David Kubik joined BKSk in 2003 and was named partner in 2018. He plays a strong role in the design of both institutional and development projects and pays careful attention to details in both custom interior work and base building new construction. David is experienced at coordinating large consultant teams on complex projects. He is currently the Partner-In-Charge of two new high-end multifamily residential buildings: The Keller and 111 Charles Street, both in the West Village and the recently completed 601 Washington Street. He also recently led the design of two commercial development projects in the Gansevoort Market Historic District: Gansevoort Row Development and 405 West 13th Street.
David holds both a Master of Architecture and a Bachelor of Science degree in Architecture from the University of Maryland. He has received an Award for Excellence in Design and Fellowships at both the Graduate and Baccalaureate levels, as well as a Thesis Citation. David taught design studio as an adjunct lecturer in the Architectural Technology program at the City University of New York. |
---|
ABOUT THE PROJECT:
BKSK secured a complex approval from the Landmarks Preservation Commission for the block-long redevelopment of a collection tattered low-rise commercial buildings near the High Line in Gansevoort Market Historic District. Careful historic research and analysis of the existing buildings, particularly the history of uses and former configurations, enabled a strong rationale for taller building heights and the demolition of some existing fabric on portions of the block. An important part of the Landmarks approval process, and something that BKSK takes great pride in doing, is presenting to preservation groups, the local community board, and select government officials. In this case the presentation made a successful argument for the development along the street and the properties are currently in various stages of completion, with an impressive roster of luxury retailers, and tenants including Hermes, Match Group, Inc., and the reopened Pastis.

Photo by Amy Barkow Photo
TRANSCRIPT
00;00;00;00 - 00;00;05;09
Doug Patt (DP)
Let's go inside the vault. The design vault.
00;00;05;11 - 00;00;35;04
David Kubik (DK)
From avenue to Avenue across all of these 11 buildings. That was generally programmatically, what was sought after by the client was good commercial space, whether it was retail or office. So then really the next question was, okay, let's look at these buildings, understand which ones were perhaps more intact, more attractive the way they were, which ones could receive some additions, and were there any buildings that just didn't have really kind of great architectural character and warranted demolition and starting over and so we had a little bit of all those.
00;00;35;07 - 00;02;59;25
DP
This is my guest, David Kubik, AIA. I'll share more about him shortly. In this episode from the Design Vault, we’ll highlight David's project called Gansevoort Row. BKSK Architects made its imprint on the Gansevoort Market Historic District in New York City with a collection of landmark approvals. The redevelopment of a full block of tattered, low rise commercial buildings near the High Line.
Through careful analysis, BKSK made a strong rationale for taller building heights and some new construction along portions of the block. The new development project has a roster of luxury retailers, commercial and office space. The row buildings include existing facades, along with a creative variety of contemporary versions. Interestingly, each new building of various sizes features a unique blend of colors and patterns of brick.
The street facades maintain a turn of the century aesthetic with traditional elements and details, while employing modern windows and expansive metal awnings.
Hi, I'm Doug Pat and this is Design Vault.
Today we're talking to David Kubik, AIA. David Kubik holds a Bachelor of Science and Master of Architecture degree from the University of Maryland. He joined BKSK in 2003 and was named partner in 2018.
He works on the design of both institutional and development projects and is experienced at coordinating large consultant teams with expansive layers of complexity. He is currently the partner in charge of two new high end multi residential buildings for BKSK, the Keller and 111 Charles Street, both in the West Village and the recently completed 601 Washington Street. He also led the design of two commercial development projects in the Gansevoort Market Historic District, one of which we will discuss today, the Gansevoort Row redevelopment.
David has received an award for Excellence in Design and fellowships at both the graduate and Baccalaureate levels, as well as a thesis citation. David taught Design Studio as an adjunct lecturer in the Architectural Technology program at the City University of New York. So welcome, David. Nice to have you with us today. So, tell us a little bit about BKSK in New York City.
So where are you guys located? What's the size of the firm and what type of work do you do?
00;03;00;04 - 00;03;30;13
DK
Well, thanks for having me. A little bit more about BKSK Architects. The firm was founded in 1985. We've always, right from the beginning, been a firm focused on ambitious design, really over a broad range of typologies, whether commercial or residential institutional. And as we're going to talk about today, we have many, many projects that have obtained approval from the Landmarks Preservation Commission. That's a particularly special part of our practice. The firm is located here in New York City. We're on West 38th Street. It's currently led by six partners and we're about 50 people.
00;03;30;15 - 00;03;32;12
DP
So how long have you guys been in New York City?
00;03;32;19 - 00;03;43;26
DK
We've been here practicing since 1985, and we were down on 25th Street for a number of years. We recently moved up to West 38th Street in 2020, which was an exciting time to move an office.
00;03;44;02 - 00;03;46;22
DP
How was that? Was that fraught with challenges?
00;03;46;23 - 00;04;12;05
DK
It was fraught with challenges. We literally moved the weekend of the shutdown. So, we moved out of our old office on the Friday and moved into our new office on that Saturday. And if everyone recalls, Sunday was the day that New York City really, effectively, shut down. So, we plugged in our new server, plugged in all of our new computers, and crossed their fingers that everyone could log in remotely on Monday morning. And miraculously, it all worked.
00;04;12;12 - 00;04;15;02
DP
That is unbelievable. So, you guys weren't fully remote.
00;04;15;04 - 00;04;21;01
DK
Fully remote as many did for a number of months. But yes, all of that came down to literally a day.
00;04;21;08 - 00;04;25;19
DP
As an aside, did that last for employees or is everybody back in the office now?
00;04;25;22 - 00;04;37;12
DK
We're all back in the office now. We kind of have some flexibility in terms of working remotely like many do. You know, you can have kind of a hybrid week somewhat, but like many companies, for a number of months, we were fully remote, which is tricky for an architecture firm.
00;04;37;19 - 00;04;42;22
DP
Absolutely. So, tell us a little bit about yourself. So how did you end up at BKSK?
00;04;42;24 - 00;06;07;23
DK
Sure. So, as you noted in the introduction, I was attending University of Maryland. I grew up in New Jersey, so always had kind of a fondness for the New York City area, was really excited by the architecture that was happening there. So, while I was still a student at the University of Maryland, I did have a summer internship with Clement and Holl Span architects, who are really also well-known mid-sized firm here in New York.
After graduating, I worked for about a year and a half at Michael Graves Architect. Most people don't know this, but they did at the time have a New York City branch office. They were not just in Princeton, New Jersey. So, I worked for them for a little bit. And then in 2003, I joined BKSK Architects. And at the time I was really looking for work where I could have a heavy involvement in the creation of the construction documents and during Construction administration.
I loved the work that BKSK had. There was a real high level of design ambition and you could tell there was a real study and appreciation for the craft of what they were making. And I loved the idea that I could be both involved in the design and documentation as well as have the opportunity to be on site while it was being built, which on some of the larger firms, sometimes that's not always in the cards.
So, it was a little bit of a shift for me to go to an office that was a little bit smaller, a little bit more locally focused. But there was something that I recognized I was really interested in and BKSK was able to provide that. So, it was a really rewarding shift and I really enjoyed that practice.
00;06;07;25 - 00;06;13;13
DP
So now you're a partner. Has that changed at all your role in the office? Or tell us a little bit about what you do now.
00;06;13;16 - 00;07;17;01
DK
Sure. So obviously some things change, and I'm happy to say that many things haven't. Sure, my role has changed. I'm involved in more projects; I'm overseeing those projects in the kind of sort of senior leadership role you'd expect when you hear the term partner. But – and our office is a little bit bigger now than it was when I joined in 2003 – but, I would say that the ethos has not changed and we still, as architects, as kind of a tight knit group there in the office, were still very much focused on what I was describing earlier, which is high level of ambition in the design work that we do. And we really like to understand how things get built and the craft in which it takes to build them.
So, we enjoy working with contractors. That's not an adversarial relationship. We like to be on site, you know, and communicate directly with the subcontractors and the general contractors. And that's a process that we see can have a lot of opportunity for collaboration. And again, doesn't have to be this sort of adversarial standoff, which sometimes it can unfortunately sort of devolve into. But we try to make sure it doesn't go there and that everyone's working together in the sandbox to create something beautiful.
00;07;17;08 - 00;07;24;10
DP
Let's dig in here and talk about our building. Tell us a little bit about the Gansevoort Row project. So how did your office get the project?
00;07;24;16 - 00;09;12;02
DK
One of our existing clients, a client that we had already completed a number of projects with us, approached us about this project over our capital. I definitely can go on and on about that. Relationships. We're really happy with that relationship. They're a terrific client. They understand what it means to do a project of quality.
And so, we were honored when they came to us about this opportunity and this site. It's on the south side of Gansevoort Street, stretching from Avenue to Avenue, from Greenwich Street to Washington Street. It's really three pieces of property. But when you look across those parcels, it's really 11 individual historic structures that occupy these three properties. So, it was really quite a collection of buildings and structures that we had to grapple with and understand. They were all a little different. Some were more carefully preserved and intact than others, but the entire site had to be presented into the Landmarks Preservation Commission and whatever we designed, they had to approve.
So, what's interesting about that process, I think right out of the gate is that, if you're working on a site that is not subject to LPC approval, the very first thing you do is understand what the local zoning regulations allow you to build. How tall can I go? How big can I go and plan? What is the bulk that's permitted? How many square feet of floor area can I build? When you're in a landmarks district, you do not have rights to that floor area. You have to present a design that is compelling and as they deem, quote unquote, appropriate. It's often the case that you do not get to realize all of the square feet or all of the bulk that zoning might describe for that particular district. And that happened here, too. We didn't reach the full floor area allowed. We realized a lot of floor area for the developer, which is of course good for them. But we did have to present something that was appropriate for the neighborhood, appropriate for the scale on the street and the specific site context that we were dealing with.
00;09;12;05 - 00;09;16;01
DP
So, tell us a little bit about that. So LPC is Landmark Property.
00;09;16;06 - 00;09;18;19
DK
Landmarks Preservation Commission, so LPC for short.
00;09;18;19 - 00;09;22;20
DP
And you said they had to approve what you guys designed. How does that work?
00;09;22;25 - 00;09;50;24
DK
Because they were in a historic district. It's the Gansevoort market district. Anything that gets proposed has to first go in front of the LPC group and they have to review it and approve it before you can get your building permit, before you can get your approval at the local building department. So, it's not a, quote unquote, as of right district where you just follow the local code, follow the local zoning and you're off and running. We have this extra step of scrutiny. Whatever we present, they ultimately have to approve.
00;09;51;02 - 00;10;02;25
DP
I saw a great photograph; I think it was on the website from 1938. So, tell us a little bit about the history of the site. Is it interesting and why hasn't it been developed to this point? And what has happened along the way?
00;10;02;29 - 00;12;06;24
DK
It is very interesting. It has many chapters which we could spend hours talking about, but I'll summarize it a little bit in the sense that there was different types of buildings that were built here, whether it was a store and loft building or more of a warehouse building or purpose built garage buildings. In this district, you would see many different types of buildings. It wasn't sort of so perfectly monolithic like in some other historic districts. And in, generally speaking, many of these buildings were built to a certain height, often around five stories, six stories. And then when the city kind of really fell into tough economic times, a lot of these buildings were cut down to two stories because it was a strategy for building owners to pay less in taxes.
Unfortunately, a lot of these quite nice historic buildings would get cut down arbitrarily to two stories because that's just what made sense if you had a store and maybe one level of offices or storage above but, they didn't really need more than that. And this area of Manhattan on the far, far west Side, you know, became this sort of meatpacking district. And it just wasn't very desirable real estate in New York City for many, many decades. And then as economic growth has kind of pushed the city in recent years and decades, you know, finally this neighborhood has become a place where it's seen as advantageous to develop. High line, obviously, changed a lot of that. The new Whitney Museum, being literally on the opposite corner from this site, changed a lot of that. And our developer, Aurora Capital, are really responsible for a lot of the development in this neighborhood.
So, they've really boosted the appeal and the economic viability of this neighborhood. So, it was interesting to really understand the history of those buildings and it was sort of time for the next chapter of what could happen with these buildings. And so, your original reference, the 1938 photo, we looked at a lot of that carefully because it was obviously history and context that matters when you're dealing with these buildings. And in some cases there were narratives about bringing some of these buildings back up to their original five story height and in other cases not, which we can get into a little bit more specifically. But yeah, it was a bit of a mixed bag.
00;12;06;27 - 00;12;16;16
DP
So, I understand the scope of the project was to create successful retail, commercial and office space. Tell us a little bit about the scope and then the programmatic requirements.
00;12;16;18 - 00;15;29;27
DK
Sure. So, from avenue to avenue, across all of these 11 buildings, that was generally programmatically what was sought after by the client was good commercial space, whether it was retail or office. So then really the next question was, okay, let's look at these buildings, understand which ones were perhaps more intact, more attractive the way they were, which ones could receive some additions. And were there any buildings that just didn't have really kind of great architectural character and warranted demolition and starting over? And so, we had a little bit of all of those. So, you know, if you start generally looking at the block on the eastern end, there were more buildings that were pretty intact, had good architectural character. And we got from a sense in the community that they were cherished a bit more than some of the others.
So, you'll see on the eastern end the scale kind of stayed down at two stories. On the western end, there were two sort of blocks of buildings, one which comprised of five store and loft buildings, almost tenement style rowhouse looking type buildings, but more commercial oriented. Those buildings were all cut down from five stories to two. So, we proposed to put a three-story addition on that two story structure and raise that to a five story building.
And then lastly, on the western end of the property, and that piece of property being directly across from the Whitney, was just a one-story garage building kind of purpose-built garage building. It was not an original building in the district and really had no kind of architectural merit or character to speak of in the historic designation report for the neighborhood, it was described as non-contributing, which is also a term they use for buildings that might be in a historic district but were really never part of the original fabric and don't have any real value or they're not adding value to the district. So that was a corner property that was deemed acceptable to kind of demolish, remove that one story structure, and build something brand new. So, on that far western end, we proposed a new six story kind of warehouse loft looking building. And this goes back to the strategy of where is it viable to add bulk and square footage for the developer to kind of realize their investment? And where does it make sense to not do that?
And so, it was in a sort of perfect, even monolithic approach. Let's just add two or three stories across the whole block from avenue and avenue. We didn't do that. We said, you know what, on the western end, it makes more architectural sense to grow the properties and go higher. And on the eastern end, it makes more sense to keep them a little lower.
What was also interesting about this project was, you could imagine the owner could have very easily said, okay, we have three pieces of property here. Let's go to three different architects and just treat them like three individual projects and go to landmarks three individual times. But we didn't do that, and I think that was really smart on behalf of the owner, regardless of who they hired, to treat this as one job because you could treat it almost like an urban design exercise, a master planning exercise, you could look at the whole block and sort of horse trade square footage and decide where was it more appropriate and palatable to pump up the square footage and where was it not. And so, I think that we recognized it as a unique opportunity. We wanted to get our heads around, immediately about, where does the architecture support this intervention and where maybe does it not.
00;15;30;04 - 00;15;35;06
DP
So, at the end of the day, were there any project restrictions in terms of the heights of the buildings?
00;15;35;13 - 00;16;57;15
DK
Definitely. There was a lot of scrutiny about height, but it wasn't coming through either a code or zoning regulation. It was coming through an in-depth conversation with the Landmarks Preservation Committee and the Community board. So, when the Landmarks Preservation Commission approves your project, their permit has a title, and at the top it's Certificate of Appropriateness. Their measure of, you know, whether or not something should be approved really centers around that term appropriateness. So, it's very subjective.
So, they're looking at the context. How tall are the buildings around you? What are the styles of those buildings? What are the colors of those buildings? Do they have a lot of glass? Do they have a little bit of glass? You know, is all of the architectural language context bulk history. So, it's about storytelling is one way we like to think about it. What is the narrative that justifies your project? Like, what is the big idea of your project? And it has to be rooted in the history of the site, the context of site, and an appropriateness. So, there was a lot of analyzation of what were these buildings.
You mentioned the 1938 photo. That was one photo that was really important. There were many others. And so, you're really crafting a story. You're telling a story. So, what we proposed, we hope, extends the sort of natural evolution of this block like I was referring to earlier. This block has many chapters, and this is just the next chapter. Buildings go up, they come down, they go up again. And this will kind of be an evolution that the neighborhood will probably continue to see.
00;16;57;17 - 00;17;06;02
DP
Since the process with the planning commission was so subjective, how many people are on the planning commission? Was that really challenging? Because everybody's got to agree, right?
00;17;06;05 - 00;17;34;27
DK
Sure. I can't recall the exact number right now. I think it's around ten commissioners. And so, you know, you have to have a majority of the commissioners to obtain approval. You don't have to have unanimous approval. We went to the Landmarks Commission two times in order to obtain that approval. But we involved ourselves with a lot of kind of community engagement and – and meetings ahead of time because we wanted to make sure that what we were bringing was something that was viable and supportable in any way that we could.
00;17;34;29 - 00;17;44;17
DP
So, tell us about the building plans. I would imagine as you run across the facade, some are rectangular, summer more square, but they all fill the entire block?
00;17;44;20 - 00;18;47;10
DK
Well, it's actually a little bit different. So, the buildings that are on corners have different requirements than buildings that are mid-block. On both the eastern and western end – on the eastern end is an existing building. That building is built full on its lot because a corner building can be built full, it doesn't have a required rear yard. So, the eastern building was a purpose-built garage building, really kind of special, unique yellow brick house has a really bright image to it and we retain that building because it has some really nice character to it. Hermes is in there right now, as a high-end retailer. That's a special condition.
In the mid-block portion of the project, there is a rear yard, and the ground floor is built full. But once you're above the ground floor, starting at the second floor and up, these buildings do have rear yards. And then our new building that we proposed on the western corner that I was talking about earlier, same situation that it's very common.
The zoning allows it. Most buildings in New York City, when you're on the corner, won't necessarily have a rear yard or a side yard or anything like that. And this building doesn't either.
00;18;47;13 - 00;18;54;03
DP
So, tell us a little bit about the style choices, right. I mean, it looked to me like there were at least three buildings that remained.
00;18;54;09 - 00;19;46;22
DK
More than that. I would say on the eastern end there are two. And then in the mid-block portion, it's one building. But historically it's really three structures. Then there's this group of five, and then there's our new warehouse building on the western end. So that's why I was saying it's kind of like 11 structures stretching across three pieces of property when you really get into it, in terms of their history. They are different styles. They're all a little different.
The one on the eastern end was kind of a garage building. The ones mid-block are more kind of a store and loft, so they have kind of commercial storefronts at the ground floor and then kind of punched opening double hung window language above that. And then on the western end, our new building was not so much a store and loft had more of a kind of a warehouse look, so much heavier masonry language with much bigger areas of glass kind of departing from the individual punch window language.
00;19;46;24 - 00;19;58;24
DP
So stylistically, the newer buildings are slightly more contemporary than the existing buildings. Did you have different architects working on different buildings and coming up with themes?
00;19;59;00 - 00;22;06;12
DK
We definitely had a pretty substantial team in this project, and we are very collaborative in the office. So regardless of what level you might be practicing at our office, we're all at the table together. Everyone's contributing ideas, which we think is a great way to work and really fun. Obviously, as you kind of break down the teams, there were certain people dedicated to certain areas of the project. I also worked really closely with my partner Todd on this project. He had a deep involvement in this as well. So, it was really kind of the two of us on this.
What I think is fun, and as a general observation across the whole block, is that once we had a clear understanding of the kind of existing language of the architecture, whether it was garage or store in loft or warehouse, when we had our interventions, we did it in such a way that was quite respectful and kind of playing off the traditional languages of those buildings, but clearly contemporary at the same time.
So, the brick detailing is done in a traditional way, but with modern techniques and modern, you know, sort of expressions that are a little bit different. So, in the mid-block building, the one that has a three-story addition on a two-story base, there we used brick that was very similar in tone to the second floor that existed, but then also came up with a very special window language that involved some terracotta tiles on the transom that allowed for bigger glass windows but a smaller masonry opening. So, it felt appropriate for the scale of that facade. And then on the corner building, we really wanted to bring the sort of large heft and substantialness of the masonry detailing that you would see on a lot of the older warehouse buildings, even some of the buildings directly across the street from us. And so, we used a technique called a concealed lintel system to allow all of our brick returns, whether they were eight inches and in some cases 12-inch brick returns. You had these really beautiful brick returns both in plan and in sections. So, above the window, the window heads, you can really see 12 inches of brick wrapping and returning to the window, which you don't always see in newer buildings now, but we thought was really important for a building like this to be well detailed like that and show that depth of masonry, which is so characteristic for a lot of the historic buildings in that neighborhood.
00;22;06;19 - 00;22;17;28
DP
Now, I saw some patterning running vertically along one of the taller buildings. Tell me a little bit about that because that motif appears as a lintel above the windows. What is that?
00;22;18;02 - 00;23;52;26
DK
Yeah, so that mid-block building that was five store and loft buildings all kind of put together on its eastern facade because the building next to it was cut down like we talked about down to two stories. It's sort of exposed on that brick facade, the sort of scar of where the chimney would have been. So, there was a very sort of roughly demolished zone on the side of that facade where you could tell by looking at it, ‘you know what? I bet you there was a masonry chimney there and it all just sort of got roughly demolished.’ But it was kind of a signature moment on the side of that building that you would really see in the historic photos, and you would see in that 1938 photo.
So, we kind of wanted to bring back that chimney scar, but we did it with these terracotta tiles and behind those tiles behind that pattern is floor to ceiling glass. So, you're getting this masonry expression on the eastern facade that brings back that very particular circumstance that that building had. But you're doing it in a way that also allows some natural light to come in the building, because this is now a commercial office building. It's not a store in loft. Those upper floors are not used for storage anymore. People are occupying those floors. So, we were looking for ways to bring in a lot of natural light into this new work environment. But we wanted to do it in such a way that again, go back to that word that was appropriate for the sort of architectural expression of the building. So yeah, it was a unique moment. And the transoms, the lintel is basically doing the same thing.
Behind that is a really tall window, but from the street it looks like a smaller window, and it looks like a size window that is appropriate for that scale of building. So, it was sort of how you can have your cake and eat it too.
00;23;52;28 - 00;24;00;27
DP
Yeah, it's a really interesting detail. So how long did the design process take, city review, construction, start to finish?
00;24;00;29 - 00;24;29;27
DK
Good question. I don't know. I don’t have all of those dates at my fingertips, but I would say that while typically a project like this in our office would take about a year to document from schematic design to 100% construction documents, I think on this project it was substantially longer. Maybe a year and a half, a year and three quarters because of the extra time it took to first seek and get that LPC approval.
Once the approval is in hand, then we can really march forward and finish those construction documents. And then the construction itself, I believe, took about two years.
00;24;30;04 - 00;24;31;12
DP
How many sheets were in the set?
00;24;31;19 - 00;24;36;22
DK
It's definitely over 200. It's probably approaching 250 sheets or something like that. Yeah, it's a big undertaking.
00;24;36;27 - 00;24;38;17
DP
Did you guys model this in 3D?
00;24;38;25 - 00;25;00;27
DK
This entire city block is in Revit. It's all one Revit file that can be broken apart because we had to issue it as three sets of construction documents. Going back to the fact that this is three properties, it had to get filed at the Department of Buildings in three pieces to match up to those pieces of property, even though it was conceived as one big thing. So, yes, three sets of drawings.
00;25;00;29 - 00;25;04;21
DP
Now, a job this big, do have more than one PM? Project manager.
00;25;04;21 - 00;25;18;07
DK
Yes. Yeah, on this project we had two, Will Russell and Evan Singer, who did a phenomenal job really combing through every detail, understanding every nook and cranny. It was a real labor of love for them. I think they enjoyed it very much and they did a great job.
00;25;18;09 - 00;25;29;28
DP
So, this question comes up a lot. Did sustainability ever come up in choosing the materials for the project? And clearly brick was already out there. Did you guys just say, “okay, this is what we're going to do; we never even thought about another material”?
00;25;30;05 - 00;27;06;14
DK
Yeah. So, this project didn't seek any particular certification, but there were many sustainable elements that we tried to incorporate whenever we could in terms of material selection. I think that was also interesting is this is a conversation about adaptive reuse. One of the most sustainable things you can do when you look at a building project is reuse existing material. If you want to reduce your carbon footprint, reuse what's there, don't bring new material on site.
Many of these facades, you know, we really carefully tried to keep as much as the brick structure, whether it's party walls, you know, load bearing walls, facade walls. We tried to keep as much of that intact as possible. There were cases where, even a little scary times, you go onto the roof and you look at these old brick parapets and, you know, they haven't been maintained or cared for in way too long. And the mortar is at this point dust. And you can literally just take your hand and take the bricks off, which it was time. We are also very grateful that this project happened when it did because, you know, I think it saved these buildings, too. They really needed this intervention. They needed this next chapter in their life.
So, we, in some cases, had to demolish brick walls and keep all the brick and catalog it, put it down on the floor, label it so that the masons could take it and then put it back up and reinstall it. So, we did a lot of that careful work in the restoration and then much of the new either additions or buildings that we designed use brick. And it was a direct sort of reaction to this historic neighborhood. There was just an abundance of it, frankly, used in many different ways, many different colors. And it was really sort of a core ingredient, if you will, to any of the architecture that you might propose here.
00;27;06;16 - 00;27;11;21
DP
So, I haven't seen any of the interior photos. But do we end up seeing brick on the interior of any of these buildings?
00;27;11;27 - 00;27;35;26
DK
On some of them, again, particularly in the places where they are existing. So, in the existing two-story portion of that store in loft building, every 25 feet was a load bearing brick wall. Many of those are still there and the retailers who took those spaces did not cover them up, which is great. We love seeing that. So, you can really see a lot of that character and some of the buildings on the eastern end. You have moments to see some of that brick, too.
00;27;36;03 - 00;27;43;22
DP
It looked to me like there were at least two different brick colors that were really unique to this job. Could you tell us a little bit about that?
00;27;43;27 - 00;28;51;12
DK
So, the two brick colors on the project that we're talking about right now is a kind of a standard red brick that went on our three-story addition over the two-story existing structure. And that was kind of a nice interplay between a nice, textured, more modern looking red brick, but clearly still relating to the historic red brick that was right below it. So, you can distinguish the difference, but it's subtle.
On the corner building, there is a more sort of neutral what you might think is a more modern brick color. It's a Glen-Gery glacier gray brick. It has a lot of kind of nice texture and variation to it, which we were really attracted by. And it is perhaps a little bit more neutral, a little bit more contemporary of a tone.
That said, there are many large six story warehouse buildings directly across the street from us on Washington Street on that block facing the river. And many of those buildings had some pretty neutral tones in their brick selection as well. Maybe perhaps a little bit creamier, a little bit warmer, but not that different from what we were proposing there. So, we thought it was kind of a nice sort of interplay between those tones and still felt quite appropriate in the color.
00;28;51;17 - 00;28;59;24
DP
And how did you guys ultimately find the right colors for the bricks? Did you guys simply have samples in the office, or did you go out and take a look at them?
00;29;00;02 - 00;29;49;10
DK
Yeah, both. So, we really want to gain all those samples in the office and kind of build a library that we can consider. We looked at mockups on site to make sure that we were really happy with it and just walking around the neighborhood looking at these tones and seeing really how they relate. So again, it's nice to feel like the selection is growing right out of the context, but with a little bit of a modern twist, we think is actually quite nice.
And that brick in particular, we really loved the variation in the shading. You get kind of different colors within it. There is a little bit of texture and stippling to the brick finish as well, and we kind of joke around that sometimes if you look at a material sample up close, you think it looks messy, but it's that messiness. When you put it at a building scale or an urban scale that really makes that brick look good and crafted. So having that texture we think is kind of important.
00;29;49;12 - 00;29;57;20
DP
That's a really good point. So, did your team learn anything interesting through the design and construction process? Anything come to light that was like, this is kind of cool?
00;29;57;28 - 00;30;55;01
DK
I think what's just fun about designing in brick is it's a particular knowledge set. It's kind of its own craft or game if you want to call it that. You really have to think about the module of brick and how it wants to be used. We know a typical module for brick is either eight inches or twelve inches, quite commonly, and when you start designing your building, you have to be thinking about that brick module from day one, how it courses out vertically, how it courses out horizontally.
There were moments we learned a little bit of the hard way where we thought we had it exactly right and we didn't have it exactly right. And we had to make changes on the fly. Work carefully with the subcontractor, but you can't ignore the module of brick. You have to kind of work with it, don't work against it, and your details should sort of celebrate the natural dimensions of that brick. And I think we learned a lot about that. We had done already a number of brick buildings in our history of the firm, but this one really had a little bit of everything in it, which was really quite fun.
00;30;55;03 - 00;31;08;02
DP
Isn’t it interesting that we deal with buildings, but we're really dealing with math, right? Everything has to kind of fit into those modules.
So, did you guys have any trouble finding a great mason to work with on the process?
00;31;08;09 - 00;31;56;12
DK
So, we rely very much on our contractors to find those subcontractors. So, we worked with a great general contractor here who did find their way to a mason who you could tell right from the beginning was enjoying their craft. They would constantly ask us questions because they just wanted to make sure that they were getting it right per the design intent. And we thought that was really great.
Again, going back to something I said earlier, it was a good collaborative, positive relationship between everyone because we just wanted to make these buildings, you know, as best we could. And so, I think that mason did an excellent job in this project, and it really shows if you walk the block. And whether you're looking at very careful noodling and restoration on the buildings to the east, or the obviously more expansive, impressive new construction on the west, all the detailing, all the construction is very tight. It looks great.
00;31;56;18 - 00;32;03;21
DP
It's good to hear. So, this is the last tough question I've got for you. You've been an architect for some time, I would imagine. 20, 25 years.
00;32;03;26 - 00;32;07;14
DK
23. Yeah, depending on when you want to start the clock. But yeah, somewhere in there.
00;32;07;14 - 00;32;14;24
DP
Right. Exactly. So, if you could give your younger self some career advice, based on who you are now, what would it be?
00;32;14;26 - 00;33;36;07
DK
I guess I would say, and it's something that's been important to me, and I guess it was a bit of a leap of faith, I kind of found my way to BKSK architects for a reason. I feel lucky that I ended up there, frankly. It reinforced an interest I had, which is really to understand what you're making.
I enjoy design very much. You know, we want to blue sky and think very ambitiously about what a project could be. You want to push the envelope. But I always like to couple that with the reality of how something gets built. And I think that constant tension, if you will, about being ambitious, trying something new, being innovative, I always want to couple that with understanding how you build because a lot of times the innovation will grow out of something quite conventional, or an observation about how things get built. ‘Well, this is how we normally do it.’ Well, what if you just did it the normal way, but turned it 90 degrees and now you have a new detail and you can express things differently. So, those two things don't have to fight each other, and they could actually reinforce each other. And I think that's something that I've tried to instill in people who have worked for me or when I've taught at City Tech. I think that is something that I've found to be a kind of rewarding aspect of the practice. I also think that goes back to where I went to school at University of Maryland. That was something that was kind of a core part of their ethos and their pedagogy about what they taught. And I think it's important and I recognize the sort of value of it as a practicing architect.
00;33;36;09 - 00;33;55;16
DP
Back when I was in Maryland, working in Baltimore, I was out on set with a contractor and he said, “Doug, do us a favor. Do yourself a favor. Always draw something that can be built.” So, learn construction, right? You may be an architect and you may want to be a designer, but you've got to learn how everything goes together first. That’s great advice.
00;33;55;18 - 00;34;20;00
DK
Yeah. And we try to practice this in our office now. Myself and my partners, we all kind of grew up together here at the firm. Once you get through one really big project of consequence, it makes you a better designer for the next project. It's like learning a language. It's like learning a grammar. Once you understand it and can speak the language and know how to form sentences and the structure of it all, it just makes you a better designer for the next one.
00;34;20;04 - 00;34;26;16
DP
Absolutely. David, it's been great to have you here. Thanks for your time. Where can people go to learn more about BKSK architects?
00;34;26;23 - 00;34;35;25
DK
bksk.com Please go ahead and visit. We're also on all of the major social media platforms. Welcome anyone's input, or anyone wants to reach out.
00;34;36;01 - 00;34;38;19
DP
Awesome. Thank you very much. It’s been great to have you as a guest.
00;34;38;21 - 00;34;42;15
DK
Thanks for having me. This was really fun.
You May Also Be Interested In
We Can Help With Your Next Project
Discover the latest + greatest in design trends, industry news & pro tips from pros.
For all of your project needs, you’ll find everything you need at a Supply Center.
Let Us Know How We Can Help!
Design Vault Ep. 9 PA State Archives with Paul Neuhaus
ABOUT THE ARCHITECT:
![]()
|
Paul Neuhaus, AIA, LEED AP is a senior designer for HGA in their Minneapolis office, and has been practicing for 30 years. Working in their Arts, Community and Education (ACE) practice group, Paul's project work includes studio arts and performing arts facilities, science labs, student centers, and life science classrooms for higher education; as well as libraries, a church, and very recently, a paper archive for the State of Pennsylvania.
Paul strives to engender a sense of community and belonging for those who visit and work in the buildings his team designs. Paul's process centers on discovering how the project site, culture, and program can shape space and take form, to reflect his client's aspirations and give dignity, purpose, and pleasure to people's lives. |
---|
PA State Archives
HGA
View Project00;00;00;00 - 00;00;05;12
Doug Patt (DP)
Let's go inside the vault. The design vault.
00;00;05;14 - 00;00;34;08
Paul Neuhaus (PN)
They wanted a full archive with plenty of space for growth into the future. The storage has different requirements depending on the kinds of documents. So, we needed to create spaces that allow them to continue to collect. And a lot of the people who come in to do research, which is another big part of what they do, they collect and preserve. But they also provide these documents to the public for access, for research, or just for curiosity and to learn.
00;00;34;11 - 00;02;55;10
DP
This is my guest, Paul Neuhaus. I'll share more about him shortly. In this episode from the Design Vault, we’ll highlight Paul's project, the PA State Archives. The new Pennsylvania State Archives Facility collects and preserves valuable paper documents while making them available to the public for viewing and research. The building is a state-of-the-art archival facility with an enhanced building envelope and HVAC system for the optimal environment to preserve historical paper documents.
The street facade features a linear, steel framed louver structure which surrounds a two-story high glass enclosed pavilion. The pavilion is connected to the main building, which accommodates the two public research rooms and staff spaces. While much of the building requires a windowless approach. A wide assortment of colored Norman size bricks were used to give the facade a varied and playful appearance.
The building used 350,000 brick equivalents in a blend of five different glazed brick colors. The building is three city blocks in size on three acres of land. The total storage area on three floors is 50,000 square feet and includes oversized, cool, cold, secure, and digital archives.
Hi, I'm Doug Pat and this is Design Vault.
Today we're talking to Paul Neuhaus, AIA, LEED AP. Paul has a bachelor's degree in art from California Lutheran University and a master's degree in architecture from UCLA Graduate School of Architecture and Urban Planning. Paul is a Senior designer for HGA. Paul is in their Minneapolis office and has been practicing for 30 years, working in their arts community and education practice group. Paul's project work includes studio arts and performing arts facilities, science labs, student centers and life science classrooms for higher ed, as well as libraries, a church and very recently, the building we will be talking about today, a paper archive for the State of Pennsylvania.
Paul strives to engender a sense of community and belonging for those who visit and work in the buildings his teams design. So welcome, Paul.
00;02;55;14 - 00;02;56;28
PN
Thank you. It's great to be here.
00;02;57;01 - 00;03;08;11
DP
It's great to have you with us today. So, before we get started, tell us a little bit about HGA architects. We know you're in the Minneapolis area. What's the size of the firm, the type of work you guys do?
00;03;08;14 - 00;03;26;05
PN
HGA is a national interdisciplinary design firm committed to making a positive, lasting impact for our clients and communities through research based holistic solutions. We’re a collective of over a thousand professionals in 12 offices nationwide.
00;03;26;08 - 00;03;30;21
DP
Wow. That's incredible. So how long has HGA been around?
00;03;30;23 - 00;03;51;26
PN
Oh, boy. We go back to the fifties. The office here in Minneapolis was the first office and Hamel Green and Abramson, the founders, started the firm. They were a well-known firm in the state for many years and grew over the years and became a dominant force here in the state. And today, they're the largest firm in the state.
00;03;51;29 - 00;03;54;09
DP
Do you have any other locations outside the state?
00;03;54;11 - 00;04;03;13
PN
Yeah, we have 11 other offices, so East Coast and West Coast mostly. We also have two offices in Wisconsin.
00;04;03;20 - 00;04;12;17
DP
That's a really big architecture firm. Tell me a little bit about the role that you play at HGA. How did you end up there and what are you doing now?
00;04;12;20 - 00;05;08;10
PN
I've been in the city practicing since 1992. As a matter of fact, I wanted to work for HGA when I first moved to the city from Los Angeles. Interviewed here a couple of times, and it just worked out that I got an offer from another firm in town and work for them. That was back in 92. And then I didn't end up working for HGA until 2014.
I was really attracted to the firm because of the high quality of the design they do. Even though they're a large firm, they really practice like a small boutique firm. There's a lot of collaboration and independent thinking here. They allow architects to really pursue individually on each project what they think the vision of that project should be. So, when you look at HGA’s work, you don't see a pattern of design that looks a certain way. Buildings and projects can go in a lot of different directions, and there really isn't a style for our firm, which is really the way it should be.
00;05;08;16 - 00;05;26;03
DP
Yeah, I mean, that's pretty unique. Most offices, you look at their work and you can spot the thread that works its way through all of the architecture, and I'm sure that's the same way with your office. And yet many offices, stylistically they're just churning out the same thing, one building after another. So that's interesting.
00;05;26;05 - 00;05;44;00
PN
There definitely is a commitment to modernism and contemporary architecture. We do that well, but we also do historical preservation. And so, we have people who are working on buildings that are hundreds of years old - that occurs too - where we have to tie into historical buildings quite often with the new additions.
00;05;44;02 - 00;05;45;23
DP
So, what is your role in the office?
00;05;45;29 - 00;06;26;00
PN
I'm a senior designer. I lead projects, teams that can be anywhere from just me to four or five architects, depending on the size of the project. And then we have interior design. HGA really is a full-service firm. We have architecture, interior design, mechanical, electrical, plumbing, structural, security, and AV. So, we can do it all, but we often will team up with other architecture firms around the country because we have an expertise that we can bring, which is in this case, museums and archives. So, we'll team up with locals and go after projects together, and that's what we did here in Pennsylvania.
00;06;26;02 - 00;06;30;14
DP
So, are you guys the architects of record or the design architects, or do you switch roles?
00;06;30;20 - 00;06;48;10
PN
Vitetta Architects is the executive architect, and we were the design architect. So, we had the upfront part of the project. We team together. We were always together working together, but we emphasized the front end of the project, and they were construction drawings and CA.
00;06;48;13 - 00;06;53;28
DP
All right, so let's jump into the building here. So, could you tell us a little bit about how your office got the project?
00;06;54;01 - 00;07;52;29
PN
You know, I wasn't there when we went after the project, but it's a typical story, I'm sure, which is there is a proposal out from an owner. They want a building, so they publish a proposal that anybody can submit to. And we looked for someone to team up with locally or they approached us, perhaps the local architect, Vitetta, and we've teamed up as a team and submitted a proposal. And then we were shortlisted, interviewed for it, and we were selected as the team to do it. We had experience doing museums and archives very recently before that, so that made a big impact on our selection.
I think it goes back to 2014 when we were selected for the project there initially was a different site. They went all the way through schematic on a site that was a green site on the edge of town. After schematic, they decided, no, we want to have a site that's closer to our capital complex in town. So, they found a different site and started design over, and that's when I joined the team.
00;07;53;01 - 00;07;59;04
DP
Wow. There's an original archive building, right? And that is done, I think in the brutalist style.
00;07;59;07 - 00;08;40;27
PN
Yeah, you could say that. It doesn't have many windows, so I could see how that would feel Brutalist. It's limestone, however, it's got a concrete structure, but the structure isn't expressed on the outside like you would typically see for brutalist architecture. It's at the Capitol grounds. It's 21 stories tall. And the problem with it is it's a low floor to floor, by today's standards. They considered upgrading it and expanding it, but they determined that the low floor to floor wouldn't allow them to create the updates they need for mechanical systems. Plus, there just wasn't enough space around it to move laterally. So, they decided the thing to do was to find a new site.
00;08;40;29 - 00;08;53;07
DP
So, I'm curious, when they came to you and this was their original building, did they talk at all about style? Clearly the floor heights were an issue. Did they say, “Hey, we don't want to do this again. We want something that's a little more contemporary”?
00;08;53;12 - 00;09;38;12
PN
Good question. Yes, they wanted a contemporary building. They wanted something that reflected today and the way we think about architecture today, which is great. The building that was built originally was a modern building, too. It was of its time. The History Museum is right next to it that will continue to be used. It was great that they wanted to look forward and be progressive about style, and I don't know if we ever talked style per se.
We just had already gone through schematic design. Like I said on this other site with another team. So, I think there was some sort of way of working that had already been established so that when I started on the new site as the lead designer, they had already had some confidence in us and were on board with the way we work.
00;09;38;15 - 00;09;43;13
DP
So, tell us a little bit about the programmatic requirements they came to you guys with.
00;09;43;15 - 00;11;52;13
PN
They wanted a full archive with plenty of space for growth into the future. So, of 146,000 square feet of this building, about 50,000 square feet is the archive storage spaces. The storage has different requirements depending on the kinds of documents it might be worth saying that the Pennsylvania State Archives collects, preserves, and makes available for study the permanently valuable public records of the Commonwealth, with particular attention given to the records of state government.
And as the Archives director, David Carmichael, once said, “they collect everything from parchment to pixels.” As a matter of fact, William Penn, who founded the Commonwealth in 1681, used a charter that gave him the right to establish the Commonwealth. And that charter is at the archives in Pennsylvania and as well as hundreds of millions of other documents that are important to the Commonwealth.
So, we needed to create spaces that allow them to continue to collect. So, it's important the whole process of how documents arrive at the site are brought in, brought into processing rooms, and then eventually put into storage. Quite often they're also photographed so that they can have a digital record of the document and a lot of the people who come in to do research, which is another big part of what they do, they collect and preserve, but they also provide these documents to the public for access, for research or just for curiosity and to learn.
So, there is this whole system of how documents are moving in and how they're being brought to the public to use and then put back into storage. The documents can be anything from large documents in flat files like maps. They can be eight and a half by eleven size. Some of the rooms need to be cool or even cold. So, there are different climates, let's say, in some of these rooms based on the type of media it is. For instance, film that they'll collect needs to be in a very cool environment. So, they have different climates in each space.
00;11;52;16 - 00;12;05;03
DP
Well, that's really interesting. So, let's go back a little bit. Tell us a little bit about the site. Are there any unique topographic features? Is it completely flat? Was it a pretty simple thing to put a building on it?
00;12;05;05 - 00;13;08;18
PN
Yeah, it's a three-acre site and there are two main streets on the west and east side. Sixth Street on the west is about one story above Seventh Street, which is on the East. And Seventh Street is a main feeder artery that comes into town, while sixth is more of a residential neighborhood or semi commercial residential. So, we put the public entry on Sixth Street, which is up a level which means of the four level building, there's a lower level that's a walk out, let's say on the east side.
And then the public enters on what we call first floor, which is one level up from the lower level. The site is also L-shaped, which sounds like it could be a problem, but it really isn't because it's a large enough site that it provides for the building and public space. So, we were able to create a nice plaza out front and lots of landscaping in front of the building to provide a public amenity, let's say, to the people who live in the community and anyone who's visiting.
00;13;08;21 - 00;13;11;23
DP
Did you guys have any challenging restrictions, in terms of zoning?
00;13;11;26 - 00;14;22;26
PN
There were challenges with infrastructure. We had some issues needing to connect the archive with the state capital complex with fiber optics. So, there was a fiber optic line that had to come underground all the way to our site and that was done on a different contract. But we also had a lot of flexibility. For instance, there were streetlights and so on around the site and in some cases, especially on the front where we met the public, we were able to move the streetlights across the street from us because we just didn't think it would be nice having all the lights and lines right out in front of the building.
So, there was some infrastructural work that was done more on a urban scale level to help accommodate this building. Also add that at the same time that we were doing this building, there was a federal courthouse being put in, which is just about completed now too, at the same time. So, these two large buildings that are within a couple of blocks from each other going in at the same time was interesting.
And we actually worked – we had one meeting with the local architect, the design architects of that building, so that we could coordinate a little bit on what some of the public lighting would look like.
00;14;22;28 - 00;14;44;05
DP
The building stylistically, you've got this large glass atrium space and you've got this metal framed armature that wraps that. And then I'm assuming going off in the other direction, you've got a very large block that is made out of masonry. Is that correct?
00;14;44;07 - 00;16;25;19
PN
That's right. We took that stated purpose, the mission statement of the archive, which is the archive collects, preserves, and makes available for study. We took those three ideas, and we turned them into form and gave each form its own material. So, for instance, “collects” is the storage of the archives. That became a form that you just described as masonry.
They preserve, and mechanical systems are an important part of preservation. We have the unique situation of all of the mechanical systems needing to be off to the side of the archive that couldn't be on top of the archive because we couldn't risk any sort of liquids leaking out of mechanical systems into the archives. So, all of the mechanical systems are in their own bay off to the side. That's the preservation part. And we use metal panels to describe that bay.
And then finally, “making available to the public,” there was a public element of it, and in this case, we made it a glass pavilion and we used an aluminum extruded solar shade custom made to protect people from direct sunlight but provide lots of daylight. So, it's very open, very visible. You drive by it on Sixth Street and great views in and out to the street and from the road in. But it's got its own expression from the other elements. And so those three elements look very different from each other. They each really have a different personality, but they're all neutral in color. They're grays from white to medium gray, nothing - it's a very tight range of neutral tones.
00;16;25;23 - 00;16;35;09
DP
Yeah, for a storage facility, it's pretty welcoming. The elevation with the glass and this metal armature is really quite lovely.
00;16;35;15 - 00;16;36;07
PN
Thank you.
00;16;36;10 - 00;16;51;15
DP
So, I saw some really interesting studies in your emails back and forth with Glen-Gery in regard to the colors that you ultimately chose for the facades. There's really a lot there. Could you tell us a little bit about that?
00;16;51;17 - 00;20;13;16
PN
That's a great part of the story. We knew that the archive wing would be enveloped by a long expanse of wall. Archives don't want to have windows, so there were not going to be many windows and this building was going to be up to four stories tall. So, we wanted to make sure that what we put on the building would be something that would be out of the ordinary. And we didn't have the budget for limestone. The Capitol complex is limestone. The original building was that way, but we wanted something durable and where we could allude in some way to what was going on at the Capitol. We thought brick is durable. It's a good candidate for an archive because of that, and we wanted to make some connection to the limestone.
We began looking for a light-colored brick, very neutral, something that could echo that limestone. But clay doesn't come in neutrals like we wanted it. You know, Clay typically is in the Browns, yellow reds. You can get it to be black or very close to black. But everything we found seemed to be a little bit too warm. The closest we could get was a very light-yellow brick, and even then, it just felt a little too warm. So, we started considering clay slip coatings that are available on the market for bricks that could be applied to the brick to get a lighter and more neutral look. And that's when we came across Glen-Gery. We found some buildings on the Internet that traced us back to Glen-Gery. I don't remember how, but we were able to find them. And then Glen-Gery could make custom colors in the matte, but they also could make glossy glazed finishes. So that's when we started to consider that. And from there we began a conversation with them about brick colors and finishes.
Eventually I took a trip to their plant up in northern Pennsylvania. One time I landed in Pittsburgh, rented a car, drove up to their plant, and then from there I went to a client meeting in Harrisburg. It was really a fun visit just to see that plant work and meet with the artist. They had like an artist lab or chem lab where they can mix custom colors. And we had really good conversations and that really convinced me that this had a lot of potential. It wasn't a shoe in, it wasn't sure yet that we could go this route, but I just felt like there was a path to get there.
And eventually we went the route of glazed brick over the matte finish. We found the shine and reflectance of the wall surface potentially very appealing, especially on a large building with so few windows. Second, there was a side benefit with the glazed brick, and we believe that it would help resist graffiti and make it easier to clean because we were in an area where graffiti could be an issue. So that was another selling point for going that direction. It certainly worked in terms of getting the state to back that idea of going with a glazed brick, because I think it just seemed very unusual that a building would be entirely covered with glazed brick, and it helped that we were using very subdued colors like grays. We have five colors. It's a range of grays. And when you stand back, they kind of blend together. It creates what I like to call a heathered look. You know, if this were a knit sweater, it would be using heathered gray yarn and it kind of all blends together.
00;20;13;16 - 00;20;22;16
DP
Well, when the bricks glaze, does it reflect images or light or is there anything special about the facade when you stand back and look at it, other than the color?
00;20;22;23 - 00;20;51;12
PN
In a surprising way, that was very pleasant, once it got put up – especially on that north side where it's a long wall of brick – we were really surprised and pleased to see that on a cloudy day as the clouds are going over, it reflects the sky and the clouds, enough really to - it's not like a mirror, but it gives you a nice feeling that this building is somehow relating to the sky. So we really like that part of it.
00;20;51;14 - 00;21;01;19
DP
It all sounds really cool. Before we wrap this part of the conversation up, tell me about the mockups you guys did for the colors of the brick. They're really cool. It was a great idea.
00;21;01;22 - 00;22;22;18
PN
Yeah. Thanks. We started just by getting Sherwin-Williams paint chips. They make eight by ten paint samples. We pulled out a whole bunch of neutral colors with little bits of warm and cool associated with them and had them sent to us. Then we took the ones that we found most appealing, and we created a brick shape with using chipboard, glued them down, and then we started to assemble different quantities and proportions of different colors and just started mixing things until we saw something that looked appealing.
So, we created this mockup model where we could try different proportions. We kept records of how many of this color, how many of that on each set up that we did. And we created a whole series of these that we could first show ourselves and figure out which ones we liked the best. And then we took them to the client and showed them to them and tried to find where the sweet spot was for this blend.
From there we started to work with Glen-Gery to actually come up with samples, glazed brick samples. They weren't full bricks right away. They were just pieces of clay, small, maybe four by three inches, for starters, until we could come up with something closer to the actual colors we'd want to consider.
00;22;22;21 - 00;22;45;28
DP
You know, what's so surprising to me is you take five colors, put them together on a board. You've got 30 or 40 bricks. Each one of these samples, you stand back, and you look at, I'm just blown away that you can do that on a facade, and it never looks busy. You stand back and it becomes like another color. It becomes the color in-between all the colors. How did you even know that was going to happen?
00;22;46;00 - 00;23;31;00
PN
That's a good question. You're digging into the way we had to think about this. You know, some of our mockups had more contrast. Some of them had less contrast. And I think you need to find that point where the contrast is enough to give some variety and not make it look homogenous. But you don't want it to be so contrasty that it starts to look speckled. We didn't want to speckled looking, building, so it was just a matter of setting things up, looking at them close and then walking away and looking at them from, you know, 100 feet away and just see how well they blend together. It's like pixels, right, on your computer. These were really just physical pixels. And the farther you get back, the more they blend.
00;23;31;03 - 00;23;47;29
DP
So, at the end of the day, when you guys were all done with the job, was there anything that you learned that was really interesting about the design or the construction process? Again, as an aside, being the designer architects, it's got to be interesting handing a job over and then coming back to it as it nears completion, right?
00;23;48;01 - 00;24;39;20
PN
Yeah. And fortunately, we had a great working relationship with Vitetta, Daniel Wasik, the architect who led the team at Vitetta, who did a wonderful job. We had a good relationship and all the way through construction drawings, we were actively reviewing the drawings with them and participating in meetings. They were leading that process at that point from there on out but we were still involved. And even during construction administration, I didn't get to go to the site until late in the game. However, we were getting pictures from them monthly, lots of pictures. They were really good about it. They would tell us if there were any issues, we'd work it through together. So, it really worked well. And I have to say, I've never worked with a local architect that well before. It was a wonderful relationship and I’d love to work with them again sometime.
00;24;39;23 - 00;24;43;03
DP
That's really cool. Did the GC have any trouble finding a good mason?
00;24;43;10 - 00;24;45;05
PN
I know that there were issues.
00;24;45;05 - 00;24;47;11
DP
It's always an issue.
00;24;47;14 - 00;25;23;03
PN
Yeah. I mean, when I look at the building, it was well done overall.
You know, we had some complicated pieces to it too. For instance, we had an overhang at the front entry with brick hanging ten feet out, cantilever out over the entryway, and we designed it so that the brick at the bottom was not supported by an angle. We hid the structure and hung those two courses at the bottom from a structure up inside the wall. So, we were able to glaze even the underside of the brick hanging out over that cantilever, which wasn't an easy thing to accomplish.
00;25;23;03 - 00;25;24;17
DP
Yeah, it sounds expensive.
00;25;24;23 - 00;25;44;28
PN
It was, but it's a state building and you want it to be done right, and further, I don't know if you've had this experience on your work, but I've gone back to visit buildings sometimes that are years old, ten years old maybe, and some of those angles that support brick can start to rust. So, we wanted to avoid having that happen on a building this important.
00;25;45;00 - 00;26;04;20
DP
Yeah. And you know, you're going to make a few statements in the architecture and that's one really big one right at the front of the building. Very cool. So, before you go, you've been at this for 30 years or so. If you could give yourself – your younger self some career advice, what would it be?
00;26;04;22 - 00;26;49;17
PN
Oh, boy. Well, I do meet with mentees – we have a mentorship program here at HGA, which is highly valued by the people who are just starting out in their careers. And sometimes what I'll tell them is try to pay attention to everything you do, even the details. And not just focus on the big picture because the more you can know about the way buildings are specifically put together, the more you can understand about the structure and the other disciplines, the better you can be at making those decisions and choices at the beginning of your project. And so, I always encourage architects, especially people who are interested in being designers, to learn every aspect of the project down to the details.
00;26;49;20 - 00;26;56;24
DP
Yeah, if you're not interested in being a lifelong learner, architecture may not be the right profession for you.
00;26;56;26 - 00;26;57;16
PN
That's true.
00;26;57;16 - 00;26;59;28
DP
Right? You're always learning something.
00;27;00;06 - 00;27;01;08
PN
I'm still learning.
00;27;01;12 - 00;27;08;25
DP
Oh, yeah, I am too. Every day. So, Paul, it's been great to have you here. Thanks for your time. Where can people go to learn more about HGA architects?
00;27;08;25 - 00;27;18;15
PN
They would go to hga.com, and we've got our projects there that you can look at, and our teams, our people. It's a fun place to go.
TRANSCRIPT
00;27;18;18 - 00;27;21;25
DP
That's great. It sounds like a really interesting place to work.
00;27;22;00 - 00;27;34;05
PN
It is. I really enjoy it. There's a lot of smart people here and I'm so glad that I get to play the role I play. But I also admire those people who play all the other roles that we have at this firm.
00;27;34;08 - 00;27;34;28
DP
That's great, Paul. Thank you.
00;27;35;01 - 00;27;39;18
PN
Thank you. It was a pleasure.
You May Also Be Interested In
We Can Help With Your Next Project
Discover the latest + greatest in design trends, industry news & pro tips from pros.
For all of your project needs, you’ll find everything you need at a Supply Center.
Let Us Know How We Can Help!
Design Vault Ep. 10 44 Union Square with Todd Poisson
ABOUT THE ARCHITECT:
![]()
|
For Todd Poisson, great design is beautiful, inventive, buildable, and responsible. Uniquely, Todd is both a big picture thinker and a stickler for details, with natural talent for building consensus. By collaborating closely with colleagues and clients, he consistently achieves multi-faceted success on his projects, for today's beneficiaries and generations to come.
An exemplary leader of complex teams, Todd's current work is mainly comprised of ground-up buildings in New York City. Particularly notable are The Jefferson and Citizen Manhattan condominiums, as well as 529 Broadway, a six-story retail building in the Soho Cast Iron District, who facade reflects its context with a gradient from the punched windows of one historic neighbor to the expansive glazing of the next. Todd's interest in the tools of architectural practice, as well as his commitment to excellence in project delivery, result in his teams being at the forefront of today's design research, technologies, and processes.
In addition to architecture, Todd has a contagious passion for sports. He is an active volunteer with the American Youth Soccer Organization and a former coach and referee of regional leagues. In addition, Todd is a lecturer and interviewer for Cornell University's College of Architecture, Art, and Planning, of which is an alumnus. |
---|
44 Union Square
BKSK
View ProjectTRANSCRIPT
00;00;00;00 - 00;00;05;16
Doug Patt (DP)
Let's go inside the vault. The design vault.
00;00;05;19 - 00;00;34;08
Todd Poisson (TP)
They wanted to expand the building, and a vertical expansion is taboo for individual landmarks. So, in order to get them any significant square footage additions up there, we wanted to go bold. Why not propose a more robust, bold roof scape? And given the history of Chief Tamanend being the namesake of Tammany and with this desire to really honor the Lenape, why not be inspired by the Lenape's origin story of a rising turtle coming out of the water, shedding water?
00;00;34;11 - 00;03;33;28
DP
This is my guest, Todd Poisson. I'll share more about him shortly. In this episode from the Design Vault, we’ll highlight Todd's project, 44 Union Square.
44 Union Square sits at the northeast corner of Union Square Park in Manhattan. The project includes a remarkable contemporary steel and glass dome addition to the storied landmark building on Union Square's northeast corner for Redding International Ink.
The new building expands the usable square footage of the historic building and adds an iconic anchor to Union Square. The building's former life was as the last headquarters for the political machine, Tammany Hall, an American organization founded in 1786, famous for controlling New York City and state politics for a time.
The restoration and expansion of the building includes preserving two facades, new bronze storefronts in the likeness of the original 1928 design and a three-story rooftop addition. This wild steel and glass building cap is composed of a self-supporting free form shell grid dome atop a reconstructed hipped roof with gray terracotta sunshades.
If you're wondering, the New York City Landmarks Preservation Commission unanimously approved this incredibly creative design.
Hi, I'm Doug Pat and this is Design Vault.
Today we're talking to Todd Poisson. Todd received his Bachelor of Architecture degree from Cornell University. He became a partner at BKSK in 2007 and has over 30 years of experience in the architecture profession. Todd has been responsible for the design and construction of some of the firm's most ambitious projects, ranging between residential mixed use and institutional works. Recent award-winning projects include the Gansevoort Row redevelopment for Aurora Capital and 44 Union Square, which we'll discuss today.
Other notable recent projects of Todd's are 200 East 21st Street, a 20 story, highly sustainable residential tower in Gramercy for Alpha Development and 470 Columbus, a passive house, multifamily development on the Upper West Side for the Rowe Corporation. Todd is currently a volunteer with the American Youth Soccer Organization and a long-term coach of regional athletic leagues.
In addition, Todd is a lecturer and volunteer interviewer for Cornell University's College of Architecture, Art, and Planning. So welcome, Todd. Nice to have you with us today.
We're going to talk about 44 Union Square. But before we do, I should mention that we recently interviewed one of Todd's peers at BKSK, David Kubik. He told us a bit about the firm. But for those who haven't listened to that episode, tell us a little bit about BKSK in New York City. Where are you guys located? What's the size of the firm and what type of work do you do?
00;03;34;01 - 00;04;31;07
TP
Sure. So, thank you for having me. BKSK Architects is headquartered in New York City in Manhattan, not too far away from your center here on West 38th Street in the garment center of Manhattan. We've been in business since 1985 celebrating 38 years. David and I are kind of second-generation partners. We've been in business about 38 years. We have over 200 built projects. David and I both joined the firm about 20 years ago plus and were made partners about the same time.
BKSK specializes in many things. We like to say if you know New York, you know our work. Our work is kind of separated between, generally speaking, cultural, institutional work, libraries, religious structures, parks, and commercial buildings and residential buildings. Residential projects ranging from new condominium buildings, towers or private residential projects, combining units or renovating someone's home.
00;04;31;10 - 00;04;34;01
DP
Do you guys do residential projects outside of New York City?
00;04;34;07 - 00;04;45;21
TP
We do. In fact, we have a little annex office out in Oklahoma City that we had so much Midwest work. Now we have private residential projects, upstate New York and in Connecticut and in New Jersey.
00;04;45;23 - 00;04;53;11
DP
So, tell us a little bit about yourself. How did you end up at BKSK? How long have you been there – I believe you just said that. What's your role in the office?
00;04;53;13 - 00;05;49;13
TP
Well, I joined back in 1998. So, 25 years ago I answered a New York Times wanted ad – remember those, actually where you had to get the newspaper Saturday, the Sunday paper? You got to subscribe to get them a day early to rifle through the want ads. And I answered a want ad for a project manager at an architecture firm called Burns, Kendall, Schieferdecker, with this crazy name. I thought it was a law firm. Back then there was no websites. You couldn't look up the firms. You had to go to these places, and you'd open the front door and you'd be disappointed but had to sit through the interviews to see what kind of work they did.
But the moment I met George Schieferdecker – he interviewed me 25 years ago, he's still there, one of the founding partners – knew immediately that I had found the mothership. You know, these guys knew each other from school way back. They were so intellectual. They all had lives outside the office. This was not a sweatshop kind of architecture firm that one sometimes encounters. And I've just had just a great time with them.
00;05;49;16 - 00;06;05;23
DP
It's funny, when you were saying that, all these awful memories started flooding in of making one phone call after another and going through the phone book and then showing up and knowing nothing about the work of that architect, and endless interviews. So where were you working before BKSK?
00;06;05;25 - 00;06;23;21
TP
I was here in Manhattan already. I was working for Stephen Jacobs Group, an architect who specialized, at the time, in new construction residential work. So, I really cut my teeth as a young architect in the field, hardcore development construction experience in Manhattan, which has paid off a great deal.
00;06;23;24 - 00;06;28;20
DP
So now you're partners. So, what's your role like now? Has it changed significantly?
00;06;28;22 - 00;07;48;02
TP
Sure. So over time, our roles change as partners as we grow in the firm. David and I and Julie Nelson, the other second-generation partner. Julie, David, and I really grew up there and our roles have evolved from being in the trenches and drawing every line and every detail for projects that get built. Lucky for us, our sites tend to be in Manhattan.
We're also a little bit regional. We have some work in New Jersey and Philadelphia and Connecticut, but still about 80% in Manhattan. So, we are very lucky. We could visit sites very easily to get hands on experience. And so, our roles really evolved quickly into project management, into client facing roles, consultant coordination, field work. When we were promoted to partners, our roles shift gradually into more finding work, finding new work, finding repeat clients, developing those relationships to continue getting new projects, setting the design direction for new projects, and then just kind of being the face of the project.
We pride ourselves to being involved with every phase of design as partners. We don't just disappear after landing a new project. We really stay involved in the trenches at meetings. I just came from a mechanical coordination meeting for a new hotel project we're doing. I really love that stuff. I really love the details – love the field work as well as the design and the client facing opportunities.
00;07;48;04 - 00;07;51;00
DP
I'm curious how big was BKSK when you joined them?
00;07;51;07 - 00;07;54;08
TP
So, they were about 15 people, I think, in 1998.
00;07;54;12 - 00;07;55;15
DP
And now you're 50.
00;07;55;15 - 00;07;57;19
TP
We're about 50, 52 people. Yes.
00;07;57;26 - 00;08;03;24
DP
Interesting. I love the field stuff, too. I love the people stuff. It's just the best part of the job.
00;08;03;26 - 00;08;21;19
TP
The soap opera arcs during it, like a seven, eight year project are just terrific. We refer to them at project meetings or say previously on this project in season two, you might recall that the elevator consultant said the opposite of what you just said. Like years later, it's a way to keep things light at these construction meetings.
00;08;21;23 - 00;08;22;20
DP
That is really funny.
00;08;23;04 - 00;08;43;02
TP
We try to keep it light and funny, and the construction industry has changed a great deal, as you could imagine, along with everything else. But in the last 35 years since I've been working, you know, sites are tech savvy. It seems to be it's a much more civilized kind of operation, and there's opportunities to really develop great relationships with the builders and consultants.
00;08;43;09 - 00;08;50;28
DP
Great insight. Totally true. So, let's dig in here and talk about the building. Tell us about 44 Union Square. So how did your office get the project?
00;08;51;00 - 00;17;44;06
TP
So back in 2012, the phone rang. It was Michael Buckley calling from Edifice Real Estate Partners. He invited us – because of our strength of our record of getting very challenging approvals through the Landmark Commission of New York City – invited us to join, I think it was a group of five firms that competed in a competition that lasted a month of design work, and then we each presented our work to the owner, Margaret Cotter of Redding International that month.
The design happened to coincide with when Hurricane Sandy hit Manhattan. So, our office, like many offices in Lower Manhattan, lost power. So, I brought the competition work home with me, and at the time I had a five-year-old daughter, and she sat in my lap, and we drew together. It really resonates with me to this day because fast forward ten years and there we were finishing the project during a global pandemic where we all had to work from home again. So, this project really bookended two kind of catastrophes in New York City, starting with Hurricane Sandy, working from home and then ending with the pandemic and closing out the project in 2020, using my daughter's big scooter to scoot down to Union Square. During the height of the pandemic, as work was finishing up.
So anyway, Michael invited BKSK to join this limited design competition. I dived into the history of the building. We're all students of history. We feel that every project, even if it's not a landmark project, has its history, has context to learn from. And immediately I learned the story of Tammany Hall that was different from what we're all taught in school, at least in the Northeast. We're taught that Tammany Hall is synonymous with greed and corruption and graft. And while that's all true, Tammany Hall is not named after an Irish politician of the 19th century, which you might think given the Boss Tweed stories and the background of Tammany Hall, that's in the social conscious. But in fact, the namesake of Tammany Hall is an indigenous 17th century chief, Chief Tamanend of the Lenape, who signed a peaceful coexistence treaty with William Penn in 1680, an event that's documented in our Capitol's rotunda in Washington, DC, rules that really held in place for quite some time.
Chief Tamanend was revered and legendary to the European settlers as a native representative who welcomed visitors and who wanted to listen to all voices. And listening to all voices became kind of the theme of these early social clubs, which became known as Tammany Societies. We were surprised to learn that there were dozens of these Tammany societies that dotted the East Coast from New York to Cleveland in the early days of the Republic, and I think they even predated the revolution. I think they, maybe, formalized themselves after the revolution, but the clubhouses began even before the American Revolution, where people joined and sat around talking about what ideals the New Republic should represent. And they chose Chief Tamanend to represent them as a symbol of listening to all voices. Over the centuries that story was lost. The only Tammany society to make it into the 20th century was ours here in New York, only to become known for craft, greed and corruption.
So right from the beginning we thought it was an opportunity to rebrand the building in Chief Tamanend’s name – kind of erase this idea that Tammany is associated with just greed and corruption, but is associated with the indigenous population of North America, of the Northeast, especially of the Lenape. Given that background, looking at this Neo-Georgian red brick and limestone building at the corner Union Square, which was designed originally to emulate Federal Hall downtown. Federal Hall is where George Washington was inaugurated on the balcony. Federal Hall was demolished in 1812, but it looked like Tammany Hall does today, except Federal Hall had a much more robust roof line, had a big hipped roof and a cupola, whereas Tammany Hall and Union Square chose the architects Thompson, Holmes, and Converse out of Philadelphia in 1928 – chose to replicate the federal Hall facade quite literally, but they gave Tammany Hall here in Union Square a much more tepid roof.
And so, the thought was, given the brief from Edifice for Redding International, they wanted to expand the building, they wanted to rebrand the building, but they knew it was a landmark. They knew it was an individual New York City landmark. So, demolition was out of the question. And a vertical expansion is taboo for individual landmarks. Typically, the New York City Landmarks Commission approves maybe a handful each year, but they're very difficult to convince the commission that it's an appropriate addition to the base landmark. Union Square is such a vast public space that we knew immediately that even if you put like a shampoo bottle on top of the roof, it would be seen from across the square. So, in order to get them any significant square footage addition up there, we wanted to go bold. We felt that, given this Neo-Georgian base that used to have or was modeled after a building that had a bigger roof, why not propose a more robust, bold roof scape?
So, the question is what form should that take? And given the history of Chief Tamanend being the namesake of Tammany, and with this desire to really honor the Lenape, why not be inspired by the Lenape’s origin story of a giant turtle rising from the sea, creating land to give this Neo-Georgian building the dome that it would have, could have, should have had if Tammany Hall perhaps was more honest with its intentions in 1928, when Thompson, Holmes, and Converse designed this building, which really cloaked them in kind of quasi-governmental garb at this very federal style red brick and limestone building with a pediment, portico, but a tepid roof.
So, we decided to model a very contemporary glass and steel dome modeled after a rising turtle coming out of the water, shedding water as the kind of volume to hold, to house three additional floors. And the landmarks, as you mentioned, Landmarks Commission unanimously approved it. We only had to go back once to tweak the height of the dome and some of the details.
The dome kind of erupts from a reconstructed hip roof. So, we removed the slate hip roof and recreated it in the same inclined plane with terracotta sunshades that intermittently cover the beginning of the glass and steel dome. So, the glass and steel dome starts off as in the form of a hip roof, but then quickly transforms into this parametric shell that looks like classically proportioned when one stands in front of it in Union Square. Looks like any other dome on a classic building, in terms of its proportion. But when one turns the corner and looks more obliquely on it, its organic source kind of becomes more apparent. You kind of sense something is going on there and it's turtle like as it faces north over this arched pediment that was top of the Tammany Hall's balustrade in the middle of the East 17th Street North facade.
The original building had this odd arch pediment that was kind of just vertically cantilever in there. We didn't quite realize what it was until we looked more into the history of Tammany Hall. And sure enough, they used to – before this building was built in 1928 – they occupied a clubhouse on East 14th Street down at the other corner of Union Square. And on top of that building is a giant arched, decorative element with, in fact, a 15-foot-tall statue of Chief Tamanend. That building was demolished for ConEd’s expansion in the 1920s, and that's what spurred Tammany Hall to move to this location on the northeast corner of Union Square. Chief Tamanend is only recalled on our facade in 1928 with a headshot, a limestone medallion that faces, on the north facade, over what was Tammany Hall's front door. So, the classical portico facade that faces Union Square was really always a commercial facade. The ground floor was always a retail store location. In 1928 was a manufacturer's trust bank, for example. And now just last week, we celebrated the grand opening of Petco as the new national headquarters giant, 30,000 square foot new store in the ground floor cellar and second floor of the building.
So, it's still a retail presence. And then the upper floors are remodeled to be open office space. So Tammany Hall's front door used to be below that arched pediment facing northeast 17th Street and that's where we decided to kind of turn the turtle's head on the roof. So, the glass dome takes on a little bit more of a turtle-like form as it turns its head to give that arched pediment a little bit of a home. And we think it gives it a little bit more of a reason to exist than it ever did before. And it signals that that was Tammany's front door, once upon a time.
00;17;44;08 - 00;18;00;17
DP
Wow. Some great information. There's so much to talk about here, you know, it reminds me of - I'm still a big fan of Coop Himmelblau, it's far more organized, right – but it reminds me of that kind of approach to architecture. So, there were five entries. Did you see the entries?
00;18;00;23 - 00;18;39;25
TP
We never saw the other entries. We presented our work to Margaret at Redding, like December of 2012, after a bit of a delay because of Hurricane Sandy. We were awarded the project. It took about a year for contracts and everything to be negotiated to become their architect, but we were awarded the project so roughly late 2013. We brought it to the Landmarks Commission in, I believe in 2014. We received final building department and Landmarks approval in the following year or so, and then it took a few years to build. It was interrupted a bit by the pandemic, but we finished. Construction was finished in 2020.
00;18;39;28 - 00;18;42;16
DP
So, start to finish, how long was it then?
00;18;42;19 - 00;18;54;08
TP
From the day the phone rang in 2012 to 2020. So about eight years. We've stayed on call as the landlord's architect to help coordinate work for the tenants looking at space inside.
00;18;54;13 - 00;18;58;17
DP
And this was mostly a renovation project, but there was some new construction?
00;18;58;24 - 00;20;29;26
TP
So that's great that you ask that because it appears from a lot of photographs and even as you walk around it and even when you're in it, it's hard to realize that it's actually a new building behind the 100-year-old street walls. Everything was removed except the two street-facing walls. So, we think that's a real success, that people think it is a rooftop addition with maybe a little renovation inside, because that really was the intent to be as deferential and respectful of the historic landmark as possible. But, in fact, everything was removed. The historic masonry walls were decoupled from the structure. They were braced in place by tower braces that had their own foundation systems through the sidewalk, including through a giant vault that lines the 17th Street side that has a giant ConEd steam pipe running through it. So very complex coordination that the structural engineers at Thornton Tomasetti coordinated with our construction managers at CNY to develop this very intricate tower bracing system.
I should mention Buro Happold also as engineers of the project. So, the facades were decoupled from the structure. Everything was removed inside, including the foundation. A deeper foundation was dug to give the building a very deep cellar and six new stories. So, what was a three-story building with the little caretaker's apartment hidden behind the hipped roof at the front is now a 70,000 square foot class-A commercial building, growing from about 35,000 to begin with.
00;20;29;29 - 00;20;32;23
DP
So, you had to match the existing brick.
00;20;32;26 - 00;24;16;27
TP
So yes, finally we could talk about brick. Big part of the project was restoring those two street walls, the two 100-year-old historic street walls that are red brick and limestone, modeled after Federal Hall downtown. We researched the brick. Our design partners at Buro Happold gave us a roadmap – and the restoration contractors at Pullman – very detailed road map of the two street facades of which parts needed to be replaced. But remarkably, not a lot of the brick had to be removed. We did repoint 100% of the brick, meaning partially removing, breaking back the mortar joints and replacing the mortar. The front about three-quarters-inch of mortar on all the joints, but only replaced maybe about 15, 10%, maybe less of the brick.
The brick we found; we researched where the brick was in 1928. It was from the old Virginia brick company in Salem, Virginia. And we found an advertisement in 1929 after the building was completed, and they are bragging about their new building on Union Square, and they are linking it – as a Virginia company, they’re proud of this project for many reasons – but including the fact that Tammany Hall was linked to Thomas Jefferson's ideals and Thomas Jefferson, of course, is from Virginia and is famous for designing his home at Monticello. So, the old Virginia brick company has this advertisement that we found in the Archives of Public Library here in New York that they link the brick here at Tammany Hall to the brick used at Monticello. But if you read the fine print, it's not literally the same brick, it's not from the same kilns. They say it's, quote, “in the same size and made in the same kind of cherry and maple molds as those of Jefferson's beloved Monticello.” So even though Salem, Virginia, which is right next to Roanoke, Virginia, still is about, these days, even a two hour drive from Monticello, they wanted to connect themselves to the legacy of Thomas Jefferson with this new building for Tammany Hall, which was pretending to be or, you know, acting as a quasi-governmental building.
They were really a social agency too. We shouldn't forget that even though that they were known for terrible greed and corruption and fixed elections and did all kinds of bad stuff, they really operated as a social service organization for newly arrived immigrants here in New York City. So, they, however, used Lenape iconography in ways that weren't so appealing to us, from our point of view, looking back. They didn't care for the land of a people. They use their imagery. They used Chief Tamanend's name, but they didn't necessarily care for the Lenape people. And we wanted to reintroduce the Lenape authentic voice into this project. So early on, right after we won the competition, we reached out to the Lenape center here in Manhattan. We wanted to make sure that we weren't offending people by the use of Chief Tamanend’s clan's symbol of the rising turtle. We met with Joe Baker and Hadrien Coumans, some of the co-founders of the Lenape Center here in Manhattan, and they were thrilled. I was so relieved with their reaction when we showed them this design, a good ten years ago now. And they've been friends ever since. They've been great proponents of the project. They supported it through the regulatory process, writing letters to the Landmarks Commission, appearing with us side by side. So, they've been a great partner with this, and we've shared the design as it developed with them. So, we like to think of them as one of our collaborators in this project. It wasn't part of the brief, it wasn't part of the commercial real estate project, but we kind of thought it was very important to bring an authentic voice to this project from the Lenape point of view.
00;24;16;29 - 00;24;28;08
DP
So, we know that you guys had to match the existing brick out there. Was it challenging to find a brick that you could use, and what was that process? What did you ultimately go with?
00;24;28;10 - 00;25;50;02
TP
So, looking at the existing conditions of the brick walls, they were in remarkably good shape, considering it was 100-year-old building. We removed maybe five, ten percent of them. We used our construction manager partners at CNY, hired Pullman, incredibly talented folk at Pullman to restore the brick. They used, I think it was like a four-inch diameter grinder blade to remove the first, say, three quarters of an inch of mortar out of all the joints. 100% of the joints were repointed with mortar that we selected to match the original mortar.
The bricks themselves are an incredible mixture of Glen-Gery molded brick, and Heathcote, and spec sand DD-58, and Catawba, and a Roanoke Original. So that is all mixed in to create the dappled, dark red, velvety, rich red brick that are dappled with a very dark rowlock. Some of the rowlocks are very dark, so there's many bricks that are mixed into this, specifically chosen for each moment, each part of the facade that was being replaced. It's only about ten or twelve bricks at a time, in little clumps, that had to be replaced where there was a crack that was going through them. So that's how we restored the Flemish bond of the building. That bond of the landmark has a beautiful Flemish bond pattern to it that we restored.
00;25;50;05 - 00;26;02;13
DP
So, let's go back to the roof for a little bit. Was there any discussion internally when you were working on the design that it was just way too contemporary? This was not going to fly?
00;26;02;15 - 00;27;41;12
TP
Sure. So, we looked through history at examples of iconic, bold, contemporary rooftop additions onto landmark or historic structures. We looked at, specifically, for example, the Reichstag in Berlin. Lord Foster designed a striking, bold, contemporary glass dome onto the government building in Berlin. Of course, they lost their dome through war and bombing, and it was reconstructed in a contemporary fashion. But, interestingly enough the original Reichstag Dome did have glass in it. That's a fascinating case study for us.
We also looked at other freeform shell grid structures. That is the technical name for this structural system that can span over vast spaces without any vertical supports. So, the entire dome, the entire roof is not supported by any internal column or wall. It rests on new perimeter concrete walls that go all the way down to the new foundation. The loads are distributed down columns that are in between all the windows, in the historic facade, down to the new foundation in the cellar. So, we looked at Foster's courtyard cover at the British Museum, for example, that utilizes the same kind of system of freeform shell grid, which is also boldly, iconically, contemporary against a landmark base. The thought here was by restoring the base, by restoring all the brickwork and the limestone, we strengthen the landmark base in order to allow it to have a contrasting style on the roof, that the roof could be strikingly contemporary as long as we paid attention and were respectful to the restoration of the base.
00;27;41;14 - 00;27;55;03
DP
So, I read a little bit about the solar insulation, light infiltration. You were concerned glare clearly was going to be an issue. Could you elaborate on the probability studies you did investigating those elements and how they impacted design?
00;27;55;03 - 00;29;31;14
TP
Our partners at Buro Happold did fascinating studies with daylight. We directed them and wanted to make sure that we weren't going to cause reflection problems with this parabolic to other buildings. There are some case studies around the world of curved glass buildings causing problems to their neighbors, including there's one in London that focuses heat to the degree that it was causing fires on the sidewalk across the street. So, we certainly did not want to be known for that. So Buro Happold helped us study the probability of reflection on to the neighbors. We pinpointed the pieces of glass that would be the culprits – the whole selection process of the type of glass, with Buro Happold's help and all their studies – it was determined that a combination of tint and clear glass was the solution to inhibit reflection, but also to prevent too much solar heat gain and also to prevent too much internal glare.
So, from the outside, the glass appears a bit dark. On sunny days, it's reflective just enough to give it a shiny kind of silvery tone, and you can see the clouds, but it doesn't reflect rays of sunlight directly, like laser beams into the neighbors. And while you're on the inside, even though the glass on the outside has a darker appearance from the inside, your eyeballs adjust and it's all color corrected. Your eyes don't see dark. They see blue sky. They see the beautiful terracotta details of the neighboring historic buildings. It was, in the end, success of glass selection to inhibit all those potential problems.
00;29;31;16 - 00;29;40;17
DP
So, did your team learn anything interesting through the design and construction process doing something this unique? I would imagine you've never done a roof like this in the office before.
00;29;40;21 - 00;30;52;21
TP
We haven’t. It's our first freeform shell grid. It was New York's first freeform shell grid. There is a similar covering at Moynihan Train Hall to their barrel vaults, but they opened six months after we did, so we are happy to say, after an eight-year design process and construction, we kept saying we're going to be New York's first freeform shell grid. We're the first one to enclose internal space. I think there's a similar system that might be on some like entry canopies. There's one for like the seven-train extension to Hudson Yards and there's one out in Yonkers, but those do not enclose covered space and they're not nearly this large. So, we're proud to say we're New York's first freeform shell grid.
They use acres of this system in Asia and Europe. It's a very common system to span large swaths of space. It is used here in this country. For example, we visited the Smithsonian Institute down in Washington, DC. The Portrait Gallery has a courtyard cover that's similar to the British Museum cover. Foster came here and did kind of an encore for us in 2007 with the Smithsonian cover. We studied that system too, in terms of how it let light in, and in our studies of glare, etc..
00;30;52;24 - 00;31;05;21
DP
Yeah. What I find so interesting about the roof is that you could have simply created a typical Mansard roof and then added glass to the top. But the whole thing is glass, which is so unique.
00;31;05;21 - 00;31;52;26
TP
And a mansard roof, of an appropriate proportion, wouldn’t enclose nearly this much square footage. So, we wanted to get our client as much square footage as possible on top of this historic building. And it needed that extra oomph. The dome portion in the middle, which would never be able to be really enclosed by a mansard of any kind of historically accurate proportion. So that's what led us to both the form and the structure to enclose it, because the freeform shell grid is kind of the perfect device to span such great distances so the interior can be super flexible.
We built three floors within it, but those could be removed, they could be remodeled, they could be reconstructed to serve any purpose because all the loads from the roof system just go down the side perimeter walls.
00;31;53;02 - 00;32;18;06
DP
It's a great project for architecture students to look at in terms of learning how to develop an idea to make form, right. It's just so clear. And yet if you knew nothing about it, you just say, “Wow, they just put a glass dome on top.” But there's so much more to it that created so many unique details and so many beautiful things and facets, and I'm sure that space on the interior is wonderful.
00;32;18;09 - 00;32;25;04
TP
It's really terrific. There's opportunities to connect all three floors interconnecting and the possibilities are endless in there.
00;32;25;06 - 00;32;40;23
DP
So, you've obviously been an architect for quite some time, over 30 years. So, what career advice would you give your younger self, looking back after practicing for all this time? What have you learned? What's an idea that you've really locked on to that you'll never forget?
00;32;40;25 - 00;32;53;00
TP
One of the founding partners at BKSK, Joan Krevlin, said to me 25 years ago when I joined the - one of the things that she always kept with her as a young architect is do your job and tell the truth.
00;32;53;02 - 00;32;55;22
DP
What great advice! I love that!
00;32;55;29 - 00;33;42;02
TP
It's a great profession. And as you said, students of architecture have a great time in design studios. And this is a project that is really right out of studio in a way. I love showing it to students because like you said, it's super accessible in terms of the visuals, but it has a great connection to social history and the importance of context, the importance of research that you just don't come into a vacuum and design a building. You look at the context, you look at history, and you look at what you can learn from it. Because this could have been, like you said, just a flat top mansard roof. But discovering the history of the Lenape connection to this building was just remarkable and a great opportunity. I've met the Lenape Center folk. They've asked me to join their advisory steering committee. It's just been a wonderful experience.
00;33;42;04 - 00;34;03;22
DP
I love what you said. You don't just come into a vacuum and design a building. You don't. You don't. And that's what you learn in school. And hopefully you get to use that information, use that process, use that paradigm when you graduate, and you become a real architect. Right. So, Todd, it's been great to have you here. Thanks so much for your time. Where can people go to learn more about BKSK architects?
00;34;03;27 - 00;34;09;06
TP
We can be found at www.bksk.com
00;34;09;08 - 00;34;11;09
DP
Todd, it’s been great to have you, man. That was really cool.
00;34;11;25 - 00;34;16;12
TP
Thanks. This was really fun.
You May Also Be Interested In
We Can Help With Your Next Project
Discover the latest + greatest in design trends, industry news & pro tips from pros.
For all of your project needs, you’ll find everything you need at a Supply Center.
Let Us Know How We Can Help!
Design Vault Ep. 12 50 Nevins Street with John Woelfling
ABOUT THE ARCHITECT:
![]()
|
John Woelfling is committed to creating sustainable and resource-efficient designs, using an integrated and holistic approach that reduces impacts on the environment and positively effects the health and comfort of building occupants. He leverages his broad experiences working across project typologies, from education and recreation to healthcare and infrastructure, to inform his leadership of the firm's mixed-use residential projects. A recognized Passive House expert, John's focus on sustainable design practices is guided by proactive education of evolving green technologies and incorporating them into his design work.
He frequently lectures about affordable housing and sustainability, speaking at the Center for Architecture, AIA NYS, Urban Green and GreenBuild, Forum for Urban Design, Reimagine Conference, and the PHIUS Passive House Conference. John holds a Bachelor of Architecture from Virginia Tech. |
---|
50 Nevins Street
Dattner Architects
View ProjectTRANSCRIPT
00;00;00;02 - 00;00;05;14
Doug Patt (DP)
Let's go inside the vault. The design vault.
00;00;05;17 - 00;00;33;16
John Woelfling (JW)
We looked at that rectangle and where the opportunity was to expand the building horizontally, and then really started to figure out where the best units would be located, where the best apartment layouts would be in the existing building. It was actually a challenge. We were not going to change the fenestration where the windows are located or the size of the windows.
So that really dictated a lot of the apartment placements and the size. So I think we were pretty clever about putting all the like fundamentals and figuring out how the floorplan would come together.
00;00;33;23 - 00;03;17;20
DP
This is my guest, John Woelfling. I'll share more about him shortly. In this episode from the Design Vault, we highlight John's project 50 Nevins Street. 50 Nevins Street is located in downtown Brooklyn. It literally appears to be two buildings in one. The approach was to reinvigorate a century old building through gut renovation and addition, which provides affordable housing, housing for formerly homeless individuals and mental health services.
The historic site, with its new ten story addition, features 129 new apartments. The building was originally designed by famed Brooklyn architect Frank Freeman, opened in 1913 as a YWCA. In the early 1930s an extensive portion of the building was shaved off to enlarge. Schermerhorn Street and make way for the subway line. That adjustment resulted in an imbalance to the original Colonial Revival building.
The new couple design ascribes value to the existing building and helps restore the balance it had lost. The existing red brick building remains shorter with a classical cornice. The new building sits slightly taller, flush and adjacent with a recessed connector which visually separates the architecture. The contrast in masonry color, dark connector and stylistic changes to the forms and facades set the two buildings apart esthetically, though clearly their co-combined.
Hi, I'm Doug Pat and this is Design Vault. John Woelfling is a partner at Dattner Architects in New York City and holds a Bachelor of Architecture from Virginia Tech. John leverages his broad experiences working across project types like education, recreation, health care and infrastructure to inform his leadership of the firm's mixed use residential projects.
John is a recognized passive house expert. His focus on sustainable design practices is guided by proactive education of evolving green technologies and incorporating them into his work. John's committed to creating sustainable, efficient designs that use an integrated, holistic approach. He frequently lectures about affordable housing and sustainability. Speaking at the Center for Architecture, the New York State AIA, Urban Green and Green Build, Forum for Urban Design, Reimagine Conference and the Phius Passive House Conference.
So welcome, John. Nice to have you with us today. So tell us a little bit about Dattner Architects in New York City. Where are you guys located? What's the size of the firm and what type of work do you do?
00;03;17;22 - 00;05;20;11
JW
So Dattner Architects is a firm that's been around for close to 60 years. We are located in Midtown Manhattan, just like a ten minute walk from the studio, so it's nice and easy to get over here. We've been there for a little over a year and a half, but our offices have been in New York City for our entire life of the firm, we’re about 110 people now.
I just met with a few people and we're looking at hiring some more people. So it's a good time to be practicing in New York City and working on housing and the wide variety of work that my firm does. We do a mixed bag of cornucopia of project types. We do housing, which is what we're going to talk about today.
We do subway stations, we do marine transfer stations for garbage, we do a salt shed here or there, medical health care, schools, libraries, a whole mixture of projects. I'm going to talk about some of the advantages that gives us a little bit further on if we can.
One of the projects that you or maybe some of your listeners know is a project that's on the West Side Highway at Spring Street. It is a salt shed. These types of projects that you might normally see that are a salt shed are very utilitarian domes, and they just protect the salt from the elements. But our project, we did something kind of clever, which was we created this shell that was inspired by the crystal and shape of the salt. So it's this kind of crystal that sits along the water along the West Side highway.
So if you're going up and down the West Side Highway, you've probably seen this. Keep your eyes open for it now. But that's an example of how my office has this sensibility of taking these very civic things that could be very plain and very understated and look for those opportunities. And sometimes we hit a home run, sometimes, you know, we get on base.
But each one of those projects is a real opportunity to take a civic piece of architecture, which is what we do. We do civic architecture, and we look to make the city, the city that we live in the best that it can be. So I'm very proud to be part of the work that we do. It's a large group of people, as I said, 110 people. It's inspiring every day to be able to go into the office and work with such a great group of people.
00;05;20;14 - 00;05;37;25
DP
That's so great. I mean, you're doing exactly what you're taught to do in architecture school, right? You're taking advantage of the project at hand, you're being creative, you're being thoughtful, you're impressing the client, you're making beautiful things for people that live in the city. It sounds fun and it's a good time to be working. You said you're busy.
00;05;38;02 - 00;06;15;19
JW
Yes, we are busy. We've had some ups and downs. But I do think one of the advantages of our firm is that we have this mixed group of typologies. So, you know, when housing was like going gangbusters a couple of years ago, we were really busy and a lot of our work was housing. But as things have shifted over to more infrastructure, which is actually what we're seeing, we're seeing a lot more investment in infrastructure.
We're having those subway type projects, those marine transfer stations, those types of utilitarian transportation and infrastructure projects are taking over a greater percentage of our work. So we're continuing to stay busy. So the old adage of diversifying your portfolio applies to many, many things.
00;06;15;21 - 00;06;20;29
DP
So you are a principal in the firm. How long have you been there and what's your role in the office now?
00;06;21;01 - 00;08;13;19
JW
So I have been a principal there for 20 years. I've been practicing as an architect in the city for 30 years. So I landed at Dattner relatively early in my career and found it to be a great place to stay and work. So I've been there for that long. One of the things that I focus on now is our housing work, our housing studio.
As I mentioned a few minutes ago, the housing work has been a great source of workload in the past decade, 15, ten years. As that work became more and more important in the office, we needed to have leadership to take over and really guide that practice. And one of the things that me and others in the office have been focusing on is integrating really innovative, sustainable design strategies into our housing.
And this, I think, has its biggest benefit in affordable housing. The way housing often gets developed in dense urban environments like New York City is that it is the harder to develop sites that are most likely to be affordable housing because they are the less desirable sites, the sites that are either adjacent to a highway, adjacent to a subway, difficult geometry, a lot of rock, some sort of challenging situation, which thank you for the recognition that my firm and me personally are doing what architects are trained to do looking at these challenges and finding the opportunities.
So that's what we do. We often are faced with challenging sites that maybe are right near infrastructure that is really adding to pollution and environmental degradation. So this idea of sustainable, affordable housing I think is really in our work translated into environmental justice, taking people who might normally live in these underserved communities that have this infrastructure and a real inequity for environmental considerations and trying to make that better. And one of the ways we do that is through Passive House.
00;08;13;21 - 00;08;20;04
DP
So let's dig in here and talk about our building. Tell us a little bit about 50 Nevins Street. So how did your office get the project?
00;08;20;06 - 00;10;13;14
JW
So one of our clients, ICL, which stands for Institute for Community Living, and they are a not for profit organization that does just tremendous, phenomenal work in the city, serving really at-risk underserved people in New York City. They owned this building. They purchased it in 1986. As you mentioned in the intro, it was originally designed as a YWCA as an SRO, a single room occupancy building.
So all the rooms were like single bedded rooms. There was a common cafeteria and kitchen and common bathing facilities. So it was like really stacking people in. And this was like an old model of housing people that was, you know, appropriate at a certain time in the city's history. But not really contemporary residential standards, what we would expect today.
So that was kind of the history of this building. You also mentioned the shaving off of the north end of the building, which actually we suspected that through some research, but we didn't really get it confirmed until we got into the building and started doing the demolition and saw, oh, this is where they replaced this column with a different type of steel that was in the original building.
It was riveted steel. In the new portion it was rolled sections. We'd see the back up wall or actually the composite wall. And the original building was all brickwork. It was all bonded brick wall in the new building in the modified part that happened when they widened the street, it became a terracotta block back up with then the finished brick in front, the window details were different. So it was actually really interesting to have that kind of confirmation and see it once the demo all happened. The building has this legacy of being modified and I think serving the greater good, the widening of the street and the shaving off of 20 feet of the building was done so that there would be this greater public amenity of the subway station that would be improve the life of all New Yorkers.
00;10;13;16 - 00;10;18;24
DP
Yeah, interesting. It's all related. So what was the building next to your building?
00;10;18;27 - 00;11;33;13
JW
The building next to our building was a recently constructed hotel, which was a very different building type, superstructure type construction techniques, and much taller than the existing building as well. So it was a really dominating presence. So one of the things that we tried to do and I think we were pretty successful is kind of mitigate that presence.
It was just to the west of our site. But yeah, we wanted to kind of bridge that more contemporary with the traditional classic building that was retained on the site. The strategy that we employed for the redevelopment was to expand the building both vertically and horizontally. The horizontal piece was easy. You just, you know, you build next to the building.
There was a parking lot. Basically a service area for the existing building, which is, you know, very handsome pre-war building. But that pre-war building kind of vintage came with a lot of burdens or a lot of legacy issues that made the building more difficult to use as a contemporary building that needed to be handicapped accessible.
The systems were out of date really at the end of their service life. So we had to do some major kind of heroic things to this existing building to keep it.
00;11;33;13 - 00;11;34;14
DP
And you wanted to keep it?
00;11;34;21 - 00;12;03;18
JW
Yeah, absolutely. It was such a handsome building also, I've mentioned sustainable design, but one of the most sustainable things that you can do if you're doing a project is to keep an existing building, keep the shell, keep as much as you can. Now, obviously, you've got to like do some demolition and throw some materials away. But if you can keep that building out of the landfill, keep that building from having to be shipped to the landfill and all the energy that goes into that retaining that energy that was originally used to build the building, that's one of the most sustainable things that you can do of all.
00;12;03;24 - 00;12;06;09
DP
So tell me, is the subway system still there?
00;12;06;11 - 00;12;21;03
JW
Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah. It is. We don't quite feel it rumbling in the building when it goes by, but there were some really special supportive excavation considerations that we had to do. We had to be really concerned about settlement. So there was a lot of thought put into the foundations of this building.
00;12;21;03 - 00;12;22;27
DP
Yeah, the new foundations.
00;12;23;00 - 00;13;57;28
JW
So the new foundations were complicated. The existing building foundations were also complicated. When we did this vertical expansion above the existing building, I mentioned earlier the term heroic, and it really was heroic. I mean, when I look back on this, I think, Oh my God, what was I thinking? And we actually convinced somebody to do this. We convinced a contractor to do this.
We convinced our client, which, you know, there are great clients. I don't want to make it sound like I've deceived them, but it was a really courageous project to both undertake by all parties. In the existing building we built above, there was additional load that we were superimposing on the existing superstructure in that building. We had to brace one of the columns so that we could lower the footing and increase the size of the footing.
And the way we did that was and when I say we, I mean it's really the contractor that did this. We came up with the concept, but they executed it. There was a huge beam that was spanned from one column to another that supported this column temporarily, that we were going to lower the footing on, and they jacked that beam up and supported that column so that the existing footing that was undersized could be pulled out, excavated further down, and then a new footing could be introduced and an extension of the column.
So gutsy acrobatics to do this. And the way they tested whether that beam, a temporary beam that was put in, whether it separated the footing from the column, was they took a piece of paper and they slipped it between the footing and the base plate of the column to see if it was actually separated. So they wanted to test that to make sure there was daylight before they pulled out that existing footing. Phenomenal construction sequencing and logistics. It was a gutsy project I'm very proud of.
00;13;58;01 - 00;14;00;21
DP
So what were the project restrictions like for you guys?
00;14;00;26 - 00;15;33;11
JW
So there were a couple of restrictions. When we first started looking at this, we wanted to increase the density of the project because it was a rare kind of once in a building's lifetime opportunity to increase the amount of affordable and supportive housing that could be provided in downtown Brooklyn. So our client ICL, knew that this was kind of their one chance.
So we looked at a couple ideas, a couple of options, and to get to 129 units, we had to bend, maybe break the rules of the New York City zoning resolution. And the way you do that is you go through something called a ULURP. It's a process that involves community engagement. It involves talking to city planning, New York City city planning departments, and doing something that is not as of right.
The current zoning resolution and building code allow you to build certain things. As long as you get approval from the Department of Buildings, you can build those. But we needed to bend the rules here or break the rules to make this actually happen. So we went to the various city agencies, went to community boards and made this proposal to expand the building vertically, to increase the floor area ratio, the amount of floor area that you can build on the site.
And we were successful in that because I think a lot of these stakeholders recognized that this project was going to really make a difference to so many people's lives and be a community asset. So normally we've all heard the term NIMBY, not in my backyard. Normally. That's one of the things that we bought up against when we do these types of projects and there was some of that, but I think it was much more toned down because people recognized the benefit of this project.
00;15;33;18 - 00;15;37;18
DP
So did you guys have the building completely designed when you went to the people?
00;15;37;21 - 00;15;48;12
JW
No. We had the vision. We kind of had a good idea how many units were going to go into the building. We knew what the program was going to be. We had some of the renderings completed because that's really important to making that pitch to stakeholders.
00;15;48;18 - 00;15;51;24
DP
What about height requirements for you guys? What limited you?
00;15;52;00 - 00;16;15;09
JW
I'm going to try not to get too much into the weeds and the zoning resolution, but this is it actually falls into a limited height district in downtown Brooklyn, which we adhered to, but we needed the increased floor area. The height was somewhat limiting, but there were other limitations on the building as well. We could only add so many floors onto the existing building before we kind of maxed out on what we could really feasibly do with the existing foundations and the existing superstructure.
00;16;15;11 - 00;16;24;13
DP
So let's talk a little bit about the building plan. So the existing building is like a long rectangle. So what did you guys do with your additions?
00;16;24;15 - 00;17;55;23
JW
So one of the really critical things for affordable housing in most housing, all housing is efficiency. And the efficiency was really driven by the desire to maximize the number of units that we could put here so we could serve the most people. So we looked at that rectangle and where the opportunity was to expand the building horizontal lean and located our cores, our elevator and our stairs in a spot that worked best for that, and then really started to figure out where the best units would be located, where the best apartment layouts would be. In the existing building, it was actually a challenge. We were not going to change the fenestration where the windows are located or the size of the windows. So that really dictated a lot of the apartment placements and the size. New York City has something called light and air requirements for the apartments, you need to have a certain size window for a certain size room, and you can't go below that for both light daylight and ventilation.
So the existing building’s layout was determined largely not completely, but largely by the existing fenestration layout. And then we had more flexibility in the new building portion, but that was also a challenge because it was a very limited floor plates and it really had to integrate with the existing building. We had corridors that we had to figure out.
We placed the elevator in the inside corner where the two buildings meet, because that's a place where you can't really put apartments because there's no windows there. So I think we were pretty clever about putting all the, like, fundamentals and figuring out how the floor plan would come together.
00;17;55;25 - 00;18;01;04
DP
How did the apartment sizes compare from the old building to the new building? Are they exactly the same?
00;18;01;06 - 00;18;57;09
JW
No, it is dramatically different. The original SRO, the single room occupancy, I mean, the rooms were eight feet wide, ten feet deep. So really puny and not in any way contemporary or fair housing model for the residents that were going to come back. So we basically blew out all those interior partitions and relaid out the building interiors.
The original building was actually a double loaded corridor. And when I said below the corridor, I mean there's a hallway down the middle and it's got apartments on either side, fairly efficient way to do it. But it was such a narrow building and the site is so narrow that when we redid the building in this more contemporary model of apartments, we couldn't fit a double loaded corridor in there.
So it's really a single loaded corridor in the existing building. In the new building, we had more flexibility in the site dimension, so we were able to do a double loaded corridor in that portion. But it was, yeah, a real challenge to adapt the existing building. But as I said, you know, it's one of the most sustainable things you can do.
00;18;57;16 - 00;19;01;06
DP
Are the apartments a lot larger in the new building and the windows taller?
00;19;01;12 - 00;20;38;07
JW
I would say in the new building, no, they're not significantly larger. They're just kind of what they are. I think the windows are maybe a little bit taller, certainly wider. We wanted to have some affinity between the two buildings. We didn't want to have like completely different fenestration sizes, which really I think would be inequitable to the people who would move into this building.
But we did in many ways, we made the new building distinct from the existing building. You go around New York City or any other city that's been around for a while and you see these buildings that are historic and have been adapted. You know, there's a couple of ways you can do it. You can either be matchy matchy about it and try to replicate in new construction and new materials a very similar thing.
And that's usually pretty apparent. It's never seamless, even if you could make it perfectly matching, I just don't think that's genuine. I don't think it's a truthful representation of where we are in the construction and it's not necessary. There may be times when it's merited, but it shouldn't be your knee jerk reaction. It shouldn't be the starting point.
So one way is to be absolutely seamless about it. One is to put a cap on top of the building. But we wanted to make this building really tell a story about the history of it. So we basically wrapped this new piece of contemporary construction up in around the existing building and allowed it to kind of finish off the existing building.
You mentioned earlier some of the adaptations that have happened to the building that I think really compromised the original integrity of the design, the symmetry and the way the building ended. So I think we kind of rectified that with this new construction that comes over the top and helps finish the building in a way that I think looks more appropriate.
00;20;38;12 - 00;20;42;27
DP
So tell me about the cornice on the existing building. Is that new or was that there?
00;20;43;02 - 00;20;51;14
JW
That's actually a really interesting question. The cornice we thought from the street level. Oh, that's the original cornice. It looks very detailed and looks contemporary on the building.
00;20;51;16 - 00;20;52;11
DP
It's gigantic.
00;20;52;11 - 00;21;05;12
JW
It's gigantic. Yeah, it's probably four feet tall and overhangs three feet. It's yeah, it's enormous. But we got up there and when we started to do that demolition that I mentioned earlier, it's made of fiberglass. So it was actually done some time, I think in the…
00;21;05;12 - 00;21;06;06
DP
Sixties or so?
00;21;06;06 - 00;21;27;27
JW
I think it was actually in the eighties. I think after ICL originally bought the building, they did a couple modifications to make it better suit their needs, not to the extent that we'd most recently renovated, but they, I think, replaced the existing cornice with a fiberglass one. The fiberglass one is in great shape. We kept it. We like took it off where we had to for construction sequencing and logistics, but then put the thing back and just re-caulked it. It's done now.
00;21;27;28 - 00;21;40;09
DP
But it's a great cap to the existing building and it really sets the two buildings apart. And when you look at the additions, it all kind of makes sense. And that cornice I think does a lot to do that.
00;21;40;14 - 00;21;53;23
JW
Yeah, it's a very formal gesture, that retaining it and then allowing that to be part of this kind of bridge. In this reveal that you also mentioned earlier, the reveal is very intentional to help make that separation very visible and legible.
00;21;53;29 - 00;22;01;25
DP
So did you guys have to make many structural changes to the existing building? You gutted it and it's steel? On the interior?
00;22;01;25 - 00;22;06;18
JW
Steel frames, multi exterior wall. We did do window replacements.
00;22;06;20 - 00;22;08;26
DP
Changed the way the walls are insulated?
00;22;08;29 - 00;23;14;11
JW
We did, yeah. We did a spray-on insulation. I know there's some critique of spray on insulation, but it really was the right material for this because it gave us our vapor barrier and our improved insulation all in one shot. But yeah, we did that on the inside of the building. One of the principles of Passive House, which is a system to really decrease the building's energy requirements, you significantly drive down the energy loads in a building using the system.
And the way you do that is a high performance building exterior. That's one of the strategies, is you make a high performance building exterior, which is both your windows and your insulation and your continuity of the insulation and your air vapor barrier. So in historic buildings you're somewhat limited with what you can do with that continuous insulation because you've got your slabs coming in, the slabs are buried on the exterior wall or the steel, but there's thermal bridges that just can't be avoided in these buildings of this timeframe.
But we did the best we could. And on balance, with the insulation on the inside and the new building’s envelope, we were able to get a building that could easily comply with the energy code. So yeah, we had to insulate the existing buildings walls and that's how we dealt with that.
00;23;14;18 - 00;23;22;17
DP
You guys had to replace some of the existing brick. So talk a little bit about that and then tell us what kind of brick you used on the new addition.
00;23;22;20 - 00;24;41;25
JW
Sure. Yeah. The existing brick, we had to undo some sins of the past at lintels the repairs that were done previously. Not quite sure when they were done with maybe a little bit less sensitivity to matching the brick and the mortar. So that was some of the repair work that we did at the existing building. The existing building also has a base, a very formal base.
It's a very classical design to have that base. So we wanted to, that was another one of these affinity points that we wanted with the new building. So we created this base, which was a dark grounding brick that's a Glen-Gery product, it's a Black Hills velour. The velour is the finish on the brick. So that kind of established the base of the building.
Then above that, we did a much lighter, more contemporary brick, also a Glen-Gery product, White Plains velour. Again, the velour is the finish of the texture of the face of the brick, and we did similar coursing, the mortar is very different. The mortar in the White Plains is its own mortar. The existing buildings, mortar repairs were their own mortar, so they would match that building's texture and coloration.
But through a combination of the same brick size, the same coursing, and also picking up on that limestone detailing that's in the existing building we did kind of create this affinity between the two buildings. So they're definitely distinct from each other, but they're also kind of of a family.
00;24;42;01 - 00;24;48;23
DP
Yeah, it's a nice touch. It ties the two buildings together. So how long did this whole process take from beginning to end?
00;24;48;25 - 00;26;00;29
JW
That is a good question. So the ULURP is something that you don't normally undertake. The ULURP is a discretionary approval process, so that added about a year to the design time. So I would say it took about 18 months to design the building, and the construction of it was also really complicated. It took, I think, 30 months to build it, and that included demolition, it included the excavation, and a global pandemic.
So it was one of these projects where, you know, we had to figure out how to do this, how to work remotely, work with the contractor, with all these site safety considerations. So we were fortunate enough that in the city there was a program that allowed for affordable housing to proceed. So it was told to the Department of Buildings that this is an affordable housing project and they give you a special permit that you post on the construction barricade.
And that allowed us to proceed. Now, it doesn't mean that we could proceed business as usual. Before the pandemic, there were all sorts of hand-washing stations and protocols for staff to be, you know, separate. And we would show up on site, we'd have masks, we wouldn't walk between crowds of people. So the fact that it got done in two and a half years is kind of a real testament to the partnership between ICL, the contract and the design team.
00;26;01;05 - 00;26;21;21
DP
So you'd mentioned the unique construction detail with this steel column that you guys had to alter the foundation for. What about some of the masonry on the exterior? Were there any unique construction details that you guys had to come up with? For example, for the connector, how did you guys end up doing that? I mean, is it all pretty straightforward?
00;26;21;23 - 00;27;03;24
JW
Well, yeah, I guess straightforward is a real simplification of what's involved. But yeah, we had to figure out where the steel was going to go, where we were going to break that new steel versus the existing steel. There's got to be some tolerances for movement and construction tolerances. That bridge was really made through that recessed metal reveal that you see separating the two buildings.
So we made it easier on ourselves by doing it in that different material that allowed for a lot of tolerance. It could be pushed back 18 inches and if, you know, was 16 inches in one place and a little bit different on the other side, you couldn't really tell because it was a very different material. So I think we're smart about making our lives in the contractors' lives a little bit easier.
00;27;04;01 - 00;27;08;11
DP
And how does the new additions touch the building next to it?
00;27;08;11 - 00;27;12;07
JW
There is a seismic joint.
00;27;12;07 - 00;27;13;06
DP
Really? Is that pretty typical?
00;27;13;06 - 00;27;41;21
JW
It's pretty typical, yeah. And it's based upon the various heights of the building. For every 50 feet it's one inch. So I think we had a setback from the property line three inches because we were just over 100 feet. So for every 50 feet you got one inch. So if you're 110, you got three inches. So we had something called an MCO joint, which is just a squishy finished joint that you kind of stuffy in after everything else is up and constructed. And that allows for any sort of seismic movement in case there's an earthquake.
00;27;41;23 - 00;27;45;28
DP
So tell me a little bit about the Enterprise Green Communities Program.
00;27;46;00 - 00;31;03;17
JW
It is a program that any affordable housing project that is going to be using public funds needs to adhere to. It's a little bit like LEED, LEED is a very broad system. So Enterprise and LEED are broad. They talk about community connected communities, recycled materials, water usage, energy usage, healthy interior environments. So that system is really helpful and I think it helps there be a consistency through all of the affordable housing that's being built now that there is this level of sustainability that is not only about carbon, it's about water, it's about interior indoor air quality.
So that's a really important system. The Passive House system that I've touched on a little bit earlier takes one piece of that, the energy piece of it and really ramps it up. So Passive House is about investing in that building exterior. You have a high quality envelope with continuous insulation, continuous air barrier that allows for very little air to come in or out of the building.
And that continuity is also part of the windows. And the windows are usually high performance windows that are either triple glazed or just high performance glazing. And what that really allows the envelope of the building to do is to be almost like a winter jacket. I think a good analogy aside from the winter jacket analogy, is like a thermos, an insulated cup versus just the standard deli coffee cup.
Your deli coffee cup is going to lose the heat in the coffee pretty quickly. If you've got the thermos, it's going to retain that heat for a lot longer. So what that allows you to do in the building is retain interior internal heat gains. And the internal heat gains are lighting, appliances, people occupying the space. So those internal heat gains that you can gain passively and retain in the building allow you to really drive down those heating loads in the building.
So in a building built in New York City, similar to 50 Nevins on its scale and its size and its number of occupants, you can heat the apartment with a hand dryer, so you really drive down those heating loads. You've got to cool the building too. So that high performance envelope also helps keep that cooled air, that energy that's invested in the air, keep that inside the building.
It's not leaking outside the building. You're not getting hot, humid air bleeding into the building when you're exhausting the bathrooms and the kitchen. So Passive House is really taking the energy component of any affordable housing building and really ramping up the stakes and making it a much more high performance building. There's more to it than that. The mechanical systems need to be designed and balanced for that.
There's domestic hot water that needs to be taken into consideration, but it's an area of practice that we are really pushing for and advocating with our clients for not only just being democratic and equitable for the buildings and the environments that they're often located in, but there's also regulatory pressures that are coming down the pike. There's something called Local Law 97, which is going to fine buildings if they don't have certain energy performance, if they emit too many emissions, whether it's carbon or sulfur dioxide or whatever, there's metrics for buildings of certain types and their sizes. And if you are not meeting those standards, there's going to be penalties to pay.
00;31;03;19 - 00;31;04;26
DP
So that's coming down the pike.
00;31;04;26 - 00;31;42;01
JW
That's coming down the pike. I think 2025 is the first threshold or maybe it's 2026. But we're designing buildings now that are going to take a year to design, two years to build. So by the time they're operational, we're in Local Law 97. So we're advising clients to not put your heads in the sand on this. You know, a lot of people aren't doing this.
The intense heat that we've been feeling, the wildfires in Canada, the fires and migration, we're starting to see the stuff hit the fan. So our clients are reading the writing on the wall. Local Law 97. There is a Local Law 154 that's banning gas usage.
00;31;42;04 - 00;31;43;20
DP
Natural gas.
00;31;43;20 - 00;31;53;10
JW
Yeah, natural gas. And you've actually done something that I want to check you on. Yeah, sure. It's natural gas, but who told you it's natural gas? It's fossil gas. The idea of that, it's natural. Okay.
00;31;53;10 - 00;31;55;02
DP
I was distinguishing from propane.
00;31;55;06 - 00;32;17;11
JW
Okay, well, it's kind of all the same stuff. It's all carbon that goes into the atmosphere and affects our climate. So I don't mean to be a jerk about it. And I find myself kind of being programmed by certain, you know, sales pitches and how they want you to perceive these things. So, yes, there's a natural gas ban, however nice you want to say it. So there's all these regulatory pressures.
00;32;17;11 - 00;32;20;23
DP
When you say local law. So this is New York State, New York City?
00;32;20;26 - 00;33;06;12
JW
Local law is just New York City. There's state legislation that's also banned gas fired equipment. And California's doing a similar thing. So it's amazing how much the landscape is shifting under our feet. There's a building in New York City not too far from where we are right now that was designed six or seven years ago. And one of the really innovative, cutting edge technologies that they used was to use a gas turbine to produce all of their electricity.
There was a cogen plant, so on the top of the building on the 73rd floor, they've got a gas turbine. And I believe it's also producing domestic hot water for the building's use, which seems, you know, at the time innovative, were going to be more independent. But I can't imagine trying to propose that sort of strategy now. So it's really amazing how much the landscape is shifting under our feet.
00;33;06;14 - 00;33;12;19
DP
So you've been an architect for 30 years. If you could give your younger self some career advice, what would it be?
00;33;12;21 - 00;33;55;23
JW
Knowing what I know now, I wish I would have been more thoughtful about sustainability and how important that is, because I think the decisions that we're making now, we're only really going to see the benefits of that or the implications or the results of that down the road and when I think about how much carbon has been put into the atmosphere since, like I think 1992, I think 50% of the carbon that's in the atmosphere was produced I think since the nineties. So it's not climate change, global warming. It's often thought about as something that's occurred in over a century. And a lot of the legacy emissions were from the beginning of the industrial revolution, but it's really not the case. It's really in this compressed time frame that's in the last 30, 40 or 50 years.
00;33;55;25 - 00;34;02;22
DP
John, it's been great to have you here. Thanks for your time. Where could people go to learn more about Dattner Architects in New York City and yourself?
00;34;02;25 - 00;34;18;20
JW
It's really easy. We've got a website, Dattner.com, I think we have a good representation of our work there. You'll see that all of our work is basically in the city and we can ride the subway to get to our site. So it's a pleasure to have spoken to you today and glad to be able to share some of my experience.
00;34;18;23
DP
Thank you very much and great to have you here
You May Also Be Interested In
We Can Help With Your Next Project
Discover the latest + greatest in design trends, industry news & pro tips from pros.
For all of your project needs, you’ll find everything you need at a Supply Center.
Let Us Know How We Can Help!
Brick Blueprint with DS Architecture
Cleveland, OH
Architecture Firm
DS ArchitectureDirector of Design
Eric F. ProsDistributor
The Thomas Brick CompanyDS Architecture maximizes client involvement, from design conception to the final stages of construction. DS Architecture encourages clients to join the design team by reviewing and approving every major milestone of the architectural process.
When we asked Eric F. Pros, Director of Design at DS Architecture, about his recent project, Lakewood’s Fire Station Number 2, this is what he had to say:
Q: What was your inspiration for this project?
A: We were inspired by the history of the Lakewood Fire Department and the surrounding neighborhood. This project was a renovation and addition to an existing historic fire station in Lakewood, Ohio which is the most densely packed city in Ohio. The existing building’s character was recognized and celebrated while we improvised on its character and introduced innovative new ideas to not only honor the history of the building, but also elevate its identity with some contemporary style.
The urban context of this site was an inspiration. Because land is in high demand in this city, we had to make the most of every bit of the property, while still being a good neighbor. These conditions which initially seemed like restraints were used as helpful parameters for the project and helped us make informed decisions about the building’s placement, scale, massing, and rooflines.
The people that would be the end users of this facility were an inspiration. The first responders have a great deal of pride in their community and are recognized by the neighborhood as a symbol of civic pride. The long, tall façade of the apparatus bay that could have felt imposing or out of scale with the rest of the neighborhood was instead leveraged as an opportunity for public art and innovative wayfinding signage. The flemish bond brick pattern was articulated in a way that gave the field of brick depth through a textured backdrop for a metal sculpture. The corner of the building that faces the roadway received some special brick detailing attention by rotating the stretcher units 30 degrees in a way that formed a block number 2 that is reminiscent of the fire department’s insignia on their vehicles. In this way, a standard off-the-shelf masonry unit was used to create unique dramatic effects.
Q: What was the overall goal, or desired outcome, for this project?
A: The first goal of the project was to upgrade an existing fire station to suit the needs of modern firefighting and emergency medical services. The pre-existing facility did not offer appropriate space for the new fire trucks and did not have adequate bunk space for first responders. As public safety continues to evolve, the way that fire fighters performed their duties 100 years ago is very different from today. The vertical growth of the city has made it necessary to have longer ladder trucks to respond to emergencies that may occur in high rises.
A secondary goal was to give the first responders a facility that they can be proud of. In a similar way, the residents of the City of Lakewood should be proud of the buildings that represent their rich community and the diverse history of their neighborhood.
Q: Why did you choose brick for this project? How important is material to your approach?
A: There are many reasons why brick made sense for this project. There is a sense of symbology for the fire stations to be constructed of brick. Red brick is somewhat synonymous with fire stations and contributes to their iconic presence in communities. “Fireproof” buildings constructed predominantly with masonry became popular and embraced by fire departments.
Because fire stations are public buildings that are occupied 24 hours a day and often maintained by the crew, low maintenance materials, like brick, are preferable. The long-term durability of fired clay masonry products makes them a good investment for such buildings. The longevity of this material ensures that the building will be a building that the City of Lakewood can be proud of for many years to come.
Material choices greatly impact the perception of a building by the public. As a symbol of safety and civic pride, this fire station needs to evoke a sense of stability and permanence. Glen-Gery brick effectively communicates these ideas in a way that not only fits into its historic context but suggests a long-lasting presence.
Q: What interested you most while designing this project?
A: The people that would be using this building 24 hours a day, 7 days a week are really what this project kept coming back to. Providing a sense of dignity for the first responders that keep the City of Lakewood safe are what this project is all about.
The ability to collaborate with local artist Scott Goss on his metal sculpture installation was truly an honor. The building itself is focused on many of the practical considerations for a fire department, but Scott’s “Shielded Together” installation takes the building a step further and truly pays tribute to the men and women who have dedicated their lives to service. The metal sculpture is highly visible and is lit at night so that it can be appreciated around the clock.
Q: What features of brick are most important to you? What made you choose Glen-Gery?
A: Each project is unique, and every masonry application presents opportunities for innovation. In this project, finding a brick that matched the historic color and texture was our first challenge. Thankfully, Glen-Gery’s robust catalog of clay colors and textures allowed us to have several options to consider that were very close to the original brick from 1919, and the later addition. We were fortunate enough to test several sample panels in natural light next to the existing brick to see which option would give us the best match. Our final selection was Wavetex Red Bark. This brick perfectly complements the existing brick from a century ago. Additionally, because we were using brick in some unique ways with multiple faces exposed to the exterior, finding the right texture that would receive light correctly was critical to the success of the project.
The quality that Glen-Gery provides is an additional reason for our selection. The long-term endurance of the material gives the owners of the building a particular level of comfort because masonry is known for its resilience. On the design side of the equation, the brick’s quality is an added benefit.
Q: What made this design process different from others you have worked on?
A: This project presented several challenges, and seemingly limited opportunities for innovative solutions. A collaborative design process with the client and our team helped to streamline the design process and established goals. Where our innovation came into play was in how we treated the material and the installation that made this project truly unique.
Special care was given during the design phase to enable the project to be built while the facility can serve its primary purpose of serving the community. It’s not uncommon for public buildings to remain operational while a capital improvement project is underway, but this project proved to be more challenging since there was minimal extra space on site. The builders worked diligently to keep the construction from interfering with the spaces needed for the firefighters to perform their duties.
Q: How did you utilize the International Masonry Institute (IMI) for this project, and what was your experience like?
A: The IMI is an incredible resource for designers and contractors. They provide technical expertise on proper masonry detailing and installation and advice on unique designs. The Ohio Regional Director is Tom Elliott, and I owe him a great deal of gratitude for his knowledge and dedication to masonry design over the years. The IMI partners with local BAC training centers to provide hands on training for masonry apprentices and continued educational opportunities for skilled craftworkers.
Once we had developed a design, I reached out to Tom to get his feedback on our concept. We reviewed the details together and decided this project could benefit from a full-scale mockup. I generated some drawings of the brick detail that we were working on that not only showed the detail in elevation and isometrics, but also a course-by-course series of plans that allowed the craftworkers the ability to easily understand the design intent at each course. The bricklayers knew exactly which units needed to be solid or cored, and which ones were to be rotated 30 degrees. Although we shrunk the overall scale of the detail down vertically for safety reasons in the training center, the intent of the design was appreciated.
Q: What is a typical timeline for a project of this scale?
A: The scope of this project was well defined from the beginning which allowed us to streamline the process into 2 distinct phases. This scope of work also allowed the contractors to construct the project while keeping the station fully operational during construction with limited interruptions to their service. The design timeline was approximately 8 months with the construction duration taking nearly 12 months due to the unique phasing of the project and sensitivity to keeping the facility operational.
Q: Has this project won any awards?
A: The Lakewood Fire Station Number 2 was recognized in the 2022 JBC Masonry Innovation Competition through the International Masonry Institute (IMI).
You May Also Be Interested In
We Can Help With Your Next Project
Discover the latest + greatest in design trends, industry news & pro tips from pros.
For all of your project needs, you’ll find everything you need at a Supply Center.
Let Us Know How We Can Help!
Brick Blueprint with STAT Architecture
New York, NY
Architecture Firm
STAT ArchitecturePrincipal
Suzanna TharianProject Manager
Carina NaulaProducts
Ebonite Smooth, Glacier Gray WesternThe goal of STAT Architecture is to provide quality architecture services by understanding client needs, working with budgets, and adhering to deadlines, while providing reliable services. Their focus and expertise lies in new construction projects and the gut rehabilitation of existing buildings. With services that extend through all aspects of the design and construction process, STAT Architecture prefers to work with projects from the inception of the design right through construction completion.
When we asked Suzanna and Carina about their recent project, Soundview Townhomes, this is what they had to say:
Q: What was your inspiration for this project?
A: Soundview Townhomes are located in the Bronx, across from Soundview Park, which opens to the Bronx River. We wanted our architecture to celebrate this unique park frontage, formalizing it with elegant townhomes and maximizing pedestrian access to the park. We looked to the tradition of garden and cooperative apartments in the Bronx and Queens as a point of reference. These building traditions sought to provide equitable and affordable access to light, air, and green space by proposing low-rise units adjacent to parks or gardens. In this vein, we were looking at the affordable housing built by Andrew J. Thomas in the 1930s, but also projects of a more modest scale, like the Regional Planning Association’s Sunnyside Garden. I should note that all these projects, building conventions, and typologies we referenced during design are brick buildings.
Q: What was the overall goal, or desired outcome, for this project? Why?
A: Site for this project is a former parking lot on a NYCHA property. Relatedly, our goal with this project is to replace an automobile infrastructure with a pedestrian infrastructure. The production of street friendly space has a lot to do with the subtleties of façade design. Layout questions—e.g. How far from the street? Where to place entrances? What rhythm and height for windows?—tend to dominate. However, materials tend to best convey care. So, when we selected our façade materials, we really sought proud, durable, stand-out materials to make this project a good neighbor to the Soundview community.
Q: Why did you choose brick for this project? How important is material to your approach?
A: Clients, neighbors, preservationists all seem to like brick best. Brick converses easily with New York’s historic fabric and the local authorities in the Bronx were also very keen on brick. Building practices are an evolving set of conventions. Buildings aren’t made the way they used to be, but neither are bricks. Buildings and aesthetics evolve in parallel conversations between builders, producers, designers, and the public. Our office has been working for 20 years with Sal Pate at Consolidated Brick. From Sal, we learn not just the cost of various bricks, but where and how they were made. All these aspects are important to us as designers. The manufacturing processes and location tell us about the embodied carbon cost of the materials we choose, while finish and color communicate contextuality and care.
Q: What features of brick are most important to you? What made you choose Glen-Gery?
A: For any material, our first priority is due diligence regarding its health and carbon cost. When it comes to aesthetics, the biggest differentiator is the finish texture. Some bricks can look clay-like and awkward, but we’ve had a lot of good experiences with Glen-Gery. It’s a reliable and attractive brick. Your team is very skilled at emulating the molded brick look that gives a project that majestic old New York feeling we all look for.
Q: Why did you select Sioux City product?
A: To be honest: color. We pick out bricks in person. We browse the showroom, pull things we like and put them all up on the wall. Ebonite smooth literally sparkled. We needed an attractive base; ebonite was an easy choice. We choose to complement it with glacier gray which is buff brick speckled with blues and creams.
You May Also Be Interested In
We Can Help With Your Next Project
Discover the latest + greatest in design trends, industry news & pro tips from pros.
For all of your project needs, you’ll find everything you need at a Supply Center.
Let Us Know How We Can Help!
Brick Blueprint with OOMBRA ARCHITECTS
Philadelphia, PA
Architecture Firm
OOMBRA ARCHITECTSProducts
Belgian Grey Wirecut, Silver City Wirecut, 90 L Corner [Custom], Exterior 161 Corner [Custom], Exterior 168 Corner [Custom]OOMBRA is a small, creative firm of design professionals, focused on creating thoughtful, unique and socially responsible environments using skills forged through past experiences that are built on meaningful and lasting human relationships.
Through diverse expertise, OOMBRA creates spaces meant to evoke a conversation, an emotion and an experience. OOMBRA takes a client’s objectives and communicates them through compelling designs. They believe successful architecture and placemaking is realized when the complexity of the problem is simplified through the design process, resulting in a clear expression of purpose, material, light, shadow and form. OOMBRA strives to create a strong sense of community and a responsibly built world that enhances the human experience.
Q: What was your inspiration for The Avant at 1148 Frankford Avenue?
A: This project sits in a parking lot used for the historic bank on the corner of Girard and Frankford Avenue. The Kensington National Bank, designed by renowned Philadelphia Architect Frank Furness, served as a significant source of inspiration. The bank's intricate details and bold architectural features provided a rich tapestry from which to draw creative ideas. However, the challenge lay in creating a new structure that paid homage to the historic building without overshadowing it. Our goal was to design a building that not only complements the architectural legacy of the Kensington National Bank but also introduces contemporary elements that speak to the evolving character of the neighborhood. We wanted our building to be special but also sit as a background building that allowed the Kensington National Bank (KNB) to really shine. Balancing these elements required a thoughtful approach to design, material selection, and the integration of modern functionalities, ensuring the new structure harmonizes with its historic surroundings while standing out as a landmark in its own right.
Q: What was the overall goal, or desired outcome, for this project?
A: The overall goal for The Avant project was to create a design that both respects and complements the historic architecture of the Kensington National Bank. OOMBRA aimed to integrate modern elements with classic details to create a timeless piece that contributes to the neighborhood's architectural heritage while providing contemporary functionality. Another goal was to keep the project within budget, meet and exceed the client's expectations, and ensure the building ultimately met the needs of the end users.
Q: Why did you choose brick for this project? How important is material to your approach?
A: At OOMBRA, we love using brick for its historical relevance, ease of use, and the knowledge of building by local trades. Additionally, brick has a relatively known cost and experienced less fluctuation during the pandemic. Brick was chosen for its enduring appeal, historical significance, and versatility. In architecture, material selection is crucial as it influences the aesthetic, durability, and contextual relevance of the building. For The Avant, brick helps bridge the gap between the historic bank and the new structure, ensuring a cohesive visual narrative.
Q: What interested you most while designing this project?
A: The most intriguing aspect of designing this project was the challenge of balancing respect for the historic architectural elements with the desire to create a contemporary and functional space. This duality required innovative design solutions and a deep appreciation for the site's historical context. Additionally, at OOMBRA, we have a wealth of experience in designing housing, making this project a particularly good fit for our expertise and interests.
Q: What features of brick are most important to you? What made you choose Glen-Gery?
A: The key features of brick that stand out include its durability, aesthetic flexibility, and low maintenance. Glen-Gery was chosen for their high-quality products, wide range of colors and textures, and their commitment to sustainability, which aligns with OOMBRA's values.
Q: What made this design process different from others you have worked on?
A: This project was unique due to its strong historical context and the need to seamlessly integrate modern design elements without overshadowing the historic bank. Additionally, there were challenges in fitting a residential building on such a tight footprint where a typical 60' double-loaded corridor building would not fit. We had to be creative and used our "OOMBRA LT Studio ©" unit that allowed the building footprint to be reduced by 21' in width. This project was also a bit of a full circle moment for our firm, as we opened our first bank account for OOMBRA in this Wells Fargo Bank. Phase 2 of the project is currently under construction to add another 5 residential units to the second floor of the historic bank and a commercial space on the ground floor.
Q: What is a typical timeline for a project of this scale?
A: A typical project of this scale takes about 8 months to design and a year to construct, but this took a little longer with the supply chain issues and construction cost increases that occurred during the pandemic. The building was completed in the Fall of 2023. It houses 60 apartments and a retail space, including the relocation of the Wells Fargo bank from the KNB building into the new building along the corner of Girard Avenue and Dunton Street. Moreover, the collaboration and commitment from our project team and the clients, Alterra/HK Partners, were instrumental in overcoming these challenges and achieving the project's goals.
Q: Has this project won any awards?
A: The Avant project won an AIA Philadelphia Honor Award in 2022 in the Unbuilt category, recognizing its innovative design and successful integration with the historic bank.
You May Also Be Interested In
We Can Help With Your Next Project
Discover the latest + greatest in design trends, industry news & pro tips from pros.
For all of your project needs, you’ll find everything you need at a Supply Center.
Let Us Know How We Can Help!